Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Are you for or against Texas allowing people to shoot criminals?
Find answers to your legal question.





Are you for or against Texas allowing people to shoot criminals?

Recently a Texas man shot two illegal criminal aliens robbing a neighbor's house. The Family's house he was protecting were themselves LEGAL immigrants so there is clearly no racial motive. Even the Black Panthers have not claimed in their protests any racial motives.

Also the Police now say that the man who fired was also confronted on his own property as well.

The question is really do you think that the rest of the nation should follow Texas' lead in this area or should the rest of the Nation condemn Texas Law?

http://www.drudge.com/news/100926/audio-texas-man-kills-neighbors-burglars

Please let me know what you think
Additional Details
Gabriel, respectfully you are incorrect. Don't feel bad though I saw the interview only last night where the Pasedena Chief of police said that the 61 year old home owner was confronted on his own property and that right before they were shot one of the men moved closer to him AFTER he'd ordered them to not move.

Why should I as a homeowner have to allow robbers to come and go as they please? Have we lost our collective minds?

BTW These two violent felons it turns out had rap sheets a mile long each and were part of a gang. They'd been in America illegaly and for years were on a criminal rampage.

I think they got off easy. At least tehy don't have to spend years (at my expense) locked up and suffereing in prison.

At least we can take solace in the certain knowledge that they died doing what they loved...


    




Ms.L.A.
I am for it. Our neighbors look out for us and vice versa. If I caught someone in their home robbing them, I'd shoot first and ask questions later and the exact same is true for my own property. Why should illegals or any other criminal be allowed to pillage and plunder another's home? I suppose some may say let them have it, I say hell no that's what's wrong with our nation today. There are boundaries that should not be crossed much like our borders!!


texas beach girl
Well, it's either that or the criminals will shoot ME first. It's our right to protect ourselves, living in Texas or not.

I would gladly shoot criminals in my neighbors' house and I would hope they would do the same.

-Adrienne (Houston, TX)


Squirrel Cage
Rating
I am for it. They were robbing the house


asdf
Rating
I am for it. These "gangstas" who wreck communities and terrorize parts of the cities think they are so badass. Well, obviously not when armed and vigilant citizens are ready.

BTW, illegals don't have rights. And we have the right to defend our property.


Tony Blair
Rating
I agree with the guy that shot them. Illegals are here illegals and shouldnt have rights.


kiddkosmic
For it.


The Voice of Reason
My hat is off to Texas! Protect your property if the government wont protect the borders!


Po
Personally I prefer to beat thieves to death.


open thoughts
Rating
I think that if you are protecting yourself, your family, or your property, and the use of deadly force is necessary (and if they are in your house, I do not care if they are leaving) then shooting criminals is warranted.

pplz1st...so by your logic, he should have held them at gunpoint and robbed them. That would have been equal, right?

John L....if you walked in on your young daughter being raped by a man who, if you did not shoot, would snap you in half or shoot you, would you kill them? You say it is never okay....are you going to watch someone rape your small child, wife, whoever? I don't think so.


ramarro smith shadow
It is obvious that such individuals have no respect for property or life of others, thus perhaps this is the only message they comprehend or will be deterred by and if so then this is the answer.


Mother
ABSOLUTELY YES.


Wrenched
Actually, The rest of the states would do well to adopt that portion of the Texas Constitution.


Sway_27
Actually Quanell X did say something about the Horn shooting, but now that Horn made national news, 2 more would be burglars have been shot and killed and i fully support it.


Thomas SR
Rating
Yes! The only time you will really wish you had a gun to defend yourself is when you are confronted by a criminal who is armed with one. I used to be staunchly anti-gun until I had a group of drug-crazed bikers literally kick my front door in one night. Only the fact that my neighbor came to the rescue with a gun of his own saved me from serious injury or death that night. We live in a rural area, and the 911 operator informed me that it would be at least 45 minutes before the sheriff could arrive. I told her that they would probably only find my still-warm body by that time. Right about then was when my neighbor heard the commotion and came over to rescue me. He held all 4 of them on the ground at gun-point until the police arrived to arrest them. It's a sad fact, but you can research it for yourself: New York and Washington D.C. have the tightest gun-control laws in the nation, AND they also have the highest gun-violence rates in the nation. Figure it out. When the government force fully disarms all of the HONEST, LAW-ABIDING citizens, then only the CRIMINALS are left with guns. And they have the advantage of knowing that their victims will be without a serious and effective means of protecting themselves against an armed attacker or home-invader.


Fonz
I think that you have the right. I'm all for it... I'll bet there hasn't been a robbery in that neighborhood since.


Mezmarelda
Rating
According to VP Chaney, you can shoot anything that moves in Texas.


I'm gonna start another riot
Yes they were a threat to him once they were on his land then he sees them breaking into the house next door. Are the robbers going to return and take out the only witness to their crime


Jim P
I believe a person has a right to defend their property. Don't know enough about the Texas case to say whether it was a righteous shooting or not, that call is made by the responding officers.

Burglary can so often lead to more serious crimes, so many rapes and murders are perpetrated by burglars who break in, get caught, and flip out. IMHO a person in my home without my permission is on VERY THIN ICE.

Personally, the two occasions I have used my own weapon to defend myself or my home I did not have to fire a shot. The bad guys saw my weapon, saw I was ready to use it, and ran away.

I am not a backshooter, I let them leave. In both cases they did NOT come back.


costa
Rating
I think that illegal criminal aliens should be shot - but it needs to be controlled by law.


