Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Do you think welfare benefits should be ended for illegal aliens?
Find answers to your legal question.





Do you think welfare benefits should be ended for illegal aliens?


Additional Details
Lots of responses on this one...


    




Eclipse
They are not getting any welfare, you moron. Not from the government, at least.

The basic concept of being in a country "illegally" means that they aren't documented on government records. And to receive assistance you need *documents* and to be registered "in the system".

No legal visa = no documents = no assistance.
So why don't you learn a bit before spreading all that hate?


Hadenough
Some posters are "lion" maybe not intendedly or very misinformed.

They can get Benefits--I know they can.
State's are making laws to prevent this---why would they do if they were not?
Income not citizenship is requirement for many of the benefits..

I don't care if the poor get the help they need--but too many are using it not as a helper but as a lifestyle-legal and illegal.

And we can't help the world that is impossible-so I feel citizens first and when they are all taken care of--than reach out. Not before.

I don't know what the answers are--we don't want to see those who need it-go without. But we don't want to see citizens go without because the well is running dry, and it is. We owe them protection of these Benefits--OUR sick our elderly our injured soldiers.


backinbowl
I think welfare benefits should be ended for Wal-Mart, which although it is the largest company in the history of the world expects the American taxpayer to pick up the tab for the health insurance costs, food stamps, and other assorted below-poverty-line expenses of its hundreds of thousands of employees!


Daisy
Rating
I agree with hadenough on here! She is sure right about all those responses here who are "lion!" People, don't think for a minute that illegal immigrants are NOT getting welfare benefits (including food stamps) - they most CERTAINLY ARE! They don't have papers, you say? How about the ones who have fake/fraudulent papers! Many do! How about the ones who have "anchor" babies - many do! Don't tell me they only get benefits for their "anchor" babies, because that is not true - they get benefits for themselves and the rest of their families, too, in many States.

Yes, this needs to stop IMMEDIATELY! All illegal immigrants and their anchor babies need to be deported back to their home countries as soon as they are found in the USA - no exceptions!


scottyurb
Lou Dobbs said it best on the last Real time with Bill Maher. The illegals are providing 7 billion in tax revenue for 57 billion dollars in services. Are you getting 8 times the benefit from your tax dollars? You'd kinda think Bush would like a "round-up"--goes with the cowboy attitude!! Please not that welfare is any free government service from schooling to health care.


donthatethaplaya1
Rating
absolutely


princess_29_71
Rating
Of course, this only encourages them to come to our country for their free ride.


Eeyore
Yes because the funds for welfare are paid by the taxpayer and illegal aliens get paid under the table because it is ILLEGAL for an ILLEGAL ALIEN to work an alien has to obtain a green card to legally work in the states. So If they are being hired they get paid under the table. Which means they are not paying taxes.


sidekick puppet
Rating
I don't think most people realized they were getting anything at all until about the last couple years or so.


darlene100568
Rating
Of course.


razeumright
Rating
YES, if there is a God in heaven, YES!!!!!


Brian S
Rating
Yeah. And we should use the extra money to deport them, get their gangs off the streets, and build an electric fence on our border.


Nelson_DeVon
Yes--no doubt about it.


Jen G
Yes


ladystarrchild107
Rating
Personally, no I don't feel they should. People are answering this question and coming down pretty hard on you. In all due respect to them, they are wrong. If an illegal alien woman gets pregnant, did all of you know that she can get health benefits? You can email me and I'll give you numbers to call if you need proof. Once a child is born here, it's easier for them to stay here. I see the games they play. They come here, have babies and stay here and just sit at home, collect welfare and make babies. They can't get jobs because they are illegal but they can get health care and make babies and since their kids were born here, it makes them citizens and the children are eligible for benefits. Sad but true.


April J
DEFINITELY!!! They should not be able to get federal aid from a country that they don't contribute to. All of the illegals receiving welfare have bankrupted the system so bad that an actual US citizen can't get help to keep their lights on!


§««ëÑ¡GmÅ»»§ ™
They shouldn't recieve them in the first place.


layjc01
Rating
if is there any way for them to pay taxes, they should get benefits too


Carol R
I think welfare benefits should be ended for all able bodied HUMANS of any creed, race, color, or ethnicity.


primamaria04
Why do you complain about welfare when you pay more for education ? Why do you complain about it at all? you are entitled to the same benefits by law if you ever happened to fall into hard times.


SittinPretty!
Definitely!!


