Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Anti-Immigrationers: Has an illegal alien ever taken a job you wanted?
Find answers to your legal question.





Anti-Immigrationers: Has an illegal alien ever taken a job you wanted?


Additional Details
I am going to have to call you on your BS positions... I see people find mixed race people from south of our borders and discriminate against them for immigrating illegally, but I don't see any of you crying about eurotrash in New York or Miami illegally immigrating and taking jobs, or Canadians, .. But "those darned mexicans gotta go back home"....

Yes, you are racists, it doesn't matter if you will admit it to yourselves or not.


    




The Red Angel
Rating
EXACTLY THE POINT.....perfect question and antis know it, now that they are seeing theyre PROVING THEMSELVES WRONG....now theyre trying to say THATS NOT THE ISSUE....hahahahah......when thats the top reason they give on previous answers as why illegals are a problem

antis...do you seriously think we cant look at previous questions on this forum to see your lies .....


bookworm YES you just made our point !!!!!!! WOOHOO!!!!

Immigrants are taking jobs Americans dont want to do, and employers are unable to pay anything higher to stay profitable


youarewrongbobisright
Rating
Nope - but they do take my tax money and raise my costs for things like:


Education
Medical
Welfare
Housing
Energy costs
Food stamps
etc. etc. etc.



EDIT:
Dummy you are a DUMMY!!!
Taxes are not a choice - buying a tomato is a choice. The cost to me in higher taxes is something that I have no control over and is far, far more then the very small costs for a little extra labor costs in farm products. The labor cost is only a few cents for a tomato -I'd gladly pay a few more cents (even a lot more then that) if we didn't have to subsidize big business for their cheap (note I did not say inexpensive) labor.


mikea_va
Rating
You know you are avoiding the real issue right???


Sherilynne B
No. I own my own business so they haven't taken the jobs of anyone working for me either because I, of course, do not hire illegals.

DEPORT ILLEGALS NOW!


Crazy cat lady >^ ^<
Rating
All I know is Jobs like McDonald's,Burger King etc were for high school kids in the days on their summer vacation or when they were on spring break or even after school now those jobs go to illegal aliens ..Rarely now can I go to one of those establishments and the person who is taking my order speak English


B.Kevorkian
Yes. Of course, it was when I was much younger (and there weren't nearly so many illegals in the country). Now that I have a college degree, it's legal H1B visa holders who poach the jobs I'm after. While that's inconvenient, I don't have much grounds to object to it: thier employers are at least complying with the letter of the law.


scottanthonydavis
No, but they have filled the jobs our children take as first jobs during the summer school break.

Not to mention I eat at most of the places they have taken jobs and that kind of disgusts me!

There are American's who would take those jobs if they were available at an American rate. The only reason American's don't take the jobs they fill is because they have lowered the pay rate at those jobs with their cheap labor!

This isn't about them taking jobs anyhow!

This is about the gangs and crime rate, the driving insurance rate and the billions of lost tax dollars they cause through having anchor babies on American soil and collecting through welfare.

Their kids who are in gangs (90%) tag walls all over the U.S. which also cause millions in painting repairs. They lower the property value where ever they go.

What about the millions in medical like emergency room baby deliveries?

What about the millions in tax audits and investigation because of their identity theft and fake tax claiming through Social Security!

It isn't just about the jobs!


Your name here, cheap.
Rating
Yes. Try getting a job as a carpenter or drywall hanger these days. Pay is less than half what it was while greedy contractors charge more for the jobs.


vtjames7433
Rating
False premise to the question- people aren't anti Immigration, they are anti ILLEGAL Imigration. I know you cats intentionally blur the lines to make it some racial issue or what have you but that doesnt change the fact that immigration is different than people jumping the border without permission.


JUSTME
Yes. Had a house cleaning business employing several people. When the illegal criminal aliens invaded my area they undercut my prices and I was forced to let my people go and close my business down.


Joe H
Very good question. Actually I have had to compete and work alongside illegal aliens but its because I was totally unwilling to accept a dime from the gov't to buy milk or diapers for my kids.
But out of that I will tell you I was ALWAYS and without exception the only white guy on the shovel/broom/mop/toilet brush/pressure sprayer wand, back bent and as its sometimes said here in the south "workin' like a mexican".
But now, after college, my competition is other white people. And not just US born citizens all WASP males.


Gretl
An illegal alien cannot take my job, but I know that people in construction and other small businesses are being run over, because they cannot compete with the cheap labor of hiring illegals.


