Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

How can we deport 12 million illegal immigrants?
Find answers to your legal question.





How can we deport 12 million illegal immigrants?

Do you think it's possible to do it? It will take a long time obviously, but what solutions would you give on this issue?


    




NYC_me
One at a time. But seriously, the first thing we need to do is enact laws that severely punish anyone hiring an illegal or renting a house or apartment to an illegal. If they have no place to work nor a place to live, I'm sure they will do most of work for us. Secondly, we need to enact a law that states that if you are born in the US but your parents are here illegally, then you are not entitled to citizenship. We hear a lot about them simply coming here to work, but there are many that come to drop a baby so that they can get on the public assistance systems.

Lastly, if these fail then we need to do what they did in Chicago last week and begin random ID checks of people that are suspicious.

As a side note, isn't it interesting how the people that spew the terms "bigots" and "racists" so often on these boards are the ones that are always attempting to inhibit the rest of our free speech on issues such as these? Hypocrites.


yupchagee
We can't, but if (among other things) we crack down on those who hire them, many will leave on their own. They come here for jobs. If they can't get jobs, they will leave.


ken
Rating
By bus. I think is is possible. Just enforce the labor laws of employment. Right not it cost each family $2000 per year to support this group so maybe the only thing they should be allowed to receive is a bus ticket. I probably would not take long.

Would you stay if you could not make a living?


Gary W
Rating
bring our troops home from Iraq and concentrate on securing this country!


pechorin1
You take away thier jobs and let them walk home. Seriously, if the jobs dry up, the people will leave. If they commit a crime, or try to work then they can be arrested and deported.


?
It’s not possible. But it could be close if we start punishing human smugglers and business that hire illegals.

We need to be harsh on those that steal identities for fake Ids and the like.

I’m not racist, I don’t have a “thing” against Mexico. People forget that there are other illegal immigrants other than Mexicans here.. I’m against any illegals.

I know a man from India that spent 16 years trying to get to the US and has been here about 10 years and you should hear him talk about his brothers and sisters that are still in India. While others are walking among us.

This is not an American supremacy thing. A lot of other countries have a harsher naturalization laws. I know countries that only let citizens buy land. In the US you can buy land no matter who you are…

A few months ago an Illegal immigrant killed a woman in a hit and run. His defense was that he should be deported because his being illegal means the American laws do not apply to him. Yet he was on welfare and had a crappy job and a car. So he had the right to drive, work and reap benefits..

It’s a double standard. Either naturalize them or send them away, I don’t care just change laws so this won’t happen again. Every other country has tougher laws so it’s time we do to. Our proverbial melting pot is going to be boiling over the stove.


?
Rating
Deport them as you find them.

Or have ICE go to one of their rallies and start rounding them up!


joeandhisguitar
Rating
using WW11 troop movement philosophy I am confidant it can be done. I think the best way to rid our nation of illegals is to remove the incentive for employers to hire these criminals. The employer should face jail time and stiff financial penalties for hiring illegals. If this is done the illegals will leave on their own. Well...most of them anyway.


Dog Lover
Rating
Here is the solution:

Public statement by the government that any business with illegals as employees have 3 months to shed them... and then they are fined 100 bucks a day for each.

Tell all illegals that they have 3 months and all public assistance will be cut off.

Tell all illegals that the public school system will turn their children away after 3 months.

Watch the mass exodus at the Texas border on the first day of the 4th month.


Tommiecat
Rating
my suggestion is that since they work on phoney green cards... we tax green card income heavily say like 31% with no refund options they will all go back to Mexico I guarantee it.


The Thinker
unfortunatly 1 case at a time? sad innnnit or open home depots and walmarts,,, in mexico?


Lisa
Rating
How about outsourcing them to India?


sweetblueyes
stop giving them things, like welfare checks, jobs, insurance, RIGHTS, housing, etc.

and stop giving it to people who support or aid them.


MH/Citizens Protecting Rights!
Start with one and keep going until you get them all. 50 states -- 1000 illegal immigrants deported/per day per state --means we deport 18, 250,000 illegal immigrants in one year. I'd say that would make a pretty big dent in the problem, wouldn't you?


JessicaRabbit
A bus load at a time - BTW estimates are usually higher than 12 million. Of course 1 is too many!

Jailing employers is a good option too. We don't need a new law to do that since it is illegal to hire illegals!

To all those that say we can't do it or they are part of our society, WRONG! We don't need them - the "mega marches" proved that. We can do it if just start!

To the person that lies about the high cost of produce, that's a scare tactic used by the pro-illegals. The cost of labor is tiny, maybe a few cents. There is no such thing as a $5 head of lettuce!


progunr
Rating
Simple, one at a time!!!


ndniw
Rating
one at a time!!!!!


Antiliber
Rating
Cut them off from government support then give them a month to turn themselves in and deport.. then they can start the legal immigration process. those that do not deport and are caught are deported for good..


