Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Isn't it pathetic how some people say "your ancestors came here, so why can't the illegals?"...?
Find answers to your legal question.





Isn't it pathetic how some people say "your ancestors came here, so why can't the illegals?"...?

It's not my fault the Native Americans didn't have international immigration laws. Not to mention, when my particular ancestors came here, they came in LEGALLY.


    




Phil S
Rating
You speak as if the white people respected the laws. Name one treaty they made with the native americans that they didnt violate.


betterdeadthansorry
Using the past as an excuse has always been the favorite argument of individuals with limited present-day logic and evidences to support their side, next to ad hominem attacks and the race card.

The whole deal with the native indians, the pilgrims and that stupid Mexican-American war has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with today's immigration problems, and everything to do with the question of current legality, current sovereign laws and current law enforcement.


misskate12001
Rating
And you're ever so proud so you remain in unidentifiable profile?


straightup
Rating
Your statment/question is stated a little harshly, but the point, that when many of our ancestors came to America there were not immigration laws as there are today, is well taken. Our country must evolve as the population continues to rise. Additionally, the economy is ever changing, and policies, including immigration, directly impact that. So, yes, there are laws which need to be followed for the betterment of society and the protection of the country and it's economy. No illegality should be tolerated, either by the immigrants or the companies that hire them.


blotto
Rating
Absolutely! My ancestors had to jump through every kind of legal hoop imaginable, PLUS fork out several thousand dollars, and wait in line in order to come here LEGALLY.


RENEGADE.
It is not your fault that My ancestors did not have the foresight to know that their land, lives, and way of life ,would be systematically destroyed by A hostile force of invading land hungry savages who used every and any means possible to exterminate all indigenous peoples they encountered on their way west to the pacific coast . So, in reality the land you live on is stolen property.
If you cannot or will not defend what your ancestors have left you, We The Original Peoples of this land will gladly show you how. We have learned much from your ancestors.


ajflkajfsalkfsalkfna
Rating
yes i agree with you and i think its also pathetic how people make this a race issue.


Cooljerk
When my ancestors came here there was no society, or welfare or free health care (paid for by others).
My ancestors helped create the society will live in, they fought and died in wars and built roads and cities.
What does this mean you ask? Just that the I (we) should be able to reap those benefits, not someone who just crossed the border last night.
We can't let everyone who wants to come here in, we have to have limits, it's that simple.


glduke2003
OK...people who came here legally, have studied our history and our laws....the people that have not, don't understand our history or our laws, so they tend to break our laws and cost us tax dollars, i think we have enough problems in our country right now...and taking on a bunch of under educated illegal immigrants is not the best idea for our country.....I understand that life in other countries can be hard but that's up to their countries government to handle


§чﺀﺀчβчﻯ†a
Now why didn't your family just stay in their own country? Why did they just HAVE to come here huh?


bob h
Is it? Consider every immigrant came here illegally because the land was taken illegally according to the Natives' point of view. Does not matter that the Natives had no immigration laws. The country was stolen. If many of our courts had not accepted that point of view, there would have been no court ordered reparations granted to Native Ame5rican Nations. Using that argument, mine were also illegals.

The INS also has set quotas on how many from which country are allowed into the country. Since those quotas seem to based on race, they sound unconstitutional on the face of it.

Taking either view, the US has no jurisdiction over who is legal & who is not..Seems to me both sides have a point.

By the way. Answering your own question is called propaganda, a direct word for getting on your soapbox Seems like I read somewhere .it violates Yahoo guidelines.


amish-robot
It's a whole different world than 300-400 years ago. Yeah, our ancestors mistreated the natives. Does that make it ok now? of course not.
It's about assimilating. My ancestors learned English, became contributors to this new society, not dregs, and respected others. This cannot be said about the new immigrants. They come here with no intention (most of them), contributing. They drain the welfare system, the schools, the hospitals, and send what money they do earn here to Mexico.
Lowering wages, because they don't pay taxes for the most part so they net more than someone else making the same wage who is paying taxes. Forcing the legal workers to look for higher paying jobs because they can't sustain a living wage.
I dunno. This country is going to hell in a handbasket.


Cheeto
Rating
Speaking of ancestors, you and I might be related. hello cousin.


D
Could you please describe the differences between the immigration laws of your ancestor's and the current laws?

No?

Yeah, that's the problem...you have no idea how hard it is to immigrate in the world TODAY. Try it some time...seriously.


Zapata
Rating
Who do they got permission from.


rogue chedder
Guess that makes us all illegal immigrants,


already_enuff_spice_in_this
The white people who signed treaties with Native American Tribes made only one promise they kept..that was to take away our land and kill many doing it.


xcelix
Rating
So, that makes you a better human, how?


