Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Cars & Transportation Safety

RE: Safest distance between vehicles.?
Find answers to your legal question.





RE: Safest distance between vehicles.?

I"ve read 6 excellent answers to my ? and 1 stupid one. However, my question still hasn"t really been answered. I asked "What is the safest MATHEMATICALLY distance between 2 vehicles traveling at 55 m.p.h.?". The 3 sec. rule, or the car-length rule? Assume both vehicles are similarly equipped.


    




Fred C
Rating
Much safer at 4 seconds. Even at 3, if the reaction time of the driver ahead is faster than you, and the tread depth is a little better than yours, you have a chance of rear-ending him in an emergency stop. One car length per 10 mph is going to be pretty close to the 3.5 second mark, but it is hard for the average person to guage car lengths. The car length rule was also established when full -size cars were a lot larger. 10 lengths of a 1958 Chevrolet is a lot different from 10 lengths of a 2001 Camry. The 2-second rule touted in some manuals really only is safe if you and the driver in front are both graduates of a performance driving school, no matter what anybody else says. Why? the AVERAGE reaction time is just over 2 seconds. Remember, to get that average, some have a 1.5 second reaction, but some have a time closer to 4 seconds. If that person is you, or the person behind you, guess who is going to be in an accident?


bigtendude
Rating
I was taught in driver's ed. in high school........ 1 car length per 10 mph. example 70mph. 7 car lengths.


goose
Rating
definately the 3 second rule. No matter how fast either car is going or the performance of the car. If you keep a 3 second cushion between you and the car ahead you will be much safer. 3 second rule-- When the car ahead of you passes a stationary object start counting seconds. When you pass that same stationary object stop counting and you will know how many seconds behind you are.


UCANTCME
Rating
Driver's Manual recommends a minimum 3-second following distance between your vehicle and the vehicle ahead of you.

This rule applies to passenger cars and light trucks traveling in ideal conditions.

When conditions are less than ideal, you must increase the amount of distance between you and the vehicle ahead of you.


1mom
I'd go with 3 seconds = 3seconds is always 3 seconds a car length can vary quite a bit


Geezer
60 mph is 88 feet per second, so you travel 264 feet in 3 seconds if you're going 60 mph. A car length is about 16 feet, so 264 feet is almost 17 car lengths -- a lot more than a car length for every 10 mph. A nice way to look at it is to decide how much time you want to give yourself to respond to something immediately ahead. I use the 2-second rule in clear, dry conditions. If someone is following me too closely, I leave more room in front, to reduce the chance that I might have to make a sudden maneuver.


Aerostar
The 3 second rule gives you more room.
1 car length per 10mph would be about 15' X 6 (60mph) = 90'
60mph = 88' per second. 3 seconds of distance gives you
triple the time to react. 55mph X 5280' / 3600secs = 80.6 fps
80.6 X 3sec = 242 feet for the 3 sec rule
15' X 5.5 = 82.5feet for the car-length rule (and many cars are
not even 15' long). The SAFEST distance is obviously the
greater distance. In order for 82 feet at 55mph to be safe,
you would have to be paying full attention ALL of the time.
If your reaction time exceeded 1.02 seconds, you would
collide with the car in front of you. If you're paying attention,
your reaction time would be about 0.6 seconds....less than
a half-second margin for error.


oklatom
Three second rules works for all speeds. As the vehicle in front passes a mark, count. If you get to 3 or better before you pass the mark, you are okay. If not, increase the distance. Also when stopped behind another vehicle, make sure you can see both rear tires which will tell you that you're far enough back to avoid hitting them should you be hit.


BFH
Rating
Three seconds.


loco_tech85
Rating
There are 2 unwritten rules regarding this matter, both of them can be found in the NYS Driver's Manual, but neither of them is actually printed into law.

The 2 rules are: either 1) 2-second rule (determine a fixed object and see if you can count to 2 while following another vehicle - if you do you're too close) and 2) 1 car length for every 10miles per hour on that roadways speed sign (in NYC highest speed is 50 mph - so 5 car lengths).

