Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Can anyone tell me some trueth about the West?
Find answers to your legal question.





Can anyone tell me some trueth about the West?

A Ghanaian woman who was removed from a Cardiff hospital where she was receiving cancer treatment and flown home after her visa expired has died.

Source: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/wales/7305963.stm


    




dattguy
Rating
This is a bit debatable. Some people support her removal while some people did not. Unfortunately, it's the UK government who have the last say and though they didn't show mercy, we cannot fault them for doing what they thought was right in order to win votes.


beth x
Rating
It is a sad thing, but how many British people die from receiving inadequate care from the NHS?

The truth about the West is that it is not the Promised Land, even for its own citizens.


peter b
For all you people who think that it was wrong to deport her.
This country does not owe the rest of the World a living.
The next time you see or hear about the NHS struggling to treat a OAP, or a children's ward having to make cutbacks due a cash shortage you would do good to remember that, but if you want to be a good Samaritan you can pay out of your own pocket the next foreigner who requires free medical treatment.


Irn Bru
Rating
it could also be said why should she have the treatment if she is not paying taxes, a Ghanian women who is not a british citizen which occupies cancer treatment that someone else may not have acess too, i understand thats a rather harsh approach but i think thats how some people look at things like this im afraid.


MonaLisa Overdrive AM VT wannabe
Would she have been better off had she just stayed in Ghana?


kemlyn
whats the problem? the law is the law! she and her family should be happy that she died in the country she was born in. if you are trying to make an issue out of her being treated badly my the nhs.why couldnt she get the same treatment in ghana? i will tell you why. because she thought she could come over here and get it done for free.thats why!


Lori K
Rating
Some truth...okay. Many people die of cancer, whether they are treated in Wales or Ghana. Plane rides don't make cancer worse.


Barne-Hurst
Too many people coming in.Sorry she died, but we
just can't cope with all this influx!


Oswald W
Isn't it a strange that Britain gave up all her Colonial Territories and when she left, those very same People who couldn'.t wait for their independence ,now latch on to try and keep as close to Britain as possible . Even if they have to do it in an illegal manner.


nellie
Rating
I don't understand what your question is. What do you want us to tell you? Any country has to have laws and rules to live by including immigration laws, which, as I understand it, this lady had disregarded by taking the risk of working here illegally. It's heartbreaking that her situation was exposed because she became ill, but what a dreadfully difficult decision the authorities had to make. Personally I think they should have shown compassion and let her stay longer to see how she responded to treatment, but that is just my own sentimental view and I'm not answerable to the tax payers of this country. My heart goes out to her family and friends, but like all of these stories there are so many issues involved.


SnoddersB
Rating
And????? We, the general public in Britain, are fed up with these health and other scrounger immigrants. As we in England have problems getting the NHS to do anything for us why should we put up our money, that which is left after the EU has scrounged what they want, for any one else. Charity begins at home and the sooner this government threw out all illegals the better. do you think that she would have left had she not been in a place where she could have been found????


Neil T
I`m sorry that this woman has died. However like many people she came over here for treatment, having not paid a penny in contributions to the NHS, why should the taxpayer be defrauded by her and her ilk?
Let charity begin at home!


Scouse
Rating
I have no objection to someone coming here and taking ill and being treated on the NHS but I do have a strong objection to someone who is already ill coming here and crying foul when the NHS does not treat them.

I think we all know of horror stories of people who have lived here all their lives worked and paid taxes then going into hospital and actually dying of neglect I myself know of one case in which the neglect was so bad it would have almost been manslaughter but he had a family to take the hospital on


Al S
life is rough, isn't it?


Wild 4 U
Rating
Call the NHS what you like, but the treatment and service you receive, is far better than anywhere else in the world. Dollar for Dollar.


LUCKY
death of a child, arab, immigrant, a mother, a house pet is never a good thing. perhaps only in a sense that, that being is no longer fighting pain.

the least we should do, is pay a thoughtful moment to the one who will miss her and and the one's whom she no longer touches. i quarantee you...... when your call comes, i'll pay you that respect. even animals circle the carcass for a while.

I


robert c
I feel sorry!Very sorry for that poor woman!However!Can the British NHS support the entire Worlds sick!?


Badwolf
Rating
She should have said she was a terrorist who hated the west and hailed Bin laden, she probably would have been given the keys to the city


Medion
This woman did not sponge of the British people, as I understand a fund was set up for her to have the treatment.
The government make such a show of kicking out one sick woman, you would think they had repatriated a thousand terrorists.
Perhaps she should have come into the country illegally and stated she would be harmed if she went back. You could see the government falling over themselves to assist her in every way possible.


