Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Cars & Transportation Safety

Who has the right-of-way?
Find answers to your legal question.





Who has the right-of-way?

One car is traveling slower than the speed limit on a road that is freshly covered in snow. Another car who is in a blind driveway backs out in reverse. There is limited visibility. The car on the road going on average 20-30mph slams on the brakes at a far distance (determined by skid tracks in the snow), the ABS kicks in but to no avail hits the car coming out of the driveway. The person coming out of the driveway claims the other driver was speeding, the other party denies it and blames it on the slippery conditions. That same night many other accidents happened because of the snow and limited visibility. Who was in error in this accident?


    




mayberrynut
Lets put this in to perspective. I'm in my car driving down a snow covered road and you are backing out of your driveway. I don't think as a veteran Police Officer this is a hard question to answer. I live in VA and there is a code that states you must yield the right of way to oncoming traffic in the street when pulling from a private driveway. See below.

§ 46.2-826. Stop before entering public highway or sidewalk from private road, etc.; yielding right-of-way.

The driver of a vehicle entering a public highway or sidewalk from a private road, driveway, alley, or building shall stop immediately before entering such highway or sidewalk and yield the right-of-way to vehicles approaching on such public highway and to pedestrians or vehicles approaching on such public sidewalk.

The provisions of this section shall not apply at an intersection of public and private roads controlled by a traffic signal. At any such intersection, all movement of traffic into and through the intersection shall be controlled by the traffic signal.
Whoever pulled our of the driveway is at fault. There is no way a judge would rule in favor of the driver from the driveway for a couple of reasons:
1. Why would you pull out in front of a speeding car?
2. You can't judge the speed of a vehicle just by looking at it.
3. It's like any other intersection the vehicle already i the road has the right of way.


Blue2Grey
Rating
The car on the road has the right of way... Despite what the person backing out of the driveway states.


somdmom22
The car on the road has the right of way.
Doesn't matter that the other car has a blind driveway. They yeild to you... You have the right of way reguardless of road conditions or speed.


import guy
well the car going down the road obviously has the right of way over someone backing out of their drive way.... wtf were the people backing out of their driveway thinking? what, everybody should stop for them?
good luck


Southern Girl
The ERROR falls on the driveway guy.
He can't back into traffic. Residential speed is 25mph. but slower in bad weather.


gldjns
The person on the road has the right of way over someone backing out of a driveway, regardless of weather conditions. If the driver of the car on the road was well under the speed limit, and did start braking at a considerable distance, he was not at fault. On the other hand, the person backing out should have been extra careful, looking in both directions and in the mirrors, to make sure there was no oncoming traffic. He evidently did not, so I'd say he is to blame for the accident. I've seen a lot of drivers throw their cars in reverse and peel out of their driveways as though they were in the Indianapolis Speedway, with no regard whatsoever to oncoming traffic, forcing drivers to slam on their brakes or risk hitting the offender and possibly creating a pile-up.


Pimpin John
I believe the police will side with the person on the road, unless evidence of speeding or unsafe driving exists.


wmwiv
Rating
The easy answer is that the vehicle in the roadway has the right of way over the vehicle exiting the driveway. Obviously other factors may come in to play but in its most basic form a driver entering a roadway always has to yield to the oncoming traffic exlusive of any traffic signals or directional devices to the contrary. On a side note, it is very possible that the driver on the main road could potentially be liable if it was determined that he lost control of his vehicle and that failure to maintain control was the proximate cause of the accident.


