Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Cars & Transportation Safety

Should senior citizens be banned from driving after a certain age?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should senior citizens be banned from driving after a certain age?

i heard someone suggest on the news that senior citizens should be legally banned from driving and be given free access to ride the bus once they reach the cut off age (probably between 70-80). this is to avoid many auto accidendts caused by senior citizens each year. your opinion?
here's a video to look at also.. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MjgPNeT5SKw


    




Mish
Short answer: yes. Long answer: yes and no. In an ideal world we would have a system in place to individually assess drivers as they reach a predetermined age, and that would decided which are still able to drive and which are not. That's just not feasible with the system setup now, so it would be safer to just cut people off. Not to mention it would cut down on traffic and pollution. Great question!


bungee
age should have nothing to do with it. what should matter is driving ability. all you need to do is read the questions on this thread and you have to wonder how any young people even can get their license.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,


dirtytricksracing@sbcglobal.net
Rating
If we do that then the minimal age for getting a drivers license should be raised nationally to 25 and be tested every year. The drivers 25 to 15 are one of the biggest dangers on the road. If for no other reason is they do not seem to be able to drive with out talking on some kind of phone and now they have to watch DVD's while they drive.


nj2pa2nc
Rating
that would be considered age discrimination. I think all driver's should be tested every few years. Bad drivers come in all ages.


mscherpenberg
I think many seniors are not capable of driving at that age and many need to have their licenses pulled sooner. There are plenty of people that are not safe at any age. The argument could also be made on the other end for young drivers and that the age should be raised. I think the real solution is to perhaps start retesting them increasingly more often to make sure they are still capable drivers. There are some senior citizens in their 90s that are perfectly capable drivers so it isn't completely fair to make assumptions about capability based on age. Why banned someone who has no problems and is a perfectly alert and capable driver just because of his or her age?


Rob
I don't think age is the issue. I know a guy that is about to turn 90. still in excellent physical and mental condition. the guy could run a marathon if he wanted to. I think that they should be required to retake a driving test if pulled over though. this should however be applied to anyone who holds a license regardless of age. I have seen people well under 50 that shouldn't be driving.


UCANTCME
If they can prove that they are able to drive and are of sound mind and judgment then NO.........

The reason is that most car accidents are by teens from 15 to 21 years of age so should they be banned ???


MiMi
I don't think that picking an age is a good idea. Each senior should be licensed to drive according to their mental and physical capabilities. Some are not good drivers at 55 and some are great at 90.


popeye
Rating
that old bag in the video is proof that senior citizens should at least be tested every year. their just as dangerous as a young driver who drank one too many.


Hruth
Rating
No, of course not, that's ageist.

Once you turn 50, you should have to retake your license test every 5 years, once you turn 70, that should be every two years, and after 80 you should have to pass the test every year along with a note from your doctor saying you are fit to drive.

That way the seniors who can drive aren't discriminated against, and the ones who can't drive, don't.


blahblahblahblahblah
Rating
I think they should be retested after a certain age but to ban them is just wrong. My grandpa is 83 and a good driver, he drives 7 hours to come visit us at least 4 times a year. Perhaps make them get their eyes checked and retake the driving portion of their test every 2 years after 65.


raha
Rating
Age is not a matter what matters is the persons ability &health condition,Regan led nation aging more than 70 Mcain may now ,they are seniors can they lead a nation but not a car





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Car crash what casses them to happen?
...


 Would God give me signs and signals?
If I wanted to receive an answer from God.. So on some paper I wrote either Yes or No for instance to a question that I had and I wanted it to be answered. So I would prayer to God.. ie God am I ...


 Any know a trick for not getting ticketed for not wearing your seatbelt?
if you get pulled over before he sees you arnt wearing ...


 Why do people run red lights and stop signs?
...


 Is it illegal to drive in bald feet, or must you wear shoes and socklets?
...


 My windscreen fogs up ... best way to prevent it ?
It is winter in london.
every morning i have to suffer with a fogged windscreen as soon as i put the heater. t
he only way out is for me to put the heater and airconditioner on. that ...


 HGV Stopping?
I was driving a artic and the lights changed to red and got flashed iv recived the fine and points. thats ok now the but
if i had tryed to stop i would have blocked the road junction and shot ...


 Cars driving through the green man?
Where would i contact to complain about cars driving through a red light (green man is up for pedestrians). this happens every morning at the same place at least two cars go through the traffic ...


 When an emergency vehicle approches, you should stop immediately wherever you are on the road. Is it true?
...


 Driving/mobile phones?
I think the current legislation is reasonable, but why is it wrong to phone, but ok to light up whilst driving?
Playing with fire whilst driving? Now THAT sounds ...


 Can you duble buckle if you can not how do you fit 5 people in a 4 seated car?
my sister is coming from california for christmas and we want to bring my ...


 Is it legal to hit a car if it's blocking your driveway?
Is this legal or illegal in College Station, Texas? I live in a residential neighborhood and usually when my neighbors have company they park in front of our house. Well a couple of time someones ...


 Why is ambulance spelled backwards on the front of all ambulance?
...


 Is there any law about driving with the boot open (when moving furniture for example)?
I need to pick up some bulky furntiure, and won't be able to close the boot so will have to tie it down (and some bits will be protruding). Is this actually legal? Any adivce on safest way to ...


 Have you been in a automobile accident before, me yes?
...


 At what minimum speed can an automobile's cruise control be activated?
...


 Smoking at the gas pump???
Is there any possible way to start a fire smoking a cig at a gas pump? Just with the cig? Or sparks from when someone flicks the butt?

I was at the station and a kid was puffing away... I ...


 What do you think all women should know about maintenance on their cars?
I have to put together a PowerPoint on "what women should know about maintenance on cars" and I was wondering wht other people felt is necessary. So please tell or give sites ln what you ...


 Why do i only have to use one foot when driving?
Ok i am going to turn 16 in like 1 month and when i go back to the states i am getting my license. So my question is why do i have to use only one foot when driving an automatic? will it cause an ...


 Car accident, how should I deal with this?
The girl that hit us is at fault. She hired a lawyer, avoid all our calls, we're waiting for the police report. I believe that the officer would put her at fault. Should I still hire a lawyer? I&...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Friday, May 25, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024