Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

My good deed of the day,what are your views?
Find answers to your legal question.





My good deed of the day,what are your views?

Just spent most of my day helping a polish man who works with my husband,find a decent flat. He's away from his wife and kids, working hard,not sponging off the tax payer. Would like to know if you think i did a good thing or i'm daft for supporting an immigrant here to work,thanks.


    




SKA
Rating
Anything you do with good intentions and from the kindness of your heart is a good deed!


Gretl
Rating
Good thing if he's legal. That was nice of you.


yahooyahooyahoo
I think youve done a really lovely thing. I always think it must be so hard for some of these people who are working here from poland or wherever,they are away from their families,English is not their first language,it must be difficult,Id hate to do it,so yes,that was lovely of you.


PrettyKitty
You did a good thing.... After all, he's a human being just trying to make his way in the world. Not all immigrants are lowlifes....

The Polish are some of the most hardworking people in Europe...


skiingted
I think what you did is great. Coodoes to you! (That is a pat on the back from one of us from across the pond)


45 auto
Rating
If he is legal with proper papers than your a princess>If he is illegal than you helped a criminal> Your call>>


billy
Rating
You've done a really good thing.

Life is about what you can give, not what you receive.


elsputnik
You helped a person.... full stop - feel good about it!

Far too much hang up everywhere on where people are from, at the end of the day we're all human beings!


moon_flower_unicorn_power
Rating
God bless you.


chris n
I think you did a very good deed. Well done. That man will remember what you did for him and it will colour his view of this country and our people. He won't brand us all a load of baddies. What goes around does eventually come around. A long time ago at work, I was nice to someone's wife. No big deal. Many years later, the man was in an important job with a choice of contractors to use. He used my company because I'd been kind to his wife and I got a bonus. I'd completely forgotten my good deed - but he hadn't. Good on you.


kiwi
Yup. Good deed.


Tattoo Ted
What defines a good deed? People approve of so called good deeds because it benefits them or society.

In this case, the Polish man benefited as indeed you have by gaining praise on here.


justaskin
Rating
it's a good deed more people should do good deeds!!!


Andrew L
Rating
The issue of immigration is one for politiicians to decide. It shouldn't prevent anyone from doing a good deed, and helping someone in need. Which is what you have just done. Good on you.


DankRuse
If you are helping a legal immigrant then I applaud you for your service. If you are helping an illegal I hope they put you in jail for harboring and aiding a criminal.


button moon
Rating
always a good thing to help people whoever they are! i think thats so sweet, your a nice person and i expect he very pleased of your help and company throughout the day! if only more people would be as kind as you, the world would be a much better place xx
take care xx


Lisa T
Why are you doubting what you have done? If you think that you have done a good deed then why are you questioning it. If the man was grateful for your services then consider it a job well done. As long as he knows that they are the only services you are offering!!!


Yoda
Is he legal? I assume he is since you call him an immigrant, not an illegal alien...


LadyMoonlight!!
I'm sure you did a good thing.

Personally I am not happy with the amount of Polish etc coming here - you will see from a previous post how badly my partner and I are struggling and competition from Eastern Europe is not helping us one bit. You said that your partner had a good job and so I guess Polish immigration is not affecting you in that way, and you are OK about it.

Me personally I would not have helped. I would have wanted to see him go home to his wife and kids and free up a job for someone like my partner. But as you are no doubt OK financially and not in the situation we are in I'm sure you are not bothered by Easter EU immigration. Its all a matter of perspective.


sammy
Rating
No you did a kind thing.


jojo9
Don't worry about the opinions of these people. Worry about what God thinks. In his eyes there are no borders to limit you from helping a HUMAN being. You did a wonderful thing regardless of this mans legal status!! God bless you!! :o)


luvettes15 *I Eat Sea Kittens*
don't listen to tattoo ted praise is worth nothing ..trust me especially if you think you might not deserve it which is the case here but you did a good deed nice job


Richard
If he is a legal alien then you did a good deed. If he is an illegal alien then you didn't do a good deed.


r b
Rating
If he is here illegally, then you did no one any favors. As an aside, what job did he take that no Anerican citizen couldn't fill?


only the truth
Rating
i think your stirring it


Marxsparx
Rating
You'v just opened a can of worms





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What are you going to do when we all get amnesty?
You are crazy if you think that this will not happen. We will get amnesty and be a big voting block. Then we will begin voting Mexicans in office. Wait and see. Who is going to stop us? If you ...


 Do people like illegal law breaking criminals?
isn't that what people who sneak in over the border are?...


 Why when the gaysmarch in LA nothing happens. When Latino march LA police attack us ?
We are in the park andthe police attack us but they dont attack the gays even though they are aginstG...


 Should the US invade Mexico?
They're already here anyway, it would solve a lot of problems and makes more sense than the war in Iraq....


 Would you like to see a law making English the country's official language ?
...


 Are the immigrants really taking jobs of legal American poeple in the U.S?
I know for a fact they are not taking the jobs of high paying bussiness just jobs that are some peoples last ...


 People outside of the U.S., what do you think of Americans?
...


 How does an Illegal justify their right to be here?
I saw where someone said "They just do jobs US Americans are too lazy to do" Then mentioned field work.Immigrant labor makes up 25% of the agricultural work force. Meaning 75% are from the U...


 Why do they arrest and deport the Chinese illegal immigrants?
At least they are working in Chinese Restaraunts and not taking other people's jobs. Also, they are not homeless and they are not involved in violent crime against English like the African, J...


 My Bully's parent's are illegals. Can I call the immigration authority and report it at school?
His parents are illegal's, can I call the border patrol and have them kick his parents out of the country? They are illegal. The bully is legal.

Can I get back at him, by doing this?...


 Should it be a crime to help illegal immigrants?
...


 Why are we paying tax for immigrants and bogus asylum seekers..................... ?
...


 Will Immigration Ruin the USA?
Like global warming, immigration seem inevitable. Will it ruin our lives here?...


 Why some Brits feel so feared of immigrants stealing their national identity?
Is that because they are all immigrants or their descendants, so some of them feel unsettled and endangered by newcomers?
Similar thing goes about Americans.
Additional Details
S...


 Are you oppose, or for immigration?
...


 The issue is "Having"to learn Spanish not as a choice?
I speak 3 languages fluently.And am learning Spanish.But that's my CHOICE.Do you think you should HAVE TO learn Spanish?

That's the point I think I see people trying to make on ...


 Has anyone seen this?
The majority are "just here for a better life?" What about the ones like this? Am I supposed to feel sorry for these menaces?8/3/2006

by William Gheen of Americans for Legal I...


 Do you think a wall on the border is really going to work to stop illegal immigration?
I think we should close off our borders with Mexico too. I mean we should have both things, borders closed and border fence. That's really going to stop illegal immigration!...


 Will a border fence and an increased gestapo border patrol actually solve the immigration problem?

Additional Details
In a country that prides itself in an ideology that all men are created equal and that strives to protect the civil liberties of individuals throughout the world, it ...


 Is it still a crime if you murder or harm an illegal immigrant?
It seems like it wouldn't be since they're tresspassing anyway. At least not a crime here in the USA....




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034