Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Cars & Transportation Safety

Failing your driving test for accidentaly driving through a puddle and splashing someone?
Find answers to your legal question.





Failing your driving test for accidentaly driving through a puddle and splashing someone?

How ridiculous is that?

i think that is so unfair!

http://uk.news.yahoo.com/itn/20080909/tuk-l-driver-fails-test-for-splashing-pe-dba1618.html

its being treated as a crash!

who agrees?


    




"isitme"
It's not unfair at all, she committed a moving traffic offence for which you can be prosecuted.

Judging by the answers here, a lot of people will fail their test, and rightly so.


Zath
its not at all ridiculous ..its the duty of a driver to be aware of what is going on around them puddles don't just appear out of nowhere so the excuse " And if I'd swerved to avoid the puddle I might have caused an accident " is just a cop out. She should have seen the puddle and moved to avoid well before having to swerve out of its way .. suppose the guy was standing there with a kid ..and rather than the puddle it was the kid who stepped out into the gutter. People have just become bad drivers to caught up in themselves and not worried enough about other road users.

Im glad i don't have to share the road with this driver


Train Hard Live Well
Rating
I AGREE WITH THE DECISION. Splashing people with a puddle is illegal. Throwing litter out the window is illegal. Spitting at someone through the window is illegal. Blowing the horn and waving at people is illegal. Were do you draw the line? She should of slowed down until there was no traffic on the other side of the road and then drove around it. SIMPLE FOR ANYONE WHO KNOWS HOW TO DRIVE AND ALSO HAS STUDIED THE MANUAL.


k
Rating
Being splashed by a puddle is NOT funny, especially if you on your way to work.

It happened to me yesterday. If I had gone home and changed I would have missed the ONLY bus that goes from the village were I live to the nearest town, and would have lost a whole days pay - which I can NOT afford.

If anybody had bothered to read there Highway Code, you would have seen it is a Criminal Offence to splash a pedestrian.


jammygal
It's a real bummer. Wrong puddle at the wrong time.

But you should have slowed down enough so you didn't splash the person. Not doing so,deliberately shows a lack or consideration for pedestrians. Doing so accidentally, shows a lack of control of your vehicle or lack of awareness of the road surface.
Puddles often conceal pot holes, open drains, foreign objects...any of these can cause your car to swerve if you are driving at speed.
If there was room you should have steadily moved out to avoid the puddle, if not you should have slowed down and driven carefully through it like I said.

If it was a really big deep puddle you should also have tested the brakes gently afterward as they would have gotten wet.

You should have noticed the puddle in time to take either one of these actions - this is why your instructor will go on about looking ahead, planning your next move.

You will pass, just keep trying! Remember they have a huge responsibility to the public on whether or not to pass you, and they can only judge you on how you drive in those 40 minutes.


Lauren
Rating
If you were the person being splashed would you think it was unfair I don't think so !


dadseimaj
She broke the rules. she failed . Simple as.

IF she had been paying attention to the road then she would not have been driving faster than the conditions allow and she would have been able to negotiate the hazard in the correct and safe manner.

Suppose there had been a bus at the bus stop. Would she have ploughed into it and expected a pass? I think not.



A hazard is a hazard . It does not have to be ten feet high and bright red .

Funny how it is always the examiner's fault in the event of a fail


Twisted_Ace
Rating
The driver committed a driving offence, contrary to the Road Traffic Act.

If you commit an offence on your driving test, you will fail.

Why is that ridiculous?


WelshLad
Rating
I agree, as they failed to pay attention on the road.


Aberdeen Tyke
Yes, it is unfair. Because i was soaked as were my daughters by a fuel tanker on the Leeds Ring Road and when i went to Pudsey police station to report the offence, the pigs told me to go away as it 'was trivial'.

You cant have it both ways.


UCANTCME
Rating
It is very stupid but the question has been asked 50 times already.......


