Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Can we clear something up?
Find answers to your legal question.





Can we clear something up?

Am I right when I say that this immigration issue should not be compared to the civil rights movement?If I was black that would really piss me off.
Additional Details
I can't decide,but I will say this,I shouldn't have said that if I was black it would piss me off.It does piss me off.


    




?
WOW!!! Finally... Something You And I Agree On Pancha

The Black Community In Our Nation Is Largely Composed Of The Descendents Of People That Were VICIOUSLY STOLEN From Their HOMES And FAMILIES
And Brought To This Country AGAINST Their Will,
And TREATED Like ANIMALS And PROPERTY,
And SUFFERED BEYOND COMPARE To ANY OTHER PEOPLE In Our Nations History

ILLEGAL ALIENS in America are here only because
they are GUILTY of CRIMINAL VIOLATION of our FEDERAL LAWS,
Jumping our borders and living in a shadowy underground economy.

They are Morally Culpable for Shoving Aside those who Adhere to the Law
and Enter These United States in an Orderly and Legal Fashion

There Is NO COMPARISON Here

THERE IS NO INJUSTICE HERE -Except To The AMERICAN TAXPAYERS-

WHERE IS THE INJUSTICE To The ILLEGAL Immigrants???

ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS SNEAK Into Our Nation Without Authorization,
And STEAL The RIGHTS Of American Citizens
The RIGHTS That MANY Have DIED FIGHTING To Get For This Country

All The While Enjoying The Liberties That American Citizens
Have Worked HARD For Over 200 Years Through Our History To Get

They Are Trying To Steal AMERICAN HISTORY

And Now They Are Attempting To STEAL THE RIGHTS That Dr. King FOUGHT SO HARD For
And GAVE HIS LIFE To Get For His Community

And Then They Have The AUDACITY To COMPARE This To The CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT???

NOONE EVER Held YOU In Chains-
NOONE EVER Bought Or Sold YOU-
NOONE EVER FORCED YOU To SLAVE In The Cottonfields AGAINST Your Will-
NOONE EVER Chased YOU Around In White Pajamas In The Middle Of The Night-
Or HUNG YOU From A TREE And WHIPPED You Till You Were CRIPPLED Or Dead-
NOONE EVER Blew Up YOUR House Of Worship, Killing YOUR Children-
YOU NEVER Had To Sit At The Back Of The BUS -
YOU NEVER WERE DENIED SERVICE At A LUNCH COUNTER-
Or DENIED The Use Of A RESTROOM-
Or A WATER FOUNTAIN-
Or A SCHOOL-
Or A HOSPITAL-

NOT ONE OF YOU EVER ONCE Had To Experience The INDIGNITY That The Black Community Faced In This Nation

YOU STOLE Your Way Into This Nation
To Get UNLIMITED, FREE HEALTH, EDUCATION, And WELFARE Benefits
Out Of The POCKETS Of Hardworking American CITIZENS
(Black, White, Hispanic, Italian, German, Polish, Asian, MiddleEastern, CITIZENS - Need I Say MORE???)

The Black Community NEVER HAD The BENEFITS That ILLEGAL Immigrants Are Taking (STEALING) For Granted
And THEY WERE CITIZENS, Crushed By OPPRESSION

Till Dr. King Began To Open Our Eyes

The ILLEGAL Immigrants Were NOT Peacefully Protesting,
As Dr.King Would Have Surely Condoned -
They WERE Of A MOB Mentality
And They WERE DEFACING OUR AMERICAN FLAG
And THREATENING AMERICAN CITIZENS

I NEVER Heard Of ONE Instance Where Dr. King
Or ANY Of His People
DEFACED Or DESTROYED An American Flag -
Or THREATENED ANYONE

HIS People Protested PEACEFULLY
Because Dr. King INSISTED On It

And They Were Subject To Even MORE Indignity.

