Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Do you find it offencive when you have to fill in a section giving your race on an official form?
Find answers to your legal question.





Do you find it offencive when you have to fill in a section giving your race on an official form?

I do and I asked the lady running the course how other people felt about it. I was suprised to hear her say that no one dislikes it more than the ethnic minorities.
Is this true?


    




mazzo2001
Rating
actually, sorry but im white and i find it very offensive because it seems like they are looking for a particular race, personally i also get angry when they reject you because of yr race of course im from the uk i have never been rejected like that because it is illegal in the uk but anyway just to let you know yr not alone,


PATRICIA MS
Actually I would like to mark Mexican because the are getting the benefits of our country and I may as well have some.


Sweetpea
Rating
What I found interesting was looking at SAT scores and it showed how you rated amongst your race. We will never have equality as long as there are special rules for some.


mstr_gekko
I am not offended, but I am offended when I have to push 1 for english......


Del Piero 10
Rating
Also the form doesn't cover all possibilities. I remember a South African getting all worked up because they had to tick White because there was no White African choice. She wibbled on about it so long and loud in the end I told her to find the Pedantic African box and tick that instead.


Without-style
I dislike the categories, I also don't see how my race changes anything.

I would of assumed the ethnic minories would welcome the labels as it is essentially entirely for their benefit afterall and are essentially fast tracked through most things due to the nature of the policies set forth to encourage these minorities, ie. Police welcome all 'minorities' including British people with a heritage from the east, gay people and women. I'd say only the male Britain has to be afraid of these forms (for the record, if it counts I'm a female)

You now days have "British Indian, British Asian (Pretty much the same thing?, British African, British this and that.

Should we also have "British Scottish, Brittish Welsh" Surely these sub-categories also deserve to have their place? (Yes I realise Scotland and Wales make up Britain but they're entirely different 'countries') In turn British English, but the majority of these people are white, and don't fill anyones targets unless they are women.


203
I don't find it offensive but I do fail to see what relevance it has to anything when it is quite aboviously just pandering up to the political correctness nazis who like to count these things and then use the information for their own agendas.


Whatev' Yo'
Rating
I am white and I do not like filling in that block either. I think it is something non-important... and yes it makes me uncomfortable. It is like they are saying "what race are you so we can get a preconcieved notion about the type of person you are."

The woman who told you only minorities seem to get offended over it is wrong as well... many of my co-workers from my last job would always gripe about that part of any survey, application... ect. that they had to fill out. Of course, I was in the Air Force, and diversity was one of the things I liked about it.


Duffer
Not offensive so much as intrusive. I always refuse to answer, likewise the questions on religion. It is no-one's business but mine.


XD
i dont find it offencive, i just think its stupid, it doesnt make a differnce to how you will work-its unnecessary.


Maggym
Rating
I who is Hispanic and a proud American, find it offensive. It make me feel that I am only half American.

When my children where in school and had to fill out those school form, I would mark other and put in American. I taught my children the they are NOT hyphenated American, just simply and proudly an American.

I feel that having to answer what race a person is only divide us as a nation.


tamia
Rating
yes i find it a bit offencive, because what has my race got to do with getting a job, or going for a school trip.


AV
Rating
i am proud of my race n alwayz will be brown n proud!


hemihead_38
Rating
I hate that also and I'm white. Gives you the feeling that they are being racist.


archkarat
Rating
Sometimes I mark African American. Simply because if you be believe in evolution and the out of Africa theory then eveeryone on the planet could mark Africa.


Z
Rating
No, I've got far too many serious things to worry about.


pacer
Rating
It has never bothered me. There usually is a place where you can just choose "other" if it bothers you that much.


Just here.
Rating
i dont really care. You have to be proud of your race. Just mark the answer with pride.


Crazybird
Rating
I'm more offended by white-non-hispanic. Can't be plain ole' caucasion anymore.


firefly
I am white, English, and find it offencive to be told I'm 'racist' for wanting to put 'English' "It must be British". This to me is a long way round to all the PC brigade stating that we are racist, because we've had to put British with its association to the BNP. rather than English.

But surely it shouldn't matter what race Creed colour YOU are, all Britains are treated equally. As far as I can surmise the race relations act is a do-gooder petty muck stirring organisation, that occupies all with trivia, ie. 'black coffee' and misses the more dangerous quite occurrences.

