Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Anchor babies?
Find answers to your legal question.





Anchor babies?

Why are babies of ILLEGAL immigrants allowed US citizenship? If a bank robber gives the money to his/her children do they get to keep it?
Additional Details
uhhh... Mr Pototo head, get a grip. Do you really believe that a baby born to an illegal immigrant did so without the illegal parent being present for the "crime"??? WOW imagine that!


    




♥♥Cheelicious♥♥♥
Because of the 14th amendment. What does a bank robber have to do with a baby?


Lori K
It shouldn't be but that is the law currently. Birthright citizenship is an outdated notion and most modern countries have already done away with it. The US and Canada are the 2 major nations who are clinging to it.

To make a fine point...it's not the 14 Amendment that allows birthright citizenship, but rather the current judicial interpretation of the 14th Amendment. That could change.


AlenaT
Rating
I think that law should be changed because this is the one of the reasons mexican are coming to US....


Darth Scorn
Are laws say that if you're born on American soil, you're an American citizen. I don't agree with people who say that having a baby in America is reason to let you stay, but the child is clearly here legally.


Lady Freyja
Rating
It's stupid. We need to do away w/ citizenship through birth. Only children born of legal U.S. citizens should be afforded citizenship.


Mindbender
Rating
Actually, children born to illegal immigrants -- if challenged on a Constitutional basis, would not be allowed to be citizens because they are products of an illegal act. We have research to prove that the 14th amendment to the Constitution and the other recent acts that are supposed to promote this illegal citizenship do not give children of illegal immigrants automatic citizenship.

We U.S. Citizens and law-abiding immigrants are mad-as-hell and we're not going to take this crap anymore. There will be impeachments and lawsuits and Constitutional Challenges. 2008 will be the year of the U.S. Citizen obtaining and guarding their Constitution and their rights and taking their country back. It's already started and we're moving forward. No more benefits for law-breakers!


Joel W
I am not a birthright citizens.. my parents were citizens. Both in fact, but one was sufficent. And no..we are not all anchor babies.. most of us are born of American Citizens.

Anchor Babies: born in the USA - Enormous taxpayer costs
Article by Stephany Gabbard and Frosty Wooldridge
July 9, 2004
http://www.frostywooldridge.com/articles/art_2004jul09b.html
Published on MICHnews.com

If you don’t think our Congress is taking Americans for a ride, think again. According to Dr. Madeleine Cosman, "At least 300,000 to 350,000 anchor babies annually become citizens in California." In 1994, 74,987 anchor babies in maternity units cost taxpayers $215 million in Stockton, California. In 2003, 70 percent of the 2,300 babies born in San Joaquin General maternity ward were from illegal aliens. That number has exploded today with over three million illegal aliens residing in California.

The French economist Frederic Bastiat said, "The unseen is more expensive than the seen." In Stockton, California, the Silverio Family was featured in the Wall Street Journal in 2003. They were fruit pickers who arrived illegally from Oxtotilan, Mexico in 1997. The wife, Felipa had three kids, but popped an anchor baby named Flor. The child was premature and spent three months in a neonatal incubator at a cost to the San Joaquin Hospital of over $300,000.00. They conceived another, Christian. The second baby made them eligible for $1,000 per month welfare. Because Flor is disabled, she receives $600.00 monthly for asthma. Although the illegal aliens made $18,000.00 annually picking fruit, they collected $12,000.00 of your tax dollars for their anchor babies. One night the father, Cristobal crashed his van. He had no license or insurance. Taxpayers paid for all hospital bills. That’s why 77 hospitals in border states were going bankrupt in 2003, but Senator John McCain wrote a rider into the Medicaid Bill for $1.4 billion of your tax dollars. It passed. Not to finish the spending spree on these anchor babies, the children attend California schools at a cost of $7,000.00 per year over and above what their parents pay in taxes. The cost for all five of their children for one school year exceeds $35,000.00 times 18 years for a grand taxpayer total of $630,000.00. This is only one family. No wonder California is $38 billion in debt.

