Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Cuban Immigrants vs. Mexican Immigrants. Fair?
Find answers to your legal question.





Cuban Immigrants vs. Mexican Immigrants. Fair?

Why are Americans so up in arms about illegal Mexican immigrants possibly getting amnesty and work permits? Cubans have been coming to American for decades and the immigration policy for them is basically "if they make it to the US they get asylum and a green card". Mexicans too are fleeing a corrupt government, poor conditions, and a horrible economy.

The current "wet foot, dry foot" immigration policy where if they are caught at sea they are return but if they reach US soil they are allowed to stay was enacted in 1995. Details on the policy are available at: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wet_feet,_dry_feet_policy

What ever happened to equal protection under the law? You cannot, constitutionally, treat Mexican immigrants any differently than you treat immigrants from any other nation.

Either END the special treatment of Cuban immigrants or grant the same special treatment to ALL immigrants.


    




Ya heard me
I agree, lets END the special treatment of Cuban immigrants. No illegal should ever get amnesty!!


Joshua H
Cubans are refugees from a dictatorship. Mexico may have its flaws, but it is nothing like Cuba.


Erick Q
The biggest difference is that Cubans are fleeing from a Dictatorship whereas Mexicans are fleeing a (corrupt) Democratic government. The immigration policy that you referred to makes it legal for Cubans to seek asylum once they are here. There is no such policy in place for Mexican immigrants, making any undocumented immigrants (from most countries) illegal. You can't ask for protection from the law if you are breaking the law, although even illegal immigrants have civil rights.

I get what you're saying, but I see how extending that invitation to ALL immigrants would put a huge strain on our economy as well as our national security.


Call Me Bwana
Rating
There's a difference.

Cubans are NOT allowed to emigrate freely from Cuba. Mexicans are allowed, nay, they are encouraged, to go to America.

Big difference.


Jeannie Out of the Bottle
Rating
Cuba--oppressed communist nation under a dictatorship.
Mexico--democratic nation which the citizens vote into office.

Cubans seek asylum. Mexicans and many other illegal aliens seek the almighty dollar only.

I have far more sympathy for the plight of Haitians, citizens of Darfur or Myanmar than those from our southern neighbor.


Melrose a
Fleeing from a communist dictatorship is different than fleeing from a country that is going through rough times. Hispanics have at least some opportunity to make their country better, if they stay and fight for what they believe in. In this country those who came before us had to fight for the freedoms and opportunities we have.


Victor
As somebody said, Mexicans can move freely in and out of their country and theirs is a democracy. No political oppression

We have a comunist dictatorship in our country

If the Mexicans want to receive fidel and the little brudder as rulers and send Felipe Calderon to us as our president, be my guest


(O \ ! / O) 67 Bug boi
How many cubans are there in cuba?
How many mexicans in mexico?

Sorry gotta block you.


Rick
Rating
The government in Cuba IS NOT ONLY CORRUPT. IT IS ALSO COMUNIST !

Does Mexico have a comunist government as well ?

Learn the facts before opening your mouth

And, yes. fidel is to blame in the first place for us not to be allowed to come here in many cases.

Of this, I am sure


Yak Rider
Rating
In 2007 about 3,500 Cubans made it to the USA and were able to stay under the terms of the Cuban Adjustment Act of 1965.

3,500, that's it.

Get over it.


Lego Indy
Cubans contribute more to this country than Mexicans, but if the choice is no special treatment of Cubans or the same treatment to all illegals, then I vote for no special treatment.

Or how about this: Let's treat Mexican illegals the same way Mexicans treat illegals in their own country, minus the rapes and murders.


D S
Rating
It's not just the Cuban vs Mexican immigration policy that should be looked at.


The Golden Buffalo
cubans are not allowed any avenue for immigration, mexicans can apply at the local embassy. I'm not sure if fidel is to blame for cubans not being allowed to come here. IDK the specifics, but i think the US does not allow any legal immigration from cuba. So when the baseball player declares asylum in america it is not because he was not free to leave cuba but because he does not meet criteria to be let into america and get a green card.

just as many americans flee thier own corrupt govt, poor conditions and horrible economy. any country i go to will enforce thier immigration policies if they catch me breaking thier laws.


MowYourOwnLawn
You have a good point and yes we should abolish the wet foot dry foot claus before we lose Florida entirely. Have you ever been to miami? It truly is a foreign country.


kingoyaks
Rating
It is just one of the many quirks of government.
I agree that legal immigration is the only way people should be allowed to stay here.
Instead of writing on the internet, write to your local Congressman/Senator, and see what they say.
Cheers


qnffktyd
they hit ur new $75,000benz and u cant sue them cause they dont exist in this country. how bout that?


billi1905
Yeah it's wack. Remember when we returned all the Haitians to Haiti? We had them at a temporary prison at Guantanamo. I do believe immigration law needs major reform, but I do believe we need limits. I also think we need a guest worker program, and an end to automatic citizenship to children born in this country to illegals. We also need to continue to increase aid and assistance to Mexico, and end the embargo on Cuba. That's my two pesos worth.


