Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

I'm not trying to be racist, but...?
Find answers to your legal question.





I'm not trying to be racist, but...?

several friends have told me that no matter how much we (i.e. colored skin people) contribute to American society, or if we become citizens or our kids grow up here, we will never be considered as first-class citizens.

And when someone asks me where I am from & if I tell them I'm an American - then people will think I'm stupid, because apparently I'm supposed to say I'm an Asian American or an Indian American.

Is that true or false?


    




Aisling M
Rating
those people are idiots. say whatevr u think is true


sharia_vigilant
Rating
Nope, you keep telling them that you are an American. Not a hyphenated anything.

My wife is Mexican but, she does not refer to herself a Mexican or a Mexican-American. She refers to herself as an American and a proud one at that.

Stand tall and proud for what you believe and don't fall for what the "progressive" liberal Left tries to bait you with. Not everyone is racist like that.


baby g!rl
Rating
i think you should be proud to tell them you are American and who cares what they think...say what make you happy...not them


looloo27
Rating
I think if you are an American citizen, you pay or taxes you contribute to society YOU ARE AMERICAN. Doesn't matter the color of your skin, or from what ethnic background you are from.

God Bless America!!!!

You say your "friends" said that stuff to you?? Sounds like you need new friends honey!


ahedou2
Rating
In my opinion, the only people that consider themselves first class citizens are rich white people.


Yahoo Answer Angel
It's false. I see successful people, living an excellent life, even with very very dark skin. In the business world, your effort and production determine what kind of "class" citizen you'll be (unless born wealthy...I'm thinking Ted Kennedy, upper class in income only).


Rebekah
Rating
It is your "friends," not you who are making the racist remarks. I think you are right on, not stupid at all.


xuserx2000
depends on if the "someone" you ask is an intelligent person or not.


que otro hay
Rating
say what feels true to your heart. you are the only one qualified to classify yourself. as for the rest of the people, don't worry about what all these people are saying!


Chris R
Rating
It's not racist.

Notice how everything is racist today?

Let your light shine from your deeds before men, and let their racist opinions be proven wrong.

Start with being a person, not a race.


MARSHA G
Rating
If you're in the US and someone asks you where you are from, they are expecting something like Los Angeles, CA, or NY, NY... not I'm an American or Asian-American or Indian-American. Thank god, or I'd be a Welsh-Irish-English-Indian American... and that would be a mouthful...


scottyisrude
I'm married to an Asian. Noone I know considers her second class at all. I think you're overreacting, my friend. True, people of all "colors" can be cruel and disciminatory but for the most part Asians have nothing to fear.


45 auto
Rating
Try saying a USA citizen>


Anybody
It's another kind of racism. They are telling you that no matter how successful you are as a minority, you will never be truly American or Canadian which is just as wrong as telling people to give up all their culture, history, languages and faiths to become exactly 100 percent like W.A.S.P.S. If people want to integrate, marry outside their ethnic group or religion, learn the language, live in a mixed neighborhood and work for a regular company, they have that right as much.


j swiss
If your born in America you are American. President Roosevelt once said (para phrasing here) if you live in America and you call yourself anything but American i.e. asian american, mexican american you are a traitor.
If you live in this great nation and benefit from all its perks..freedom, economy, etc and you do not consider yourself American get the hell out....thats my opinion.


onetwothree
You're an AMERICAN, no matter what some people might say.

There's no such thing as "Asian American", "Indian American".. or "African American".

People who are citizens of this country are all Americans. It's as simple as that.

Also, there's no such thing as 'first class' or 'second class' citizens. That's all on the minds of certain people.

I could name a few 'white' people who could be considered 'second class' citizens, based on the filthy way they live. So, it's not a matter of skin color.
.


Mr. Wiseguy
green is the color that make you first class or not.


gigi
Rating
that is FALSE!!!!!!! who is that narcissistic pig???????
You are as American as anyone else.


sweetnsimple8182
Rating
who cares what ppl say or think if ur from america and u live here that makes you american even if you just moved here theres no certain color to be american and you can be first class all you want your first class when you get the money lol


Bryan~ Unapologetic Conservative
Rating
I can't speak for everyone... no one can...
but in my opinion, you're not only an American (no prefix) but you're a great American for speaking up and exercising your right to free speech.
What makes America great is the contributions of peoples from every ethnicity and culture...
what I decry right now is the destruction of that culture by those too self-centered to realize that we're not:
African Americans
Asian Americans
Irish Americans

... we're just Americans.
I'm of Italian descent on my mother's side but I'm not an Italian American, I'm an American.
There's a reason my family moved here.
Do you ever hear the term "European Americans"?

When we get past adding these prefix titles to what we really are, maybe we can finally come together as a country.
When we realize that one's skin isn't important but one's heart is critically so... maybe we can put the past behind us.
In my book, you're an American.
Thanks for being a part!


twalla128
Rating
false we are all first class citizens. if God made you, then you are first class all the way


THE WRAITH OF GOD IS COMING
Rating
No your an American or I am british, german, native of this land American, it is just getting stupid.


GoYankees&Giants!
Rating
If you are American citizen, you are "American".

I get the same question from people when I tell them I am American. Then they ask "No, what are you really?" I just laugh. LOL.

