Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Cars & Transportation Safety

Is it acceptable to go through an amber light to avoid an accident?
Find answers to your legal question.





Is it acceptable to go through an amber light to avoid an accident?

Hello, I'm pretty new to driving and am worried I will get into trouble for going through a light on amber which then turned red as I passed the stop line. I was intending to stop, but since there was a car following very closly behind I decided that in order to avoid causing an accident (i.e. stopping abruptly) i carried on as the cross roads were clear with no pedestrians/cars cyclists. I'm not sure if there was a camera, there may have been and I'm wondering if it is likely that I will recieve a fine for this despite trying to avoid an accident (it's not a common practice of mine to run red lights, I'm a cautious driver).


    




zebediah
Rating
that is precisely what the amber light is for, means prepare to stop, but if that means slamming on the anchors and being ran into then go through the amber


j2frw
Rating
You are allowed to pass through on amber if it is unsafe to stop, ie someone following closely.


scragette2000
Yes amber lights are fine


mowhokman
it is perfectly fine to still go on amber.


The One
No worries you will be fine


mimi
would you rather pay a few thousand dollars in damage and deal with insurance and another upset driver OR get a ticket for going through a red light? Yellow means slow down so if you see that you might not slow down in time or might cause an accident i think this its your call.


FAST&FURIOUS
Rating
u can go through amber lights when ever what ever the reason its fine


?
As per working in New York State - Clearly stated a Yellow light is the same as a green light. A yellow is a warning that the light is about to turn red - it doesn't mean speed up.

Unless your vehicle is less than 45 feet prior to a marked crosswalk or building line at the time the light turned red you are considered in the intersection which means you are okay.

If the light turns red and you are 45 feet or more of the crosswalk or building line and enter that area you are in violation of disobeying a steady red light. Whether or not someone is on your rear would be up to the issuing officer - at that point it is a discretionary opinion of the officer, especially if he pulls both vehicles over at once (yes it is possible, and done quite often with some cautious skill by the officer).

A camera red light is not a violation against the driver but against the vehicle (registered owner is responsible).


Bob the Boat
Hi,

I and many guite correctly would pass through an amber light instead of braking heavily.
That is why there is a short amber period as merely a warning that a red is imminent.
Technicaly it only an offence to put a wheel over the line on a red signal, so you did the correct thing.

Bob


musicdancerecords
Rating
An amber light means "prepare to stop", but if you cannot safely stop, it is OK to go through. If there was a camera and you get a fine, you are within your rights to contest it, By the same token, if you had of stopped and the car behind you hit you, that car is at fault for traveling too close. You did the right and safest thing you could.


Jay
Rating
Yellow is not red! Sounds like you did the right thing. It's always a good idea to avoid stopping so abruptly if at all possible.


go†h ho††ie
Yes


eyecue_two
Yes it is. The yellow light is a caution light to tell you that the light is about to turn red. You can even run a red light to avoid an accident if you have to. There is something called an affirmative defense and also there is a lessor of two evils defense. The camera would not have a picture of you if the light was yellow. You better have witnesses though if you geet a ticket for it.


I ♥ GH
Rating
Whatever it takes to avoid an accident. I doubt any judge would convict you if you explained the situation (and he believed you).


Zach
Rating
If you do it to avoid an accident, or other potentially hazardous situation, then it's perfectly acceptable. If you get pulled over, explain to the officer why you went through the amber, but 9 times out of 10, he will have seen it and let you go.

As for intersections with cameras, I'm not sure how they would work (we don't have many here in Michigan, if we have them at all) but I'm sure that if you received a ticket, and explained it in court, you'd get off.


rowdy
Yes, the law states "an amber light means STOP unless doing so would cause an accident".


Trevor h
An Amber traffic light means stop at the stop line unless you have already crossed it, or you are so close to it that to stop might be dangerous or cause an accident.


sick of extremists
Rating
Amber means stop as much as Red, but it is not illegal to pass through on amber if to do otherwise would cause an accident.


