Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Cars & Transportation Safety

Is it safe to drive with a winter tyre and a summer tyre on the same axle?
Find answers to your legal question.





Is it safe to drive with a winter tyre and a summer tyre on the same axle?

Bought some part worn tyres today, when i got home i noticed that the dealer had fitted a normal michilin tyre and a continental winter tyre, is this safe to drive on?


    




Moosey
Rating
TIRES


dadseimaj
Rating
NO NO NO!!!

You will fcuk up your handling BIG-TIME!

What on earth were you doing buying Part worn tyres? You don't know their age or history. If one of them has been run on flat or low pressure even for a short distance you run the risk of blowing the sidewall. If the date on the DOT code says it is five or more years old then the tyre is perished and no good.

Go to a tyre depot, get some NEW ones they won't cost you THAT much if you shop around.

When it comes to tyres, Always buy the best you can afford and DON'T try to do things via the scrappy. You'll end up in a ditch if you do.


markpwilms41m
No, it is not safe. You should not mismatch tires types and sizes. In other words, the front axle should have the same type and the back axle should have the same type.


italy_coolfun
No it is not safe. You want the same type tire, model, tread on the same axle. Anything else can cause erratic handling and possible loss of control/


LEX
Rating
Mate sorry to reply here as your mail is not open, thanks for your reply (rage thing) i had to delete it long story!!


support worker
Tread difference is NOT important..what is important is that you dont ever mix different condition tyres on the same axle.
Imagine if you had a formula one car on the track with mixed tyres there would be carnage.
They will have an impact on all round handling especially braking. Go to a recognised tyre agent not a cowboy. What is your life worth to you and your family


PAUL F
NO They have different compounds and very different road holding properties


bungee
Rating
not really


bass fishing
Rating
It depends o the tire type and size. If the winter tire has studs they maybe illegal for road use if there is no snow or ice. Also if they are dfferent sizes they will wear fast and could cause damage to your axles and ther drive componets


freddiem
Rating
I would not use a Michelin tyre with any other tyre on one axle but that is personal preference. Michelin is a premium brand and Continental a budget brand...another good reason.


Bardic
Rating
As long as they're the same size and aspect ratio, and the method of construction is the same they'll be legal.The latter part is the one that gives concern.
From a practical point of view the handling may well suffer too. Personally I'd never have different tyres on the same axle, and for that matter I wouldn't use part-worn tyres either as there is no way of telling what has happened to them in the past.
I appreciate money can be difficult, but if really pushed I'd go for new tyres from one of the "budget" manufacturers. You may not get startling performance or tread life from them but at least you know the casing doesn't have a hidden fracture or something.


Fordman
As long as the tires are the exact same size, then it shouldn't be a problem.

I advise against this though. I always replace the tires with the same size and type and brand on the same axle. To be honest, I always have 4 of the same tires on my truck or car.

I take it you are short on cash, or you would have gotten new tires. We all do what we have to, just to get by.


noruleschris
T Y R E S in england!

Its fine as long as one tyre is wet and the other is kept dry!


Feather
NO!! because the tread patterns give off a vibration that go down the axle and will eventually damage the ring gear on the differential (rear end).
not to mention different treads hold the road differently the snow (winter) will not hold the road as good as the summer
on winter tires you normally have metal spikes or studs installed in tire and will definately limit tire grip on the road.


Phil McCracken
Tyres (yes TYRES, English was invented in England, so our spellings are correct) should be identical on the same axle, and preferably all 4 (and the spare) should match. Tyres which do not match could result in an MoT test fail.


Fishermans Friend
If the tred patterns are the same no probs, if not go back and get them to change it, can cause damage to car or effect handling.


Chuck T
Rating
As long as both are the same size , have good tread and are inflated evenly it isn't a problem...





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 TOP GEAR : What's the point ?
On Top Gear just now Clarkson was sat in a car that drives itself. I just don't see the point in that. What would you do whilst sat in the drivers seat of a self driving car ?...


 How easy is the practical driving test to pass first time?

Additional Details
never mind ive just passed woo hoo ...


 Car jacking??
I'm Moving to Baytown Texas from the country in Mississippi.I have seen on the news last week of carjackings in the Baytown area.Have you ever been carjacked and what are some good precautions?...


 Why do people love to jump out of planes?
...


 What's better a Chevy or a Ford?
any card will be fine....


 Dont you think its dumb that you have to use a booster seat untill you are 4 foot 9??
im in freakin middle school and i barely dont need to use a booster seat! im 5 feet. in all the comercials it says that you should use a booster seat untill you are 4 foot 9. i think thats crazy! i ...


 My first driving lesson?
was just so scary and I was a wreck, everybody says practice will help me improve my confidence.. will it.. trying to remember gear changes, peddles just seems so complicated and being on a road with ...


 As a new driver, How can you decrease your risk of accidents on the motorway?
...


 My son just get driver license yesterday and he crashed the car today?
my teenage son just got his driver license from DMV yesterday and today he badly crashed the car. I sent him to driver's school, gave him several sessions of practice while i was seated with him,...


 Right turn on red?
Even if it's safe to make a right turn on red, can I stop and wait until the light turns green? Is this ok or I will be issued a ticket for blocking /impeding the traffic? I am curious about ...


 How many drunk driving accidents happens a year?
...


 Airplane disasters normally end up everyone's dead. Why don't we build escape pods to passenger airplanes?
Do we not have the technology?...


 Do you ever get annoyed when somebody in front of you insists on coming to a complete stop at a stop sign?
I mean, this is California. Come on! Wastes gas for one thing.
Additional Details
Thank you Sato, and Stooge, isn't it a little early for you to get deleted again?...


 Please help me, i need advice about parallel parking!?
I am taking my car test next month (UK), and am confident with everything EXCEPT parallel parking.
i just find it really hard!
My instructor has told me loads of times, but i just don'...


 Do no parking road restrictions need double yellow lines. for 2 yrs road has been used now 20 cars ticketed?
A road in aberdeen is used by many to park on to go to church cinema pub etc during the evening and has been for atleast 2 years. There is a no parking restriction at the start of the road but ...


 What is your 1 biggest pet peeve regardin driving habits of others?
Please select ony 1 -more than enough for all, I'm sure- and give reason. Be specific, not something like "lousy drivers". After much thought and an inward vote on this I decided mine ...


 Why do people try to find the closest parking space?
It's most annoying because they'll drive around in circles just so that they can find a spot that's twenty feet closer, for the time it takes to walk twenty feet, I could park in that ...


 Auto gears safer than manuals?
I am no stranger to manual gears having driven them for many many years however since using auto gears the last 15 years or so I find them safer especially when dicing with boy racers. whilst they�...


 Driving Behavior Question?
Does it bother you when people don't use their turn signal when they move back into the right lane after passing you on the expressway? It bothers me quite a bit. Don't know why but it ...


 What do you think of the new law out about the new child seats in cars?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Friday, May 25, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024