Additional costs for illegal alien children stem from translators, advocates and middlemen. MediCal in 2003 sponsored 760,000 illegal aliens. Supplemental Security Income is a non-means-treated federal grant of money and food stamps. Be assured that scams and fraud run rampant. Over 500,000 ‘mentally disabled kids’ are on drugs for ADHD and ODD. One lady, Linda Torres was arrested in Bakersfield with $8,500.00 in small bills in her pocket. It was her SSI lump award for her disability, which was heroin addition.

Just so Americans across the country don’t feel left out, let’s move to Georgia. Net Fiscal Costs of Illegal Immigration for Georgia: Births of illegal aliens in Georgia cost to taxpayers:
2000-- 5,133 births cost: $13 million
2001-- 9,528 births cost: $23 million
2002—11,188 births cost: $27 million

Additionally, receiving public assistance in 2002 for 25,000 children of illegal aliens cost Georgia taxpayers $42 million annually. Health care costs to Georgia taxpayers for illegal aliens in 2002 was 64,000 doctor visits which ran Grady Health System into a $63 million deficit. What is it in your state? This picture is a small window into the massive fraud being perpetrated on your wallet by your congressional leaders. What is your senator or congressman doing about it? The simple answer fulfills French economist Bisbiat’s rule of the unseen. Your congressional reps assist this fraud! They encourage it every day by doing nothing about 2,200 illegal aliens crossing our borders and they have done nothing since 9/11 to deport the estimated 13 million that are already here.

So what will you do? How about taking action! Join www.NumbersUSA.com and www.SecuredBordersUSA.com and www.TheAmericanResistence.com and www.DeportAliens.com and www.ImmigrationsHumancost.org and www.ReportIllegals.us and www.CommonSenseOnMassImmigration.us.


x x
The 14th amendment is the source of this problem. It was intended to force southern states to allow former slaves citizenship and the vote. It was not intended to allow illegals to have babies that grant them a free ride in the USA.
Dual citizenship should be stopped also!
The robbery part makes no sense.


Punkin
It's the way the Constitution is being interpreted. It don't think it is the correct interpretation, however. Not all Americans of Hispanic descent are of the criminal type that flaunt immigration laws and/or encourage others to do the same. This daughter of legal immigrants hates illegal aliens and illegal immigration. We welcome all new members at http://youdontspeakforme.org/ an organization of Hispanic Americans who love America and support her immigration laws.


NSA
According to the actual 14th amendment, they are not automatically granted citizenship.'

Birthright citizenship is for children born to citizens; it can be offered to those born to legal visitors.


Mother of 5/Madre de 5
Rating
I am an American citizen who bore the children of an illegal immigrant who later became a legal resident (in 2006 the application process takes about 5 years). Does this make my children anchor babies? I think not! My children have every right to be in this country, and any child born in this country also has that right! Thank God for the U.S. Constitution!


bakphx
The upside is that the babies aren't illegals! :0)


John
That's due to our out-of-date Fourteenth Amendment.


buddy
Rating
land mines


GoYankees&Giants!
Unfortunately, it's part of our Constitution. But the good news is there's a bill called AJR 44 in Congress which focuses to modify the 14th Amendment to exclude illegals of this priveledge.


tuesday101
well, in this country it's starting to change from 'innocent till proven guilty' to 'guilty until proven innocent'. But it doesn't go forward to illegals, sadly. I hope it changes on that subject.


A blank!
Rating
Orphanages.


Whyruafraid?
Because it's the law. if you don't like it, gather up enough money to pay off a group of politicians to change it, or get the hell out of my country!

Honestly, What part of LEGAL don't you understand!

We only want LEGAL citizens here, not illegals. Anchor babies are LEGAL Americans, it's the LAW.


Harmony
Because that's the way it is. I myself was born here with BOTH parents who WERE illegal(past tense, they are not illegal anymore!) And you know what? I thank God each and everyday for giving me the opportunity to be born here. My life has changed dramatically. I am about to graduate high school and go to college. I am so grateful for the opportunities this country has given me. i am sorry that you feel that way about us. We are not bad people. And we have the same right to be here as you.

