Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Cars & Transportation Safety

Would you stop to help an injured dog?
Find answers to your legal question.





Would you stop to help an injured dog?

My husband and I stopped to help an injured dog. We turned our flashers on, so that no one else would hit him, and tried to see how badly he was hurt (he looked fine except that he was lying in the middle of the road). Another woman (with a large truck) also had her flashers on and she'd called the humane society so we were waiting on them. Anyway while we were standing there a 16 yr. old kid slammed into our car and totalled it. We were very blessed that he hit the car at an angle so it went into the ladies truck otherwise it would have kept going and killed all of us (the idiot didn't even try to break). I've since been told that it is unadvisable to stop for wounded animals as this sort of thing happens alot.

So, knowing this, would you stop to help an injured dog in the middle of the road?
Additional Details
This was on a residential street with high visibility.


    




Sahara
I don't care. I would stop to help an injured animal. I might try to move it though to get it out of harm's way. I hope that kid lost his license because he doesn't deserve the privilege. If he was my son, he would have lost the car. I would have punished him severely for his irresponsibility. I'm so glad that you all were not killed.

My mom stopped for a family of ducks like all of the other drivers on the divided highway (busy shopping area, lots of traffic lights). This stupid hispanic driver slammed into us. He had plenty of time to stop. I looked in the rearview mirror and saw him. He didn't think we should have stopped. He had the nerve to ask to borrow my cell phone which I reluctantly did but I reamed him for his behavior. We called the police. We had other drivers waiting with us. The family of ducks were fine. His license said VT and it wasn't even his car. I think he was illegal because his license didn't look quite right. I'm not an expert but it looked like it had been through a lot.

I would say in the future to do what you can to be safe because those drivers are out there that are only about themselves and no one else. How he got his license is news to me but he must be able to lie well.


s.w
Rating
yes, i would stop to help any injured animal. maybe this kind of thing happens alot, but i could not stand to just drive by and let a poor animal just lay there and suffer


.
Rating
Yes, I would and have helped many injured animals over the many years I have been alive and most likely will continue to do so.


Ryde on
Rating
Yes, but I wouldn't leave my truck in the lanes of traffic, instead I'd put the dog on a blanket or tarp and carry or drag him to the side of the road.

As far as liability, it's still the kid that hit you at fault, consider if you had simply stalled.


UCANTCME
Rating
Yes, I still would stop because a dog is just like a human and if you pass it by, then dont expect help from others..


kenbgray
Rating
Yes I would and I have a number of times. I also stop for cats. I think in this state(ma.) you have to stop for a dog, but not a cat. Having had many a dog in my life, I figure if the dog was driving, he would stop for me. I love animals.


logicalgal
Rating
Yes, I would stop.


thud.fan
Rating
Depends on what kind of road...If on a highway, definitely not, since most animal fatalities are because the animal jumped out of the moving vehicle - the driver should be shot...If I can render aid without putting myself or others in danger, then I would...Bottom line is if I do stop, especially on a blind curve or a place with limited visibility, I would make sure that enough warning is given back up the road to let approaching drivers know to slow down.


JAJ
Rating
Yes, I would stop. My mom and I stopped one day to help a dog that was in the road and he seemed to be having trouble walking. We thought he got hit by a car. The dog could barely hold his head up. We were about 2 miles from home, it was raining and it was starting to get dark so we decided to take the dog home with us. After we got home we realized the dog was not injured.

The dog was having trouble walking because it was so weak. The poor thing was extremely skinny and starving to death. We had to spoon feed the him because he would not eat on his own. Since the dog did not have a home we decided to keep him. We named him Lucky.

I have told this story to all my friends and family and I was surprised that several of them told me that they wouldn't have stopped. There was no way I could have kept going. Something just told me that I had to stop that day and see about that dog.


tracker101
I for one would stop for injured dog or cat and yes accidents like that all the time people don't think ahead and a 16 yr old has no brains anyhow??


Wolf Harper
Rating
It's a judgment call whether you can rescue the animal safely given traffic conditions. If it's not safe (or even if it is), it's almost certainly better to call the authorities, they'll come out with emergency vehicles with sirens and flashing lights, and they'll do a job and take risks they're paid to do (which you are not).

You're not more a hero because you refused to call for help. That's a myth. In fact, by not involving the authorities there's a fair chance you're actually stealing a pet from another loving family who misses it.

If you care about the animal, follow its path through the animal control system, ask to adopt the animal, and you'll surely get it, unless the real owners are found.


