Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

If American's crossed over into Mexico would they grant us the same benefits and courtesy America provides
Find answers to your legal question.





If American's crossed over into Mexico would they grant us the same benefits and courtesy America provides

I think not!

Let them clean up their own and create jobs for these unskilled and uneducated workers!

You people who support are part of the problem and you make this a racial issue!


    




Mary W
Rating
Of course not. They would complain to their (leaders???) that we are coming to take over their country. I think our government needs to be replaced with officials that will not only listen to those that elected them but would act on their behalf!


Krasus
Believe it or not, Mexico has tougher immigration laws than the U.S. does.


crazysk8tr15
haha your right if you cross over there you'd be thrown in a prison and probably treated like a dog


lollipoppett2005
Rating
I wouldn't hold yer breath!


Ms.L.A.
Rating
You are entirely correct!


SallyJM
They would not. Central Americans who cross the southern border into Mexico and are caught are treated very roughly. Some were killed (perhaps by accident) when Mexican soldiers were trying to capture illegals riding on top of a train.

The Mexicans don't mess around. Unfortunately, they hypocritically oppose any toughening of border control by the United States. What's good for the goose...


wingshooter08
Rating
If they did, don't you think the Mexicans would being staying home?


donttrustsnowmen
mexico will enprision u in a hard core back door prison--u will be deported,and no they will not give free medical care,no tax breaks and u may be fined..They do not tollerate illegals.


annamichele9
We would probably be shot on spot or deported immediatley.


knowssignlanguage
Rating
NO they will not treat u as nice as we treat them
you have to learn their language
you can not have any government help
you can not pick where you want to live the born citizens have choice first
and you will never become total citizen
and that is if you want to live there and want to become a citizen those are their rules
IF you ask me we need to adopt some of those rules our self.


THOMAS A
HELL NO if they could afford to do that our immigration problem would be so small we wouldn't pay it any attention. cause the people would be staying and some of us would be going there.


james b
lol..hell no...they already secure their souther border with their own military and don't allow anyone in from el salvador etc....hypocrite scum.


James S
Rating
glitterbabeprince - you must be one of those born as result from the last amnesty.

Get help - denial is an illness!

1. 3 million illegals every six months - that's crazy

2. No matter what you say illegals abuse our welfare - fact

3. Illegal women give birth to their babies in America for only two reasons - free(stolen)medical and free(stolen welfare)rides


Farseer71
No we wouldn't. They can't even provide electricity in parts of Chiapas. They have no control over their own cities and their ecomomy would be in the tank if it weren't for remitances sent from illegals in the US. Mexico is much better off now than it was say 50 years ago but they still have a long way to go to catch up with the developed world. Traditionaly in Latino culture you don't tell someone something they don't want to hear. If you tell a latino that they are doing something wrong they automatically assume that you are insulting them. That's one of the reasons that Latin America is soo poor. No one wants to tell the screw ups that they're screwing up. No one calls the corrupt out even though everyone knows who is corrupt. I have 6 years of experience living in Honduras to back up what I say. Hell, carpenters down here can't even hang a door straight. Things are obviously better in the US. It is too bad we didn't keep Mexico after the 1848 war. I'm sure Mexicans would have a much higher standard of living. One thing the racist La Raza people need to understand is that we took all of Mexico and could have kept it. We just didn't want to. Personally I think Texas by it's self could whoop Mexico & all of Central America in about a month. Ooops I forgot, Central Americans don't like Mexicans because their borders with Central America are locked tight. Guess they don't want an illegal alien problem like the US has.


amazin'g
Rating
No way! I've lived in Mexico, and they are very strict about allowing foreigners to live there. You have to PAY for the privilege and show immigration a bank statement that proves you can support yourself in order to renew your status! Otherwise, they "invite" you to go home. They are, for the most part, courteous, but no, they DO NOT give you any benefits.