Both of these "theorems" should be expanded in the event of bad weather or operating a motorcycle or truck/tractor-trailer.

Unfortunately, neither of these explanations is used in the NYS Vehicle & Traffic Law pertaining to Following too Closely (tailgating).


anj_petro
Rating
It's 2 sec rule in day time and 4 sec in the night time.


mmszbi
Rating
The 2-3 second rule is the best in my opinion. The reason is that the distance is directly tied to the speed the vehicles are traveling. The higher the speed, the greater the distance. When in doubt, add a couple seconds and increase your reaction time. In bad weather, add another couple seconds. I drive semi trucks for a living, and generally use a 6 second rule on good roads.


jack w
Rating
your are traveling at 10.9 feet per second = one hundred and nine feet


Denise S
Rating
The car length rule, and I don't have time to do the math, I have to go to church. GOD BLESS ....:0)





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Asians are bad drivers!!!!!!! yes or no?
your opinion...i believe yes, especially women. I am not stereotypical it is just the truth....


 What would happen if you ran into the side of a speeding train head first?
From the platform!!...


 Is tailgating while driving considered assault? What rights do we have to defend ourselves?
I was wondering about this because tailgating is one of the most dangerous and common issues on the roads, and nearly always goes without consequence or deterrence. I am aware that retaliation after-...


 Which is the safest place to sit in a car?
...


 Car Accident - who is at fault?
i got in my car, drove to the end of the road and stopped, wanting to turn left into a main road, i look right and there is traffic coming. so i wait, while waiting a car parked in the main road on ...


 Why is it that our roads are so lumpy? Can't the government build a proper road?
We can send a man to the moon but still, no one know how to build a road that won't lump up in the winter.
Additional Details
BUT EVEN WHEN THEY DO CONSTRUCT THE ROADS THEY DO A CRAP...


 Are cats safe on car rides?
I love bringing my kitty with me in the car when I run around town. Is that safe for cats? I know it's not for my chinchilla's, with them being so fragile. So, I'm just making sure it&#...


 Whatever happened to the rule for driving, that you stay back 1 car length for every 10 mph you're going ?
I NEVER see anyone doing that any more...It's safer, but if you don't watch it & you're hanging back, someone will jump right in front of you....


 Question regarding car crash death?
Hi everyone,

Last Saturday a friend of mine died in a car crash. He was 19 years old.

He crashed on an unfinished part of a country road, so the surface just had stones on it. H...


 What is the most outrageous or dangerous thing you've seen another driver do?
We've all seen women putting on their makeup while driving, or someone reading the paper while in traffic. So what's the most unusual, outrageous or scary/dangerous thing you've ever ...


 Is it true that driving on the backstreets uses more gas than the same distance on the freeway?
...


 Is it considered child endangerment to let a 13 yr old drive?
If A childs parent allows or is teaching the child to drive at the age of 13 and the Police pulls them over to a stop and the child is in the drivers seat. what are the consequence
Additional D...


 How can a friend stop static shocks from the car?
...


 If im traveling in the opposite direction of the way the speed camara is pointing can i still get flashed?

Additional Details
it flashed as i went past but it could have captured a motor going in the opposite direction to me ( the way the camara is pointing) and it is a fixed ...


 Driveway blocking an entrance laws and procedures ?
A guy in my street has a driveway with a dropped curb, last night I parked my car and it WAS NOT blocking entrance to his drive way at all..but he decided he wanted to park his car outside his ...


 Which is worse: driving too slow or too fast?
...


 Should you turn off your cell phone at the gas pump?
...


 How do you study for the written part of the driving test?
I live in Ohio and I wanted to know how to study for the written part of the driving ...


 Would you stop to help an injured dog?
My husband and I stopped to help an injured dog. We turned our flashers on, so that no one else would hit him, and tried to see how badly he was hurt (he looked fine except that he was lying in the ...


 Where can I find something for Grandma when parking in the garage so she doesn't run into the back wall?
She pulls in and cannot judge the distance well. Hanging the tennis ball to touch the windshield didn't work, and putting in a concrete curb may not work. Maybe some kind of light like a ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Saturday, May 26, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024