Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Do illegal immigrants take our jobs, pay no taxes, and send US money back to Mexico?
Find answers to your legal question.





Do illegal immigrants take our jobs, pay no taxes, and send US money back to Mexico?



    




♥♥Cheelicious♥♥♥
Rating
Oh my goodness! What an original question! Only the 386th time someone asked this! No. No. And people are allowed to do whatever they wish with their money.. key word here meaning it doesn't belong to us, so maybe they do, it's none of my business.


muerto mujados
YES

YES

And Hell YES.


thundercloud
Rating
of course


maccrew6
Rating
yes...next?


swampy
Yes, Yes and Yes.


pawbear53
Rating
essentially. that's very true


I'm Q from the Q Continuum™†
Rating
hell yea


me-inside
Yes.


Kerie K
Rating
Yes, and the people in Mexico actually live off that money .... because the government there is corrupt. Pathetic, really.


FlossyJane
Rating
yes and the problem is with most races that come here is they live very basic so they just take out and not put back in. What happens is we are left empty and they are full.


dogwood345
Yes they do


stan b
Rating
yes


Postville
Yes they take our jobs. It is a common pro illegal propaganda tool to state they only want the jobs that Americans dont want. Most illegals. Well 98 % of them work in the service industry. These same jobs were held by Americans before the Illegal influx. The jobs have changed to exploit this cheap labor and now rely on it to maintain current profit projections. This is also called undercutting. When you hear Obama speek of wage stagnation it is in direct result of 35 million illegals saying they will do any job for less. When the job market has that sort of demand on labor then there is no need to increase the wages.

Yes/No They do not pay taxes LEGITIMATELY..Meaning the ones that are paying in are doing so under a STOLEN social security number.If they are paying under a TIN then they are not illegal. Most day laborers do not pay taxes and thus rob from the system.. Either way a LAW has been broken.

Yes they send money back to Mexico. Not all illegals are from Mexico however most thats 90% of illegals are from Latin America or Mexico. Anyway, they remit on average of 17.8 billion dollars a year.The issue with that is that this money is now flowing through the streets of Mexico. All or most of the illegals you see either are building a hacienda or have built one. Meanwhile, the money is not promoting sound US economics.

Illegal immigration is a financial sickness and needs to be addressed immediately.

Detain
Deport
Repeat.


Anna P
Rating
Mmm, if they take our jobs, they also pay taxes (witholding from the paycheck). Yes, not all are from Mexico, second ignorant comment (ignorant meaning why dont you know this stuff). yes, they do send money back, that's often why they come.

Wanna pick some lettuce or cherries and see how you feel at the end of the day? Bet you wouldn't come back!


"lysol"
Rating
Would u pick strawberries 4 10 bucks a day? The system is, what it is. Ain't no Gringos gonna do that work, u can make a lot more sellin' drugs. Case closed!!


thinkingtime
Are these the same people accused of staying home all day and living off benefits? Just wondered...


Clumsi_Muneca
NO! they take the jobs other people don't want.
maybe. some do!! not all immigrants are the same. some actually work hard to earn a living for them and their family. Yes, some bring drugs and and things like that but its not just illegal immigrants.its not just Hispanics that are into the drug cartel!
Yes, but so what? its their money and it doesn't hurt anyone!


mlb
Illegal immigrants do take our jobs but only jobs that we don't want. Who wants to work in a field picking tomatoes? Some do pay taxes but since they are illegal can't file for a tax return which benefits the government. They do send money back to their country. We need to have some compassion for these people. How would we feel if our kids were going without basic needs being met? We would do the same thing that the illegals are doing to support our families.


benchasebrown
Rating
Uh... YEAH! DUH!


milt560
YES!!

All illegal immigrants MUST self-deport or be forcibly deported!!!

Illegals do the following:

- steal our jobs
- depress wages
- have anchor babies
- steal our identities
- steal healthcare
- steal welfare / wic
- steal education benefits
- overburden our schools
- increase crime
- don't assimilate / don't speak English
- send money out of the country
- change our culture

Illegal immigration is not fair to immigrants that use the legal process!!!


Desperate
Rating
Yes, they do. So the Arabs, the Africans, the South Americans,the Russians, the Europeans and so on.

What is your point?


jeffmesa35
yeah so what


blogger
YES they take our jobs and not only cherry picking jobs either, A lot of the smarter illegals take ESL classes usually at the local high school at night, and learn basic english then they take more high up jobs like working at a hotel front desk or working at a car rental agency, so STOP saying they only take the labor jobs because that just isn't so!


Cluster C
well here goes 15 in a 3 bedroom house all on min wage. rent is 750 by 15 = 50.00 dollars a month a piece. that leaves one person with a good hunk of money for a new ride , rims , bling bling. or what ever.and what is really sad most are making 10,12 ,15 dollars an hour. right now there are not enough jobs for the american citizens . not even low paying labor jobs. yes they have devastated our economy and our work force . enough is enough, sick of it all. old news is a touchy subject. get over it already. same question , different day. dry stale toast,


Patricia C
Rating
Yes, they take the jobs that Americans won't take. Good for them.


hi
Rating
Uhh... don't Americans "immigrate" to Asian countries too...? What's so wrong about it...? We're all on the same planet...


dan b
yes an we got big mexicun drug cartels all ovr the us too who r kidnappin regular folks for drug money ransom.

if u dont belive me look it up 4 yoursef


R
Rating
Illegal immigrants do take American jobs which is mainly why they come to the US in the first place. They also send a lot of the money they earn back to their native country, probably around $23 billion a year. However, illegal immigrants pay billions in taxes each year (No one is sure exactly how much). For example, an estimated two-thirds of all illegal immigrants in the US pay Social Security taxes but will never receive the benefits. Actually, the only benefits illegal immigrants are eligible for are emergency medical care and kindergarten to 12th grade education.


alex
1. they didnt steal your job. they were just more willing to work for that job.
2. they pay no taxes, as they are not Us citizens.
3. what do you mean by sending back to mexico? is it wrong to send money to help your familia? yes the send money to mexico and i dont know how that can offend anyone else but an white us citizen.


