Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Do you think this was a good way for my buddy to handle an illegal using his ID to get a job?
Find answers to your legal question.





Do you think this was a good way for my buddy to handle an illegal using his ID to get a job?

He found out when he filed his taxes that he also works in a chicken plant in the next town over. So last friday he went to that plant and walked into the office and asked for his pay check. Pretty cool, he made 350 bucks while running a business 30 miles away. I asked him what he planned to do with it, he told me "What do you think" and cashed it. He told me he plans to go and see how much he makes next friday also.


    




David S
Rating
I think things will work themselves out over time, at least until the illegal moves to another job. Tell your buddy to give I.C.E. a call. ice.gov

But be careful, as he might be called a racist and bigot.


mikea_va
He should bring a cop with him the next time and arrest the guy who is using his ID.


rlstaehle
Well, he has to do something to recoup his losses for the extra taxes he has to pay. Good for him.


m.a.i.i.
Rating
I love it. I agree to take federal officials next time with him!


21st Century Pragmatist
Rating
Well technically it is his money since the person used his ID to get the job. Sometimes things have a natural way of working themselves out. If the illegal complains, then all your friend has to do is turn him in, problem solved.


foaagain
Hahahahahaahahaha
roll on floor
awesome story
i hope he has already contacted ICE and the FBI
without spending the money
so they can get the guy


Ali A
"IF SOMEONE IS USING YOU ID AND YOU FAILED TO REPORT THAT AND INSTEAD DO BASICALLY THE SAME THING! THEM YOU BOTH SHOULD BE PROSECUTE TO THE FULL EXTEND OF THE LAW!

JUST BECAUSE SOMEONE COMMIT A CRIME USING YOUR NAME IT DOES NO GIVE YOU THE RIGHT OR MORAL/LEGAL AUTHORITY TO DO THE SAME!"

On the contrary, try reporting it and you'll find out that no one in government has the authority to do anything because of privacy laws.
If someone uses your SS number, the SS Administration can't tell you because it's a violation of the THIEF's privacy! Getting the police to go after identity thieves is extremely tough. Heck. Just look at the recent Supreme Court ruling that says if an illegal alien uses your SS number, but doesn't know it belongs to a real person, it's not a felony EVEN THOUGH IT HARMS YOU (emphasis mine).

As for "stealing", well, if the illegal alien is using this guy's SS number, then the IRS will be coming after this guy to pay the extra taxes on this "income" anyway. Who's "stealing" from whom? There's a quote from Shakespeare, to the effect that he who steals my purse steals trash but he who steals my good name steals everything. The illegal alien is committing the greater theft here.


luckymom
Rating
That's great! Hahaha! Love it.


legal lover :)
That is too hilarious!! Like what is the illegal going to do about it....he set himself up for this to happen!


Micky....the resurrection
Yes, nice one!


Loretta C
omfg, i'm in shock, literally shocked. nfw. how lucky was your friend to be so close and find the idiot. way fricken cool. lmao

he might get into trouble for not reporting it.


PJ
Rating
What he is doing is theft. It serves the other guy right, but it is still theft. He might get arrested when he goes in this Friday.


shy_gal2
So just because there is someone using his ID it automatically makes him an illegal? Well let me tell you that there are americans who do it all the time and I wish I were making this up but I'm not.

I do believe it's wrong to steal identities but it's the same by stealing someone elses check for what he didn't even work for.

Oh btw I know that americans also do ID theft because two towns near where I live there are two white guys (brothers) and are working on 4 different ID's. I would say something about that but its' not my business


LeighAnn D
Rating
No because he is not being anymore honest then the person who stole his SSN! It may have been his SSN, but technically he didn't make the money.He can get into a lot of trouble for what he did. I would think that if somebody stole his identity that he would want to report it, and not go collect money somebody is making under his SSN.


sweetdeysies
Rating
IF SOMEONE IS USING YOU ID AND YOU FAILED TO REPORT THAT AND INSTEAD DO BASICALLY THE SAME THING! THEM YOU BOTH SHOULD BE PROSECUTE TO THE FULL EXTEND OF THE LAW!