St3N0
yes . it is what would you do .smak straight in to the crashed car ???? dint think so lol


bob
You are usually ok as long as you are fully into the intersection when the light turns red. Amber basically means stop if you can...otherwise clear out!

In your situation though...better to be rearended (their fault) than to take a chance at a ticket or hitting someone that is jumping the gun on a green light. If you hit someone it would very likely be your fault.


UCANTCME
YES IT IS BUT IF A POLICE OFFICE SEES YOU HE OR SHE MIGHT NOT THINK SO.


Marky
Rating
Technically, if you were following the speed limit, you should have enough time to slow down when the light turned to amber.

You were either drving too fast, else didn;t notice the light until too late, else you didn't make a decisio in a quick enough time. If there was a camera, then they should be able to see what the outcome is.

You could argue that the car behind was driving too close, but the camera would be able to determine that too.


Mr Mills
Rating
I swerved to avoid a child once,.... and fell off the couch!


Amirra
If the light turned red before you crossed the stop line (if you weren't speeding) you should have had plenty of time to stop. A cop would not buy your excuse. Keep in mind that if he rear-ends you, he's at fault, not you.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Do u think that THIS is violent?
the nusery rimes like humdy- dumpty well he fell off of a wall. rock a bye baby "when the wind blows the cradle will fall" three blind mice... there not only blind but they got there tails ...


 Is it the law to indicate when driving??????
...


 Anybody else driven mad by the size of british parking spaces!!?
...


 Car parking outside my house?
i am fed up of persons from the next street which is on an incline, parking infront of my house as our road is flat, i am registered disabled and have a sign on my gate asking to be left clear, The ...


 Is it fair to wait 6 months after your permit to get your license?
Shouldn't it be at least 3 months or less?...


 Alcohol and driving?
Why is it that after years of goverment campaining they haven't made it illegal.Why is it there's still a legal limit and people are still getting killed, injured,etc
They've ...


 Bouncy car at motorway speeds?
I have a nissan micra 2005 and at about 60mph or higher, it becomes a bit bouncy, i feel like its bouncing all over the road and have to hold on very tight to the steering wheel.

is there ...


 Should I stop driving?
I passed my driving test a couple of months ago. It took me five attempts. I came home last Friday to collect my car and have been driving every day since then. Today I went on the motorway with my ...


 How many seconds is a safe distance when you're driving?
What says you? Why?...


 Poll Do you like traveling in the rain?
I drove for two hours today in the pouring rain,,,,,,I hate to drive in the rain! How about you?...


 I am going to teach my dog how to drive today. Should we start with automatic or stick shift?
I will operate the gas and brakes, of course....


 How do you deal with aggressive drivers when you're on the road?
...


 Can my daughter sit in the front of the car?
She is 9 but is still slightly under the required hieght to do without a booster seat.
This is not a problem but since the law changed she has always used her booster in the back.

We ...


 IMPORTANT!!!! please look.. its about speeding?
I just want to say something to everyone who is reading this.. and it would be much appriciated if you pass this on to everyone you know

im a 16 year old girl.living in a town wher mostly ...


 When to Signal on a Roundabout?
We're having this argument in work. Some guys think when you get on a roundabout you signal right until you turn off, then you stop signalling.

Some think you signal right when your ...


 Why Do People With 4X4's Drive Fast In The Snow?
Don't they realize they can't stop any faster than anyone else?...


 I'm interested in getting a scooter, but I have a 7 yr old daughter. Is it safe for her to ride with me?
I know scooters are fairly slow--most under 40 miles per hour. Is that safe for a child as a passenger?...


 Who is right? My boyfriend or me?
My boyfriend keeps saying that when you get to intersections that have stop signs and no traffic lights (including in mall parking lot areas), you have to guess your way through. I keep telling him ...


 Would you drink and drive?
Do you think it's kool to drink and drive If so why do you think it's kool to drink and drive?...


 What are the Little black box's on top of traffic lights are they sensors or cameras?
The sit on top of lights facing front of car and are about the size of childs shoe box and have black perspex on the front my mate and i have been trying having this discussion for years i think they ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, February 7, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024