Badcock
The guy who was backing out is at fault.


doug_servicetek
Rating
the driver on the road always has the right regardless of speed of driver or road conditions.

it is the responsiblity of drivers exiting out of a drive way to have a clear view and judgement to enter a road.
if he could not see it is still fault of driver exiting the driveway.as this happen to me from a blind spot and I was charged.


dreynolds699
Rating
the person backing into traffic lanes is at fault he was entering the lane ,it is the same as if they are making a left turn across a lane of traffic and struck by on coming traffic they are at fault, as a driver you do not have the right of way when entering a lane of traffic while making a right or left turn
or pulling out or backing out of a driveway


UCANTCME
The vehicle that driving on the road will always have the right of way, its the law.


cul8r_32
Rating
it is the fault of the person who is backing up. They should use extra caution when puling out of the driveway since it is a "blind" driveway, and obviously the person who was already on the street was trying to avoid the accident, and using caution determined by the speed limit and skid marks from trying to stop.OF course, no one is going to admit fault, and no one should slam on their brakes anyhow. people have to pump the brakes in slippery conditions.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Is it really worth it to take driving lessons?
I have my class 7 learners and I will be going for my class 5 within the next month or so. Basically, I want to know if anyone has taken professional lessons and if they really feel that they are ...


 I need to know if the car accident i was involved in was my fault??
I was driving on a snowy freeway doing about 35-40mph. The lane i was in wasnt plowed very well so i ended up swerving and doing a 360 and ended up facing the oncoming traffic. But i didnt hit ...


 Does driving ever get easier? PLEASE ANSWER!?
so i have my permit and stuff and today was my first driving lesson with my instructor and and was a LITTLE hard, but i'm just wondering, will driving get easier over time?
please answer. <...


 Do large trucks have good visibility with their mirrors?
Several times i have been driving and i'll be beside a truck and they'll try to change lanes on top of me! i drive a fairly low down car - 300zx and i am wondering if the trucks can't ...


 Trying to find a good car seat. I'm in between two right now Recaro Signo or Britax Boulevard?
Money is not a problem when it comes to safty therefore I just want to know which one is better and why....


 When did using turn signals become an option rather than a regulation?
I drive quite a bit for work and am sick to death of people not following the rules of the road and this particular on really gets to me. Does it get to you too?
Additional Details
UCANT...


 Is a crash course better than doing driving lessons?
...


 How do i get a coppyright on my ideas?
...


 I think my GPS tried to kill me, what do you think?
I was driving an isolated mountain road near Zion National Park and my Tom Tom gps told me to make a right turn 100 feet ahead, that would have taken me flying off a killer of a cliff. Thank the ...


 I slid on blackice on the highway and flew off the road. What would have happened if I hit the trees?
I keep going through this in my mind. I skidded off the road after hitting black ice---flew through the air and wound up in a ditch about 1/8th of an inch from trees. I only hurt my arm. What would ...


 Why should you check your rear view mirror before you brake to a stop?
...


 Why do people race to the next red light?
...


 Should the driving age be raised to 18? Why or why not?
This is for my research paper. Any info you can give me would help. ...


 Who goes first on a 3 way stop sign?
I know about 4 way that whosoever comes first goes first. But I am a liitle bit confused about the 3 way? Is it right that 3 way and 4 way are similar....


 This ignorant son of a gun cut me off while he was hitting the road and he just stares at me?
i should have honk him , but i didnt...omg...and while he was trying to hit the road he couldnt control his dumb car , and i almost rear ended that retard , he should have just wait until my car ...


 Who has the right of way in traffic circles in the United States?
We have one at my apartment complex in Oklahoma City. Today I entered the circle when nobody else was around. Then this person comes up to the circle right as I'm about to go around, and ...


 Does wearing sunglasses when driving in heavy rain help increase visibility?
I don't know if this is a myth. A Malaysian policeman told a friend recently that wearing sunglasses in a heavy downpour makes it perfectly visible as if there were no rain....


 A huge spider fell on me while was sitting in the passenger seat of hubbys' car yesterday.....?
I had the screaming abdabs and made him stop the car there and then. We'd been taking rubbish to the skip and it got in with me. Well, I'll stop rambling, but would my husband have been ...


 Slippery Roads?
Is it true that the roads are more slippery after the first rain of the wet season? Like if it hasn't rained in a really long time will the roads be more slippery than after it has rained a few ...


 Have you ever parked in a handicap parking spot?
even though you aren't supposed to?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Saturday, May 26, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034