Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Child Adoption

International adoptees and birth certificates?
Find answers to your legal question.





International adoptees and birth certificates?

I am feeling a bit dumB for not knowing this but what happens with birth certificates in an international adoption. Does the adoptee retain their OBC from the country of their birth or is it amended to show their adoptive parents as their natural parents? If it is the latter do they also change the country of birth?
Additional Details
So in international adoption there is no fake bc provided. Very interesting. I never would have thought international adoption would be more ethical in this area, apparently it is! Thanks for the info!


    




almost human
I'm from Korea too, but a little further along in the discovery process than Kateiskate.

In Korea, there is no birth certificate per say. There is, instead a family registry, called a Hojuk, which traces the lineage of family clans. When we are born, we are usually listed on the family registries.

We are turned into "orphans," even if we have living parents, by way of a document registering us as orphans.

Once we are an "orphan," we are given a new family registry and we are listed as the head of our family clans! with no parents and, of course, no offspring. Our real Hojuk still exists somewhere in Korea, separated from us, and I hear our names are then "x'd" out...(yeah, that horrifies me too - being literally "x'd" out)

This erasing of our past makes us available for international adoption.

Upon completion of adoption proceedings in our new country, we are given a new birth certificate, one which "live birth" is not in the title. Our adoptive parents are written in where the form states the mother and father's identity. It is very curious, because we were born to people who reside in one state at the time of the "birth" certificate, yet our place of birth is in a foreign country.

I would call this a fake birth certificate, and I would also call this less than ethical.

As part of my documentation process preparing for my return to Korea, I also had to renounce my Korean citizenship. Not only do I have a family registry with my name "x'd" out on it, locked in some vault in Korea, but I have also always been a Korean citizen.

Being an international adoptee is often surreal.


ETA:

One of the wonderful things UNICEF is doing is registering children's births in developing countries. This is badly needed, because there is still inter-country slave trading in parts of Africa and Asia, and there is also international child trafficking. If there is any way we can, we should document and preserve the family ties of children.


kateiskate
Rating
I don't have a birth certificate from Korea. I have no record of my actual birth there. The birth certificate I do have has my amom and my adad's names on it.

I'm not even 100 percent I'm korean because theres no info on me before I was left at the orphanage.

Mine says country of birth is Korea.


Mei-Ling
Mine showed Mama and Baba as the natural parents.

The translated version showed them as the natural parents, and then Mom and Dad as my adoptive parents.

I don't have an amended birth certificate that I know of... unless my Canadian citizenship counts?

ETA: It varies. I was just speaking regarding my own situation. I have heard of Korean BCs that were amended...


Jennifer L
I'm sure it varies from country to country, but we have our children's original birth certificates that lists their biological parents. There was not an amended birth cerificate until we re-adopted them in the US (which is required by the state we live in).

ETA: Wow. 3 TDs for stating a fact: that there wasn't an amended birth certificate until coming to the US.


Indian-vision(un-blocked)
Just like Kims answered about Ethiopia and Randy about India. Many many births in India are not recorded as they are often not born in Hospitals. Especially if they poor, from villages or the child out of wedlock.

So often orphanages do not have the exact date of birth of the child nor do they know of the natural parents. In case of adoption like Randy said birth certificates are issued with the date being a guess.


kims
My children are from Ethiopia. When we met their father we did ask about their birth informaton. He told us they don't register births where he is, and they surely don't celebrate birthdays or anything so they just kind of go by what season the children were born in. So the birth certificates the government gave us do list their real family and real place of birth, but the dates are guesses. That was in the papers we got from the relinquishment proceedings. In our adoption paperwork they gave us birth certificates that list us as the adoptive parents.

When we validated their adoptions in our state we were issued birth certificates for them that list us as the parents.


Randy B
Rating
My 16 year old has no birth certificate. Canadian or otherwise. She was given a notarized document from the Indian courts which stated her date of birth and her status prior to adoption (ie: no parents, no known family, abandoned at the Missionaries of Charity orphanage in Rajgarth...). Other then that, that was it.

When we formalized the adoption in Ontario we then obtained her adoption papers but nothing more. The only formal ID she has which lists her DOB and such is her Canadian passport and her official citizenship card. Other then that, there is nothing. I did contact the Province to ask about a birth certificate of some sort (someone told me they would issue a "certificate of live birth" card) but they told me that there was no such ID/Birth Certificate document available to her.

It's never hindered her/us in any way however. She was able to get her SIN card (same as a US SSN) and her health card. She was also able to get her Province of Alberta ID card. All that remains is for her to get her drivers license and with the ID she has it won't be a problem.