LadyMoonlight!!
We cannot provide NHS care for the entire world as well as for our own people. The NHS was set up to care for British people, not to look after the poor of every other country as well, we don't have the funds or infrastructure. Its very sad about this lady but if we allow one person to stay we will have to allow them all and our system will collapse.

The treatment she needed was available in Ghana, she just wasn't able to pay for it, which suggests that the fault lies with the Ghanaian Government, for not providing all its citizens with the healthcare they need. I suggest you turn your anger to them.


penelope_pitstop
Rating
That is really sad. I feel bad for her friends and family. I know there are a lot of you who say she was a burden to the British tax payer but if you were to read the article in full it does say that there were people donating funds to help her get her cancer treatment in the UK.

I understand she breached immigration rules but it did seem a bit harsh to deport her while she was obviously dying in hospital - These are just my personal thoughts as obviously this woman had friends and family who cared about her and immigrant or no immigrant she was a human being so she does deserve a little respect rather than the old, "kick her out now" approach which is all too common on yahoo answers where immigrants are concerned.

Yes she was wrong to breach her immigration conditions but she didn't kill anyone for goodness sake - at least try and have some compassion for the woman.


Blazing Pen Avenger.
I find this story, truly shocking. An Exparte application to a High Court Judge, supported by Affidavit with Exhibits, would have been sufficient, to, temporarily 'stay' any deportation order. The application would have been granted; pending any subsequent application (Ex or Inter Partes) or appeal.


old know all
Rating
Proof that if you scratch British civilisation, you'll find a savage lurking below the surface.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What LEGAL rights do ILLEGAL immigrants have in the USA?
...


 Are the Native Americans actually immigrants themselves?
Did they come from Siberia and cross the Bering Strait landbridge? If this is true why do the people who support illegal immigration use the Native Americans in defending why breaking the law is okay?...


 Would you emigrate if you could?
I don't think I've met many people who wouldn't (we're in south east England) so where would you go?...


 Why do americansthink that illegal immigrants are taking their jobs?
...


 Moslem women give birth to 3.6 children each on average , british women 1.8 can the uk survive and how ?
...


 Do you really think illegals want to just work?
or in the back of there mind do they really want to take over? not that they could but mexicans still hold a grudge over the war in wich we won in a fair fight.do you think it is already happeneing ...


 Why isn't Gorge Bush doing anything about illegal immigration?
Except making it easier?...


 Whi is it that liberals don't understand the diference between legal and illegal when it comes to immigration?

Additional Details
Ti Lady D and all others: I NEVER saind anything about Mexican. I am referring to ALL illegal aliens, including, Arabs, Asian,and European.....


 Why stupid americans dont know crap about inmigration !!?
Ohh come in a legal way !!! if it would be easy dont you think everybody would come in a legal way idiots.

Calling criminals to people that just want a better life, you are the freaking ...


 If asylum seekers are so glad to get out of their country, why do they cross 3 or 4 others to get here?
...


 Are you sick of hearing that we stole California from Mexico?
Some people need a history lesson. The Republic of California broke away from Mexico and was an independent nation before America brought it in as a state of the United States Of America.

M...


 Talking about illegal actions or immigrants?
You think illegal immigrants are violating the law, what about all that territory that was taken away from Mexico ILLEGALY back in the 1800's? ? California, Nevada, Colorado, New Mexico, A...


 What would Jesus do to illegal immigrants?
Would HE deport them or would HE give them green cards?...


 What does this question have to do with illegal immigration?
Why do McDonald’s game pieces now come in English AND Spanish?


Can someone explain the rationale behind these kinds of questions?...


 What do you think of this?
This is information was retrieved from INS/FBI statistical report on illegal immigration.

62% of all "undocumented immigrants" in the United States are working for cash and not ...


 When Hispanics take over will they make white people work in the fields, and be maids, etc?
...


 Why do people think someone hates America just because....?
they point out things that are hypocritical? I don't hate America, I just think that people are making a huge deal over Mexicans comming over. This country was built on immigration. I don't ...


 Don't you hate it when...?
when people who were born in america say that they deserve it and others don't?

i believe that people born in america are just plain lucky and thats that. they do not actually "...


 Uh-huh, and illegals aren't dirty?
If illegals pick all of our produce as you pro-criminals say, are they poisoning our lettuce and spinach supply?

E-coli breakouts.

There was a study done on Mexican food ...


 Can you see a time when Britains born in Britain are in the minority?
In a story about how the Government failed to plan for the impact of immigration on public services, particularly in relation to immigrant births, the following statistics are posted:

LIVE ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034