DJ
Rating
They might have to if twelve to twenty million of us (or more) show up making demands. And I don't think they realize that that could happen. If anything happens here we will want our generosity to be repaid. They will have to grant us full citizenship, as we would accept no less. LOL! They wouldn't be for open borders any more and they might decide to build their own fence!


Falcur
Rating
Of course not. They don't even give that kind of service to their citizens.


Liberty
Rating
of course with a bullet in the head


cj_sez
Mexican laws are much stricter.
One must be financially secure and place no burden on their resources.
One must not have a criminal background.
The General Law of Population establishes the rights and obligations of foreigners and the immigration status permitting foreigners to enter Mexico for the purpose described therein, such as to carry out business and remunerative activities, which are prescribed in individual authorizations granted by the Ministry of the Interior.
They have many restrictions, including:
Retirees: foreigners over 50 years of age engaging in non-remunerative activities but receiving from abroad funds such as interests from investments of their capital in certificates, banking institutions, or from any income coming from abroad, provided they receive a monthly income equivalent to 400 times the daily minimum wage in force in the Federal District and 200 times the daily minimum wage per family dependent. There are restrictions regarding residence in certain cities of Mexico in which there already are a high number of foreign residents.
and
Among the various requirements that may apply to obtain immigrant status are possession of a valid passport, demonstration of economic solvency, and presentation of a certificate from the police authorities in the last place of residency indicating there have been no criminal violations, and payment of fees, personal appearance before the granting authority.

We need similar restrictions.

Mexico has a single, streamlined law that ensures that
foreign visitors and immigrants are:

• in the country legally;
• have the means to sustain themselves economically;
• not destined to be burdens on society;
• of economic and social benefit to society;
• of good character and have no criminal records; and
• contributors to the general well-being of the nation.
The law also ensures that:

• immigration authorities have a record of each foreign visitor;
• foreign visitors do not violate their visa status;
• foreign visitors are banned from interfering in the country’s internal politics;
• foreign visitors who enter under false pretenses are imprisoned or deported;
• foreign visitors violating the terms of their entry are imprisoned or deported;
• those who aid in illegal immigration will be sent to prison.



If the United States adopted such statutes, Mexico no doubt would denounce it as a manifestation of American racism and bigotry.

Read the info at the links in sources.
Mexico has no tolerance for illegals or people who won't benefit their nation.

Our laws enable Mexico to use the US a dumping ground for their non-productive citizens.


Who Else?
Rating
No, they wouldn't. Foreign governments, and not just Mexico's, treat Americans who overstay their visas quite harshly. I overstayed my visa when I was in Jamaica many years ago, and I had to sneak OUT of the country to avoid a beating. I don't think any nation is as easy on illegal aliens as the U.S.


Loco in SW Houston
Rating
I hate to bust the Kat's bubble BUT it is NOT a racial issue -- learn the DEFINITION OF RACE. It is not a ethinic issue neither but one of nationalism, or national pride.

Yes Mexico has tougher immigration standards than the US.
Yes Mexico has jobs that are in the US and you need a "worker's visa" or their equivelant (I think it is called a sponser).

But why would one want to go to Mexico and do those jobs, when the health benefits, pay, and retirement is a lot worse that what is in the USA.

NOT ALL HISPANICS THAT COME HERE ARE MEXICANS, so many Americans need to realize that. Also, if we are against the people coming to this country ILLEGALLY, doing jobs that the trash of our country are to lazy to do, then we should ALL go back to the land of our ancestors; whether it is in Europe, Africa, or Asia. The first TRUE white (for lack of a better word) in this country were ILLEGALS, but the Indians that were here first had no problems welcoming them in with open doors.


