Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

How come immigrants can work in this country?
Find answers to your legal question.





How come immigrants can work in this country?

even if they cannot speak English, but an English person cannot get an "official" job in Wales unless they can speak that 'dead' language?


    




hakuna matata
There are jobs that the English don't want to do admittedly, but by the same standard there are jobs that we are prepared to do, but cannot get them as the employers do not want to pay the wages that we expect, so they hire the immigrants at a lower wage and leave us out of the job market. This is also lowering our standard of living back to the level of other poorer countries. This is breeding a lot of resentment, and adds to fuelling a backlash towards the race relations that the government is hoping will integrate smoothly. My wife is Welsh. but does not speak welsh as it was never a requirement in South Wales to do so, so why they make welsh speaking a requirement for a welsh local authority job is beyond me. I just hope that something will soon be done to rectify this problem before it's too late.


kit
Rating
Because they are people too and they need jobs like the rest of the people to survive in this world.


Pennyless
Rating
£1.50 per hour.... thats how


third space
i think you'll find that the immigrants don't get "official" jobs (i'm assuming you mean governmental/ local authority type jobs) either. I'm sure an Engslish person could get a job as a cleaner, delivery man, shelf-packer etc. in Wales.

hope that answers your question.


PETER F
One word, capitalism. People want cheap labour, the kind of work that no Uk citizen will take but an imigrant will. We demand cheap products in the shops, producers want to make bigger profits so the easy way is to find a workforce willing to accept lower pay and poorer working conditions. Don't get me wrong, I'm not a communist, but capitalism has it's downsides too.

And for all those people going on about do gooders, it has nothing to do with them. The reason Imigrants find work is because people are greedy and want things for less.


kysteelgirl
because our government (both parties) are more corrupt than any third world country!


Robert W
Rating
Because you don't want to do the works that they are doing.


alberto g
Rating
Jake:
Why you asked if immigrant can work in the USA, I don't understand your question. All legal immigrants can and are working in the USA. That's the reason why we have a strong economy and a powerful country. We the American people are against the invasion of illegal immigration not legal immigration. Hey I used to have a girl friend from Wales, she was great!!! I met her in Tobuk, Saudi Arabia. Good luck.


poodle
Rating
BECAUSE THIS COUNTRY IS JUST SO SCREWED UP.


klc7770
Rating
slave labour i guess.
these employers pay what they want.


acegunner
Because we have bosses of companies who are only too happy to exploit them. Lets face it a lot of immigrants are working legally and paying taxes. Putting some of our own benefit scroungers to shame. They should be taught English and integrated into our society properly.


iusedtolooklikemyavatar
Rating
The jobs they are taking around here are quite awful, One is a packed meals factory. They are paid the absolute minimum and I have heard that the firms take rent and transport of them, which is probably illegal. These firms are often black listed by the Job Centre and even if you are claiming JSA, you would not be forced to take a job with these firms because they are known bad employers.
BTW First group (bus Co part) take on Polish drivers because no one else wants to work for them. This country has hit rock bottom, employers are becoming complete tossers.


colmfiveten
Rating
ok, its difficult to know what way to answer this, it all depends whether you're approaching this from a "back to their own country" point of view or not.
If that's the way that you're approaching it then i've got to point out that last time i checked its a round world out there and giving out about immigrants is off the mark imo.
If you're giving out about immigrants you're missing your focus on the real culprit - the employers - or, for want of a better world, capitalism. The rich in society will exploit immigrants - both legal and illegal to their own end. That might be the callifornian rich with mexican cleaners or suppliers to sainsbury's that use illegal pickers, packers and so on.

Why do they do it? well as said above its all about the money.

What should be done? Well the Trade unions need to work at recruiting lowpaid (and illegal) workers - fighting for conditions, pushing for government recognition of illegals - even organising english language classes.

Blaming the immigrants - the lowest paid in the race to the bottom - is the wrong end of the stick and can lead to a very nasty set of conclusions


\
welsh is not dead language


whoopscareless
Rating
it's not a dead language if people still speak it.

it's an employer's discretion who they employ; if they have no scruples, they will employ someone who can't speak English on an 'unofficial' basis because a) they can pay them less b) if they can't speak English they can't complain and c) they're probably not going to pay tax on it and d) because they have no scruples.

maybe the Welsh have more morals, employment-wise? I don't know.


deadly
Rating
Welsh is not a dead language. There are few jobs in Wales that you need it for. I think you are taking immigration a bit far if you include the other parts of the UK in your rantings. Eastern Europeans may be different but did you vote in Blair? That's your answer.


Tabbyfur aka patchy puss
Rating
The answer is simple. The English are to lazy to get out of bed and work. They would rather sponge off the tax payer such as myself and have the life of luxury and do **** all for it.


yazzskh
Its because they will take any kind of work.


hy[]er =P
they work for cheap money and plus they have soo many people soo u can get the job done quicker fo less money


mad keith
slavery that's how and its government that's behind this trade


marcoporres
Rating
Because they are allowed to and rightly so. Most of them are willing to work harder than we do for much less pay.


Bella
Cause it's cheaper and if they can't speak English they can't demand things from the employer.

