Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

If someone came to your door on Christmas and asked if they could work for a bite to eat?
Find answers to your legal question.





If someone came to your door on Christmas and asked if they could work for a bite to eat?

Would you give them a paperplate of food and not have them work for it? Or

Find some odd job for them and give them the food? Or

Ask them for papers proving citizenship and feed them if they could prove citizenship? Or

Kick them to the curb even tho they might be a homeless vet who fought for you but didn't carry any papers with them?

Merry Christmas everyone and May Peace follow this year!


    




Curt
Rating
"He who does for the least of them, do so too me", said Jesus. Invite them in, give them the food, and wish them a Merry Christmas!!

Merry Christmas to All


Carrie Ann
I would give them some easy quick job, to make them feel like theyve earned it. Give them some pride.


catmaninmo
Rating
I have done this. I used to make them a sack with sandwich, chips etc. I have also had some who asked for any money I could spare, and used to oblige, until one day, I went out to check my mail, the day after helping someone and found the bag with the food still in it tossed in the ditch. I no longer do the money thing. Food only.


grumpyoldman
Rating
If they offered to work for it, I would give it to them. If they were hungry and just asked I would probably give it to them. If they looked like they were on drugs I would kick them to the curb unless they had children with them. Merry Christmas!


dogsngoat
Rating
On Christmas, I'd probably just feed them.

On any other day I'd probably find something for them to help me with (I've got plenty of odd jobs I need help with) and pay them some and feed them.

Of course this depends on what I'm doing and their attitude but 90% of the time this is what I'd do.


Ida Slapter
Rating
They'd be knocking on the door of an empty house since I'll be out of town!


keshia
I say feed them and dont make them do any work.


retired military wife
Rating
There will be no one at my house on Christmas Day, because my husband and I will both be at a local homeless shelter preparing and serving lunch and dinner.


Trinity
I would feed them, any day of the year... never know when an angel may stop by in disguise.


Lil's Mommy
Rating
I would give them the food without having done any work. They could eat off the same dishes as my family and they could sit at the table with us. Two wrongs don't make a right. Any person with a heart, which many do not would feed the person and not think about where or what happened to them to get them in this position. God tests us with little acts like this all the time and it is our choice whether we make the right decision.


a TRUE American
I would gladly share my Christmas dinner with any American. No illegal alien would come begging for food. They all receive too many food stamps.
So, my answer is "yes". I would share without having them work for it.


contemplating
Rating
Anything you do for them will encourage them to come back for more. I would refer them to local services (homeless shelters and foodbanks in the region). If they were going door-to-door, there is a fairly high probability that they are looking for empty houses -- so I'd call the cops.

Giving them jobs around your house can be dangerous. It's too bad that people like Elizabeth Smart's parents had to find that out the hard way. (that's the 13y/o girl in Salt Lake City, UT that was abducted at knife point from her bedroom in the middle of the night by a homeless man that had done roofing jobs for her father)


Micky
Honestly if someone came to my door that I didn't know I wouldn't answer it. There are too many bad people who victimize good people especially during the holiday season.


chief8
I'd give them food but keep them out of the house.

Merry, merry Christmas.

BTW, I'd also offer him a heavy jacket if the weather is cold.


Magma H
Rating
Just give them food.
But stay away from the house.


I still heart fugin
I would just feed him...don't care if he is illegal or not.

A human is a human. I'm shure when I'm standing in front of god and he asks me "did I help my fellow brother" he's not gonna ask if he had papers or not.

I'm sick of this political c*ap....people know what right, and yet they decide to turn the backs on poor countries and worry more about there vacation homes or there next new car. Hope that makes you happy.


Michelle N
I wouldnt judge them in anyway,,it has to be very embarrasing to ask for food, I would feed them, and point them in the right direction for further help, shelter and somewhere to work. I think we should do to others as we wish to be treated as well, we are all human, no matter what color your skin, if your from a different country.


Ana C
Rating
I would feed them. God said to feed the hungry, clothe the poor, visit the prisoners, and to do unto others as we would have done unto us. Humanitarian aid is not a crime.


Ms.L.A.
I would feed them but I don't want anyone I don't know to work around my house. So I guess the first option that you gave. Merry Christmas to you and yours as well! If they couldn't ask for the food in English that I understood, it would be kick 'em to the curb! Sorry!


