For Americans - Illegal Immigration...?
Find answers to your legal question.
For Americans - Illegal Immigration...?
|
Illegal immigration is a serious issue here in the U.S., thousands of illegals cross our southern border on a daily basis, assume false identities and either take American jobs or get on welfare (or commit violent and drug-related crimes.)
Each illegal immigrant saps money out of the American economy without putting it back in.
Please note, this is not a racial issue, this is an issue of American laws being broken. Do you have a solution or suggestion as to how we can deal with this problem? Additional Details Ok, so now I'm going to update with my own opinion - any illegal who commits a crime in the US should be IMMEDIATELY be deported upon conviction. It costs $40,000 per year to house one prison inmate, and roughly 25 percent of our prison inmates are illegal. Why are we paying for them to have three squares and a warm bed? Employers who hire illegals with false papers should also face fines and/or jail time.
The migrant worker plan is a good one, and for those who wish to work here then return home, great! More power to them.
Those immigrants who come here, work full-time, pay taxes, and are good citizens ashould be allowed to go through the naturalization process. The dishonest few who come here simply to get on welfare need to leave. now.
Let me just add that my own grandparents aer immigrants - they immigrated from post-WWII Norway, and are naturalized citizens.
It is a priviliege to be American - you either earn privilege or you are born to it. Fair or not, that's life.
|
|

LoneStar
|
1--Enforce the border, even if it means with troops. This is an invasion.
2--Sanction those who hire them. I mean jail. Even for little old ladies who hire them to mow the lawn. If there is no work, they will not come.
3--End birthright citizenship. These women who come over to shell out a kid so it will be a US citizen are a problem.
4--NO government benefits for illegals. I mean no school, no health care no food stamps, no nothing. That will also slow it down.
5--National Identity card for all, with biometrics. I used to be against this, but desperate times call for desperate measures.
6--Major jail time for the coyotes. That is if we don't shoot them as invaders and leave their bones to bleach. |
|

marieb12976
 |
I am half mexican. And I totally agree with the laws. My grandparents came to America legally. They took the time to fill out papers and get permission for citizenship. I am not ashamed of my heritage but I am ashamed of those taking advantage of the laws. America needs stricter laws. I always thought it would be a good idea to only allow so many in per year, extensive backgrounds searches, and tests. Tests be language, medical, etc. Something needs to be done. |
|

Youth Pastor
 |
Honestly,
1. Secure the borders using troops (just to deter illegals).
2. Have a better process of citizenship.
3. Stiff penalties for employers who hire people without proof of citizenship/ green card.
4. Deportation.
5. Have the nation of Mexico become a state in the union. |
|

jonnyli200
 |
Illegal immigrants are taking the jobs that normal Americans would never take. Corporate America needs the cheap labor of illegal immigrants to compete with the cheap labor of countries such as China. Maybe Americans should get off their lazy @$$es and get an education so they can enter an industry where you can't be replaced by an immigrant who barley speaks English. |
|

mcg0722
|
National Security along the borders!!! Deport the ones who are still here. How much money do you think we can gain back once we do that? It's just like breaking into someone's house. It is illegal! This is our country and they are breaking into it. The illegal mexicans need to be sent back there.
Why is it their country is so poor and crime ridden, and most of it is not abandoned? They need to go back to fix their country and stop invading ours, and no more money, jobs, and welfare for them!!!
The schools are overcrowded and they have illegal car insurance- not to mention the cars they drive are lawnmowers! Insurance rates are more expensive for the rest of us. I hate having to hear it every time they fly down my street.... UGH! |
|

Leifr EirÃksson
 |
Round them up and deport them. Then build a 35' high and 20' thick reinforced concrete wall from Brownsville, TX to San Diego, CA. Place an armed Border Patrol Agent on the wall every 30 feet. If an illegal alien comes in again, send them to a Federal prison for 10 years. Send employers to prison who employ them.
Imprison those who overstay their visas. Imprison those who marry illegal aliens. |
|

Cowgirl
|
deport -
No SSN/id deport, dont wait!
many kids come to school with no ssn, u can make out they r illegal - deport asap. |
|

Kenneth H
|
Your whole assumption is in error. Think about how illegal immigrants get jobs. American employers hire them knowing full well that they are illegal. This is done to get the cheap labour they provide to make the employer more money. The illegal immigrant probably spends a greater percentage of his income buying basic item to survive than you do. Yes illegal immigrants are a cost to such systems as welfare, schools, etc. but what would you do if people were dying of starvation in your neighbour hood. Or you found out that your gardener's children could not go to school. The vast percentage of illegal immigrants work at menial low paid jobs which you or your family want nothing to do with. Most are honest and hardworking but have no voice because they risk deportation and as such become a victim of rhetoric such as you have just written. |
|

yost s
 |
My solution to the immigration problem is so simple. We just add another star to our flag and have the state of Mexico follow our laws and pay taxes as the rest of America does. If that is not agreeable than the country of Mexico needs to repay our country for all the freeloading per person that has entered illegally. |
|