Nicholesta
Rating
Nope.
That is also not my objection to illegal immigration.


crazy hefer
You are ranting and raving All about opinions that Donot agree with your own!!!!!!!!! Grow up!!!!!!!! Get an education!!!!!!!!! Read the newspaper, and listen to the news!!!!! Better yet leave the country!!! WE would be better off without Greedy shitheads like you!!!

No, illegals have not taken a job that I ever wanted. They have taken jobs that I Needed to Put Food in my mouth!!!!!!! to give me Money for said food!!!!!!!!! jobs that I should have gotten because I was and am here LEGALLY but that they got because they were here ILLEGALLY!!!!!!!!!


joeandhisguitar
The jobs that are commonly done by illegal aliens were considered a right of passage in the workforce for students and teens. Those jobs,ie: mowing a neighbors lawn, fast food and the like were once done by Americans like myself in my youth. I do not compete with criminal illegal aliens anymore for those types of jobs, but i have and will continue to look out for the interests of the generations of Americans behind me that have lost that right of passage in the American workforce. You have proved MY point, that for supporters of illegal aliens and illegal aliens themselves it is all about them. I do not have to be in direct competition with an illegal alien to know that illegal immigration is wrong.


Joe Iwojima
they have ran anglos out of schools here in texas by their sheer numbers and have contributed to the spiraling crime rate. they fill our couty hospitals and roads with unlicensed and uninsured drivers. you will be paying for these unwanted invaders for years to come amigo.


Bookworm
Rating
It wouldn't bother me if Mexicans came here the LEGAL way, but most of them don't. I'm not anti-immigration, but I am anti-ILLEGAL immigration because my taxes go to give them a free life here in America.

No, no illegal has ever taken a job that I wanted. But then, I never wanted to scrub toilets or mow lawns.


marmiteontoast
Rating
No. But then I've never worked for an employer who hires illegal aliens - only employers who require that all non-US citizen employees fulfil the I-9 requirements and can prove their legal status and employment authorisation in the US.

*edit* Oh... maybe I shouldn't have even answered this question, as it's addresed to 'anti-immigrationers'. As I'm an immigrant (a 100% legal one, thank you very much) myself, I can hardly be 'anti-immigration', and I probably don't qualify to answer. But I do know that my employers don't hire illegal immigrants. So...


danno
Rating
that's not the point you idiot


Yoda
Is the country in this post racist?

http://www.cbn.com/cbnnews/world/060815a.aspx

All countries have the right to have immigration laws.
All countries have the right to enforce its borders.

And they don't have to explain WHY to you.

If you don't like laws, rules, and regulations, go live on a deserted island somewhere BY YOURSELF.

Because, like it or not, this is the year 2007, and WE DO have immigration laws.


forgivebutdonotforget911
Rating
I speak for my daughter and some of her friends that are looking for work and a first job. The answer is YES.

They have applied at a number of fast food places to work. One of the questions they get asked is, "Are you bilingual?" They all put down no. They all got turned down for that reason.

Just why do you have to be bilingual to flip a burger, serve a soda or clean a table? The places do not want Americans who want higher pay and an easy job. They want illegals who will work for less and bust their butts so they do not get fired. They want illegals who will not complain about safety violations or not being paid over time. They want indentured servants. They want people they can pay under the counter so they can save not having to pay Social Security or Workman's Comp Insurance.

So yes, jobs are lost due to the illegals. They need to go home.


Mattymc323
First ! We are not against immigration ! Immigration is the legal migration of people from one country to another. Legal Immigration ! Second we aren't racist thats a word used to shut down intelligent debate on the subject. Be careful you aren't impeeding the free exchange of ideas by using that word. Your argument is all wrong. You need to have more respect for those who have waited and tried to get into this country legaly. They spend alot of money and wait for a long time to get here. Illegal immigration isn't really Immigration at all its an invasion. Millions of undocumented people flooding over our borders. Jobs ! Contractors in this area who follow the letter of the law reguarding employment are losing contracts to employers who hire illegals. But that is the very least of my worries ! Our very culture and our way of life is threatened. Diseases that were virtually destroyed 30 years ago are comming back. Illegals crossing the borders without proper immunizations are spreading diseases like TB.... Use your head man ! Its so much deeper than what your question covers.


Bush Blows
No, but because of them, 17 medical clinics in los angeles have been closed

the only way you couldnt be bothered by illegals is if you dont pay taxes
Get off your booty and earn a check for once!


froggy_logic
Rating
nope i have worked with a few mexicans and in my expirence they were great.

No the real issue is humanity. before you are American and they are Mexican we are all humans and desire the same thing in life. who are you to say nope you cant have it only because of where you were born!

