
Felicita1
 |
both can be traumatic and with adoption there is a huge chance that the emotional pain will NEVER end as there is no closure.
why can't she keep her baby?
An adoption agency is the LAST place she should go if she is trying to decide. They stay in business due to money they get from people paying to adopt babies. Of course they're going to tell her that adoption is wonderful because this is how they make money -- if she doesn't surrender her baby they won't make money from it. Yes, it is conflict-of-interest. Even in agencies that do "parenting plans" as well, the pressure is still on to ensure that a certain number of babies will be surrendered for adoption.
Abortion is a decision for early in pregnancy. You choose between abortion and becoming a mother and those are the facts. When your baby is born you will be a mother and only THEN should you decide to keep your baby or not. Until then, it is far too soon to make any sort of informed decision -- until your baby is in your arms you may not realize the importance of the mother-child bond between you and your baby. But adoption agencies want mothers to "make an adoption plan" while still pregnant so she feels she cannot back out. This is a form of coercion, especially if she meets/sees prospective adopters who want her baby and seem so much better than she is.
For more information on the trauma of losing a child to adoption check out
http://home.att.net/~judy.kelly/thesis.htm
http://www.originscanada.org/the_damage_to_mothers.html
and the collection of stories here: http://www.exiledmothers.com/babies_taken_for_adoption/index.html
and no, open adoption is NOT any easier for a mother than closed adoption and in fact can be more painful. Mothers losing a child to adoption "registered significantly stronger symptoms than the bereaved normative group in 8 or the 14 bereavement subscales: social isolation, somaticizing, sleep disturbance, appetitive, vigor, physical symptoms, optimism vs despair, and dependency. ... results shown in Table 3 demonstrate that mothers relinquishing a child for adoption tend towards more grief symptoms than bereaved parents, especially if the method of adoption was open adoption." (Blanton & Deschner, 1990) |