Ladymoonlight- Why doesnt your BF just take the £5 (its not far of mimimum wage)? That way he'll be doing something he enjoys, and hell be getting more experience which will help him when a better paid position comes up.


shinningstarofthecarribean
Rating
Immigrants are petitioned for...Illegal immigrants are a different story..

They just need an employment Non Immigrant Visa.


LadyMoonlight!!
Its not just "English" people who can't get an official job in Wales without speaking Welsh

I'm Welsh but like many of my countrymen I don't speak the language. I don't come from a Welsh speaking area of Wales, my parents didn't speak it and my school didn't teach it (The Welsh Language Act came in too late for me).

And I can't get an official job because of this! I'm a Welsh History Graduate but can't get a job working in Welsh History because I'm not bi-lingual!

How the hell do you think that makes me feel! Like a foreigner in my own country!

As for immigrants they do the same job for less. My (English) BF is a trained mechanic but can't get a job in the motor trade in Cardiff as trained mechanics are entitled to earn about £8 - £10 per hour and as Cardiff is full of Poles and the like its easier to employ a Pole who'll do the same job for £5 an hour, even if he can't speak English.

So my BF has to do a shitty minimum wage pub job even though he took the trouble to spend 3 years doing a mechanics apprenticeship. I don't know why he bothered.

Bella - because they won't offer him a job on £5 an hour - they KNOW he's trained and qualified to earn more so they won't offer him a £5 an hour job, they'll offer it to a foreigner who they know won't complain or take them to an industrial tribunal, which a British person might.

Besides we couldn't pay our mortgage and council tax etc on £5 an hour - he has to do all the overtime under the sun to get by as it is. Immigrants don't have council tax, mortgages etc to pay.


*[RANDA and TYLER]*
Rating
cause we r nice and the work 4 cheap.


Jacqueline M
thats because the do gooders are on the case , if your an immigrant to the UK you have more rights than a UK citizen





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 When people say "Illegal"...?
all you automatically see is Mexican. Why is that? Do US people not know the meaning of their own words? Illegal isn't a race. Please don't group me with the other illegals. I'm a ...


 Did you Know this Proud Fact about this History about our Great President Bush!?
Bush Family History Rocks!!!!
Even Europe knows!!!!
http://www.guardian.co.u http://en.wikipedia.org/
We should be so ...


 Too many immigrants into the uk?
why does this country allow so many immigrants, without even stopping and thinking what kind of people are entering the country. i know most immigrants who are employed are benefiting the country but ...


 I want to marry an illegal immagrant. how do i do this?
I am a US citizen and she is an illegal immigrant with no criminal record. how long before i can get her papers and what do i have to do?...


 How do the people in the UK feel about American immigrants?
I'm just curious....


 How many of you would actually be willing to go and pick lettuce all day as a job?
Im curious, because lots of people say illegals are taking our jobs but is this really a job people want? Or picking oranges or cantelope or watermelon? Field work I guess I am asking about. I really ...


 What do people have against immigration?
Yeah. What is it? At some point or the other, most of this nation immigrated here anyway.
Additional Details
No, what I'm saying is that your ancestors probably immigrated here.
...


 Do you think if you live in this Country (USA), you should learn English?
My doctor stated in Spanish, to an ONLY Spanish speaking couple, who brought their child into the emergency room that they needed to learn English if they were going to live in this country, because ...


 If the illegal immigrants were mostly coming from Europe instead of Mexico would u still be upset ?
...


 Will immigration be your greatest concern when voting for president?
It will be mine....


 Who is more racist the minutemen or the coyotes?
Coyotes leave their own race of people to die out in the desert. Minutemen report and detain illegals. Just a poll.
Additional Details
wagonmaster38 you must live in a gated community?...


 Do you hate Mexican Americans too? or just Illegal Alien ones?
what about the ones who have been here for generations do you hate them too, some of those poor ones dont even speak Spanish anymore.
Additional Details
I personally dont hate Mexicans ...


 How are you going to like it when I get amnesty and trade my 6.50hr job for your 15hr job?
Looks like the senate is going to pass my immigration reform bill and send it on to congress to pass it too! Then on to mi amigo Bush. Ha ha ha ha! move over America here I come.One day I'll ...


 What Would It Cost to Deport Illegal Aliens?
Imagine that you came home tomorrow and found a stranger living in your home. Would you pay $148 to have him removed, or would you instead just legally adopt him and give him the run of the place to ...


 If Illegal Immigrants really want U.S. citizenship, then WHY do they wave Mexican Flags at their rallies?
Those of you who support ILLEGAL immigration, please answer this !!!
Additional Details
St Patrick's Day is once a year. I can understand on Cinco De Mayo, but at EVERY immigrant ...


 Wat do you think about ilegals?? should the goverment give them green cards?
...


 Why are some people so ignorant about immigration?
some people say immigrant don't pay taxes and sell drugs but I ask myself how do they know that. Be fair to immigrants because they help us and our economy....


 How can I save money on Gasoline and help Illegal Immigrants?
I think I have a Plan. Since I have become jaded to the various solutions proposed by the Republicans, Democrats, Sierra Club, ACLU, etc. I have elected to solve the problems as they affect me. It ...


 Profiling, whats the problem with it?
Is it not a valid way to catch criminals?...


 Who says immigrants are good for the country ?
Because they are.It's true.What do you think ?

http://www.mailonsunday....




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044