Mom
 |
Get over it!!!!! |
|

princess angel 2207
 |
the united states is in the process of blocking the barrier between mexico and the united states, that should be enough. also as an american for 32 years, i feel everyone in our country should have the right to work here and should be able to become a citizen. my husband has been waiting 10 years to get his papers, so are family can be sucessful in our business.. |
|

★★gone♦fishn'★★
|
line up all the blacks on the border....Tell them that whenever a mexican gets across, that thier unemployment and welfare benefits will decrease due to more mexicans cutting into their pie.... |
|

camaroluva
 |
I would say, all illegal immagrants in this country need to be sent back to their own country. allow no more green cards or u.s. citizenships. block the borders and anyone who does try to get in will be jailed immediately and then sent back. if they are in this country illegal, they are put in jail till they can be sent back. if they are here on green cards they have to pay taxes right away, and become citizens right away in every aspect. if they commit crimes they are treated just like americans are. they are not allowed to live on welfare forever, they pay the same thing we americans do, they go by the rules the same way americans do, and they learn to speak english, not the other way around. we are here and speak english, if they come into this country, they speak it too or get out. |
|

Jeff
|
Illegal immigration will always be a problem in America no matter what. However, this problem can be better contained with stricter border control. The government could pass some laws that could help control this problem as well. |
|

Satan
|
your buddy Bush and his Disiples are sapping all the oil, gold, uranium and mercury from Iraq.. And you claim your selves broke? I think your government is too occupied to kick out the mexicans because they found wonderland - Iraq |
|

ranger12
 |
The Native Americans believe there are 300,000,000 million illegal immigrants here, look what those immigrants have taken from them, their food supply (bison) their country, and left them with some barren land out in the desert and some people who think that blond hair is somehow better that any other hair. |
|

cosaxteacher
|
My solution, build walls with manned towers and high powered rifles. I am quite sure that if there is a threat of death for a border crossing attempt, the number of people trying will go down very quickly. Also, prevent them from having access to anything without paying money up front. No hospital emergency rooms, nothing. Make it the most undesirable place to be if you are here illegally and the flood of illegals will go away, quickly |
|

Ricky
 |
Enforce laws penalizing employers to where it is cost prohibitive to hire illegal aliens, and watch how fast the issue dries up.... |
|

purpal2002002
 |
gosh all i know to do is make it harder to get thourgh the border |
|

PermDude
 |
The best long-term solution is to eliminate (or seriously reduce) the backlog at INS. A person in Mexico who wants to come here legally has an 18 year wait (!).
Illegal immigration is a response, not the original action. We need to do what we can to encourage legal immigration, including making it easier for people who want to follow the law to do so.
[Note, however, that illegals actually put a lot of money back into the economy. But you also have to remember that the money spent on them is a lless than what might be spent on, say, union labor, so it is not correct to think of illegals as only a drain. A reduction in the cost of food, for instance, would not be a drain since it allows the poor to buy more of it]. |
|

jrjameson
 |
Let them be. If it wasn't for the illegal immigrants, no one would be watching the World Cup Soccer Championship in America.
The illegal immigrants are bringing in hundreds of thousands of dollars with pay per view, soccer parties and such.
Americans do not watch soccer. |
|

yars232c
 |
One person can't. You have to be able to vote. You have to organize. Or, you could learn Spanish and become Mexican.
Just think, soon we'll have an Nascor International Highway with Mexican Custom Agents in Kansas City. Then we'll have SPP, which will make Mexico, Canada, and the US one single economy, with their decisions on immigration and trade above our own Supreme Court.
We are about to become a two teir nation over the lowest common denominator out of all three.
It appears the only way to stop illegal immigration is to turn the country over to Mexico because their laws don't allow it.
That's when we say we should coulda woulda - but didn't. |
|

cirestan
|
Seriously: Make the US uninhabitable without proper citizenship. Make it impossible to rent an apartment without two or three forms of ID, make it impossible to get any type of job. Crack down on Americans that are hiring and renting to Illegals.
Once they realize there is no work or home for them here they will have to go home. Illegals who are arrested for whatever reason needs to be treated like a foreign terrorist, not like some poor guy without a driver's liscense who got pulled over for speeding. |
|

mthtchr05
 |
First of all, have companies stop hiring them to begin with.
Second of all, fire all imigrants who are here illegally.
Finally, shoot all of them that try to come in. |
|

Texas Cowboy
 |
I cannot agree that they do not put anything back. They absolutely do. But, illegal is illegal and it should be contained.
I do not trust these polititians. We are putting up a huge wall at great expense but, at the same time we are offering free education, jobs, free park access, free medical aid and the list goes on. We cannot blame these people for taking advantage of the resources offered to them. What we can do is stop giving it away. It costs no money to do this and makes our schools, hospitals and other services cheaper for us and more profitable.
It is rediculous that the politians keep offering incentives given no place else in the world to anybody who sneaks over the border. |
|

