Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Cars & Transportation Safety

Sould smoking be banned while driving?
Find answers to your legal question.





Sould smoking be banned while driving?

Just like it is illegal to use your mobile phone. Think about it, it is just as dangerous if not more so. How do you light it safely, say what you like but I don't think it is very safe.


    




FuturisticKid
Rating
It's a subject I have debated many times in the past and yes I would say yes it should be banned.

I class it as a distraction to drivers, the passangers and others on the road while driving just like mobile phones and even eating in the car which I believe someone got fined for eating an apple once - bizarre.

So yes I would be all for it! I am not trying to take smoking away from people but isn't driving to focus on where you're getting and looking out on the road instead of lighting one up and puffing away?


literarytony
Rating
Anything which can take a drivers attention off the road should be considered unsafe and looked at very carefully. Banning is a strong word and is all too easily brought into these types of debates, though sometimes it is justified.

Personally i would bring in a law which says if you must smoke whilst out on the road, then pull over and stop to do so. If you need the nicotene stick to calm yourself, for example, then you are not in the best state for driving anyway. Drivers would be expected to pull over if they had to make a phonecall and do not have a hands free kit, so the same principle could apply to smoking.


LOVELY LEGS 11
Rating
Smoking SHOULD be banned when driving.

Driving requires your 100% attention and with a ciggy in your hand/gob your attention is only 50-50.

BAN SMOKING on the roads,in all pubs/clubs,hospitals etc.


Grizz
Hi

I think smoking should be banned full stop, and further more, anyone who smokes in the vicinity of a none smoker should be prosecuted for willful endangerment because they KNOW they could be causing serious life threatening damage.

If you purposefully rammed someone in your car and they survived and intent was proven you would be done for attempted murder because you knew your actions could kill them.

Geordie


shogun_316
The thing they should ban is tossing the butts out the window. should be a $1000 fine. Let em kill themselves by smoking.

I knew a person who said they didn't like using the ashtray because it caused the car to smell. ?!?!?!?!?! How stupid is that?


Statto
Yes
Especially if there are children in the car.
Opening a window isnt good enough.
Do these people not care about their children when their own pleasure might get disrupted.
Makes me sick.
But.
I do think people should be allowed to smoke.
At least it keeps the population down, almost as well as religion does.
Everyone should have the right to do anything to themselves as long as it does not affect anyone else. That includes smoking.
Every packet should an even bigger warning saying you will not get treted for smoking related illnesses on the NHS. No matter how skint you are.


sharkgirl
It uses a hand that should be on the wheel. But then I guess...should they ban eating while you are driving, nose picking, blowing your nose....it's all the same really


Atheist
Rating
In my eyes, smoking should be banned entirely. It kills millions of people a year, even children.


Smoking is a horrible, terrible, aweful habit to begin.


But, that's just my opinion.


tturbod2001
I've been driving professionally for about 38 years, no accidents and I have been smoking even longer.Using a cell phone takes your mind off your driving , So no to the smoking band.Maybe next they will not allow you to use the radio, cd player, and the like.I've seen DVD players mounted in Dashboards.Now, How dangerous is that?


Rachael H
Rating
Very interesting question and one I've often pondered on myself. Incidentally I am a smoker (not proud of it). In the news recently someone was fined for throwing a cigarette end out of the car window. Another incident someone was fined for flicking ash out of their window (yes, honestly). This means that drivers are now being forced to use their ash trays in the car which, as I'm sure even a non smoker knows, is well out of their line of sight.
As a smoker I am very "torn". I wish to continue smoking whilst I'm driving (although I don't do it a lot). I do not condone littering and, to an extent, agree that cigarettes should not be thrown out of car windows (although I think not flicking ash out is taking it a bit far) yet I think it is potentially dangerous to try and stub a cigarette out in the ashtray whilst travelling at xxmph.
So there you go - the answer to your question is probably, yes. And that's from a smoker.


racyragtop
Why stop at smoking - I find changing gear, using the indicators, looking in the rear view mirror, winding down the window and checking the speedo all equally distracting - maybe we should ban these as well.


pinu
Rating
Logically it should be banned b'cos apart from the ills of smoking known to everyone, smoking in cars can be a source of distraction( especially if u r lighting one while driving) & may lead to a crash.
While many long time car smokers may scoff at the idea but its taking precautions which can avoid the inevitable.
Its like the good ol' saying ' Smoking in bed is dangerous. The ashes that fall could be your own!'