StoneCold
I was out doing a bit of x-mas shopping, and had a fella in a wheelchair ask me just exactly that question. "Do you have a job I could do for a couple of hours." Knowing I didn't have any work for him, I still chatted with him a bit. He happened to be a homeless vet, and I wasn't about to have him do a job for me because he had already done enough just by serving this country. I turned to put my great niece in her car seat, and buckled her in. And after doing so, I took money that I carry in my truck, returned to the vet, and gave it to him.

I personally have yet to turn down someone who is hungry, or in need of something or another. So if they showed up at the house on x-mas, I would feed them.


motroo
Rating
I guess it would depend a little on the initial meeting with the person. Maybe they look like an axe murderer, then to the curb. Maybe they seem like they really need help, Just give the food. Maybe they seem like they have/had alot of dignity and wouldn't take food without earning it a little, then I'd give a small amount of work and alot of goodies.


Amanda h
I would feed them... Perhaps I would ask them to shovel some of this snow that we have way too much of. Hungry is hungry. I care not what color you are, or, what language you speak. It is my job as a member of the human race to do everything in my ability to help others.

And, this happens at my house very often. My mother is convinced they somehow have my home "marked" at the curb or something. Whatever. They do some sort of outside work, and, I am happy to pay and feed them. No problem... "Marked" or not....





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What is your opinion on all of the illegal immegrants who crossed the border from Mexico?
I am not going to give you my opinion cuz then you will probably copy me. I just want your opinion!
Additional Details
Ok sorry this is messing with my head so much! My opinion is that ...


 Why do illegal immigrants feel that my fellow citizens and I should be responsible for their bills??

Additional Details
"Jorge" I agree. Some are coming here to make a better life for their families. But at my expense!! And many of them could care less about what they are ...


 If Americans don't like Mexicans, explain me why?
the most beatiful blonde american women marry Mexicans?
Additional Details
Brirtney spears is dating a Mexican, did you know that? and this is just one of too many examples....


 Why is doing nothing better than this dead immigration bill?
If the immigration bill is truly dead, doesn't that mean that the status quo just continues the way it is? So why is it better to have millions of people here illegally than trying to do ...


 What is the meaning of illegal....and is an illegal immigrant illegal?
...


 How do illegals in the US pay their taxes and contribute to Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, etc.?
If they are undocumented, they have no tax ID. What are they doing to pay taxes and report to the IRS?...


 Who here is tired of the illegal immigration issue?
The fact is there are illegal immigrant from all over the world but you only concentrate on Latinos, maybe because they are the majority. Whey don't you complain about other races? Russian, C...


 Was the US found by illegal immigrants?
The "greatest" country came to be after some illegal immigrants started killing the locals, then separated from England to avoid paying taxes to the legal British government in order to ...


 Why is it that if Mexicans have so much pride and love for Mexico why don't they stay there?
...


 Every American needs to do this, and commit to it, to fight the wave of illegals.?
Every American needs to commit just ONE day to going down to the border, and help build the wall. If even only a third of the country did that, we could have that wall built in a week. The minutemen ...


 Is racism a natural instinct in dominant males?
Back in the cave man days the men had to protect their territory against other tribes so that their family would survive. In the past few thousand years men have also been on the front line defending ...


 The British complain about immigration but how many of them emmigrate?
Following yesterday's question I stirred up a hornet's nest. I decided to check how many Brits there are abroad. I found the following on the BBC

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/...


 Why do pro-illegal immigrants refer to the minute men as racist ?
Why do pro-illegal immigrants refer to the Minute Men as racist, when People from all colors are free to join ?
Additional Details
I noticed alot of people , have not read my question... ...


 How is it racist to want illegal immigrants to be all kicked out?
Last I remembered "ILLEGAL" didn't become a race....


 Is there anyone else here from the future ?
...


 You really want to compare my forefathers with illegal immigrants?!?
The editorial in the Aug. 5 issue of the Mountain View Voice ("Many sides to the immigrant question") was the final "push" that made us write this response. To us, it is insulting ...


 Whether illegals contribute to the economy or not isn't the issue...?
And if they supposedly do jobs that Americans won't do, that isn't the issue either. Illegal immigration is in fact, ILLEGAL.

There are lots of US citizen criminals who ...


 Mexicans Are Some of the Most RACIST People Out There?
And you people have the nerve to say Americans are racists. Wer're talking about a country whose society still finds blackface comedy to be hilarious. Of copurse, let's not forget Vicente F...


 Will Britain become more violent has immigrants continue to flood Britain?
...


 Where is the best place to live in Mexico?

Additional Details
I don't want to live in the US I want to know a great place to live in MEXICO. I don't want to here about crossing the border, a fence, or anything to do ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034