ANTI-ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION
|
find a way to drive them out an push them out show them we dont want them here anymore an we dont need them here an we never did. if you see an illegal immigrant report them if you see a bussiness having illegal immigrant working for them report them.
Burn there flag like they burn ours |
|

gokart121
|
Charge the country of Mexico the sum of 150,000 dollars for each and every one of their citizens that comes to america and screws up. I guarantee there'll be mexican soldiers joining hands from the gulf of mexico to the pacific ocean and helicopters and everything else they can muster to keep their people at home after that....the first 10 or so will get their attention, after that it'll be 'hands across mexico' LOLOL |
|

Caus
 |
first you should tell everybody in the southern USA to quit their jobs to become famers, becuase without illegal immigrants this country would not have enough food to feed itself.
oh and you would all have to do it for minimum wage
You do realize how much of the US economy is generated from these immigrants? |
|

badjanssen
|
two fences..both electrified..with a moat containing alligators and electric eels in the middle...followed up by guard towers and shoot to kill orders....
that will do for starters... |
|

Molly M
|
first of all, not all immigrants are doing this to our economy, but unfortunately the big majority does.
im not sure how i would solve this- but i do believe that bushs way of dealing with it (a giant electric fence) is extremely inhumane. the border definately needs to up the security though! |
|

|
|
|
|
Why do illegal immagrants in America think they have rights? |
| In my opinion if you are here illegally ,and are not a citizen , then you have no rights. You should not be able to recieve any benefits at the tax payers expense. Should not be able to drive or rent ... |
|
Is it okay for illegal immigrants to stay in the U.S.? |
| what do you guys think? i mean if its to pursue the "american dream" then why not. I know a lot of immigrants are willing work jobs most americans would not do. But, the thing is how about ... |
|
If the mexicans work so hard? |
| why is it that thier country, mexico, is a craphole? if they worked so hard, shouldn't their country be half-way decent? it should, but they don't work as hard as they'd like to ... |
|
Do you think people born in America deserve a better life than people born in Mexico? |
| Why should the quality of life for the same work be higher in the USA than in Mexico? And given that it will be, why is it fair to tell people that they just can't have that because they were ... |
|
Why is america changing its language???? |
| no matter where I go, or no matter what I listen to there is always more spanish then English. I mean the L.A. Mayor did a whole speech in spanish on tv 2 or 3 weeks ago. I walked into a walmart ... |
|
Where in the world can I go to live where girls don't hate other girls for no reason? |
| I'm from the USA, and I am just sick of these spoiled, catty girls who think only about themselves and whoever else is privileged enough to be part of their inner-cirlce. Don't they realize ... |
|
Shoulf foreigners alowed to claim benefits? |
| I think if you come to this country (UK) for asylum or for whatever reason, then you should NOT be allowed to claim ANY benefits.I also think you should have to pay for medical care, except in ... |
|
Why the people in USA think that they are the only AMERICANS? |
AMERICANS are Mexicans, Brasilians, Argentinians, Cubans, Chileans, Peruvians, Colombians, Venezuelans, and all the countries on AMERICAN CONTINENT,
Do you understand?
NOT ONLY ... |
|
Europeans,came here,killed the Indians/Mexicans then called it America? |
| Genocide on a horrendous level....Put the last living Indians in little pieces of land...and guard the borders preventing the Mexicans from returning...to there native land...I know i am gonna get ... |
|
If I know someone is working illegally in my country should I report them? |
| I know someone who is here on a student visa which permits them to be employed by someone else for up to 20 hours a week. However I know that on many occaisons they not only work more hours, but are ... |
|
What should American do with white Americans when the Mexicans are the majority in 2050? |
| should they be trated as third class citizens, oppressed, enslaved or shipped to work camps?... |
|
Why US citizens are so Idiots and Dumbs???? |
....Ignorants,arrogants,rude,selfish,mea... Additional Details I don't need any proper English...i live in my Third world country thank God...and proper English....give me a BREAK!!... |
|
Without judgment as to right or wrong do you think it possible to deport 12 million people out of US? |
| Congress is debating options to deal with illegal immigation. Is mass deportation a viable option? How would it be done? How long would it take? Just curious about what others think.... |
|
Should we kick the whites out of America? |
| Haaaaaaa..... Americans were always stuck up and looked every one down,like they were better than the Hispanics or Blacks.Always so proud that this was their land and that we were outsiders...How ... |
|
Is anyone else offended by Spanish taking over? |
| I should not have to press 1 to hear English when calling my bank. I am not saying to get rid of other languages, but why cant English be the default?... |
|
When are Mexicans going to stop crossing the boarder? |
Additional Details and im not talking about mexicans period so stop calling me raciest im talking about the ones that are making my parents pay for them to live here when there ... |
|
Are people afraid to air their true point of view? |
Jack Straw aired his point of view about muslim women and veils! Are you a racist, bigot if you agree with him?
I want to say in a open forum that I agree with him and understand the ... |
|
Do we know that we all came here illegally and who is it to judge what is legal and illegal way of entering? |
| we are all from a line of immigrants except for native americans...who are the people in congress to justify what is the legal way of entering this country...the congress bought there way to make ... |
|
|