Is deporting wrong??

Zipperhead

any other country that has an illegal alien either arrests them and puts em in prison as fodder for the others, or deports them. Why is that so difficult to understand? They are there/here, illegally from another country. Send em back. What's the problem? If you're talking about Mexico, do a little research about how they treat the people coming across THEIR borders from the south. It'll open your eyes, unless ya care to remain blind.

dpilipis

Slavery better than deportation? Now I have heard everything. Perhaps you are unaware but, we have a constitutional amendment that prohibits that.

ProUSA2

For those that think America is wrong for enforcing its immigration laws, want to talk about "invisible lines", and deporting illegal aliens, what do you think of this link???

http://www.cbn.com/cbnnews/world/060815a.aspx

P.S.

Here's the text for those that don't want to click the link.

MEXICO CITY, Mexico - For the past month, America's attention has been focused on the Middle East war. During that time, another 300,000 illegal aliens have crossed America's border with Mexico. But you won't believe how Mexico treats its illegal aliens.

Illegal aliens from Mexico were allowed to march through America's cities, demanding citizenship â€“ some even waved the Mexican flag. But illegal aliens inside Mexico, mostly from Guatemala and Honduras, are literally on the run.

Some travel by train and some hide, trying to stay one step ahead of the Mexican Federal Police.

The Mexican government was outraged by the movement to build a new wall on America's southern border. Mexico's Foreign Secretary Luis Ernesto Derbez went before the cameras to protest.

Derbez said, "Mexican immigrants are not felons or terrorists. They are human beings who deserve respect and the opportunity to live with dignity."

But in Mexico, when it comes to the treatment of its illegal aliens it's, â€˜Do as I say, not as I do.â€™

Mexico has called U.S. immigration policy "harsh," and has called the proposed wall on the U.S. Mexico border "shameful." But some have called the Mexican immigration policy "hypocritical."

Enter Mexico illegally and you're treated as a felon. If you're caught by the Federal Police, you'll be fortunate if you're only deported immediately. The unfortunate are robbed, abused, raped, or even murdered by corrupt police officers.

Fernando Aguilar Neri coordinates Red Cross efforts to help illegal aliens in Mexico.

â€œWhen people approach us, they are usually fearful that we work with the government and are afraid of being reported,â€ said Neri. â€œâ€¦One of the seven principles of the Red Cross is complete neutrality and independence, so we can't cooperate with the Mexican government on the illegal alien issue.â€

Neri says that most illegals moving through Mexico try to avoid the cities.

The Catholic Church also shields illegal aliens from the Mexican government. CBN found two shelters for illegals in Mexico City, but weren't allowed inside.

Most of the Central Americans inside are on their way to the United States. They'll be fortunate if they arrive unharmed.

One immigrant from El Salvador said, "If you are carrying any money, the police take the money and then say, get out of here."

"We still have 20 days of travel (to reach the United States)," another one said.

But if you're a Mexican wanting to enter the U.S. illegally, then you can count on the Mexican government's help and support. It even has a special department called Grupos Beta that helps Mexicans cross the U.S. border illegally.

But in an interview with CBN News, the head of Mexico's Immigration Service, Hipolito TreviÃ±o, denied it.

â€œGrupos Beta is the Mexican government initiative which does not help people cross the border, but they do assist them when they have problems in the border area,â€ Trevino said.

But Grupos Beta gives them a booklet, which includes tips on how to safely cross the U.S border. Trevino denied the allegation that immigrants are also given maps by the government.

â€œNo maps,â€ he said. â€œWe give them recommendations about the dangerous animals they'll encounter, how much water they need every day, what to do in case they get lost, what to do in case they get detained by the border patrol, which paths are dangerous because of crime.â€

The reason for the government's help? The cash sent home by Mexicans in the U.S. constitutes the second biggest source of foreign currency in Mexico after the oil industry. Last year that was $20 billion, or 2 percent of Mexico's GDP.

About 10 percent of Mexico's population is now living in the United States, thatâ€™s over 10 million people. And how many illegal aliens in its own country has Mexico legalized in the past five years? Just 15,000.

The Mexican government may think a new wall on the U.S. border is offensive, but critics are saying far worse things about Mexico's immigration policy.

Dogsnoop

Is breaking the law wrong also?

Darkwolf

Deportation in not only necessary, but right.

rwcrufler

No. Becoming an illegal alien is wrong.

LadyAmerican

No I think deporting is fair if not they need harsher punishment for people who break the law like that.

I do not believe in slavery, that itself is evil. And I sure as heck don't want lawbreakers in my military.

What part of ILLEGAL do you people not get?

Do you guys REALLY not see all the negative picutres of the illigals andhispanics holding signs saying they are taking back the parts that we bought from them or they lost in war?

Come on people WAKE UP!

little eccy

If I steal your money, is it wrong that I should be punished and made to pay it back to you?
If I stole your house, is it wrong that I should have to leave and give it back to you?
Why is deporting considered punishment? they are only going home.

Yoda

I noticed your post and link to CBN shut them up ProUSA!!

Good job!! They have no response when confronted with facts they can't handle. LOL!!

IHateUrIllegalHusband

No, deportation is not wrong. It's also not a sufficient punishment. Our punishment here apparently needs more "teeth". (I'm really not sure if you are trying to be funny about the rest or are just a nut).

Deport all illegals!

chichibaby

No they all need to go the hell back to where they came from!

Geno

No, deporting is not wrong. It's called ENFORCING THE LAW. LAWS THAT ALL COUNTRIES ENFORCE.

I agree Yoda.

Notice they gave you thumbs down, but didn't respond!! Cause they have no argument and resort to a lame "thumbs down".

lisaa89

Deporting is NOT wrong. What do you mean "too strong of punishment" they're here "Illegally". My opinion is get ALL illegals out, no exceptions. If they want to come here then they need to do it the right way! We need to stop the BS, and all the states need to agree on one thing, which is deporting all illegal immigrants. I see people sporting the Mexican flag on their cars and shirts, that pisses me off this is America not Mexico, if you like Mexico so much to support them, and disrespect this country, you need to get out because obviously you don't belong here.

Balloon

i agree ....... the constant struggle between cultures has always been and will always be .. every society in history that became self proclaimed "enlightened" to the point that they tried to "get along" with their enemies becomes destroyed by their enemies .. just like the idiots in our culture buying this "inclusionism" crap ......

Commandant Marcos

I know that here we do not tolerate illegals at all, you come here and violate our immigration laws you go to jail, for God knows how long, then deported. No foreign flag waving demonstrations either, they get their liberal butts beat up and thrown in jail along with the illegal scum.

ed s

Any way to get them outtahere is right (deportation or self-deportation aka attrition)

If you keep them it would be only to build a wall. I imagine 12M people working over a year can achieve quite a nice result (see wall of china). Call this the 'wall of shame' for Mexico's unability to sustain itself. When they are done building then take them outtahere, and ask Calderon to fix his own corrupted country so they never want to climb their wall

summer

no they should not be forced to go into the military and heeeeell no they should not be turned into slaves. that is so sick. have your spouse or friend chain u up and whip you with a whip and see how you like it. sick, sick, sick. how dare you get on here and insult the intelligence of Americans?

~Cheta K.~

Do u know the conditions those people live in? Trust me forcing them to go back home would be far worse than becoming a slave or serving in the armed forces.

meredeth the male fairy

i dont think it is right to deport

Ryan G

Punishment for what? For crossing an invisible line?

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: