Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Child Adoption

Adoptees, enough, or too much?
Find answers to your legal question.





Adoptees, enough, or too much?

I am curious, adoptees, while growing up (and even now) do you feel as though there wasn't enough focus (by family and friends) on the fact that you were adopted?

Or, do you feel as though there was TOO MUCH focus on that fact?
Additional Details
ETA: Great responses, thanks.

ETA2: Dory, you bring up a very good question, which is one of the reasons why I was thinking about this. The reason why some people might leave it up to the children to bring up might be because the parents don't want to take the chance in the child/ren thinking it's a huge issue for THEM. Of course if it's a huge issue for the CHILD, I would want to bring it up as much as it takes to help as much as I can.

An example might be, my brother was diagnosed with cancer a few years ago. He is the type of person who doesn't talk too deeply, too often. I approached him to let him know that I am there for him any time to talk, when HE's ready, but that I didn't want to bug him about it, or keep the 'wound' open all the time. Not that I wanted him to be the one to bring it up all the time, or for him to think I had forgotten. But, I didn't want to bring it up, if he wasn't in the mood to deal with it at that time.


    




Minnimouse
about right, but a couple of things i had issues were was my parents saying "before she was born" etc as if they saw me being born or something. that kind of ticked me off, seems silly in a practical sense because it IS before I was born, but they weren't there to witness it so it seems odd for them to talk about me existing to them when they didnt even know I existed until I was 5 months old. Sometimes they would say "before (my name insterted)" which felt better, before i existed to them not before i was born.

the other thing was it's all great to talk about me being adopted but they hardly talked about anything ABOUT my adoption, they didnt even tell me I was fostered until I suddenly had a memory of when I was fostered into their home (yes) when I was 5 months old. I asked them whether this memory was true and they said yes and obviously couldnt believe i remembered it. I remember it as vivid as it happened yesterday. I also discovered MANY facts about my adoption via snooping. My parents needed to tell me more about my adoption experience not just say that i was adopted.

My parents did an okay job though, they tried their best. However, by not talking about it much it meant I felt pressured to hold in my feelings.

Jessica, I don't cry and sob at funerals too for my relatives, I always thought I was heartless but maybe it's just that I've learned to bottle up my feelings so well it has become a skill. I feel sad but I dont dare show my feelings.


cruzgirlz3
Being an adoptee is a significant part of my identity, and my parents always acknowledged this. They accepted my curiosity about my past and tried as best as they could to answer my questions.

They had more trouble coming to terms with the fact that genetics played a huge role in who I was rather than parenting. They very much believed a child's development had more to do with "nurture" than "nature" and they did a very good job at nurturing me. However I felt the difference all the time because I looked nothing like them, and was very different in personality, attitude etc...I wish they had focussed more on these issues growing up.

Overall, though, my parents did a pretty good job and honoring who I am, without tying every life experience to me being adopted. Being adopted is an important part of who I am but it is only one part. My parents recognized this.


smm
Rating
i think there was just enough. the fact that i was adopted wasn't hidden but it wasn't thrown in my face either. sometimes my mom would say "i heard [your biological mom] had thick pretty hair too, you must get that from her", or "your biological father's family must have been really tall!"

so it wasn't like a dark secret, but she didn't go around introducing me as her adopted daughter either. usually i would be the one mentioning that i was adopted when people asked why i looked different or something.


sunny
They never really talked about it.

If I could change something, I wish that there had been more information about my natural family, history, and heritage.

I REALLY believe it is not healthy to grow up not knowing how you came to planet Earth. It was deeply disturbing.

Humans (intelligent ones anyway) always pursue the WHY. I didn't know why, where, from what, who or ANYTHING.

It's difficult to build a cohesive foundation with no information.


La Vie Boheme
Rating
I was not treated any differently and it was not something that was really brought up. Everyone knew but I was still very much part of the family. I don't see why there has to be focus on it at all.


dory
Definitely not enough. And the fact that they never talked about it was a silent indication to me that I was not supposed to talk about it. That was later confirmed.

I get so upset when I hear adoptive parents say they will talk about adoption when their children bring it up. Rarely will the child brooch the subject - and it's up to parents to lead conversations in many different areas of life - why is adoption the one that is supposed to be child-led.