snowchickmn
Rating
Nope! it will never happened. They are crossing the border, to get in here then have the nerve to complain that they wasn't treated right...it wasn't fair for Americans and to a legal immigrant people who undergo through forms and pay fees just to work here in USA....legal immigrants waited for a few months, or even a year just to get visa in USA to be able to work as professional like (nurse, doctors, IT's etc)....On last Miss Universe pageant, on question and answer portions, Mexicans were booing the USA, I supposed...you guys maybe know why they were booing...hmmmmm


estephania2182
That's a weak question anyway. No one from the US is ever going to invade another country as mexicans have ours because we are the country everyone wants to come to! We are the land of the free, we have resources many countries only dream of, and money is more attainable....And I am in support of immigration reform and I certainly don't play the race card. I'm just sick of nasty foul-mouthed americans that say hateful things about a group of people(not a race) and making the rest of us americans that have a little bit of compassion, look bad. It's alright to be against illegal immigration but it isn't alright to hate on people that way.


cantcu
You are right. The rich would not use a Gringo for slave labor and pawn the rest off on the Mexicans to pay!

You think they are treated well. In your dreams!

I don't support people here illegally, and I SURE AND HELL do not support those who HIRE THEM CRIMINALLY!

Why don't you talk about that for a change? No way, you just want to go after the victims.

You are part of the problem, you won't arrest those who hire them illegally. The whole state of California turns a blind eye to those used as farm laborers. Have to have your cheap wine!


chewy
Rating
No you wont have to show your I.D. to buy beer bummer aint that rude. or maybe you could eat all the shrimp and seafood you like without spending your weekly savings thats gotta feel not worthwhile. You could also get a ******** for 10 bucks. and smoke all the mary jane you could use . I bet you've never visited California because is almost like going to Mexico I live in cali and all you haters can hate me more. Living la crazy life is what its like *****


Bill L
Rating
If kids today actually wanted to work there would be no need for anyone to "cross" the border."They" are merely filling a need that has been made by the youth of america and their refusual to work.It is not a racial issue, race is always brought into a discussion when facts don`t relate to your view. I say get off your asses and do something productive,earning a dollar is much more respectful then whinning about how much better you think you are then some one else.


Esmeralda
Rating
FYI america grants nothing but S***!!! America does not help Mexicans or other immigrants they make money because they work hard!! And if they are soooooooooo unskilled and uneducated than why are they taking most of you guys jobs?


Enigma
Rating
Blah blah blah all I hear is wind, America does not provide anything to immigrant applicants but a comidic time frame and a never ending wait for persons that have every right to be here.

.


Goldenrae9
I spent a couple weeks in Mexico illegally (it's a long story). I didn't have any problems.


