Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

If persons come here illegally should we honor their childrens' citizenship...?
Find answers to your legal question.





If persons come here illegally should we honor their childrens' citizenship...?

I personally after dialoguing with several arrogant racist Mexicans believe that if their parents came here illegallly they should be deported together [this only applies to first generation illegal immigrants]... if they make it to the second generation the original offenders should still be deported but their second generation children should however be honored as well as their parents but not grand parents.... I dub this the grand parent law... help me get it through congress....


    




sethle99
I agree. If they want to go through the legal means to get here, I say they can have as many kids as they want. This crap about getting knocked up and then sneaking over the border to have a child here is just garbage. They should all be deported and be forced to get to the back of the line to get back in again.


Mephistopheles
I don't think we should punish the children for the sins of their parents. Far too often we try to make the children or even great great great grand children responsible for the sins of their ancestors. We need to stop this attitude now. It only causes resentment and it's not fair.


tikitiki
Rating
No, they should all have to go back.


sway_ii
Rating
No a child born to an illegal should be illegal as well.


Chrissy w
Rating
You people say that if parents are illegal then so are children. Works for me and if one of your parents is a drug dealer, murderer, rapist, etc.., you are too.


So...
Rating
Congradulations...you've just managed to insult myself and my family

The children should be honored in this country because they were born on this soil. The parents and the family should all stay because these children need support. With all the wonderful(pure sarcasm) people in this country...I'm awfully sure that nobody will be willing to take care of them. Truth is, with the good amount of intelligent people who responded to this post, these kids don't stand a chance.
As a matter of fact all of you b*sterds are grandchildren or great grandchildren of illegal immigrants...you didn't own this land...the indians did. It's too bad the indians didn't bother kicking you out like they should of because we wouldn't be talking about this.

So if your b*tch *** is here...so should they. And for the idiot who said that they don't amount to nothing...neither will he!

These people come into your country for a better life and I think thats the biggest compliment a country can get. Those illegal immigrants are the ones serving and cutting you meat. They're the ones at the cash registers in a grocery stores. They clean your stupid filthy grocery stores and I know a thing a too about an absent parent who works 6 days a week to provided for his children. Without them, some corporate business' or even the smaller business' wouldn't be here. They...should I say we make your damn economy run because you "civilized citizens" are too lazy and too concerned about your overweight bodies to have any cchildren.

Thanks alot @ssh*les!


double00boyz
No Not at all,Why should we pay for illegals


chicagodan1974
Personally... I agree with you. However, as the law stands right now if a child is BORN on American soil they are an American. Not only that... it's also free passage for the parents. So, to give you a terrible example that happens all the time, A Mexican woman sneaks over the border 7 or 8 months prego. she lays low until Jr. decides to come out, goes to a hospital (and in this country the hospital CAN NOT refuse medical treatment) and haas the kid. Catch 22... the INS could be standing there 1second after the kid is born they can't deport ANYBODY. I agree with you... I'd sign that petition. Or how about this one?

Everyone is welcome in our country... all you have to do is pass a GED test IN ENGLISH.. tahhh dahhh... all set. And if you're caught here illegally... .we put you in JAIL! I know, I know, it sounds crazy but I believe in punishing people who break the law.

Slainte,

-D


Phoenix, Wise Guru
Rating
Nope. Anyone born here is a US citizen. Period.


b.w.
If you are illegal so should your children be! That law about being born here makes you a citizen should be reworded to say if you are born here to two documented parents you are a citizen. If you are born here to even one illegal parent...deportation!


GratefulDad
Thank God the Native Americans didn't have that policy when we all landed on this soil !


Wesleystock
Rating
I don’t believe you should pay for your parents crimes. If your parent get’s away with murder, many years later they find them guilty but they are all ready passed, should you hang? If they die in debt with no money, are you going to pay their bills? Such lofty people we have here. As far as people being “crazy” to want to move here, where else would you rather move? People talk about how it’s better somewhere else, usually it’s some place they’ve mearly vacationed, or heard some movie star say is so much better. Anyplace is great when you’re living in your villa. Europe is chuck full of unhappy immigrants and rioters, the country is going broke.


nicholas_fahrenkopf
Rating
I disagree. As long as a person is paying taxes and contributing to the economy, they can be a citizen here. And, as the laws are now, if you're born here, you're a citizen, and YOU PAY TAXES. So that's fine by me. What bothers me are the people that come here, and start benefiting from the taxes everyone else pays. Not just social security or healthcare but having a fire and police department to protect you, road crews making and clearing roads for you etc. Those services come from taxes, and if you benefit from them at all you'd better be paying your fair share.


TigerLilly
Rating
The only way I believe a child of an illegal should be considered a citizen is if one of the parents is a citizen. Too many illegals are having babies just so they can hide behind them to stay here.


frank71175
First of all, Mexicans aren't the only illegals in this country. Secondly, if the illegal comes to this country and works does all he or she needs to do to become a resident and get a worker's permit then they have a right to live here, unfortunately most come here and do neither, but why should the children suffer their parents short commings who is to say that the children cannot become productive in this society and redeem the parents. I am the son of immigrants and yes my parents were illegal until they got thier permits to work and eventually got thier residencey, I was born here and I am not mexican. This country was built on the backs of immigrants, whether brought here by force or by decision. The only reson they should be deported is if the deal drugs, murder or get caught stealing and rape. The arrogant racist mexicans you spoke with are only speaking for a minority of the Hispanic population and they say it because they think the new ones are taking thier jobs away or making them look bad or worse they have money and they just hate the lower cast mexicans.


the answer lady
i agree


khmer_gurl_336
Thats unfair that we Americans talked that way because if you truly go back to your roots everyone is from other countries unless you are Native Americans dammit!
My folks are from another country but damn I work and pay all my taxes like any other citizen!!! And I was born here. So there..can't go back to any country except America.


walter27282000
Rating
No................