AdoreHim
Rating
I was adopted and my hubby and I adopted 2 children. All three of us, knew that we were adopted, at a very early age- and yes, it was talked about, always in the positive= however we did not make it a topic of conversation to everyone we met. I was my adopted parents child, just as if I had been their biological child- and our 2 children are our children. Bio families don't talk about there children being biological, so why should adoptees have to emphasis it to others- we are not ashamed of it, as a matter of fact extremely happy to be adopted, so don't think that any of us were trying to hide the fact.


MeerKat
Rating
just lije goldielocks, it was just right. Never a big deal ever, Adoption is an event, not a state of being.


Sims2Player
Rating
Most of the time in the privacy of our own home, there was just the right amount of focus. I mean, once they told me (at age six -- don't make that mistake, tell them from the beginning) it was only really discussed if/when I asked about it.

With the extended family though, there was way too much focus. I even had an aunt that wanted me to date her son (my cousin in my eyes) cause since I wasn't blood related it wouldn't matter. (We were only six days apart and had pretty much grown up together!) So, try to make sure that your friends and family don't make an issue out of it either as it hurts.

I did want to also add though that even though I loved my adopted parents (they are both dead now) and have never wanted to meet my birth mother or father, that there is definitely always this "gap"...this wondering and not knowing. But then, I was adopted a loooong time ago, lol! Back when the birth records were sealed and in the state I live in, to have them unsealed is a pretty big hassle and not worth my time or money.


Jessica McMahon
Rating
i think no focus on the fact that a child is adopted is a good thing, as it makes them feel more like a part of the family. for years i never thought about the fact that i was adopted except when i pointed it out to people just so they would know, but my family and their friends love me and treat me as if i've been a member all my life. now that i am an adult, i am more aware that i am not a real part of the family as i am very different then my family members in the way i think, feel, react to, and do things. but i feel some of that has to do with my life experiences and how i deal with them. i'm the only one in my family who doesn't get all upset when someone dies. if there is a lot of focus on the fact that a child is adopted then i feel like he/she can't even begin to feel like a part of the family and may act out and develop bad behavior which would cause them to be deviant later on in life


littleJaina
I'm only the sibling of adopted children, but looking back I think my parents maybe put too much focus on the adoption. Both my brothers could REMEMBER it, so it's not like there was ever really a question of hiding the information. Still, I think one of my brothers may have revolted a bit less in terms of the "I'm running away to find my REAL family" if the adoption wasn't so frequently talked about.

It is sometimes hard though, for parents not to talk about it. It my brothers case, for example, they were mentally retarded but NOT downs syndrome. This means that when people met them, and they acted differently, in order to make the people realize my brothers weren't being sarcastic or purposefully rude often meant my parents had to explain that they were metally retarded. Being that all my parents other children were on the other end of the spectrum, and my brothers were not downs syndrome (the most usual portrayal of retarded people) people often asked questions about exactly WHAT was wrong with them. When the answer is "Fetal Alcohol Syndrome" it's almost impossible to not then explain that they are adopted... particularly for me, my brothers, and my father. I mean, it's really not fair to my mother to let people think that she was some kind of alcoholic that didn't care what it did to her kids when the opposite is the case. Thus, the fact that my brothers were adopted came out almost every time we met ANYONE in anything more personal than a waitress in a restaurant.

I don't think it really bothered the older of the two, but the younger of the two was pre-inclined to anger, hysterics, and just general contrariness. (Strangely, he is also preinclined to extreme affection. The result of which is he could love you to death, and hug you every other second and then turn around and scream at you that he hated you and never wanted to see you again.) I think the fact that the adoption, particularly when it was almost always tied to an explanation of abnormality, was so often mentioned in or lives was one of the main reasons he fixated on it as a cause of pain in his life. I'm not sure exactly how things could have been handled better - but I still think the over-recognition of the adoption was definitely a problem in his case.