slilt american
OK PEOPLE, I WORK FOR WELAFARE. YOU ARE MORE THAN WRONG. 96% ON WELAFARE ARE AMRICANS.OK THE OTHER 4% COME FROM OTHER COUNTRIES. YES IT IS WRONG FOR ILLEGALS AS YOU SAY TO GET BENEFITS REGUARDLESS WHICH KIND. BUT THEY DO PAY TAXES, SOCIAL SECURITY, ECT., UNDER EVEN A FAKE SOCIAL UNLESS THEY GET CASH. I THINK THIS COUNTRY WAS FOUNDED ON THE WHITE MAN COMING HERE ILLEGALLY. AND HONESTLY I THINK IF YOU WANT TO KICK OUT ANYONE IT SHOULD BE ALL BUT IDIANS, CANDIANS, AND MEXICANS. THEY WERE HER FIRST AND THEY DID JUST FINE WITHOUT US. THE WHITE MAN BROUGHT THE GUNS AND CRAP OVER HERE FIRST. INSTEAD OF WORRING ABOUT ILLEGALS LETS NAIL THE AMERICANS ONES SELLING AND SENDING WEAPONS TO MEXICO FOR THE CARTELS AND THE CARTELS BRINGING THE DRUGS HERE. I PERSONAL THINK IT IS A GOVERNMENT THINK TO MAKE ALL PEOPLE AGAINST EACH OTHER. NOW HOW WOULD THEY GET OUR MILLITARY WEAPONS UNLESS SOMEONE IN GOVERNMENT WAS BEHIND IT. I DON'T KNOW WHERE YOU GET YOUR INFO ON HOW BAD MEXICO IS ON AMERICANS ,BUT IT IS THE SAME AS AMERICA OVERALL. EXCEPT AMERICANS HAVE NO RESPECT FOR OTHER NATIONALITIES. THEY THINK WE ARE BETTER THAN OTHER COUNTRIES WHEN WE ARE THE ONES WHOM MADE A MESS OUT OF THIS ECONOMY. WE ARE NO LONGER THE LAND OF THE FREE. WE ARE ALMOST LIKE RUSSIA. COMMUNIST. WE HAVE NO RIGHTS HARDLY AT ALL. SLOWLY THEY ARE TAKING OUR GOD GIVING RIGHTS TO US. WE WERE MEANT WHEN EARTH AND MAN CAME TO BE TO GO WHERE IN THE WORLD WE WANTED. BUT AS FOR MEXICO . NO THE KIDNAPPING AND STUFF ARE OF MAINLY MEXICANS WHO HAVE MONEY. GO TO STATE.GOV AND READ ON IT. ITS FROM THE GOVERNMENT. YES CERTAIN PEOPLE THERE WILL TREAT YOU THEY WAY AMERICAN HAS TREATED THEIR FAMILIES HERE. BUT I REMEMBER A YOUNG MAN WHO WAS FROM AMERICA WHO WENT TO MEXICO AND NOT ONLY KILLED HIS GIRLFRIEND BUT ALSO 2 OTHER GIRLS. AMERICA BROUGHT HIM BACK AND HE GOT 20 YEARS. AS FAR AS I AM CONCERNED HE SHOULD OF BEEN KILLED OVER THERE. HE DONE THE CRIME LET HIM PAY WHERE HE DID IT. JUST BECAUSE HE IS AMERICAN HE GOT AWAY WITH IT. AS AN EMPLOYEE I SEE MANY AMERICANS WHOM ARE ON WELAFARE WHO REFUSE TO WORK FOR MIN WAGE OR HARD LABOR. WTF ITS A JOB TO SUPPORT YOUR FAMILIES. I SAY IF THEY WANT TO WORK HARD AND SHOW THEY WANT TO BE HEAR AND GIVE THEM ID'S SO WE KNOW WHOM THEY ARE AND THEY CAN'T BUY ANYTHING FOR CREDIT, OR CAN'T GET NO WELAFARE OR GOVERNMENT HELP, THEY HAVENT COMMITTED ANYTHING LIKE MURDER, DRUGS OFFENSES , OR ANYTHING AGAINST CHILDREN THEN LET THEM STAY. THEY ARE OUR ECONOMY. SINCE THIS LAW ON NOT HIRING ILLEGALS THE ECONOMY WENT FLOP. NOW ILLEGALS ARE NOT SPENDING, INSTEAD THEY ARE SAVING. IF THEY SENT ALL OF THEIR MONEY TO MEXICO IT WOULD BE WAY BETTER THAN AMERICA IS TODAY. WAKE UP PEOPLE COME TO AN AGREEMENT AFTER ALL WE ARE CONNECTED. ALL OF YOU WHO COME FROM IMMIGRANTS(WHITE OR NOT) ARE CAUSING CONFLICKS FOR ONES WHOM ARE USC'S WHO ARE TRYING TO KEEP THEIR FAMILIES TOGETHER HER IN WHAT IS SUPPOSE TO BE THE LAND OF THE FREE. A BETTER PLACE IF THAT WHAT YOU SAY. MY FRIEND HAS 8 CHILDREN SHE IS A USC AND AMERICAN IDIAN THEY DEPORTED HER HUSBAND WHOM ONLY CRIME WAS PROVIDING FOR THE FAMILY. WELL NOW SHE IS FORCED TO BE ON WELAFARE AND NOW SHE GETS YOUR TAXES AND BEING AMERICAN THEY CAN'T CLAIM CHILDSUPPORT IN MEXICO UNLESS SHE DESIDED TO GO DOWN THERE. SO YOU ALL ARE PAYING FOR HER 8 AMERICAN CHILDREN. SHE CAN'T FIND A JOB CAUSE SHE HAS NO ONE TO HELP HER WITH HER KIDS AND DAYCARES WONT TAKE CHILDREN WHOM SUDDENLY BECOME AGGRESSIVE TOWARD EVERYONE. THEY WERE ONCE VERY RESPECTFUL CHILDREN AND NOW THEY ARE HATEFUL AND BITTER CHILDREN. SEE THIS IS ONLY EFFECTING OUR CHILDREN NOT OUR JOBS. THIS JOB THING WAS GONNA HAPPEN CAUSE BEFORE 9-11 HARDLY ANYONE COMPLAINED. COME ON PEOPLE GET A GRIP AND GROW UP AND QUIT FOLLOWING PEOPLE.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Whats logical about deporting 20 million ppl?
4% of the population?HOW does 4% of the population hurt the ALMIGHTY USA?
Additional Details
4% unemployment means that there is almost NO UNEMPLOYMENT....


