Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Profiling, whats the problem with it?
Find answers to your legal question.





Profiling, whats the problem with it?

Is it not a valid way to catch criminals?


    




trf6x6
There is nothing wrong with it. We should be doing it more. Nothing like seeing a Liberals wine.


NONAME
Profiling is a great tool for law enforcement. It is a fact.


lordkelvin
Absolutely....


John himself
Yes but the liberals don't want the criminals caught. With high crime rates, they can push for the elimination of the rest of the bill of rights starting with the 2nd amendment. They will use crime as a way to force us into communism.


marconprograms
Good question. I'd liketo point out that ALL the insurance companies use profiling all the time, and nobody seems to have a problem with that.


Ms.L.A.
According to statistics it is. I see nothing wrong with identifying yourself if you're not illegal, what does it matter?


Rex B
Security people use it in Airports but won't admit to the practice. The problem with it is people that look like certain cultures get singled out for special attention. Personally I like the practice and hope it continues.


open thoughts
If terrorists were white males, I would EXPECT to be profiled. I have never understood why a 80 year old white woman with a walker is given the same scrutiny at airport security (if not more for the show of it) than a 30 year old middle eastern man.

My best friend is from Iran. He finds it insane that he (and other middle eastern men) are not profiled. He is all in favor of it because it is SMART! If you ask him, he would say..."I would wear my ID on my sleeve if they would profile because in this time, it is necessary!"


KRIS
sure it is


ricmon87
But your not saying you would use it to "catch" or spot illegals by simply looking at Latinos/Hispanics?


B.Kevorkian
Rating
It can be a helpful tool. In the context of terrorism or organized crime, though, it can backfire if the 'bad guys' find out what your profile is.

If drug smugglers find out that you're profile of thier 'mules' is young women from Guatamala, than can have more guys swallowing drugs for them, and evade detection more easily. If terrorists find out you're only searching young muslim males getting onto planes, they can recruit some of those female terrorists from Chechnya for the next 9/11. If you're only on the lookout for guys with beards, they can shave. That kinda thing.


Marilyn T
I am sure it is helpful.
I still would like to know why at the airport they pulled my son and myself away to screen us longer. We were standing in seperate lines. We are both very tall and slim, pale with red hair and we were both wearing black.I assume it was because we had one way tickets..


Robert P
Ummm.. if there are three kids walking down my street every time my mail box gets demolished, who should I look to?


amnesty sucks
It's not PC but I think it should be used. I hate it how we have become so politically correct!

The problem is when the cops suspect someone, the crook will scream that he was profiled.


Rabid Frog
Rating
I can understand why racial profiling is not used much, would you want to be followed 24/7 if you were an innocent person? But those who want to take it a step further and say that people do not have to provide proof of who they are when receiving most services (jobs, education, assistance, drivers license, etc.) are just politically correct fools, as citizens we have to have identification all the time....


Zapata, like your answer, kind of ironic....


Airadine
it's hard because in one way, sterotypes are sterotypes for a reason but on the other hand, it's proven that people can be different than those within their category.

We can't say all black men are tall, but yes, some black men are in fact tall. That is where we get the profile with racial profiling. It is true that most females love purses, but not all females love purses.


The Gig is Up ferengifighter
Rating
What does a criminal look like to you.


cosmicwindwalker
fine unless you are looking for a white male wearing a white hat and you really look like your avatar.


Dog Tricks
What's right with it should be the question.Let's put it this way...I've been a victim of profiling.Not racial but financial.I had my battalion of kids with me at the clinic to get shots and when the receptionist asked for my insurance card an old biddy behind me said to another old bat"Watch her pull out a medicaid card..sniff...welfare mothers and their dozen kids.Disgraceful"Well I pulled out my INSURANCE card and shoved it in her pruney face and said"I PAID for my kids old lady and didn't sit on my wrinkled azz waiting for my hubby to bring home the bacon"The receptionist busted a gut laughing as the old bird snapped her trap shut and walked out.Profiling is wrong no matter who or why it's being done.


RE
Profiling is a big net. It hauls in many innocent along with the guilty. Just ask all those who sat on death row until recently released after DNA analysis proved they couldn't have committed the crimes they were convicted for.


Zapata
It's illegal!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Yesterday, my wife, kids and i went on a bicycle ride together.?
We were passing through this one neighborhood when a latino lady had just crossed the street. She stopped dead in her tracks and was looking at my wife(Yes my wife is 8 1/2 months pregnant as well). ...


 What would be the best way to solve The problem of Illegal Immigration?
Ive heard and researched the Issue,.a lot..and from what i gather...there already exists an Immigration Policy,..also there have been planned routes to addressing the border crossing problem..by ...


 Is anyone gonna stop the illegal alien invasion?
or are we just belly aching for no reason?...


 How many think we should just let the?
ILLEGALS stay in this country???
WELL, Then,give me your address,and i'll send them all to YOUR house to shelter, feed, clothe, and pay their medical bills for them and their fifteen kids ...


 Why is Britain being flooded with immigrants?
...


 Is there an official language in the United States?
...


 Why is every 3rd world country ran by non caucasians?
Is this just coincidence or is there something else too it?...


 Doesn Anyone believe that the demise of America is by its own people?
whining and complaining about everything? I mean undocumented immigrants at leat they take advantage of the benefits this country has to ofer and work hard to be part of this society. Unlike whinig ...


 Which meal would you serve to welcome an immigrant to the UK?
...


 Have you ever had a conversation with an illegal alien?
...


 Can anyone tell me some trueth about the West?
A Ghanaian woman who was removed from a Cardiff hospital where she was receiving cancer treatment and flown home after her visa expired has died.

Source: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/...


 What are some ideas for helping illegal immigrants be treated fairly on the job?
I am writing a 1000 word essay on this topic for a scholarship in college!...


 What country do you think I came from before living in the U.S.A.?
http://www.myspace.com/s...


 Do you think Illegal Mexicans will bring disease to the USA?
Im not trying to be mean or "racist", but seriously your from a different country with different standards. Dont you think you coming illegally is putting others at risk medically?
A...


 Why are Americans forgetting that this is a country of immigrants not racists?
Some americans are against immigration ever since they got here....


 Should the British be asked if they want multiculturalism?
It is a massive change to UK culture and I think we are not asked because most would reject this awful pseudo-intellectual concept....


 Can we please have another no mexican day?
...


 Question for the americans?
If you have brown skin does that makes you Mexican?...


 What do you think about of the illegal people?
...


 Do you hate me because I'm Brazilian???
i go to school everyday and i get A's. my parents pay taxes. no one in my family has ever gone to prison or ever gotten a ticket.
we are illegal. meaning we don't have a social ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034