Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Illegal Aliens in the US??
Find answers to your legal question.





Illegal Aliens in the US??

is it true that if the US got rid of all our illegal immigrants our economy would crash??


    




lordzander31
Immigrants legal or not do a whole lot of jobs that 99% of Americans wouldn't do and even if we somehow forced everyone of the unemployed to work there wouldn't be enough people to fill ALL the jobs that immigrants do.

The US economy wouldn't crash per se but would be placed in a serious world of hurt.

Thank God for all the hard working immigrants in our country. Remember that ALL OF OUR FOREFATHER WERE IMMIGRANTS!


annmariet14
Rating
no


sacolunga
Rating
No, I don't think so.


freeetibet
Rating
Absolutely not. We may have to start paying the right amount for certain products instead of the savings we get by employing illegals for under minimum wage. Also, certain businesses, like rental properties, may take a hit. But quite frankly, if you're profiting from illegals, then it's your own fault.


llwhateverll
Rating
NOT A CHANCE, IT WOULD IMPROVE:


The following 10 facts have been pulled from the LA Times.


1. L.A. County has 10 million people. 40% of all workers in L.A. County are working for cash and not paying taxes. This is because they are predominantly illegal immigrants, working without a green card.


2. Of the 10 million people in L.A. County, 5.1 million people speak English. 3.9 million speak only Spanish.

3. 95% of warrants for murder in Los Angeles are for illegal aliens.

4. 75% of people on the most wanted list in Los Angeles are illegal aliens.

5. Over two-thirds of all births in Los Angeles County are to illegal alien Mexicans on Medi-Cal whose births were paid for by taxpayers.

6. Nearly 25% of all inmates in California detention centers are Mexican nationals here illegally.

7. Over 300,000 illegal aliens in Los Angeles County are living in garages.

8. The FBI reports half of all gang members in Los Angeles are most likely illegal aliens from south of the border.

9. Nearly 60% of all occupants of HUD properties are illegal.

10. 21 radio stations in L.A. are Spanish language only


Ricky
Rating
No that is the liberals trying to create fear...


hayleylov
Rating
no


Bunny
No


Panacea
Rating
Our economy would boom. Illegals are HUGE net drain on our economy. We spend many times the amount they produce, supporting them. And many times that dealing with all the crime they bring here (35% of everyone in prison is an illegal alien....almost all mexican).


elperro
No, but I don't think America is ready for that kind of sacrifice.


Chicka B
Crash? NO. It would just take a small adjustment period until everything balances out. We'd all be fine.


bereal1
I think there could be some problems but the way to solve a lack of a medial work force would be for the fed. gov. to put every able bodied welfare recipent to work. You want your check? prove you've earned it. the crops etc. would come in the welfare rec. would finally have some pride in a job well done and employment would be at 100%. beat that-problem solved- send all the illegals back.


jay5002
Rating
Crash? Doubtful, However:

There are an estimated 12 million illegal immigrants in the US that make up 4.9% of the US Work Force. They make up larger amounts of the following industries:

Farming 24%
Cleaning 17%
Construction 14%
Food Prep 12%
Production 9%
Transport 7%

So expect to pay more for your fresh produce, more expensive janitorial, harder to find construction, some restaurants going out of business or higher prices, and more expensive cost to move goods.

This would be a nice recession, but not a "crash", it is a bad idea to remove nearly 5% of the US work force and not expect any consequences


loyalrebel
No the unemployment numbers would go down. Real Americans would be able to have jobs and could demand better wages.


sealRborders
NO WAY!!!!! If we did NOT have all the ILLEGALS here,LEECHING off the TAXPAYERS,we would have a SURPLUS of money, to help all the AMERICAN people( YOU KNOW, the ones who REALLY DESERVE IT!!!) WE would ALL be BETTER OFF if all these MOOCHERS would GO BACK TO MEXICO!!!!!!!


PANCHA
Rating
There would be an effect,but I doubt it would be a huge one.