WAYNE C
so it looks like the conclusion is,
if its raining motorists have to drive at 2mph so not to splash anyone.
what ever.?


flamingbunghole
lol


Boo
You hear of ridiculous reasons like this all the time.
There is a rumour that has circulated for a while now, that every examiner HAS to fail a percentage of the people he tests, regardless of how they drive, in order to keep the number of road users down.
Incidents like this just add strength to the theory.


Charlottee ♥
Rating
Ha i think ur halirous
I think thats pathetic my sister passed when she did that lool
ohh well atleast u can geta giggle from it.. just try again.. and if u dont succced do it again and again..


♠The Joker♣
That's not a crash, how strange.
I failed my motorcycle test the first time for " comfort taps ".
Hello, I need to steady the bike when I slow down to a stop do I not?

Safe to say, that some instructors are overpaid tetchy idiots.


Ali V
I agree it is absolutely ridiculous! If they had swerved out of the way they would have been penalised for dangerous driving! Unbelievable!!


emma.
Rating
The most stupid thing i've ever read.
Come one,its not like you can swerve out of the way of a puddle.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Would you get a ticket for driving w/out license?
Would you get a ticket for driving w/out a license in NY state?...


 When it is snowing so bad that I cant get to work, how do the people who drive the snow plows get to theirs?
...


 Is it true that a learner who has just passed the Driving Test must have the green P displayed for so long?
I have not heard this but my husband said it today as a friend just ...


 Going 85 in a 30 and got pulled over, how bad?
...


 Passed my driving test few days ago but don't feel confident about driving alone without an instructor yet?
Ok so here's the deal:

Passed my test on tuesday with 3 min0rs! woo
On my driving lessons the instructor didnt tell me what to do I just got on with it, so it was almost like ...


 Wrecked my car tonight, i hit him from behind,he was arrested 4 suspend license,am i still at fault for wreck?
...


 Is a 7 year old allowed to sit in the front of a car with a booster seat.?
Is it legal....


 Does anyone else want to kill people who drive 55 in the fast lane and refuse to move over to let you pass?
I seriously think I will experience road rage some day! If this sounds like you...like the song says...."move *****, get out the way!!!"...


 Now be honest ladies, do you reverse park or drive around till you find a space you can drive strainght in to?

Additional Details
Sorry about the spelling mistake, I meant to put 'straight in to'...


 Do you think mobile phones should be banned in all vehicles?
after all the accidents that have been caused by using mobile phones is it not time the goverment put a complete ban on hand held and hand free mobile phones in all vehicles, after all before mobiles ...


 If your not suposed 2 drink and drive y do bars have parkings?
if its ilegall 2 drink and drive y do bars have ...


 What was your worst car accident?
...


 I've had two car crashes in my life, both occuring below 30 mph. Should I try to avoid driving below 30?
As all the crashes have occurred below 30 mph then it is clear that lack of speed kills.

Think!
Additional Details
JG: I didn't say the crashes were my fault did I?...


 In the UK is it illegal to drive in bare feet?
I've heard from friends that it is legal to drive in flip flops but not in bare feet.
Seems barmy as i know a friend whose flip flops slipped and her foot jammed between the accelerator and ...


 Driving test...Help!!!?
i have my driving practical test tomorrow and im so nervous!
is there any advice anyone can give me!
what are he minors i might get?!?
any help whatsoever would be so appreciated!!!<...


 About school buses?
Why do school buses not have seat belts for children?...


 How can you tell when you are driving over black ice?
...


 Does flashing your high beams really trick a stoplight to turn green?
...


 Do you think the law that you must wear your seatbelt is a violation of your rights?
Wearing a seatbelt only saves/kills your own life, not others. It is the same as drinking....


 Does having high beams on considered offensive in america?
during night driving, I sometimes turn the beams on for a few seconds to see whats up ahead, then I turn them off after I've got my bearings instead of keeping them on all the time. but I ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Thursday, May 24, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024