Also if you really wanted to curb the illegal immigration would it not be much easier to crack down hard on the rich fat white guys who hire the illegals? if you remove the carrot they are less likely to cross illegally.

why not offer a trade for every fat american living off welfare more than 3 years we ship their lazyass to mexico for somone at least willing to work. those people have more effect on raising your taxes, welfare, free medical care etc as the illegal mexicans just because they were born on this side of the border they earn the right to be lazy??? . but at least the mexican is doing something constructive and trying to better themselves!!


I agree there is a political double standard. mexicans are called illegals. cubans are called refugees or defectors. it is a result of the cold war era relations with cuba the american government considers cuban defectors as a slap in castro's face and proudly put images of them on american tv for everyone to see and offer political anmesty instantly but in reality those cubans are just as illegal as the mexicans


?
Nope!


GSXR
Rating
No not at all


candyapple58
I can honestly say no.


mestizo caliente
the reality is that they dont take jobs that educated american citizens do, is nto only fast food service, they do a lot of dirty jobs that americans dotn want to do, and there is still a lot of jobs, do you think most people get unemployment check because of illegals or because they are lazy?


citizen of the world,multiracial
good question, it will be hard that a fruit picker a dishwasher or an american carwasher complains,,illegals get the job americans dont want, it really doesnt happen





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why are so many people mad at my race?
Mexicans

are you guys going to put us in concentration camps now or what, im legal born and raised in the u.s and all i hear is racism against mexicans, how we are leaches to society..what ...


 I know about a illegal imagrant who is a driving around with no licences no insurance and fake papers what do?
what should i do i dont want any one to get hurt he has domestic violnce charges aginst ...


 Why do illegals cry when you beat them up?
We beat a kid in school because he looked like an illegal and then he was crying. What a wuss, you can jump the border but can't take a beating, go back to mexico....


 Omg i met a blond hair/blue eyed woman and barely speaks english and she's mexican?!?

Additional Details
i mean she looks like a swedish model and i thought she was "american" and i started speaking to her but told me she cant undertsand english , she just ...


 Do you think their would be a difference of opinions if most illegal immigrants were blond hair and blue eyed?
People, please be honest. In my opinion, I believe most anti supporters are racist. What do you think?
Additional Details
I thought I was going to here a lot of racial driven rants but I ...


 How many immigrants will come to Britain next year?
The government reckon they are going to stop some Eastern Europeans coming to Britain from next year. Are they really, or do they realise that Britons on the whole are fed up with immigrants coming ...


 Do you think America will be officially bilingual one day?
Do you think the time will come where both English, and Spanish will be official languages in the USA. Today neither are official....


 When will the Goverment offer its proposed Amnesty for illegal immigrants?
...


 Is it offensive to legal Americans to be accused of being lazy or unwilling to do manual labor?
We have heard from advocates of illegal amnesty that they are here because legal Americans are lazy.

I am not a lazy individual, nor are the people around me. Do you have opinions as to ...


 Why racist call undocumented people criminals ??
Even the world "illegal" I see it as bad, I think the right word will be undocumented.

Immigration laws and penal laws are two different things
Additional Details
Ja ...


 England non-white very soon?
What is it like in your area?...


 Should all non-Native Americans be deported from the U.S.?
...


 Is YOUR state negatively affected by illegal immigration?
Good effect/bad effect/no change?...


 Would you report him?
He is a neighbour who has two cars, one with no tax and one with a false tax disc in the windscreen.
He is causing parking problems for all the other people who have to go out to work and earn a ...


 Would you break the law to feed your starving children?
Breaking the law is no good thing, everyone knows. but if my children asked me for food, and i didnt have money or the nike sweatshop wouldnt hire me, i would hop the fence and cross the border 2 no ...


 Do you think Americans hate towards Mexican immigrants is justified?
I am starting to believe you are being sold a nice idea that leaves you unaware of real problems, the powers are laughing at many of you....


 Why do so many Americans despise immigrants when they are descended from immigrants themselves?
Most people here in the U.S. seem to despise immigrants, especially those from Mexico and Central America. They criticize these people for seeking a better life in the U.S. and say they should try to ...


 Do you ever dream of escaping to the Caribbean?
Pick your best Caribbean island to live and work on….
Additional Details
Half the people didn't pick an island!...


 Why are people like this ALWAYS the first ones to whine about racism? (response to a Q about terrorism)?
..but they don't hesitate to use words like "cracker" and "trailer trash" and "redneck" and gringo" etc. etc. What hypocrites! I get stupidity like this on a ...


 Why is that only mexicans are considered illegals, how about Polish in Chicago, or Italians in New York?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074