 I am not racist, but I am just wondering the opinion Would do you think of immigrants coming to the USA?
...


 If you witness someone crossing the border illegally would you report them to the border patrol ?
...


 Do you think that US government should legalize illegal Mexicans?
we just want to work "hard work" not easy ...


 Since when was white considered to be a race ?
...


 Should all illegal aliens be deported.?
i truely belive that it would hurt the econommy. They build roads houses and much more for much cheaper salary. If a legal individual does this type of labor he will want an increase of wage. ...


 What do you think of people that come to this country and don't speak English or Spanish?
...


 Stop Immigration into England...Full Stop!!!!!!?
Isnt it about time the English Government shut down our Island and stopped the influx of immigration here...unless you are a surgeon or multi millionaire?...


 Why do Americans and Europeans have the right to be bigoted about immigrants ?
After all the only reason we are so prosperous is the fact we have built our countries positions in the world at the expense of all the under developed countries around the world. Whether it was ...


 Can I leave the UK?
How can I leave the UK? I would like to go and live and work in another country.... Not sure where though, maybe NY

I'm sick of the UK and want to leave.....

What do I ...


 Why is it no one can explain what jobs illegal aliens take that American's don't want?
...


 Do I really look Mexican?
I have Mexican origin relatives... by mariage... but I am 0% hispanic

I am actually Welsh...... welsh is germanic and romanic decent!
Additional Details
30.06 pointed at my ...


 Do you favor legalizing the estimated 12 million illegal immigrants already living in the US?
...


 According to the AP, there are an estimated 6 million illegal Mexicans in the US. How do you feel about that?
...


 Why are ppl so closed minded?
why do aamericans think that all immagrants are here to steal their jobs why do you think we are a burdon on you? do you not see all the latinos working in downtown LA Chicago making .002/item to ...


 How come there are Black people who don't like illegal immigration?
The White people are trying to keep illegals out because they hate minorities. Shouldn't Blacks and Hispanics stick together?...


 Would you give 10% of your income to an illegal family ?
Till they are settled in ?...


 What would US be like a month without a Mexican ?
Yards would go unkept. Mac Donalds would have no cooks. No fruit would get picked. There would be no nannies or gardners.
Building projects would come to a stop. Fields would be empty.Crops ...


 Daddy says that ILLEGAL Mexicans have taken his future........?
and he doesn't want MINE taken as well. What can my daddy and I do to make sure that I have a strong and prosperous life?...


 Why does everyone assume illegal Mexicans pay no taxes and sit on welfare?
well i happen to know for a fact that most of them do pay taxes. they cannot claim taxes because only one person can claim per ssn. so in order to get a job they think of 9 numbers off the top of ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084