1-way worldtraveler2006.
Rating
I have provided research on your question...if the U.S. got rid of all illegal immigrants, the crops wouldn't be gathered, so the food economy would crash.


Pondering Reality
If you think about 12 million people (official statistics count 12 million some say the number is as high as 20 million) working illegally in the USA, noone is keeping any records on those people to begin with. We have no real idea of how many actually work, or where they are working, or in which jobs. We don't even know how many are unemployed and live on the streets taking "day laborer" jobs. So how could the absence of undocumented people in our workforce crash the economy if they aren't being taken account of to begin with?

No, the economy wouldn't crash. It would open the jobs up for Americans to have the jobs.


CHULITA
YES I HOPE IT HAPPEN THIS NOT USA IT MEXICO
IM LEGAL IN MEXICO THIS IS MEXICO.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What do you think of undocumented students that get help into college?
If your ignorant and racist dont bother answering. Beleive it or not there are some people to come here for the American Dream. It doesn't matter what your color is it's about the better ...


 Does the "report abuse" link need renamed?
whithin the Immigration forum, should the "report abuse" link be renamed the "Shutup! Racist!" link? Please be honest....


 Why do the Americans want to tell us where we can and can't go ?
Americans act as if this land is theirs, it truely belongs to the mexican people....


 Anti or pro illegal?
i just want to see how many there are of each...just say anti or pro and why or why not if u want to. i think there will be more anti since this IS america for god sakes but im just wondering.
...


 Why Do Some of You Here Compare La Raza To The KKK??
Has La Raza ever lynched or killed anyone??

Blacks like Al Sharpton have spoken before La Raza. Whites like Bill Clinton and Arnold Schwarnegger have spoken before La Raza.

I ...


 Damn it. Don't you people care about your fruits and vegetables?!?!?
You won't have anything to eat except junk food and you will get even fatter than you are now.

http://www.washingtonpos...


 Do you think Americans, are to easy on illegal aliens ?

Additional Details
Doesn't matter what thumbs you give, WON"T take question off alien....


 We all have different views?
I can't quite figure this out. If you agree with illegal immigration then you are the "it" and everything you write must be the god awful truth. But if you Disagree with illegal ...


 Do illegal aliens feel weird walking in the US, like people are on to them? lol ?
...


 English is the ONLY official language of the USA so why are there spanish speaking options?
I have absolutely no problem with people attempting to become a U.S. citizen the legal way. They pay their dues, take the test and if they pass they are AWARDED citizenship. I am not heartless to ...


 Did the pilgrims enter America legally?

Additional Details
Had the Indians written any antii-immigration laws?...


 Why don't you mexicans fight your own corrupt government?, instead of acting like them. Are you scared?
...


 If you all agree that the protests didn't amount to much?
Then how could you say that illegal immigrants have a GREAT impact on our lives?
Additional Details
GREAT=HUGE...


 Immigration?For or against it?
...


 Should illegal immigrants be allowed to serve on juries in the United States?

Additional Details
If their voting and some paying taxes wouldn't their name come up for jury duty?...


 If I marry a US citizen can I be a US citizen too?
If I marry a US citizen in Australia (I am an Australian) and then she decides to stay here, can I eventually become a US citizen through marriage even though we live in Australia?...


 Do you feel like the INS focusing ONLY on illegals from Mexico is fair when we have illegals from all over?

Additional Details
Mr. U.S. of A, Baby!, you posted an answer...and I quote "Your assumption is incorrect. Let me guess you're here illegally from Mexico and got caught? Or ...


 "Not all illegal immigrants are that way"; and the point is?
I hear this defense on here from many folks..."theyre not all that way" or "not all are bad". What is the point these folks are trying to make when they say this? Are they ...


 Mexicans. How do you feel about them???
Illegal and non illegals how do you look at them in the social order of things???????????? Honest opinion no anwser will be reported i want honesty please Thank you ppl i will vote best anwser ...


 What if I named my restaurant "BEANERS"?
Do you think it would be allowed? Do you think people would have a problem with it? What kind of people do you think would have a problem with it? Does a double standard exist? For instance, take ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.064