Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Child Adoption

I'm not interested in adopting a child that is the same race as me...?
Find answers to your legal question.





I'm not interested in adopting a child that is the same race as me...?

Is this wrong?


    




C Wood
You need to really look at the reasons why you feel that way.
I wouldn't want to be adopted by you.
cw


Sofiakat
Why?
I think the reasoning behind it will tell you in your heart whether it is right or wrong.


Sarah Townen
Rating
i'm not comfortable saying if it's right or wrong
but here's some food for thought

why are you not comfortable adopting the same race as you?
* is it because you are ashamed of your own race? are there issues that need to be addressed there?
* are you trying to 'prove' something by adopting another race? (for example: proving you are not racist etc)
* are you doing it for attention
* can you fully explain to yourself why you want to adopt and why a different race?
* have you thought about how to support your potential adopted child in their race and culture?

just some things to consider
hope it's helpful


Jenm
Rating
Well, look at your motivation for it. I guess in a country like China, where baby girls are often given away for adoption, then I could understand the motivation there to adopt from China. But if you think it would be 'cool' or 'trendy', imagining yourself to be some kind of Angelina Jolie saviour-type, then I think you really need to step back and ask yourself who are you doing this for - your own fragile ego or a child who needs a good home? I'm sure you can find the honest answer to this question.


Carrie
I don't think it's wrong-- just remember that there are children of all races that need and deserve a loving home. Don't feel guilty about it. I don't think there's anything wrong, unless you have some deep, dark reason....


:D


Randy B
Two of my three kids are a different race then my wife and I. The only exception is the daughter we gave birth to. If that makes me wrong, I don't wanna be right.

Follow your heart and do what you want and what you can. You can't go wrong that way.


Katiebug
Rating
No....but please be open minded to all kids. including your own race.


Sarah
no, just means you want another race in the house whats wrong with that?


Mom to Foster Children
Rating
We didn't look at race when our foster to adopt children moved into the house. Out of the foster children that we have had we only had one that was the same race as us, but alass he went back home. The one we are adopting isn't the same race as us either...doesn't mean I don't love him anymore than children I gave birth to.


james
Why would it be wrong? It really doesn't matter. If you were black, white, spanish.............Really doesn't matter. If you wanted the same race as you it still wouldn't matter.


Eric
Not at all, many families adopt different ethnics than what they are.


aloha.girl59
Rating
I, me, myself, what *I* want...
Ugh.

Adoption isn't about YOU. It's about the CHILD. Get your head around that before you adopt ANY child. I see that you're new here. Please spend some time and read lots of questions and answers. Ask questions and learn. Take things to heart. And remember that adoption isn't about YOU.


depressed2312
Rating
you're just trying to be "cool" like Angie and Madonna


Babs
Rating
Ofcourse not. It shouldnt matter. All children need love and a caring home no matter their race. Good luck!


Solar Flare
Hahaha not at all. That's probably beneficial to the world because then whatever race you adopt will learn to love the race that you are.


Amy J
I think by you not being interested in adopting the same race is you, you might be having some wrong motives. What does race matter? do you want people to know that it is not your biological child? Why are you against adopting your same race? Are you ashamed of your own race or feel pity for other races? I think you need to re-examine your reasons to adopt in the first place. So, yes, I think it's wrong for you to be judgemental of your own race that you don't want to adopt the same race as yourself.


Mandy
nope, its your own personal choice. who cares if anyone disagrees, youre not living your life for them.


GoBuckeyes!
Rating
Yeah, its totally wrong to take care of a child and give them a good home just because their a different race.....

OF COURSE ITS NOT WRONG! ITS A GOOD THING!!!


xotinaaxx
In my opinion, there is nothing wrong than that (unless, of course, you don't like your race, which i doubt...)


♥BeKind♥
Rating
no. that not wrong at all. i bet its the same with a lot of other people


surfnerd
thats called reverse disrimination.


tish
yes.

it's wrong to have a racial requirement for a child. children are not responsible for their race...hence, should not be made to feel "picked and chosen" due to their race.

adoption is about the CHILD. not about the preferences/dreams of the potential adopitive parent.

IMO...if a person has "racial/gender" preferences for adoption, i think they would be do well to visit their local SPCA! that way, one can pick and choose until their little heart's content.


MarissaLynn
Rating
Not at all, a child is a child regardless of race, what ever race of the child, im sure you will be a wonderful loving mother.


Daisey Duck
First I would like to know why you want to adopt. After reading your answer to puppy love "Looking for my birth mom" (sorry don't know how to add the link) You were very hateful to her for wanting to find her birth mom. Quote " why don't appreciate your real parents (the ones that RAISED YOU and didn't just give you away)
If you are truly planning to adopt than you must be prepared that in the future he or she might want to find them. Is this why you don't want to tell the child they are adopted?
In my opinion you are not ready to adopt a child


MamaKate
Not necessarily. It would depend on several factors ;such as but not limited to: your reasons for not wanting a child of your smae ethnicity, the age of the child, how much cultural awareness/education you are willing to provide and how much the child need, etc. Good luck to you!