JUST BECAUSE SOMEONE COMMIT A CRIME USING YOUR NAME IT DOES NO GIVE YOU THE RIGHT OR MORAL/LEGAL AUTHORITY TO DO THE SAME!


La Mojarra
Rating
I agree it is wrong to use others ID's, but your friend can be charged with theft and fraud.

BTW, You have no way of knowning, that an "illegal" is using your friends ID.

I know "Americans" use others ID's also, for many reasons!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 How hard would it be for a British qualified accountant to emmigrate to the US or Canada?
I am not qualified yet, but when I am how hard would it be for me to get a job offer and emmigrate?
I would probably want to go somewhere like Oregon, definately on the west coast, so would be ...


 What should i do about my sister would the BNP deport her?
Her son Tony is mixed race his Father is Nigerian (well i did say at the time why do all Nigerians say they are Princes?)Tony is a fine chap and a nurse to boot.
Although she has had 4 other ...


 How does the US govt know that a person who overstayed his/her visa and has left the country by air is gone?
Is there a log-out form that you need to fill out at the airport? How do you notify them that you are leaving?

I'm asking this with the knowledge that leaving implies a 10 year ban to ...


 Canadian Citizenship Test?
Do I need to take the citizenship test if I took social studies 11?...


 What do I need to submit to adjust status?
I have an approved I-130 Immigration Petition, I am in the US on a B2 visa and would like to adjust my status to permanent immigrant. Can anyone tell me exactly what I have to submit along with the I...


 How much will an amnesty for illegal immigrants?
cost the British taxpayer

The Government is already saddling our next generation with huge debts. Uncontrolled immigration from developing countries, and in particular an amnesty for ...


 Whats the easiest way to get a USA visa for someone from the UK?
my bf and i have been together for over 2 years. and i have read online the easiest way to stay together would be to get married. but i dont want to rush a wedding just to stay together. He is from ...


 How make cow run fastest?
when i ride cow it go slow and not excape police. can i make cow run fastest?...


 The easiest contury to get a citizenship?
what is the easiest contury to get a citizenship in the planet?...


 Why don't people in Third World nations stay and fight and make their home countries a better place?
It's not like citizens in the UK and the USA weren't up against insurmountable odds when they fought for their freedom against oppressive regimes.

The UK had to break away from ...


 DOSE ANY1 KNOWS UK BORDER AGENCY HOW LONG TAKE FOR PARTICULAR TYPE APPLICATION?
i am a non eea family member, i was overstay in uk,i am married living with my partner more then 2years in uk and i apply for resident card in december-2008,1month later i got latter they give me ...


 Does the United Arab Emirates let Iraqis live and work there? Or even take visa?
...


 Ii'm 18 and wanna move to another country?
I'm 18 and wanna move to another country ALONe. Place where i can get my bown living far away from family? anyone know how? I'm too stupid to understand these things.

ps. I llive ...


 Can i marry somebody even f i am only green card holder?
can i marry my boyfriend in the philippines even i am green card holder?...


 . His status as an alleged illegal immigrant went undetected at the time how can this be ?
Do the police just accept any id or name the illegal gives without question and sends them on their way ?
A man suspected of being an illegal immigrant pleaded guilty today to charges that he ...


 Student visa.. Fiance visa..? Please help me :(?
My boyfriend and I plan on getting married - he also wants to go to a college around where I live. He lives in New Zealand, and I live in the USA.. missouri.

We'd originally planned ...


 Oklahoma kicks out immigrants?
Someone told me that years ago Oklahoma stated a new law kicking out illegal immigrants? Is tha true?
What law?
What happened?
ANYTHING YOU KNOW ABOUT THIS WOULD HELP, im just very ...


 DO I NEED A PASSPORT TO FLY INSIDE THE COUNTRY?
...


 Should we adopt Mexicos immigration policy?
Check out this short article

http://www.theterryander...


 I was harassed at the JFK airport coming back home?
I am naturalized and double citizen for years. I just came home(US) after 3 weeks family visit from my birth country with my American passport and I was "invited" to the office for ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.144