PJ
Life isn't fair. Have you not learned that, yet? There are different policies because of the embargo on Cuba. DUH!!!


tgif08
I agree it is not fair. Immigration laws need to be reformed soon. I believe Mexicans contribute more to the US then cubans. Mexicans come here to work, they take the jobs we do not want. Sure americans complain about them bringing down wages, yet ask them to take the jobs and they will decline.

I dont think they should grant the same treatment but they should find a half way point.


Alex K
It's all McCarthyism. The US hates the Cuban government way more than the Mexican government so it's like they're showing them up.


GreasyTony
Rating
Very good point! They should either allow the Mexicans to stay if their foot is in, or change the Cuban policy. There's more Mexican illegals in the US, therefore they contribute more!


Gloria
The difference is that unlike Mexican immigrants, Cubans, the first wave at least, came with money, which resulted in immediate acceptance by the US goverment. This financial power allowed them to put their own people in local goverment, that's why you' wont hear any talks on removing asylum status on Cuban immigrants. They also own the state of Florida, all they have to do is to threaten the current incumbent with giving their votes to someone else..and Florida is one of the states with a majority of electoral votes





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why does people say, that immigrants are taking their jobs??
I believe that no one is taking anyone´s job. People who really wants to work, don´t wait for a job to fall from the sky. They look for it....


 What does racism have to do with being against illegal immigration?
...


 Tony has one more point! We americans are in fact LAZY! WE WONT DO THE JOBS!?
When I was going to UC Santa Barbara, I participated in an Ethnography class in Isla Vista. For those who don’t know about Isla vista it is a very poor Latino community in the Santa Barbara area. C...


 Do you think there are any jobs 'that americans won't do'...?
...or is that just more hype?
Additional Details
LOL@robot berry-...


 I like to know how can i have someone come to usa and live with me without a job, but look for work?
not a lover , but as a friend. usa always want all things to be hard for all. paper work is all they know, should be good if you want to take the person in ur home ,if you never been in trouble with ...


 Why has hatred and violence towards Hispanics increased?
Do you believe that this hatred and violence has increased because of the one sided media coverage? It's seems that the media only talks about and glorifies the bad. The violence hasn't ...


 What is going on? Is Chavez the next Hitler with all his insane, extremest blithering?
Can you believe that Chavez claims to have an "informant" in the White House?

http://abcnews.go.com/In...


 Should we build a wall along the border?
If No? Why not
If yes, what kind of wall, steel, bricks, - with or without towers?...


 Why are "mexicans" so angry?
I saw them on t.v in the streets of california marching with their flags and making hateful statements to americans. Who is racist here? How did these people think this would help them? They were ...


 When illegal immigration disappears, our economy collapses, and prices soar, will you mind? No?
Okay.
Then can we sign you up to get out there and build our infrastructure? Highway construction? Maybe a nice job out in the orange fields?

I'll assume all the people screaming ...


 Immigrants REALLY contribute to society yes or no?
http://news.scotsman.com
http://thescotsman.scots
http://...


 What punishment do you think should be applied to illegal immigrants?
...


 I love illegal immigrants?
Is that a bad thing? I love them because I think they are great for the economy! They also will help cause things to change maybe in our own country?...


 Why do you hate Mexican?
There is a difference between Criminals, and Illegal immigrants. Illegal Mexicans come here for a better life not all the people have the priviledge to be born in a great country like USA. I'...


 How do you feel about the illlegal immigrants in USA?
...


 Is it possible for an illegal immigrant to say that they are from Cuba?
You know wet foot dry foot and US Citizenship and all that
Additional Details
I don't think anyone is understanding what I'm talking about I'm talking about people like E...


 Is our homeland being handed to the immigrants?
in a daily newspaper today (18-3-09) it has been estimated the one in seven primary schoolchildren have a foreign language as their mother tongue.

this equates to about 566.000 children ...


 Do Americans really think that we Mexicans travel in Burro, wear a huge Sombrero and celebrate 5 de mayo?
I would recomend Americans to investigate a bit more about other contries before they answer, they've the slightest about their southern neighbour, yet they speak as if they knew everything ...


 Does it seem fair that illegal immigrates don't do jury duty?
It seem to me that we provide all the benefits to illegal immigrates,and then don't require them to be liable for jury
duty.Americans that don't respond to jury duty can be arrested.<...


 Do you think that the laws would have been enforced if the amnesty bill would have passed?
I personally don't. They haven't done anything in the past 7 years about having the immigration laws enforced, what is to make them enforce any other laws? The only reason why they are ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034