I work for a County Council, quote:"If you are an ethnic minority, female, or have a disability then you are guaranteed an interview." It is this type of "ISM." that adds to the ill will of most decent people, and the sooner the moronic PC brigade and race relations idiots realise this then ENGLAND will start to become a much happier country.


vdv_desantnik
yes its true im white and I find it offensive


JOHN F
Rating
I dont find it offensive,I do find it curious even irrelevant most of the time but I suppose as long as the information is not used in a detrimental way ,its not aproblem


ChaChing
Hell NO! I'm WHITE AND PROUD!


Flying Hawaii
Rating
I can't remember the last time I ever had to do that. I would find it offensive. Actually, race is just a concept. There isn't really such thing as race.


rebel
Rating
im english and i dont like it


spannerbox
No i don't find it offencive, I'm proud to be British and if others don't like it, then leave.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Is illegal immigration to the us good for the economy?
Having a "debate" with a friend who said Illegal immigrants help the economy "With the millions in taxes they pay, and by purchasing Ameerican goods"

What should I say ...


 It's windy here today. I blame the immigrants!?
Come on all you Daily Mail, The Sun, The Express readers, what other crappy things can you think of that's happened to us Brits that we can blame on 'the foreigners'?

I'...


 Why can't we humanbeings all be together & united, think big, & convert this whole world into a single nation?
...


 Why do Illegals think they are not criminals?
They came into this country ILLEGALLY, therefore they are criminals breaking the law. End of story....


 Have you Brits noticed a dramatic change in the cultural makeup of your community?
I live in the US, and in the past ten years, due to immigration, I've seen a dramatic change of the makeup of my community. Ten years ago it was probably 80% white and now it's only like 60...


 Why do people display "Mexican Pride" emblems here in America?!?

Additional Details
Why don't they fly the American flag?! This isn't Mexico!

Such ingratitude......


 What kind of magical powers do illegals have to survive on less than minimum wage?
Do they know the meaning of not getting into debt?
Additional Details
Illegals do not qualify for federal aid!...


 HOW COME PEOPLE WANT TO SEND BACK ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS?DID THEY SEND U BACK TO ENGLAND WHEN YOU CAME TO USA ?No?
...


 What would you prefer an illegal immigrant from UK or legal immigrant from Mexico that refuse to learn English
...


 If you support illegal immigrants, why do you do so?
I can understand having empathy for them, but why support them to the point you think they should stay and have the same rights as actual citizens of the US?...


 Why do Mexicans say America belonged to them thousands of years ago?
I heard this on a radio news show, they say they want to take America back, starting with Colorado. I am just curious as it made my jaw drop when I heard it. Thanks....


 Is illegal immigration your top issue in choosing a president?
...


 Why do we allow terrorsim in the United Kingdom and the United States of America?
Why do we allow terrorsim in the United Kingdom and the United States of America when we know full well there is one solution, Stop immigration. Personally i would rather take no chances rather than ...


 Is it just me or is the U.S. only focusing on Mexican/S. American immigration and not Asian and European?

Additional Details
there are many vietnamese and chinese people i see in my area, maybe not in yours, im not saying any of it is a problem, it just seems like there are focusing on them ...


 Why do illegals deserve to be granted amnesty?
Simple question. And please, you can forget the "they do jobs Americans won't do" defense...I ain't buying it. Other than that, let's hear it. I want to know why they ...


 Should illegal immigrants be eligible to receive free healthcare?
...


 Zero immigration?
No more immigration to America until we gets our country in order. Build the walls to stop illegals from
crossing. No more schooling, health care, or jobs for illegals. What's your view.
...


 You want to be a citizen?Forget it.?
Has any of you who ***** about illegals EVER read the US laws on immigration?
I did. The only ways to become a citizen is to marry someone for papers or to win a lottery. Adoption works if you ...


 Why should I have to assimilate?
If I speak English,already.What else do I need to do to assimilate?If I was an immigrant?And why?Why do I need to be like you to live in this country?...


 Why do Racists Americans say that Illegals from Mexico are taking their jobs away?
Maybe they are too ignorant to know that countries like China and India are doing the jobs that americans USED to do 10 yrs. ago. For example, dialing customer service numbers to american companies ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084