He Was PROUD To Be An American
And HE SET Some Of The STANDARDS

That We TRY To Live By As American Citizens Today

There Is NOT ONE AMONGST You ILLEGAL Aliens
That Can Even Begin To TRY To Compare Yourself
To The Caliber Of The Man That Dr. King Represented As An AMERICAN CITIZEN

I Believe That Dr. King Would Be OUTRAGED At The THOUGHT
Of Comparing THIS Issue With HIS EFFORTS To This Nation During HIS Civil Rights Movement
And Im Concerned That The ENTIRE BLACK COMMUNITY In This Country Isnt Feeling OUTRAGED As Well

I Know I Am, And Im A White Man

YOU WANT RIGHTS???- YOU WANT CIVIL RIGHTS???- Petition YOUR Government-
Go Back To YOUR COUNTRY
And Start Your OWN CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT
Dont Try To STEAL It From The MEMORY Of A GREAT MAN Like Dr. King
Dont Try To STEAL AMERICAN HISTORY

HAVENT You STOLEN ENOUGH From America???

Go Find Your Own Crusader, One That Has His Own Dream, For His Own People
STOP TRYING To INSULT Dr. Kings Dream,
The Dream He Had For HIS PEOPLE,
To OVERCOME The Terrible INJUSTICES That They Faced
During A Very DIFFICULT And UGLY Chapter In Our Nations History Book

Be COURAGEOUS, And STRONG And FIGHT YOUR GOVERNMENT...NOT OURS

WRITE YOUR OWN HISTORY BOOK.....FULLFILL YOUR OWN DREAMS

AMNESTY Would Surely SHATTER The DREAM Of

Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.


pixie_vixen117
Rating
I am confused by what you mean, and would be interested in why you say this, so I could better answer your question. What should piss black people off about it?


Incorrectly Political
Yes, you are right. The civil rights movement was about ending American citizens being screwed out of their god given and constitutional rights for a century, for no other reason than they are black. The illegal immigrant movement is about people breaking the law to come here, then demanding from our government rights that they are not willing to fight for in their own country.


coolgerman77
Rating
you are right. The immigration has nothing to do with the civil rights movement. those are two complete and separate issues. I will be offended myself on that issues.


torices1
Rating
I agree with you. It's an insult to the civil rights movement.


69Stang
This is correct==Omg--Pancha--we agree on something--there isn't nothing to compare the two..way to go


Mr. Boof
Rating
For once, I think I understand what you're saying (is this the real Pancha?). This has nothing to do with, nor is it like the civil rights movement. I have seen several Blacks angered by the comparison.


Yo!
Rating
Yes, I would have to say that that is a correct statement.

The civil rights movement is about racism - and trying to end it.

This illegal immigration issue is about the law - regardless of a person's race.


drizztbabe
yes you are right. i don't see any similarities between immigration issues and civil rights movement.


mybabymydestiny
Rating
no It should not


mindless_scarecrow
Rating
tah tis true but the same thing happend to plack people we did fight to be free mexicans also wont to be free my family is mexcan on my moms moms side and on my moms dads side were black so i wont alll my people to be free my balck people r free now my mexican people need to b free


hayleylov
yep not the same


joeandhisguitar
Please try to understand...YOU DONT HAVE TO BE BLACK TO UNDERSTAND THE INJUSTICES BLACKS WENT THRU IN THIS COUNTRY. It should piss you off if you are a thinking logical person. I am beginning to think you are not. When Illegals use this notion that there is some type of similarity they (illegals and their supporters) are only trying to exploit the suffering of black Americans. this is what illegals do...they exploit America...


bradsgranny
Rating
No, it shouldn't be compared to the Civil Rights movement, because the black people were legal citizens and being deprived of rights they should have had without even thinking about it. They were treated horribly for centuries and even as late as the 50's some people didn't even consider them real humans. How's that for insane narrow mindedness? (And if it matters, I'm Caucasian.)

The immigration issue is about illegal immigrants. Whole different ballgame, in my opinion.

By the way, that was an excellent question.


Wyntersmile
African Americans did not immigrate to the United States. African Americans were brought to the United States involuntarily as slaves.


choctawdeer
Rating
if you were black and mature you would understand their plight. America is the land of the free. the mexican country is in turmoil.This is the land of opportunity.This is suppose to be the land where dreams come true. Just because some of you have it, don't deny it for some one else. Let them be free also.


Sashie
Rating
For once I agree with you!! Yippeee!!!!


Golden Girl
Rating
Get over it


eror
Immigration issues should be argued as human rights, not compared to civil rights because they're not citizens. Further more, civil rights movement is rooted by slavery and slaves were never here by their free will.


DAR
I think you are right. It really does piss some people off, and I don't see where it buys you anything, anyhow.


tbsp010103
Rating
You are absolutely right... immigrants CHOOSE to come here, where Africans were kidnapped and forcibly brought here, and they weren't given the option of becoming citizens until GENERATIONS later. It's completely ridiculous to make that comparison, and anyone who knows anything about the civil rights movement could tell you that.


luvamerica
COMPARING IT WITH CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT IS WRONG!


sugarpie
it shouldn't be compared to the civil rights movement!
it should not also be compared to gay pride! i love my gay friends.


raqes_honda
Rating
I REALLY CANT SAY BECAUSE I DONT LIVE IN THE USA


thebeatles1979
not the same but similar , african-american deserve respect.,however this movement had been inspired by the civil right mov. from the 60's although immgrants came here by choice they were force not by gun but economics weapons , neo-liberalism ,nafta(destroyed the mexican agribussines)and pilitical manipultaion
(latin american pseudo-democcracies are a lab for american economic experiments).
what is happenig is that the media it's selling this social movement as civil rigths theoriclly it is civil right movement since the son of illegal immigrants are citizents and many husband and wifes are citizents
and their spouser are not ,





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Have you ever committed a crime?
I have twice.Once a speeding ticket and another time I bounced a check.I made a mistake in math truthfully and was overdrawn by 32 cents.But the check still bounced.Because it was a very large amount ...


 Who commits more crimes in the US...?
http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov http://en.wikipedia.org/ Carefully read these official govmt statistics. ...


 What are you going to do when we all get amnesty?
You are crazy if you think that this will not happen. We will get amnesty and be a big voting block. Then we will begin voting Mexicans in office. Wait and see. Who is going to stop us? If you ...


 Do people like illegal law breaking criminals?
isn't that what people who sneak in over the border are?...


 Why when the gaysmarch in LA nothing happens. When Latino march LA police attack us ?
We are in the park andthe police attack us but they dont attack the gays even though they are aginstG...


 Should the US invade Mexico?
They're already here anyway, it would solve a lot of problems and makes more sense than the war in Iraq....


 Would you like to see a law making English the country's official language ?
...


 Are the immigrants really taking jobs of legal American poeple in the U.S?
I know for a fact they are not taking the jobs of high paying bussiness just jobs that are some peoples last ...


 People outside of the U.S., what do you think of Americans?
...


 How does an Illegal justify their right to be here?
I saw where someone said "They just do jobs US Americans are too lazy to do" Then mentioned field work.Immigrant labor makes up 25% of the agricultural work force. Meaning 75% are from the U...


 Why do they arrest and deport the Chinese illegal immigrants?
At least they are working in Chinese Restaraunts and not taking other people's jobs. Also, they are not homeless and they are not involved in violent crime against English like the African, J...


 My Bully's parent's are illegals. Can I call the immigration authority and report it at school?
His parents are illegal's, can I call the border patrol and have them kick his parents out of the country? They are illegal. The bully is legal.

Can I get back at him, by doing this?...


 Should it be a crime to help illegal immigrants?
...


 Why are we paying tax for immigrants and bogus asylum seekers..................... ?
...


 Will Immigration Ruin the USA?
Like global warming, immigration seem inevitable. Will it ruin our lives here?...


 Why some Brits feel so feared of immigrants stealing their national identity?
Is that because they are all immigrants or their descendants, so some of them feel unsettled and endangered by newcomers?
Similar thing goes about Americans.
Additional Details
S...


 Are you oppose, or for immigration?
...


 The issue is "Having"to learn Spanish not as a choice?
I speak 3 languages fluently.And am learning Spanish.But that's my CHOICE.Do you think you should HAVE TO learn Spanish?

That's the point I think I see people trying to make on ...


 Has anyone seen this?
The majority are "just here for a better life?" What about the ones like this? Am I supposed to feel sorry for these menaces?8/3/2006

by William Gheen of Americans for Legal I...


 Do you think a wall on the border is really going to work to stop illegal immigration?
I think we should close off our borders with Mexico too. I mean we should have both things, borders closed and border fence. That's really going to stop illegal immigration!...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.054