I almost ran a guy over (while he was corssing on red). who'se fault would it have been?

fritz d

Yours if he was on a crosswalk, its always the drivers fault.

waksio

I agree: "idiots are crossing the streets"
But this particular "idiot" was crossing the street on light.
If the were light, it must be pedestrian crossing lines too.
You forget that the streets are the places were people allow others to use vehicles.
What would be if instead of this idiot would be someone on wheelchair?
The green light doesn't means you should step on the gas, right away,
and "having me stop when I had the green light"
means you practically was moving.
No mater wat you thing about me, you should change the way of driving and thinking.
Tomorrow may be you could cross the light and some one in the car will think, what's idiot?
.

tom delcus

depends on where you are from. in Texas you can run him over. in Oregon the pedestrian could be playing golf on the freeway and you cant hit him

UCANTCME

It would have been your fault, the pedestrian 99.9% of the time will never be at fault.

cireengineering

Pedestrians always have the right of way.

Lady B

probaby his...

drwer2

As one who designs crosswalks, traffic signals, roads and highways, I see this every day.

if a pedestrian starts into the crosswalk on either a yellow or a red, HE DOES NOT HAVE THE RIGHT OF WAY.

This does not relieve you of avoiding a collision if you can.

Every year people are struck, injured and killed thinking they as pedestrians have the right of way whenever they enter the crosswalk or even the street. This simply is not true.

that being said, dealing with traffic is all about human behavior and psychology.

In our own office, (full of traffic engineers) one or more of us has been struck crossing the street at the light. sometimes by being stupid pedestrians and sometimes by stupid drivers.

You cannot be held responsible for someone elses stupidity or suicidal behavior.

wer

mister_argle_bargle

pedestrians have the right of way srry

Wassim S

pedestrians have the right of way

*ARMY GIRL* (*MS.G*)

HIS FAULT!

miss priss

if he was walking on the cross walk then yours if you would have killed him it would have been yours cause he wouldnt have been there to say if you did it on purpose or not

kapn

Yours...

Roy

Pedestrians always have the right of way.

michael c

pedestrians do not have right of way when there is a controlled crosswalk, if they are crossing when it says do not cross, theyre jaywalking and if you hit them, you can sue for damage to your car

yodamandemonoid

even if the pedestrian was in the wrong they have the right of way in court.

if this was to happen you would have to involve the police and get as mayn whitnesses as possible to prove that the crossing person was wrong

after that it all rests on the officer who responds and if necessary on the judge (if pedestrian sues)

dave

His for walking on red light

gaparklane

It would have been his fault for crossing on red.

love of my life

Uh if you had killed him it would have been your fault... there are alot of stupid idiots for sure....

Liteson

Sorry, it's always the driver of the car who would be at fault. It might not seem fair, but pedestrians can do whatever they want, willy nilly, short of running out directly towards a moving vehicle, and it'd be the driver's fault. It's why so many insurance scammers will intentionally get themselves hit while crossing the street, intentionally, when there is oncoming traffic. The law requires that a driver be able to see completely everything around him before proceeding. If a driver sees that there are pedestrians around they should predict that the stupid pedestrian will immediately without warning enter the road. Once a walking idiot steps off the sidewalk a driver is to stop. Of course, it's against the law to block the flow of traffic, so go figure.

melfred_20

I think it would be your fault period cause you killed him. If you hit him and he walked away his fault.

KAM

according to the law books a pedestrian has the right of way at all times no matter what!!!.the light might have been red for you but it might have been green for him when he started to cross the road,and while crossing his light changed and he was caught in the cross walk,when your light changed for you to go.always give the right of way don't demand it,be a defensive driver not an offensive one,

Misho

I hit a girl...it was red light for me so I was gradually pressing my brakes...but she wasn't walking on the pedestrian crossing..she was crossing like 10 feet before that..and I didn't see her because of the other cars...She had to go to the hospital emergency..The police said it was her fault....just because she wasn't crossing on the pedestrian crossing...but as of what I know...as long as their crossing right..they could be crossing on green and turns red while crossing..u have to wait until they have crossed.....Police would take a judgmental call on that..since u weren't able to see him because of the big truck..and green for u...so It's judgmental..

mistk_dolphins

his.

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: