Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

A mom and two sons need help -but they are illegal do I help or do I turn them over.?
Find answers to your legal question.





A mom and two sons need help -but they are illegal do I help or do I turn them over.?

the mom came to meet up with her husband, but when she got here he was living with another woman. She is now stuck. She has no more money and not a good shot of making it here. What do we do? Morally - legally


    




Ian
I think morally they should be helped in a legal fashion. I think you should do what ever you can for them now untill you help them get back to Mexico. I would be scared to be in a country that my husband or wife abandoned me in. Also, it would probably be easier for them if they just went back, I know I woudn't want to be abandoned in a foreign country.


Ray
Rating
Give her a one way ticket back.


Taka
Rating
You have to help her get back home or apply for an emergency VISA. Keep in mind if you are perceived to be harboring or aiding her in breaking the law, you can also be prosecuted, not just her.


ZICO
Rating
You help her contact her family so you and them can arrange for her return.


Yak Rider
Morally, buy her and the kids Greyhound tickets back to the border and give them a little spending money to help them get home.

If the border is only a day's drive then take them yourself and give them some money to help them get home once they cross back to where they belong.


bigDcowgirl
Turn in the cheating louse of a husband. When he gets deported, the wife will probably want ot go back with him.


berryfremont
help her out by buying her and her sons a plane ticket back to where they came from.


forktonguebush
Rating
HELP THEM! Do the right thing...You can also contact your local church.


Naturescent
Obviously they are in the wrong country. How did they get here anyway? Sounds like hubby didn't have a clue that the family was coming to pay a visit.

Why not report the husband? He loses the woman he's cheating on his wife with, he gets sent back to wherever he came from and then you can ask the local church to collect donations to return the family safely.

No harm done and we're rid of yet another piece of scum (the husband). The wife will be able to keep better tabs on hubby - who has probably always cheated on her.


Lady Cosmo
Rating
Help her out or dont help her out...why would you want to turn her in?


bgdadyp
send them back and shoot the husband.
that way you cover both the legal aspect and the moral one as well.


45 auto
Take them to a Catholic church they say they will shelter them.


Marilyn T
Help if you can. A bus ticket home is not a bad idea,she must have family back home that will be better able to hel p them then you are able to. I would try to turnin her lousy husband.


myopinion
Send her back home, best you can. Keep in mind that by aiding or harboring an an illegal, you are breaking the law. I would turn her husband in to the authorities and let them deport the both of them back to their homeland.


meathead
Rating
Help her by turning her in. It will be the best way to get her back to her homeland.


DBSII
Rating
You really should not help them unless you are willing to risk getting in trouble also. Personally, I wouldn't do it.


Micky
The best thing you can do is help her get home,she probably has family in her country.


Pengy
Rating
Turn them in enough of our tax dollars going to help illegals when people that are citizens need help and cannot get it She and her kids will get deported but will be fed and clothed


Sweetharttt
To help, you would be getting yourself into a lot of trouble. See if there is a church that could intervene. She is a criminal by being here. Can you believe what she says? She is illegal, afterall and could just be looking for handouts.


AMANDA WALLACE
Rating
if she is from honduras, you have to have precaution because the people from honduras they are falses, and lie NEVER TRUST, in the honduras


little eccy
Rating
Help them if you can, forget about politics, just be a good samaritan.


?
Rating
Love your country, turn them over to ICE.


lovin_2beme
Legally, you can be guilty by association.

Morally, there are groups out there that can help them.

If she is here illegally, they can help her with paperwork and such. What kind of help does she need?

Food pantry, shouldn't require ID for help, some shelters don't either if she needs a place to live.

Check with your church. They might be able to help too.
Dont get yourself into trouble though, once you get a record a lifetime is a long time to live with something on it.

GL


headbanger5007
one of two things.....either you can turn the other cheek....and be blind to it.. or turn them in...help them, no. they want to come here illegally its their own problem


walter27282000
Rating
Turn them in........

That Plain enough for you???


Giordano
Do You wanna help her? Just help her. And a few years from now, You'll see her and her to sons marching somewhere in the USA, spitting on your flag, calling You racist, evil, f...gringo.
Help her, and when She joins La Raza and teach her kids how to hate this country and destroy this society, come back here and ask us why You feel so guilty.


Alexis B
Rating
You are not legally liable for helping a person in need whether they have immigration papers or not. I don't know what state you are in but in my state, we have many programs for people in need and you can help her access those services. If she has been physically abused by her husband and he is legal, she can get a visa because of that. But it sounds like that's not really applicable. Ask her what she wants to do, help her do it if you can and advise her or find someone who can if you think she's being unrealistic.

Why would you ask this bunch of morons (save a few) anyway?


Brittany
Rating
Help them unless they are horrible people which it sounds like they are not. Or if you arent in a situation to help them just do neither and dont feel bad about it.


beyuki
Rating
You need to do what you feel is right in your heart , Helping somebody will never be a crime.

If you were stuck in the same situation , wouldn't you want somebody to help you.

Ps. WWJD


Erica P
Rating
OF Course! Help them! because you never know when you might need some kind of help from someone else! & remember what goes around comes around!!!


Bullfrog21
Rating
Call 1-800-375-5283
USCIS National Customer Service Center





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Would you be willing to pick fruits & veggies for $14/hr?
Apparently one farmer claims he is having trouble finding workers to pick his crops. He said if anmesty doesn't pass he has no idea what he would do. We (Here in Michigan) recently had over 300...


 How many of your friends will benefit if an amnisty bill passes in the congress?
...


 What would you think if I came into your house without your permission?
Then, if you asked me to leave I got real mad and said I didn't have to because all my friends were in everyone else's house without permission too so there are too many to ask this ...


 Because of the rising number of hispanic immigrants in the US, do you ever think you will learn Spanish?
disregard the question if you already speak Spanish.
Additional Details
being a hispanic immigrant does NOT mean that you want to be a citizen...you can be a permanent resident....


 Who do you hate more, Mexicans or Central Americans?

Additional Details
Hey dudes, didn't you pass Geography? There are Central American Nations, and then there is a Mexico. FYFI...


 Do you think there are too many foreigners in the UK now?
If so, how would you sort out the problem?...


 Immigration: racist or reality.?
Without having people jump on the 'you racist' band wagon, isn't it about time something was done about immigration, legal and illegal. This country I would say is heading for disaster,...


 If America deports all illegals that were the only breadwinners of their poor families..?
wouldn't that portray you as a cruel nation with no respect to poor people's human rights?

Don't you understand deportation could mean terminating a primary means of ...


 Why should I be a Proud American, when My Nation was created as a result of murdering children, womena and men
exetermination of cultures and traditions, enslavement and murder of Africans, and oppression till this day?
Additional Details
The sins of the Father should never be Forgotten or F...


 Am I Racist?
I have been picked to race the 400 metres relay for my college but I would much rather run the 200 meter sprint. I hate the 400 metres. I see the 200 meters race as far superior in every way. Am I ...


 If you could live in any country apart from your own...?
where would you live?

I am an englishman who has lived in Mexico for 13 years, although I would die for England, I do appreciate the standard of living I have here.

If you were ...


 But wait... AREN'T WE ALL IMMIGRANTS!?!?!?
Ha, just kidding. That's the dumbest argument I've ever heard in favor of illegal immigration. I was born here, as were my parents and grandparents.

Has anyone heard any ...


 Do u ppl hate ma because i support the illegal immigrants?

Additional Details
*btw everybody i'm not illegal and i'm not hispanic i'm white but i think the united states belongs 2 n e 1 who works in ...


 Why do illegal mexicans come to the usa for a better life but cant get a job or go to school here?
...


 I fight for mexicans rights (illegal or legal)?
my name is marioa and i think that all that is going on is dumb no one belongs to the USA WE ARE ALL ILLEGAL OK no one is better than the other. we all work the same and we all fight for a better ...


 Are African-Americans considered "immigrants?"?
I hear people always saying how this country was "built by immigrants" and say that this is so not true.
By looking at the definiton of immigrant, it says that (im paraphrasing) an ...


 I am 100% AGAINST illegal aliens; how about you?
Illegal aliens are a wart on the 'bottom' of this nation.... Don't you agree?...


 Where do babies come from?
I want to know where babies come from. I don't believe that the stork brings them anymore. My parents banned me from health class due to religious reasons, and the school allowed it. I have no ...


 What good will building a fence on the mexican border do?
Its not hard to jump it or dig a hole under it, why are they complaining?...


 Should I be deported?
I was born in England, but both parents are Afghan. They came here one year before the war broke out in '79 to do their masters degree, but couldn't return as planned for obvious reasons. I ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, February 7, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084