Elle J Morgan
Yes it should be banned
If tuning the radio or playing a cd or eating is driving without due care and attention then so should smoking be


musonic
The fascists are everywhere aren't they?

I've been smoking and driving for about 2,000,000 miles, and apart from setting myself on fire briefly, I haven't had an accident.

I don't suppose the person who asked the question will give this a thumbs up, so let's see how many smoking fascists give it a thumbs-down.


ferrari16329
Rating
if it would be banned, road rage would be a problem. if smokers wont get tehre smokes especially in traffic, alot of people will be shot. lol


bumblecherry
Quite - but what about picking your nose or scratching your bits?


Rene B
Rating
I smoke but I don't do it while driving. Somehow, I don't like the smell of stale cigarette smoke inside the cars.


Bud#21
Rating
If they ban smoking while driving, it will just be a matter of time before they ban smoking while putting.


Julius C
Rating
Hell no smoking should not be banned, I find when I'm driving home drunk off my *** its the only thing that keeps me conscience.


drapper25
Rating
no


gashfingerer
Rating
You numbnutts





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why is it illegal to wear headphones while driving an automobile in most states?
All states allow the deaf to obtain a license and drive all types of vehicles....


 Should elderly people drive?
...


 I was driving in America and cars passed me on the right side, is it legal?
In Europe it's illegal to pass on the right side, they can pass only on the left side, especially on the speed way. Is it legal in America?
Additional Details
I wasn't driving ...


 Is it possable to take driving lessons in a automatic car?
...


 Can a dog drive a car?
I brought Max to this party. Now I am drunk, but he is still sober. Is it OK for him to dive my car?...


 Why is drunk driving illegal?
Most friends of mine drive cautiously after a few drinks, because they don't want to be caught. Would a slightly inebriated requirement reduce traffic accident rates? Are there any studies for ...


 I passed my driving test a month ago and......?
I have not bothered to put P plates on but i do seem to keep on making minor mistakes,like stalling or leaving bloody indicators on but i seem to notice ppl bibbing at me and it knocks my confidence ...


 Why are women drivers SO BAD at parking?
Well the majority of them anyway. Aren't we all meant to be equal?...


 WOULD THIS CAR BE SAFE...?
would this car be safe for a new born?
i like the blue model but in black. plz dont suggest some crap car like a honda or a toyota. plz make suggestions of normal looking cars if you dont find ...


 What is 4-wheel drive?
...


 Whats ur opinon on the law that states, you can not waer headphones while driving?
please tell ...


 I have a cast on my right leg. Is it illegal for me to drive my automatic car with my left foot?
I am recovering from ankle surgery and am not allowed to be out of this cast for about 3.5 more weeks. Is it illegal for me to drive in the state of Virginia only using my left foot?...


 I have a driving test tommorrow...any advice???
This is my 8th test I think. The last four or five times I have failed on one thing. My last test I had 3 minor errors (Your allowed 15) right up till a few mins before the end. I was going down a ...


 Should cruise control be outlawed?
What it does, is keep the car going fast, after a driver falls asleep.
Without cruise control ,all cars would slow down after the driver stopped holding down the gas pedal. Cruise control makes ...


 UK ONLY- What lights do i need to use when driving at night?
Hello

I've only just passed my test and purchased a car today, I want to be able to drive at night, but am getting a bit confused by the lights.

I have the following to ...


 Have you ever been flashed by a speed camera?
I was doing under the speed limit due to poor visibility but still got flashed. There was a guy standing against the camera at the time that it flashed but I couldnt see what he was doing.
Im ...


 Why do 4x4 owners still fit bull bars when they no it increases the chances of killing persons they might hit?
...


 Turnabout in driving test?
Is it ok to cross your hands when steering when doing the turnabout in your driving test? I have my test in the morning (friday) and I'm getting mixed answers from people I have asked....


 Fact or myth? using celfone while filling up your gas tank will cause an explosion?
...


 I had a dream about my daughter being in a car accident??
I had a dream that my daughter was in a car accident. I saw her in the backseat, and a guy and girl were in the front seats. I saw the other car crash, and I saw my dead daughter on the side of the ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Saturday, May 26, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.004