Cleo
Rating
The Castle Doctrine is alive and well in Texas as well as the state in which I live.
These were bad guys with rap sheets proving it.
The way the law in written in Texas the homeowner was well within his right to do what he did on at least 4 points of the new law.
It is my hope that the grand jury will throw this inquiry out. It may send a message loud and clear to any theif or thug that thinks what is yours is also theirs.


BAJ
for it. Criminals have no rights. Blow their heads off.


?
Rating
the polic cant be every where..i will protect my self and my family any way i can ..its either kill or be killed..look how many
small store cashiers and owners now have guns behind the cash register....we seem to be reverting back to the old west days where every body will be carrying guns...


Grand Old Party
Rating
For it. We need more people like Joe Horn.


Free Thinker
Absolutely! I feel every American should be able to carry a gun...people will be much nicer to each other or they will get their head blown off!


I worship his shadow
Rating
For it... just wish I owned a gun... but won't buy one 'till the kids are out of the house.


thegod
I am 100% in support of killing criminals.


Emily L
"Trespassers will be shot"

I'm all for it. If someone's doing harm to my property, then I have every right to shoot them. If they didn't want to be shot, then they should have just stayed home.


viola f
Rating
i think its a heck of a good idea.....lots of states have make my day laws and im all for it


Cavalier KCS mom
Illegal or not I'd still shoot someone if i thought they were going to harm me, my family, or my neighbors. My Dad asked a Police officer one time "if someone was to rob our house would i get arrested if i were to shoot and kill him on my own property?" The police officer's response was "say you saw a flash so you reacted to it and thought your life was at stake. Just make sure you don't shoot them in the back. It's one less criminal the tax payers have to take care of."

I am a white American. ******* come in all colors. If they were Caucasian i'd still shoot them if my life was at stake.

It's in the constitution we have the right to bare arms.


jeffery d
I say its hard to accept. Someone being allowed to shoot someone, who is breaking in a house a crime. I would hope my neighbor like me enough to help me protect my family and possessions. I say that being allowed to do so like in TX is a great way to send the proper message. You commit a crime you will pay for it. I personally know a old woman that a man broke into her home and fell from the roof and sued her for his injury.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why don't people read the entire question before answering...?
You may be missing the main point of it by not reading the whole question. And sometimes it makes your answers look silly......Why do we do that, I have been guilty of it too...........


 Why do immgrants have to pay for flights when visiting back home?
shouldn't we get it free or paid for by the government, my 8 children and i want to visit our families back home in sudan but it is going to cost us too much money, why can't the u.k system ...


 World population needs to be reduced. Isn't it time to limit families of all nationalities to 2 children?
Isn't it common sense to want to bring less children into the world to ensure that the world stays viable? China is doing it I believe. What about Muslims? They have the highest birth rate of ...


 Do you only hate illegal immigrants or...?
Do you only hate illegal immigrants or anyone who migrated to your country although it was throught the legal process? I was just curious because I am in the process of migrating to another country LE...


 What's your ethnicity?
Just curious :)...


 Serious illegal immigration question?
I am married to an LEGAL immigrant. He has been in the US about 11 years. The problem is that a year ago his mother called him to let him know that his brother, sister, and her husband were coming to ...


 What do you think about race mixing?
Bluebirds like to be together, eagles hang out with eagles, sparrows stick with sparrows, buzzards go with buzzards. They're all birds, but they go with their own." - Muhammad Ali. (Cassius ...


 If you enter US with Tourist VISA and over extend it, are you still considered illegal?
A person that has Tax ID and paid all taxes for income and has all documentation that proves such, also has a valid driver's license... Can they be deported?...


 Why american hav so much hate for mexicans?
i am indian and asked question about immigration and i want to come legally, not illegally...but negative answers came, what wrong ? is it too bad there?...


 Why are people concerned with immigrants learning English?
I've read a couple of posts that state a concern over immigrants learning english and making it mandatory to learn it.

What is the reasoning behind this concern?

In ...


 Do you really believe that illegals don't pay taxes?
Do you believe that NONE of them pay taxes?...


 Is "America" really the land of the free?
...


 Would you riot to stop a mosque being built in your street?
...


 How many of you noticed there are two American flags at the bottom of your page?
I've been on Yahoo answers since April and just noticed there are two American flags at the bottom of the page. One for English and one for Spanish. Beyond what I've already done, (sent ...


 Would you help a Mexican get into the US to join their family there if a lot of money was involved?
I`m niether Mexican or American. This is a question in theory only....


 Should Americans be expected to learn Spanish?
I mean there are 12-15 million illegal immigrants about to be given amenesty.
Should we futher give them a big "Welcome to your new country" gift by flattering them by learning thier ...


 What would be a good country to live in ?
I'd really like to leave the UK, but obviously had it too good for too long and can't adjust to potential slavery.
Where would you emmigrate to if you could, and why ?...


 Do you openly dislike Muslims?
If so, I'm just curious as to what your reasons are....


 What do you think about bilinguals (like myself) getting paid more than a non-bilingual?
I know most of you hate ilegals and think they are the only reason for spanish being used in the US, but there are some legal Mexican-American citizens, Puerto Ricans, and other latinos that are ...


 I have enough of yahoo answers Iam closing down. but I will leave you with this thought.?
In 20 years time British will not mean pride it will mean Muslim.
It does not make me a bad person to say that....




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074