Marina G
Rating
Make the employers that hire either them send them back, or legalize them and have them work legitimately.


wcqa626
We really can't, but I do like they idea of taxing all their income at the highest tax bracket with no way of getting it back. But this still wouldn't force them to go back, because they'd still be making more here than in Mexico. When I worked as an office assistant for a construction company, I would process all new employees. And of course most people we higherd were Mexican, but the employer would get their permanent resident card and SS card, but one thing that got me, was they all had numbers from Arizona, but had never lived there. What does this have to do with anything, well unless employers actually run background checks on these people, they can get a job with fake information, but we all knew that now didn't we.


MomOfMEY
Rating
it would never happend. it requires too much cooperation from everyone. Plus, more and more enter our country everyday so unless we get better border patrol, it's pointless. Businesses would suffer as well because many farms and what not pay illegal immigrants to work on their farms.


floatnfun
bottle rockets.....


Hopps-skotch12
Rating
I don't think think that was nice.......


Mama Kimba
we can't... it's that whole "you can't keep the whole class after school" thing.


Vartha
Rating
No you can't. USA is immigrant country,
sooner or later those illegal immigrants will be naturalized
in US Citizens and their children may be sent to fight wars against Iran or another nuclear thirsty nation.
There are no solutions to this just learn to live with it.

Your forefathers were illegal immigrants too.


acierinox
Rating
The immigrants are now part of your society, like it or not. You will marry an immigrant and live abroad.


m_s_anbiaei
Rating
i dont know how can this erorr clean from my handy cam(handy cam is dcr- hc40e)
thanks for answer you


dapixelator
Not possible. They're here and it would be very difficult.


Sims
Rating
shotgun


Artistic Hand
Rating
you are an american meeeen just kill them meeeen





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why do ppl got 2 hate on mexicans?
if u think we should close the borders i guess we might as well tear down the statue of liberty as well, you know that thing that says "Give me your tired, your poor,Your huddled masses yearning ...


 Construction workers that are working on my house. Is it too late to ask for legal papers after they started?
the project?
Additional Details
hehe.....Mexicans work 100% better?? Yeah maybe at sneaking into a ...


 Me and my gf are having a baby! shes 18 and lookin after baby, im in full time work! do we get help?
im in full time work and earn about 900 a month! we live together and pay rent! will we get any help from anywhere money wise?...


 Is this the "sheriff" that you speak so highly of?
http://www.arpaio.com/...


 Shouldn't an illegal immigrant be allowed to drive to work to perform ...?
compassionate jobs that locals won't do like caring for ailing baby boomers neglected and abandoned in nursing homes by their rich kids?...


 Has a migrant ever been rude to you?
What happened?...


 What's up with all these illegal hispanics that my neighbors and I keep catching trespassing and poaching.....
.....deer and stealing livestock on our property. We don't have that problem with any of the locals who respect each others property rights. I guess they feel if they can cross the border ...


 I am Pro-Comprehensive Immigration Reforms, Civil Rights, & Amnesty for Immigrants who deserve it! I'm Mexican
To whom it May concern:

Does Yahoo Answers allow users to share their knowledge, experience and opinions ?

So, why some of my answers were deleted???

I am Mexican! ...


 Our national language is still English right?
I see signs in spanish,tv is broadcasted in spanish, instructions on things in spanish. If our national language has changed i need to know because im having tough time learning to speak mexican :-...


 If i critisize immigration does that make me a racist?
...


 Should I dump my boyfriend? Please help me.?
He called me homie and I heard that means friends. Should I dump him? I love him very much though....


 Why Americans call Puerto Ricans " spicks", Cubans " Gu's'anos, and Mexicans " beaners" ?
And whole world call Americans, Gringoes, Yanks, and *****beep****!!!!...


 What scares you so much about illegals that have made lives here?
Ok I can understand why you wouldn't want new ones flooding in everyday and the gangs/drugs ppl. But why do the ones who been here like 15/20 years working keeping their noses clean and trying ...


 Is the immigration debate really just a forum for xenophobic imbeciles to air their bigotry?
Lets face it, if immigration really was a big deal, why didn't the Republicans who are "demanding" a solution for it, "demand" Bush and his Republican congress take action on ...


 Can you be in love after just two days?
...


 When will rednecks start a riot?
When the approved 700 mile does not get funded or the money goes to build roads like congresswoman kay bailey hutchinson of texas recommended...then when will the confederate flag holders start a ...


 How long will the USA last?
Like every civilization all come to an end. How long will it take the US and what will be its demise?...


 Do immigrants come to this country because our way of life appeals to them?
or is it for work and other things like free healthcare that they come.?

if you are an immigrant, what attracted you to Britain?
Additional Details
I wouldnt mind if the ...


 Why doesn't the United States buy Mexico ?
...


 What will Pro Illegals say If America is attacked and the person entered across our Southern Border?
How will the Pro Illegals Defend there OPEN Border Policy. If America is Attacked by terriost and they simply walked in across our UNSECURE southern Border. I don't think they will find the S...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074