Political correctness is the problem. Using hyphenated terms like African-American, Asian-American, Mexican-American, etc is divisive! We should just use "American" in all aspects within our society. I guess since we still have policies like affirmative action (which in itself is racist), we will be stuck with using ____-American. So sad.


Explorer
This is true and false because no one body of people will believe one way


booman17
Rating
It is for some people unfortunately. Not me though, good luck.


rikfreese
Just find a new set of friends who arent hung up on race.

There is no true American, we should realize that by now. Only a definition that varies from person to person.


J P
The best answer here is the one that says, "I am not a racist but Americans are." And apparently the irony of that statement is lost on her.


Dominican Barbie
Rating
obviously you "friends" that have told you such a thing are close minded.....that is totally false...in this country skin color is not that serious anymore.....how much money you have is what make you a first, second, or third class citizen......ex: Oprah....nobody tells her nothing or what to do....why? b/c she has alot of money....look at those celebrities and successful minorities nobody tells them anything to degrade them because MONEY TALKS...so0 just don't listen to them and get an education


Sharon W
Dont believe that junk. I am a white American woman and I live in the mid-west. I can tell you that the old white way of thinking is being phased out.
It is generational. The new generations don't seem to have those hard core racist beliefs.
You are just as much an American as I am.
As with anything, you must focus on the positives, not the negatives.
There is still racism in this country, that is unfortunately true... but it is getting much better. We just have to be patient and wait it out.

I am not racist, but do have a problem with illegal immigrants coming here with no regard for our American system of government.


Theodore Roosevelt, 'Federal Textbook on Citizenship Training', published in 1931...
In the first place we should insist that if the immigrant who comes here in good faith becomes an American and assimilates himself to us, he shall be treated on an exact equality with everyone else, for it is an outrage to discriminate against any such man because of creed, or birthplace, or origin. But this is predicated upon the man's becoming in very fact an American, and nothing but an American...There can be no divided allegiance here. Any man who says he is an American, but something else also, isn't an American at all. We have room for but one flag, the American flag, and this excludes the red flag, which symbolizes all wars against liberty and civilization, just as much as it excludes any foreign flag of a nation to which we are hostile...We have room for but one language here, and that is the English language...and we have room for but one soul [sic] loyalty and that is a loyalty to the American people.


Mr. PhD
Rating
Your friends are pretty ignorant. We are a multifaceted society with people from so many races and religions, everyone can be considered a first-class citizen. Who are they to put someone else down? Do they live in a trailer park in Arkansas?





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Are you an American or a USA citizen?
Keep in mind that America is the whole continent from Argentina to Alaska....


 If all Latinos left da U.S. how would u feel bout dat?
...


 If a illegal Mexican citizen gives birth to a child on American soil is the child a American Citizen?
...


 Why can't you Americans respect other nationalities?
why you people think you're the best?
Why do you think you can treat immigrants like s***???
I am brazilian and I lived in the US for 8 years, and all I did was work, work and work... ...


 Why are Americans so racist?
i have traveld to many parts in the world and i have noticed that americans have a serious issue with racisim. every country in the world has "illegals" and they are kind to these people ...


 Is an "English Only" sign offensive??
http://www.courierposton
An owner of Geno's Steaks in Philadelphia has come under fire for posting a sign "This is AMER...


 I informed my Daughters school that she is NOT allowed to learn spanish (they are teaching basic spanish to?
allow them to communicate with the illegals in our schools), They complyed but informed me that it would hurt my daughter in later years as to not be able to fit in. Does it not make anyone else ...


 If I'm an illegal immigrant can I go to college?

Additional Details
i do have a student visa....


 Why is the United Sates afraid of becoming a bilingual country?
Spanish is the second most spoken language in the USA. People from Latin America are immigrating here more then ever now. If we learn another language, it would help our relationship with other ...


 What makes the United States of America great?

Additional Details
People who want to come to America have only one county in mind. They do not want to go to the other American countries like Canada, Mexico, Cuba, El Savador, N...


 Why so much pity on aliens illegally present in the U.S.?
I see them everyday and actually all look very healthy. In my opinion they want a ride on the easy USA streets. It doesn't take a lot of time to get a non-immigrant H-2 visa, actually it is a ...


 School says daughter may not have decal of Mexican flag on lunch Box, it legal? ?
...


 Don't like our brown faces? Why don't you bring it on?
Why do you stutter and get all red in the face when you talk to me in real life?

Why do you look at my kids with hatred but if you catch my eye you want to run away and hide?

W...


 Why are white people so racist?
Some white people are so racist and afraid of other ethnic minorites coming into their country and "taking their jobs" when they have been invading so many other for years and are too ...


 Is this illegal?
ok... so my friend and i are planning to spray my whole high school with silly string.. were gonna skip last period on the last day of school. i live in new jersey and i wanna know if theres anything ...


 I got a question?
i am wondering how does the American people feel about the Asian people ? ^.^...


 Do aliens live among us?
...


 Will you help me by signing my petition??
I'm watching cable, channel 55 , and Kevin Trudeau is talking about, "A weight Loss Cure"

Okay, for 1 thing, We do not have a diesease, so why are they calling it a cure??? W...


 What would happen to the US economy if all illegal workers were deported?
Hypothetical scenario... what do you think would happen if ALL of them were deported?...


 Whats wrong with being a Racist?
i want to preserve the heritage of my country

i want British jobs and housing for my countrymen

i dont want people from third world countries with different morals and ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084