Lori, let's say your parents were born in........germany. And they decided they wanted to move to the U.S. If you were born in the U.S do you believe you should be 'german' instead of american?

az guy,
I never said your parents were illegal. Oh and by the way, before they came here as 'criminals' they tried to do it the right way. But the U.S didn't give them visas. But atleast they are legal now.


Potato
American law does not transfer crime to a second person when the same person was not even present or alive at the moment of the alleged crime.

Until a person is convicted in a court of law, they all presume innocent.


Ps- Please read again my answer above- Also

The law in the U.S does not work base in my or your opinion.

UNTIL a person is not convict in a court of law you can not affirm that person is a criminal.

You can have a opinion but your opinion does not have any law validity.


Private individuals do not have legal power to establish if someone is guilt or not. Only the government using the legal court system can establish that kind of position. Until a court verdict is impose most opinions are just hot air opinions.










t





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Is it immoral to object to mass immigration, if so why is it immoral?

Additional Details
I am delighted with the answers . I was beginning to get the feeling that some people thought preserving our community was in some way "immoral" and we must ...


 Do you 'american people' (that shouldn't be that way because 'america' is Mexico, colombia, brasil,
argentina etc, etc, so, im mexican AND american!!) anyway, do you laugh of people that try to speak english?...


 Are we blaming the hispanics/mexicans equally????
I feel that alot of people are JUST blaming illegal hispanics/mexicans. Obviously they would not have jobs if it weren't for the people/ companies that hired them, so shouldn't we blame ...


 Time to grade the govt. A,B,C,D,F what grades do Bush and homeland security get....?
for guarding our borders?...


 40 million indigents in mexico?
acordingly to the ONU there is 40 million who could be considered indigents in mexico , don't u agree that the only way to stop illegal immigration is to make real aliances whit mexico and ...


 After the whole mexican immigration thing's over, will people target puerto rico since there's too many in....
new york?
Additional Details
but they speak spanish too n everyone will just keep speaking spanish. wouldnt u still be mad?...


 How do you feel about the UK Government paying for interpreters?
to help immigrants in making their benefit claims?

(Please do not say this does not happen, I have personal experience of this through my job!)
Additional Details
My point is ...


 How many years will it be before everyone in the US will be speaking spanish?
...


 This is going to be my last question for today...?
Mexicans care more about marriage and family than United Statesians. Who gives better presents on Valentine's Day?

I say Mexicans because if United Statesians gave good presents then ...


 I know that illegal immigration is illegal and of course i am against it..but what if you were in their shoes?

Additional Details
Before you get into the whole "theyre loud" ordeal ... I live on Park Avenue with a bunch of white people and they stay up till 3 in the morning drinking ...


 Whats my dangerous living in UK or USA?

Additional Details
i mean whats ...


 Should we grant gay Iranians asylum?
http://www.timesonline.c
Gay men face death in Iran. Should we allow them to stay here, or send them back to Iran if they apply for ...


 Americans will every one of you have an extra special 4th of July?
It feels extra good to be an American sometimes!

We fought for what we believed in this past week and WON!

Be Safe!...


 Whats a good title for my paper about illegal immigration?
...


 White men average 2" fact or fiction while black men average10" latinos a safe 6"?

Additional Details
lolita do u have enough research on the subject to make those statements?

not trying to say your loose or anything!...


 Should we require bilingual classes in all public schools to better the edcuation of all students?
Both American and foreign-born students would benefit from this....do you agree?
Additional Details
sorry about the ...


 If the mexican people think their country is so bad, why don't they ban together and form a new government?
form a new government?...


 Is this good for America's children?
http://www.sendemback.or...


 What do you think would happen if every country in the world had an open border policy?
I think this would be the end result of "world peace." What do you think would happen?
Additional Details
I don't think this will lead to peace, but if some level of peace ...


 Sen. Kennedy weeps for the 12 million,who live in the shadows ! Don't all criminals live in the shadows ?
Call , Email or write your reps. today! Time is running out !...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034