Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Do you think Illegals should be paid for back pay since they did'nt get paid minimum wage to start with?
Find answers to your legal question.





Do you think Illegals should be paid for back pay since they did'nt get paid minimum wage to start with?

I mean, considering if they were to legalize themselves here and be obligated to pay back owed taxes as well.

Bi-Linguals count for 2!!

Stop HR 4437!!


    




Proud Mexican
Rating
that's a good idea because if they become legal citizens they should get all the money they deserve
stop hr 4437!!!!


FoxAmericaLover!
No. They should get in the back of the line. Legal immigrants should be getting free amnesty and because they followed the laws of immigration and America, any illegal that was given amnesty should pay the legal immigrants for the rest of their lives.


scrappy06
no


Leogirl0804
LOL.......yeah.....we'll get right on that........


Camping Chick
No, they came here illegally. Why do we owe them? Of course, I would rather pay them the back wages (because they actually worked) than pay the blacks for being related to a slave (did nothing but go to court to get free money).


Politics
Rating
Two words: HELL NO!


princess_29_71
Rating
You can't be serious. If I had it my way, they wouldn't get one red penny over here, EVER!


athorgarak
WELL SURE THING THERE MR. BRAIN !!!

And as soon as a thief turns himself in, he can get free and clear title to the things he forgot to steal or could not carry, because his arms were too full!

Or how bout giving a child molester visitation rights if he admits to the crime?

Oh alberto, thou intellectual black hole, could it be that your moral compass has been demagnetized?
Did your mother let the pooch ween you?

How about letting the guy who got short changed buying drugs get a free dime bag, for admitting that he smokes it?


Beauty2020
absolutely. If we legalize them, then they should get back pay and have to file taxes. Fair is fair.


?
Rating
No, they were here illegally. but they did come here to work for a better life for their families. Risking all they had and also leaving their family. We you realize they do some of the worst jobs. Some jobs we wouldn't do. Like cleaning house and toilets for other and mowing lawns in the hot sun.


gidget lil bit
I think beauty has this one.


onelightsleeper
illegal deserve nothing, they're not of U.S.


fr_chuck
Rating
actually if they work for a company for less than min wage, they can sue and win thier back pay. Just being hired illegally would not stop the obligation of the company to pay legal wages.


bconehead
I personally think this concept would send a message to the shoddy employers that NO you can no longer get away wit subwages even if these people are illegal HOWEVER the illegals that did work for the lower pay KNEW the risks when they borderjumped so my answer is NO!

Deport them now


sqwirlsgirl
Rating
Now THAT is funny!........


windyy
Let us hope that the government wakes up and does not let them become legal. Send all them criminals back form whence they came.Yes they are criminals since they are here illegally that makes them criminals.


ladysodivine
Geez, don't give them any ideas. 20 years from now they will be hounding the government like the african-americans that they are owed that money.


69Stang
Rating
Ummm first I would like my money back for paying for everything that has been taken out of my tax dollars...then we will think about it.................


Mr. Boof
Sure - right after they pay back the hundreds of billions of dollars to the American taxpayers that have been supporting you and your parasitic amigo's. Oh, and don't forget the hundreds of billions pilfered from our country and sent back to Mexico.

I mean, what's right is right... isn't it?


hmmmmm.
Wow maybe I should. Oh wait that will never happen what was I thinking. I am an American. That will never happen.

Do you think that maybe I don't have to pay taxes because I am helping 7 million illegals.


Bear Naked
Yes and they should raise the taxes of everyone that supports that idea to pay for it. Leave the rest of us out of it!


?
Rating
Nooo....

I Think They Should Get Deported
Since They Didnt Enter The Country Legally To Begin With


Ricky
Why? They chose to work for those wages illegally. Why should they get anything other than sent home?


hayleylov
not no BUT HELL NO


just me
Rating
nope... but i think they should pay back taxes on all the money they have earned to date.


DAR
Since they weren't legally entitled to work, how were they entitled to minimum wage? Also employers would certainly kill the amnesty concept if that were a part of it.

Most illegals here are only bilingual because we paid for them to be tought English when our schools as a result don't have enough money to teach our own children a second language in elementary school. It is not a point that helps your cause.

In fact, they should get back minimum wage, but should pay $18,000 per year in school here per child educated, should pay back all health care given on a subsidized or free basis, etc.

You do not come out ahead.


sumrtanman
Rating
A resounding no!


Americans1st
They should pay back taxes, and fines for their crimes!


Angry C
Rating
You gotta be kidding! Back pay for being a criminal???


MIKE B
NO





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Illegal aliens can't drive!!!!!!!!!!!! How are they getting a license if they are illegal?
...


 Who is more of a threat to their community?
Young white men with hunting rifles?
Or young chicanos with machete's?...


 Why do "american" people hate immigrants?
If this country was started on the "melting pot" theory (people from all countries being able to come here and live freely), then wahts the problem today?...


 Why don't the racists learn Spanish for a change, as opposed to asking people to learn English?
...


 Would you like being dragged by your hair and beaten?
Citizens on the borders Sat,29,2006
by Joe Castro
News editor
Illegal immigration is one of the hottest ...


 What will happen when the USA elects a Mexican President that can't speak English?

Additional Details
I know plenty people born in the USA and can not or will not speak English, so that answers that ...


 Is it true that we're all Immigrants ?
...


 Who agrees with me that immigrants should stay in the US?
They did nothing wrong coming here to find a better live. So any one who is saying bad stuff backoff....


 Should we intern all muslims?
...


 Do you think there are too many immigrants in, and coming in to the UK?
I read on yahoo this week that 68% of britons feel there's too many immigrants in the UK,... what are you views on it? Do you think that Tony Blair has been a total idiot when it came to ...


 Why do people care if "mexicans" speak English?
Do they get all mad at the chinese for speaking only their own language?
Are they just afraid of what they don't know?
Additional Details
It is true that they "should"...


 So you think illegals have the RIGHT to protest inside the USA?
Well My friends, OUR constitution was designed togive the rules for those legally here and, Yes! lesser rights apply to those here illegally!
let us look at this a bit differently:
Say a ...


 Do you think that illegal immigration is a problem?
If so, how much of a problem, and why is it a problem, and what's the problem with it?...


 Why are only Hispanics targeted as illegals?
...


 Why does everyone hate so much immigrants?
They do jobs that american people won't do so why can't we just leave them alone??? With out them America would not be what we are today !!! READ THIS LINK AND YOU WILL SEE!!!!!!

...


 Now just why the heck do I have to press 1 for English?

Additional Details
In response to *B/R*ToNi* Cassiopeia: Some things we can never know, we can only guess. And when we do guess we only assume based on others. And being based on others ...


 Why is it if you speak out aginst illegal immagrants your racist?
why can't i and other Americans speak out aginst the rising problem of illegals invading this country, If we do were branded racist.. Well i have a few friends who are mexican who came here L...


 Why is it that anti-illegals do not just roll up their sleeves and go apply for the jobs that illegals are ...
currently doing? To put money where their English speaking tongues fail to do,as well to act rather then talk(so to say)to convince the employers that they mean business,instead of submitting ...


 Why are a lot of Americans so racist against immigrant (illegal or not)?
Have you ever stopped and asked an immigrant why they have come to the United States? If you hear want most of them have to say I believe some of you might change your mind. Why is it so hard to ...


 Do you think that English should be the only language in our country?
and also do you think you should get a fine if you speak any other ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074