Still Me
WE have to let our children guide us to an extent in this area, as in all areas. Every child is different and has different needs and responses to adoption. But that being said, I think some parents sort of overdo it a bit with pointing out their child's adoption, especially telling their child's adoption "story". This is private information that belongs to the child alone. MOST children just want to be children, like everyone else.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Cha'uri seems like it would be a pretty easy name to find.?
Can anyone give me advice on how to find a person (I'm thinking the unusual name will make it easier) in Portland area of Oregon? Also, how to go about it differently if the one you're ...


 My parental rights have not been terminated..Why haven't my 2& /2 yr old son been returned to me? Florida case
This was a private adoption case that took place last summer 2007. I was going through "HELL" and this private adoption agency took advantage of the situation and when I tried to cancel ...


 Adopting from an orphanage in italy?
my husband and i are a military family relocating overseas. We would like to start a family, but we would like to adopt first. We would like a child anywhere from 0-3 years old, and since we are ...


 Do Adoptive Parents try to encourage the childs mother to breastfeed for a few months?
This question is for the Ap's that adopted a baby.

Its the best thing for a babies immune system and was wondering if it mattered to those ap's....


 I am thinking of adopting, are you glad you did or wish you'd waited with trying?
I really want my own child. I have a stepson and even with loving him it wasn't the same as having my own. I want my own, but don't want to be selfish in the fact so many children need a ...


 First parents: Is there anything you would like your child's adoptive parents to know?
That you maybe didn't have the opportunity to tell them while your child was growing up (i.e. closed adoption), or you wanted to tell them, but were perhaps afraid of their reaction.
It ...


 Can a man without pair adopt a son/daughter?
it's such a strange situation...
i'm spanish,
i have a friend who wants to raise a child alone. he's spanish, like me, althought he lives in London. he claims he doesn't ...


 Who in the state of Texas can I contact to complain about Child Protective Services?
We're in the process of adopting two older boys and have been told false dates of appointments, placements, etc. Very poor communication between our agency and the caseworker of the boys. We ...


 Adoption in connecticut?
We and my husband are trying to figure out what we have to do to adopt a child.
We live in ct and after suffering 2 mc we are looking to adopt.

Where do i start?
What questions ...


 In australia, is fostering or adopting children difficult?
i know there is a difference between fostering and adoption. i would like info on how to go about it and what is needed. eg money, police clearance, etc. any info would be great or any persoanl ...


 Just want some opinions about my birth mother telling her family.?
Ok. I will try to make this short and sweet. I found my birth mother about a year ago. We email each other regularly. I do not want to interfere in her life in any way. She told me she was thinking ...


 Relinquishment - I don't get it.?
Can someone please explain to me why an adoptive parent *who has relinquished a child before* would proceed to adopt another child?

To clarify:
Mother has a child, but has to ...


 Do you get paid for fostering?
I have no intentions of fostering, I couldn't bring up anyone elses children

But I had heard somewhere before, i think it was on here that you get paid for fostering, I just assumed ...


 Want to know about Fostering?
Is there anyone out there that knows about fostering? I would love to know how to go about it and what type/sort of people that they are looking for. I am living in a de-facto relationship trying ...


 How do you think that this relates to adoption? (or perhaps parenting in general?)?
Your children are not your children.
They are the sons and daughters of Life's longing for itself.
They come through you but not from you,
And though they are with you yet they ...


 APs/PAPs: what are some of the stupidest comments/questions you have received regarding your adoption?
Some of my favourites:

Oh, so you can't get pregnant?
Have you tried everything to get pregnant?
How much did she cost?
Can she speak English? (She was barely 9 months ...


 Adoptees: Is it the job of AP's to provide a "better life" for their children?
How do you define "better life"?
Additional Details
I suppose if each situation is looked at individually, with the idea being to give THAT child a better home than what s/he ...


 Can parents make their children put theor babies up for adoption?
Say a teenage girl was pregnant could her parents make her give her child up for adiption?...


 For those who figured they were adopted on their own, what made you 'feel' you were not a biological child?
Most of us grow up with assumptions that our parents are our biological parents. For those who were adopted, prior to being certain, what did you assume? Did you assume that your parents were your ...


 Adopting children... (also, adopted people, can you help answer the 2nd part)?
Have you adopted, and what age were the children you adopted?
Is there a limit to how many you can adopt?
I'm in a stable relationship, from a wealthy family, and have alot of love to ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Saturday, May 26, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.064