M
I don't think it pathetic. Just the have nots wanting to "have".
Can't blame them. They want to better their life.
I think illegal immigration should be stopped. Rules are set for a reason. It might make more jobs and promote less unemployment. (I'm not an economist) But I also think many Americans should get up off their *** and do some labor.
LOL that just my opinion. Walk to McD's for a change and walk a few blocks to the store. (if it's safe)


ggraves1724
Rating
It's not that pathetic, we still accept the notion of people immigrating to this country. The illegal part is a politicians creation.

It's something to hang their hat on so to speak. If border and customs were able to do their job correctly, we wouldn't be having this conversation. The fact that you are on a computer that, probably has high speed which, may or may not be in your work place tells me that things just are not that bad for you. So I'm assuming that, the phrase, "illegal immigrant" was also brought to your table by a politician.


God of Fire
Rating
I agree and as for the chode that asked "name one treaty they did not violate..." ok. Guadelupe-Hidalgo


Sean
Yea, thats like the lamest excuse ever. "oh, we are all immigrants! omg!"


Jess
racist people have no clue what's going on in the lives of illegal immigrants....and why doesn't the government look to the north of us? There is another border up there too. You can't blame it all on Mexicans.


vanamont7
The illegals immediately fall into the clandestine activity pattern and the govo knows about it. That's the difference. That's why Ike said to guard against ' the industrial military complex.' Have any feelings akin to being in a banana republic? No offense to Latin friends who may be reading and might also be as much as able to relate what the ' strong man ' politics are really like out there.


loretta
Rating
ok, your right.


Sway 26
I agree, plus they squawk about anchor babies having a right o be here, so even if my ancestors had been illegal I was born here :P


antagonist
Rating
that's a downright racist comment





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why r some Americans hypocrites?
i mean some people say that illegals are against the law etc. its not like they are perfect and have never done something illegal. "now you respect laws right", how pathetic. others say ...


 Do you think that its OK for illegals to be here?
...


 Immigrants!!!???
if your culture and customs are so great!!! why do you all want to come to my country (canada) and when you come here- why dont you learn OUR languages and adopt our customs and cultures?? instead ...


 If Canadians were crossing the border to find jobs, would it bother you like it does when Mexicans do it?
...


 Do you think mexicans are going to be the majority in the U.S. in 100 years?
Do you think english is still going to be the official language?...


 Why is it so bad to support undocumented immigrants?
why is it so bad to have illegal immigrants to live on US land. Dont you think its good to have of all kinds of race to live on our freedom of land? Why is so not allowed why does it have to be ...


 Should the border fence be electrified?
Why not? They just go under or climb over, electrifying it would stop this immediately. Why does this country always seem like it's being run by a bunch of p*ssies. We should be hard like R...


 How do you think a man Like Jesus Christ will handle the immigration Debate?
...


 Proper grammar and punctuation!!!?
Why can't we all please write in grammatically correct English? English is not my first language, but I make an effort to spell correctly and construct coherent sentences. Please use your ...


 Why is it SO hard for some of you to understand the DIFFERENCE between?
crimes committed by American citizens, and those committed by ILLEGAL aliens????
Come on!!!! It's not rocket science!!!

AMERICAN =CITIZEN A citizen has the LEGAL right to be in ...


 Are people aware of it when they are being spiteful and mean?
I have been reading questions and answers on "immigration" and people are making comments about immigrants that make my skin crawl.

When somebody suggests shooting Mexicans at ...


 Can a Mexican immigrant get disability from america?
...


 Why dont Mexicans stay in their own countries and fight for a better government there?
Is it because the government is so corrupt, and they are conditioned by a country of wishy washy law enforcement- to where they have no respect for laws and government....


 Do conservatives believe in 'immigrants rights'?
http://news.yahoo.com/s/
In the middle of this article the writer says "Giuliani, who backed gun control and immigrant rights as mayor of ...


 How can I become a beefeater?
...


 How do I get my neighbors to turn their music down?
I asked this question before and got some interesting answers but the problem is still happening. I live in a largely illegal immigrant neighborhood, I recently moved back to take care of my ...


 What is your strongest argument for illegal immigration?
meaning a pro-illegal stance
Additional Details
i haven't heard anything besides,,,white people are racist,, and this is 'our' ...


 Why do they want to deport me ?
I sneaked back across the boarder and got knocked up, so I could have a child that is now a legal citizen. The U.S. goverment wants to deport me.... where isthe justice in that ?
Additional D...


 I have a feeling America is...?
Screwed? Who else thinks so with Barack Obama and John McCain as our runners? America will fall into a depression if either of them win the election... God can only hope in 2012 we get decent runners....


 Should Illegals have freedom of speech in America since they are not Americans?
To openly back the Aztlan movement in our streets when they are clearly invaders and crimminals?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074