Dayle
Rating
No, not a thing wrong with it!!!!!!!!!


buttah42
well if the celebrity stars do it its okay for us to do it too


Electro Punk <3
no its def. not wrong whats wrong its just that ur nationality is dif. and wat? theres no problem =]


Jennifer L
Rating
No, it's not wrong.

Transracial adoption has a lot of unique challenges. Be sure you do your research so that you are able to meet those needs.

I recommend a couple of books: Inside Transracial Adoption and In Their Own Voices.

Best of luck.

(Edited because I mis-read the question the first time... oops...)


Melba Toast
no you are just open minded thats all. i dont find it at all wrong
:)


ARKdeEREH
No. Why would it be wrong, you're just diversifying your family tree?





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Do you need permission from the biological father for adoption to take place?
Children do not have surname or contact, and mother never married him....


 Do you think most people think the child is to blame for being in foster care?
=======
"Did you like foster care? I think someone like you would've enjoyed it. What did you do? Did you kill somebody? "
========

This is the latest email I ...


 Do you support a woman's choice to give up her baby?
No matter what? Is this not what pro-choice is about. Do you trust women to do what is right for their children? Is it not ANTI-WOMAN to be so against adoption?...


 Adoptees: does it bother you that your birth certificate lists your adoptive parents as your natural ones?
In many cases, the woman listed as "mother", as if she gave birth, is infertile, and has never bore a child.

Does this lie/pretending bug you?
Additional Details
E...


 Do two aparents do a better job than one natural parent?
The NCFA believes that single mothers should consider adoption based soley on the fact that she's a single mother. In their opinion two ( stranger ) adoptive parents would do a better job at ...


 Do you think that every adult above the age of say 30, should be drafted to care for a foster child?
This would be their patriotic duty....


 Do you believe in "Baby Scoop Era" or "EMS" or was it made up?
I had never heard of BSE or EMS- Baby scoop Era or Era of Mass Surrender untill i came here on Y/a. It is said Sometime during 1970's when its claimed babies were forcefully torn out of young ...


 I almost keeled over from shock~ How should I respond to this email?
Dear Looney Tunes,

You write that you were in foster care and never got adopted. Maybe there is a reason why you did not get adopted? You are white? You were young? Maybe GOD meant for ...


 What is with the assumption a baby is going to be better off being adopted?
Many people make statements that giving a child away for adoption is unselfish, and brave. One of the grossest myths in adoption, in my opinion, is "if you really love this child; you'll ...


 Adopting a teen? am i crazy?
im 17 years old. when im 18 i want to adopt a teen. am i crazy for thinking about adopting already? im a good kid. no drugs/alcohol problems. good student. anyone want to give me some advice? how ...


 What are your thoughts on this comment?
Someone wrote: IMO infertility is nature's way of dictating who should not be parents, and adoption is stealing.

I just think I am tired and will be leaving this forum. How hurtful ...


 My gay partner and I wish to adopt a gay child?
How should we go about doing this?...


 Giving up my child for a better life...for both of us.?
I'm 19 years old, and I got pregnant. I was in a really abusive relationship, and I was terrified to have a child with him. I couldn't even think about getting an abortion because I saw ...


 Do you think putting children up for adoption is right?
...


 Abortion or Adoption? Pros & Cons?
If you absoulutly had to choose.(no other choices)
which one would you choose and why?...


 Do you feel that a foster mom should celebrate mothers day?
I'm a foster mom in addition to being a mom to bio and adoptive kids, and I celebrate mothers day equally with all my children, whoever happens to be with us at the time!
We don't do ...


 I recently gave birth but im really torn?
before the child was born i was 100% sure that i was making the right decision about giving my baby up for adoption but now that my boy has been born im having doubts i didnt relise how much i would ...


 Why do adoptive parents feel intimidated when first parents come searching for their birth children?
I would like to have some input as to why those that have adopted, especially newborns, get so upset when the first moms come looking for our children? We, as first moms, have given you, as the ...


 Can adoptees please answer this? I'm 5 months pregnant, and want to give the baby up for adoption?
What kind of parents did you guys have, like were they good to you? See, I really don't want to keep the baby, it's not like I'm scared, but I just don't want to be a mom, ever, ...


 My sister is thinking about giving her baby up for adoption and im against it.. what do you think about this?
my sister is between four to five months pregnant allready and is Due this summer she lives at home with our mother and is currently unemployed. she's 19 and this is her first child well she ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Saturday, May 26, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084