If we allow their Childrens Citizenship, Are we not Encouraging Illegal Immigration?


DeadxStar
I agree.

Where's the petition?


me
Rating
No, the children should learn by error and know their parents did something wrong. Especially so they can learn right from wrong.


I'm as cool as ice cubes
Get them all out...if it wasnt for there parents then they would not get ot stay here in the first place ...make them leave


PrincipalNZF
It would take more than an act of Congress. Citizenship is defined in the constitution -- you would need to amend the constitution to do this.

"The Stranger shall be to you as the native-born" is commanded in the Bible -- how come you never hear right-wingers quote that verse?


Circlometry™
we should make some sort of delicious immigrant soup from their womb vegetables


Ironic Destiny
I like to use Jimmy Carter with this issue. You see people yelling about people coming over here illegally but how come you don't see anyone yelling about how the people that are over here legally and are new citizens learning about our culture.
You know why- people don't like to focus on something their guilty about


sealRborders
NO WAY!!!!!!! If the parents are ILLEGAL, then the kids should be ILLEGAL!!!!!


Luvlee
Rating
"Thank God the Native Americans didn't have that policy when we all landed on this soil ! "

That was too funny!

Back to the topic! I think that the illegal immigrants need to go back to their own country and protest against their president, dictator, etc, etc about laws and humans rights for a better life. They need to stand up and be strong for their next generation instead of running.


Yukaza
Close the anchor baby loop hole....Just say no to all illegals from any where .....


noooooooooooooooooooooooooo
What??


vanamont7
Rating
Don't know, man. Right about now my feeling is, you come here, you're either crazy or deserve what you get.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Minutemen soon to be Outlawed - what will the bigots do now?
An Arizona lawmaker has introduced a bill to revise the state's statutes on organized crime and fraud by defining "domestic terrorism" in such a way that members of the Minuteman P...


 Do you believe those who say the majority of "undocumented workers" are law-abiding, peaceful people?
http://www.newsmax.com/a read the info on that link! The numbers are slightly different at current time, but the report still rings true... Roughly four percent of ...


 Lazy Americans?
Ok so everyone has a voice on illegals going to doctors not paying their bills, not paying taxes, not learning english etc...

My question is do you have the same rants with the americans ...


 Would you favor an amendment to the CONSTTUTION that would stop automatic birthright citizenship?
For anyone born in the UNITED STATES who's parents are ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS?
Additional Details
Presidential candidate Ron Paul just offered House Resolution 46,which would amend the ...


 Did U.S. immigration ever change immigrants last names?
I was told by my father that our family last name was changed from Erickson to Allen because there were too many Ericksons coming over on the boat. This would have been in the late 19th century I ...


 Why are people who hate immigrants usually the most stupid people who contribute least towards society?
Why is that most people who are against immigrants, and immigration, and blame immigrants for crime and living of the state, are the ones that are actually causing those problems themselves?...


 Do you think Illegal Mexican Immigrants have respect for American Citizens?

Additional Details
American Citizen by definintion of those born here in the United States ....


 Why is it illegal for people to come to the U.S. without citizenship...?
Think about how stupid that sounds. People who support laws against illegal immigration, listen up. Why is it bad for a person to drive from one part of the world to another and live there.
...


 Who would you rather have your daughter bring home?
A hardworking illegal who treats her well, OR an unemployed citizen who slaps her around.



Inspired by P.C. :o]...


 Why didn't the White Invaders learn to speak Cherokee when they came here??
You see, this is just as stupid a question as the one about wanting people to speak english.

America should be grateful that Spanish is so prevalent, because bilingualism enhances people�...


 Politics aside-what are your feelings on "Illegal Immigrants"- stay or go ?
No nasty comments-just be realistic and honest in your reasons why they should stay or go back home....


 Should we just cut our losses and just give California back to Mexico?

Additional Details
I'm not kidding, neither am I suggesting one way or the other; just polling to see what people think....


 If we give Mexico "their" land back, what would they do with it?

Additional Details
.
My POINT people, is that why are they so hell bent on getting it back? It will just be part of Mexico. Nothing will change. The government would still be ...


 Does everyone listen to talk radio?
I suggest you start, our nation is now at stake. TV is mostly liberal biased, you hear more in-depth truth on radio....


 People who support illegal immigration,what is wrong with them ?

Additional Details
Live long and prosper,Steve.Mr.Spock was so cool....


 Just turned 18. I work at UPS from 2am to 8am. Is it possible to get fired for refusing?
to load other trucks such as cage trucks after I busted my *** off all morning finishing my own truckS???
Ive already acquired my seniority. What are the chances of getting fired for refusing ...


 If you had a Time Machine, would you stop European rejects from reaching the shores of America?
...


 6.6 billion people on earth, can they all live in america?
What are some practical concepts on immigration policy?
Additional Details
Don, I know you're pro-illegal immigration, but you've yet to come up with anything like a 1/2way ...


 I like to date blond womans from U.S.A, I need green card, can you help me?

Additional Details
Thahts ok, I like big blonds women....


 Can an American guy live in UK?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084