Proud Mom of Rescued Rabbits
Rating
Okay. Here goes. Illegal Immigrants in my opinion do not really take our jobs. I mean how many people do you see applying for a position that will make you work in the heat/cold,rainy and windy weather 7 days a week? How many dish washers do you see standing in line to work? House keeping come on man. Latinos in general are labor workers. Yes. They do send most of their money back to their family and they live off of it because for every buck they earn here they would have only made about 35 cents in their home town. Sad honestly.
However many states are now bearing down on illegals and have laws or are starting to try and pass a law now to charge people who hire illegals to work.
Many people are happy about this. Personally I think there has to be a better solution to this then deporting.


franspace50
Yes, they do take jobs but those jobs are ones that most educated people will not want. That is not the big problem with illegal immigration the problem is that they also manage to get government aid, social security, and frequently are criminals whose background has not been checked. On the otherhand legal immigrants most often are required to have a higher level education, prove they are hireable, provide sponsors who promise to support them if they cannot find or loose work, and their criminal history is checked. The legal immigrant also pays fees associated with filing paperwork, lawyers fees, etc. It cost money to come to the USA legally. Those who do come legally who are well educated are able to contribute to our economy by creating businesses which create jobs for Americans and other legal immigrants, very much in contrast with illegal immigrants who may work menial jobs that no one else would want but drain the economy in other ways. Those menial jobs are gladly taken by the temporary workers allowed into the USA, who are not considered illegals but then the problem happens when they don't return at the required time and become illegals.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Europeans,came here,killed the Indians/Mexicans then called it America?
Genocide on a horrendous level....Put the last living Indians in little pieces of land...and guard the borders preventing the Mexicans from returning...to there native land...I know i am gonna get ...


 If I know someone is working illegally in my country should I report them?
I know someone who is here on a student visa which permits them to be employed by someone else for up to 20 hours a week. However I know that on many occaisons they not only work more hours, but are ...


 What should American do with white Americans when the Mexicans are the majority in 2050?
should they be trated as third class citizens, oppressed, enslaved or shipped to work camps?...


 Why US citizens are so Idiots and Dumbs????
....Ignorants,arrogants,rude,selfish,mea...
Additional Details
I don't need any proper English...i live in my Third world country thank God...and proper English....give me a BREAK!!...


 Without judgment as to right or wrong do you think it possible to deport 12 million people out of US?
Congress is debating options to deal with illegal immigation. Is mass deportation a viable option? How would it be done? How long would it take? Just curious about what others think....


 Should we kick the whites out of America?
Haaaaaaa..... Americans were always stuck up and looked every one down,like they were better than the Hispanics or Blacks.Always so proud that this was their land and that we were outsiders...How ...


 Is anyone else offended by Spanish taking over?
I should not have to press 1 to hear English when calling my bank. I am not saying to get rid of other languages, but why cant English be the default?...


 When are Mexicans going to stop crossing the boarder?

Additional Details
and im not talking about mexicans period so stop calling me raciest im talking about the ones that are making my parents pay for them to live here when there ...


 Are people afraid to air their true point of view?
Jack Straw aired his point of view about muslim women and veils! Are you a racist, bigot if you agree with him?

I want to say in a open forum that I agree with him and understand the ...


 Do we know that we all came here illegally and who is it to judge what is legal and illegal way of entering?
we are all from a line of immigrants except for native americans...who are the people in congress to justify what is the legal way of entering this country...the congress bought there way to make ...


 White schoolboy attacked by a gang of Asians and it is "not a racist attack" can anybody explain this to me?
http://uk.news.yahoo.com Details
The jury heard last year that Mr Webster had had a disagreement with an single A...


 Are mexicans the new slaves of America?
In corp America all the minorties are black and sometimes Asian. But you never see mexicans. But when it come to the dememer jobs of the nations all you see are mexicans, and they get as paid as ...


 Is tony Blair destroying the UK by letting in the immigrants?
...


 Is it really so hard to press 1 for English?
So many anti-immigration fanatics complain about how immigrants are supposedly ruining this country, and one of the things they complain about bitterly is how most telphone menus say "Press 1 ...


 Immigration: Will the flood of ILLEGAL Mexican Immigrants create a better America or will they turn us into a?
craphole like Mexico?...


 Are people in the States against not only illegal immigrants, but?
legal immigrants too?...


 Hussein Obama called those who opposed the illegal immigration bill racists, what do you say to him?
Sen. Barack Obama told La Raza in Miami Beach yesterday that he marched in an immigration rally.
http://washingtontimes.c The I...


 Asylum seekers?
what are your views on them?...


 Why those States full of Mexicans are the Best & wealthiest States: CA, TX, NV, CO, AZ, WA, OR, NM, IL, Aztlan
?...


 AREN'T WE ALL IMMiGRANTS ANYWAY? SO WHO CARES?
ALL YOU HATERS NEED TO LISTEN UP!

YOU PPL JUST WANT WHITE SKIN AND YOUR RACIST

ILLEGAL MEANS NOTHING

CAN YOU PROVE YOUR PARENTS AND GRANDPARENTS DECENDED FROM LEGAL IM...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084