??
My child, adopted from Guatemala has an original BC with the birth mother's name. (No father listed, born out of wedlock). Then when we arrived home, the US issued us an "amended BC" listing me as mother.

I think it's pretty cool, that way if my child wants to know anything about his birth mom then he can at least try. I am extremely grateful to his birth mom, I can't imagine how hard it was for her.


Independ"ant"
Its sad that in many countries the Original isn't the Original to begin with. I can't begin to imagine not only having access to a real OBC but not even knowing if I from the country my Aps adopted from. Children are trafficked in from surrounding countries all the time.

Watch the movie Trade (Kevin Kline) when you have a strong stomach to see just how easy its done. The US govt stats at the end of the film is disturbing.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Is it normal to have no interest in adopting a child that is the same race as you?

Additional Details
Oh no, i know someone who is thinking about adoption and feels this way. I have no interest what so ever in adopting somebody else's child... My uterus operates ...


 How do you tell a child he/she is adopted?
I know a couple who just adopted a little girl she is still an infant and they plan to tell her the truth when she's older, they are first time parents been married for more than 20 years. I ...


 If paying an expectant mother's living expenses suddenly became illegal...
would it have any affect on the number of women who eventually do choose to relinquish?

Why or why not?

Are there any other upsides or downsides to ending this common practice.<...


 Sims 2 - Adoption??
i adopted a child but i dont want this one how do i get rid of it ???? pleas help thank you
Additional Details
i asked for help because i wanted a baby not a toddler and didnt get enough ...


 All Moms: Do you feel people do not respect your role as mother because you adopted, or relinquished a child..
or are fostering or raising a step child... and so on.
Almost every parent I know does not make a distinction between myself and them in terms of motherhood, however, a comment was made back ...


 Why the assumption that a middle class woman will suddenly end up in a slum if she is a single mother?
I don't understand why the assumption that a woman who single parents her child will automatically become less than how she is raised. If a woman comes from a middle class background, a child ...


 Should social workers have more training?
Curious if anyone else here thinks that social workers need more training surrounding adoption related issues?

A reply I just saw in another question, by a self proclaimed "social ...


 How do you feel about concurrent adoptions?
Now that China's wait times have been extended to at least 5 years, I have noticed many PAPs have decided to pursue another IA adoption or a domestic adoption while staying in line for China. C...


 How do you know who's reporting your questions?
I'm seeing accusations being thrown around about certain people reporting questions. Am I missing something because I've never been told who's reporting my questions and I'd like ...


 Why are you happy with your adoption? Happy adoptees only please.?
I think the happy crowd MUST have a voice. We must drown out the bellowing of the disgruntled few who insist that we are in denial. This is insulting. Let's here some positive adoption stories!...


 Will the adoption center let me have a baby? ?
Im thinking of adopting a baby. Im 24 years old, and american and live in the United States. Im making 9 bucks an hour. Also I don't any crime record as well. But I do have bad credit and I have ...


 Which costs less? In-Vitro? Or Adoption?
My husband and I are in the military and have so far been unable to conceive.
Adoption has always been my first choice... but I can't figure out how we could ever aford it. It would take ...


 What's so wrong about adoption?
Most people in my school think adoption is horrible and I'm adopted. They make fun of adoption too....


 Are Native American kids really the easiest to adopt?
Even with the ICWA laws in place? Someone told me they were. I just inquired on a sib group of 4 native kids.
Additional Details
I've actually been afraid to inquire on Native Kids ...


 Qualifying to Adopt?
A friend recently enquired about adopting a child

The first question she was asked was if and how often she attended church and then when they found out she already had a son, they said ...


 Can I foster or adopt my nice?
Hi, the social service want give my nice for adoption, the social worker say that she prefers live the baby (few days old) with a relative.
My sister-in-law mother can' t take the baby (she ...


 How much does it cost to adopt from China?
Me and my wife plan on adopting 5 baby girls from China. We live in Arkansas, I'm 30 she's 32, and we have a combined household income of 230,000 per year.
Additional Details
W...


 Not sure if I want to adopt b/c of the credit checks and such, plus we still rent.?
Ok, this may be lengthy, but pls bare with me. My husband and I are looking to adopt but we dont want an infant, we actually prefer an older child. W already have our own, but I am adopted too, just ...


 Can my husband adopt my son?
I found out I was pregnant right after I broke up with my boyfriend. I let him know that I was and for a little while he pretended to be interested in the pregnancy. The last time I heard from him ...


 Why not include an abortion catergory just like they did an adoption one?
Abortion is something that alot of women go through and has to do with pregnancy so why not include it as well?

Just curious
Additional Details
By the way i have not had an ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Saturday, May 26, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024