Wykydtron
Rating
depends on the road I'm on! The time, and If I have my kids in the car. But the biggest thing is if this dog is going to make it can you afford the bill? If you take that do to the animal hospital it is YOUR bill. Now it seems a bit harsh Im a dog lover and I have 6 dogs. The only time I would stop if I noticed a collar so I could call the owner. Now someone will always stop! If the dog is still alive you know someone will stop I see it all the time.


Adacadus
If the animal is big enough to cause an accident by sitting in the road:

Stop, hazards on and kick/push/scare it out of the way. If it's badly injured, take a shotgun and stick two barrels through it's head. It will thrash as the brain dies first, and then you can move it. You cannot take it away with you as it would be poaching.

If it's not big enough to warrent the above, it is dangerous and stupid to bother. Phone the RSPCA and let them risk THEIR lives for a dead dog.


bungee
if I did I would move the animal to the side of the road. its never a good Idea to block traffic lanes you know this now don't you.


helloyou
yes i would because its the right thing to do instead of all of you stupid people who think it isnt okay. what if you were the dog?





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Whats the best type of car to drive?
I always wanted to drive a honda but people tell me thay give off so much problems and then i wanted a acura but i heard the same, so now i settled fot a Volkswagen jetta did i make a good choice ...


 Can you get caught by a speed camera on the other side?
In the UK, if the speed camera is on one side of the road but you are driving in the opposite direction, i know you can be flashed if your going over 30, but can you get done for it? (the lines are ...


 Who's to blame for this car accident?
Ok I was going into wal-mart; I cut threw the parking lot "Is it wrong to cut threw the parking lot an hurt my chances of winning this case?" I only cut threw 2 parking lots and made sure ...


 When backing out of a drive way and a car hits you whos at fault?
i was backing out of my apt into an alley, and a car stop and hits my car and a pole. (other car going to fast) who is @ fault?
Additional Details
_____other person did admit to being in ...


 Gas overspill at the pump?
i was pumping my gas today and just as it began to seem more expensive then normal, it spilled over and kept going. i had gas all over me, my car and the ground. a large puddle. my car still reeks of ...


 I'm born in 1992, May.. When can I drive? Cos like hasn't the driving age risen to 18?
...


 Do you think we could reduce road rage by developing more pleasant sounding car horns?

Additional Details
Wow! I guess people really hate this idea. Just to clarify, I'm not suggesting a change in volume, just the tone. Sometimes in a dangerous situation you ...


 What's up w/people in cars on the roads resting their nasty, bare feet on the dashboard???
...


 There are a lot of why’s in the world so let’s see some good answers to these?
Why are cars made to go faster, when we have roads that are so congested that speed is not essential? The technology is there so get rid of speed cameras, and fit devises on to cars to make them ...


 What pisses u off about drivers?
What do they do that annoys you so much?

Im sick of drivers who try to keep the speed limit going down a hill as well as up a hill. IT DSNT WORK LIKE THAT!!!!...


 Confusion about right of way at stop signs?
Sometimes I make a mistake & don't realize that the driver of the other car arrived at a stop sign just a split second before I did. Or sometimes I don't notice that I arrived there ...


 What would you do if you got stranded in some remote area and encountered a freak with pony tails&dark eyes?
...


 I am a new driver and I always drive really close to the curb.. how can I fix this?
...


 If I am joining a 3 lane roundabout from a 2 lane road, which lane should I be in to turn right?
Have a look at this airial photograph of an example situation.
In this case I need to be in the middle lane.
www.psychoholiday.com/partyblogs/work/......


 What will happen if petrol will go in diesel car?
SHELL(or someone else) gave an idea to use different nozzles for petrol and diesel. Need more info........


 I just done a 90mph super power wheelie on my motorcycle and fell off... Why is this?
...


 If I have a blow out in my car travailing at 70mph,what is the best course of action ?
If I have a blow out in my car travailing at 70mph,what is the best course of action ?...


 Motorcycle helmet laws...good or bad? Do you wear or not?
I ride; have for many years. I wear a full-face helmet because I know what the road can do to your head and brain. I have been down at highway speed and wore the paint off my Bell Star XL but not ...


 Im a good driver do everything right in driving lessons then get to my test and fail!!1 HELP my 4th test soon?
I am about to take my 4th test and cant stop making silly mistakes when doing my test, nerves have got me a couple of times but today i believe i did ok other than getting a serious for my ...


 How to safely drive in snow?
whats the safest way to drive in the snow if you have to go out. I get very scared especially when I feel the car slide....




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Saturday, May 26, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.054