★Fetal☆ ★And ☆ ★Weeping☆
I don't think they should have gotten them in the first place. Because of them, my husbands' grandparents now have to prove they're American citizens to get their medical coverage, which is an insult.


Drena C
Rating
There's no way that illegals should get welfare, be able to vote, or get any state or federally funded benefit.


Dr.
Rating
They should be given food stamps that cant be used.


BHANU RAVAL
yes !!!


razzyrascal
Definitely!


Ophelia
Rating
Welfare needs a complete revamp anyway, ending aid for non-citizens should be one of the first things on the list.


Mopar Muscle Gal
yes I do


loli
they never get any government help you idiot


9inches
Rating
sure send them too work in dives llike burger king or mcdonalds who wants those jobs anyways??


inna357
only if they contributed to this state by working else where . and were paid by check .. otherwise NO they should not get any help from us


lynne
Yes, of course, this is the dumbest question. I can't believe we have actually been giving all of Mexico's citizens our nations welfare funds. No wonder we are so broke now!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why do so many Mexicans seem to actually believe the SW USA belongs to them?
There is post after post on Answers from Mexicans claiming they have a legal right to be here because this land belonged to Mexico. They are Mexican, therefore they make some sort of illusive ...


 What kind of bird is it on the flag of Mexico?
It looks like either a vulture or a crow, what type of bird is it?...


 Should we take Down the American flag and replace it With the Mexican flag?
or just fly them both on the same pole with the mexico flag on the top

dont we do this when we invade and concer other countries or posts in times of war

does this mean that we ...


 Why do so many people want to move to the US?
...


 Why does every guy think that every asian is a muslim who is here to kill them or destroy their houses?
Either they have very poor knowledge of geography or they don't even know Countries Like India,(90% hindu lol if u no wot it is) China(90% no religion), and many other countries fall in asia. No ...


 If we were forced out of America, would you head South or North ???
That is if our Government , told us to Get the hell out of here ....


 I got in a HUGE argument w/my friend today about illegal immigration....?
..so he is the typical bleeding heart liberal and I am the typical anti-illegal immigrants *ahem* criminals. So anyway, he told me today that I was ignorant and self centered for thinking that we ...


 Why would shooting illegal immigrants that try to enter this country be considered inhumane?
After all, they are breaking the law and we shoot prison inmates that break out of prison every single day. I'm not racist, and this is for all illegal immigrants (haitian, mexican, jamaican, ...


 Whats so wrong to give illegals drivers license??????
first of all they can get insurance which a lot of illegals dont have because they dont have a license, and who is going to benefit from this: you. because if your ever hit by an illegal they ...


 Does anyone want to read what an illegel did ??
Do you believe this?? http://www.baynews9.com/ Details
And I will post ...


 Why Are Americans so Against Illegals?
don't they understand that their ancestors were illegal immigrants as well? Why not let everyone have a piece of the American Dream? Isn't that what its all about anyways? People are coming ...


 Why are people making such a fuss over Mexicans and peoples of color entering this country illegally?
All nationalities of Eurpoean nature have entered this country, some legally but by an large most illegally. In fact, most immigrants lied about who they actually were (names changed) and where they ...


 Honestly,do you want to pay to have 12million people deported ?
Not me, I pay enough taxes as it is.
Additional Details
Sortega is the only one who makes sense....


 Do you think that a family that came to america illegaly with a 6yr old child shuld be deported ?
the family hasnt broken any other laws exept for that one, they pay taxes,son is now 16 doing very well in school. if the son was sent back to his country he could not do anything with his life ...


 Do you find it offencive when you have to fill in a section giving your race on an official form?
I do and I asked the lady running the course how other people felt about it. I was suprised to hear her say that no one dislikes it more than the ethnic minorities.
Is this true?...


 The average Englishmen I have met so far seem to be poorly educated: they need a calculator to to find out how
much it is 1.5 + 2.5, they cannot speak and write in English properly, they do not know much of geography, science and so on. Generally speaking, they are usually poorly skilled, however, they have ...


 Should mexico just give us their country?
they love mexico but want to be here they refuse to do anthing of value with their land and refuse to fit in here so they should just surrender and give it ...


 Why do you think the majority of Americans are against illegal immigration?
The majority of Americans ARE against it you know!~ why do you think that is- Americans are a diverse bunch so it cant be racially motivated, I think hispanics that are in support of it are!~ but ...


 What would Jesus have to say about illegal immigration to win you over?
...


 What is it that mexicans like about America?
What really brings them here?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074