Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Should Illegals have freedom of speech in America since they are not Americans?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should Illegals have freedom of speech in America since they are not Americans?

To openly back the Aztlan movement in our streets when they are clearly invaders and crimminals?


    




Lotus Phoenix
Yes, they have to right to say whatever they feel like, all they way to the plane that will be deporting them back to their country.


SNOOP
Sorry folks but our Constitution gives EVERYBODY the right to the freedom of speech. You can't single out any one group and say 'no' to them. But on the other hand anyone here illegally is using our Constitution against us for freedoms they haven't earned. That does make me angry.

Get in line and get legal!


?
Rating
They did not fight for those freedoms granted to the citizens of the USA. If they are still given those rights, they should respect the country that allows them to have those rights and not uprise against it. This talk of Aztlan is bordering on an uprising and is instigating Civil War here on USA soil. Americans do not back off, we will fight against those who want to divide our country. They will be beaten back and many will die. Some of us will die, more of them will die, no doubt about that. We will prevail, conquor andpush them back across the border they illegally crossed. They have provoked this docile dragon too many times. It is ready to strike back violently.


princess_29_71
Rating
No, they have too many "rights" here as it is.


kristycordeaux
No, deport them. Build the fence, keep the invaders out.


ssgtusmc3013
Rating
they have only one right , to get the heck out of this country.


richard a
illegals should have freespeach.... In there country. Don't come here and complain you can not speak your mind. Become a resident and speek all you want. Learn the language and you can say even more, until then. shush it... and change your government, not ours


siervocal
Legal immigrants have this right also. It's not just for Americans. I believe the right is given to every person living in the U.S.


duc602
no they have no rights, ask for their green card and see how fast they take off.


Anton Mathew
Rating
Since they are not here Legally, they have no rights.


actionsinglemale
Rating
The U.S. Constitution was made for the American people, so Illegals have no right what so ever.

And JP all illegals are crimimal. They all broke the law


nickieali
Hello No, they shouldn't have any kind of special rights or privileges. IF i go to Mexico or some place else I wouldn't have the rights of their land.This is the land of the free, only to those whom are citizens.Land of the free doesn't mean everyone and your brothers come over here and do as you please..Land of the free means do as you please as long as you don't break our laws.
Invaders are Illegal Immigrants which mean, criminals.....don't have the right to be here and didn't ask to come here...DO you knock on your neighbors door or just walk in?...I knock...They just walked in....Go home.....


britsurfer1
How would you know they are illegal?


lateralus
Hell no!


Lisa M
Rating
The U.S. Constitution protects the rights of ALL people. What was it that the founding fathers said? "all men are created equal" "endowed with certain inalienable rights" "among these are life, liberty and the persuit of happiness"

That's what America stands for. The rights of ALL people. That's why they get involved in everyone else's affairs all over the globe, and many hate them.

So yes - illegals too have freedom of speech. Not the rights and privilages that are guaranteed to only Americans, but the rights and freedoms that are for ALL people.


Vodka
They are criminals had therefore have not right to protest in American streets.


Suzy Q
No!!!!!!!!!


BIGL
they got everything else what differance does it make if they want to run for president i'm sure they would be allowed .


turntable
Rating
no...


captmhunt
The First Ammendment grants the right of freedom of speech. That doesn't mean you can yell "FIRE" in a crowded theatre but it DOES mean you are free to speak your mind.

I have lived all over the world and I have lived in countries run by dictators... some benevolent and some tyrants... but the one thing those countries share is, you are not free to speak your mind... if you DO say something against the government, and the wrong person hears it... you will just disappear and nobody has to listen to your rantings again.

About the only thing the sets America apart from the other third world countries... debtor nations with a Fascist ruling party ("FASCISM" A system of extreme right-wind dictatorial government)... is the fact that Americans can say what they think anywhere they wish to say it.

If you really want to end free speech for Illegals with whom you disagree... then what is the NEXT group you want to take freedom of speech away from?... Gays?... Anti-abortionists?... Catholics?... Religious Conservatives? ... anyone who disagrees with the Bush policies?

Once you start down that slippery sloap called "NO FREEDOM OF SPEECH"... eventually, you will be in a group that MUST be shut up because of their beliefs or view points.


EVY
yes!!!! they still have some rights


FaerieWhings
Rating
While I definitely do not support illegals, voluntarily, even criminals have the right to freedom of speech in this country.


JP
So you're saying that not everyone deserves freedom? Not all 'illegals' are criminal invaders (that sounds like one of those retro Space Invaders knockoffs). Some are families looking for a better life, or people running away from abusive homes and governments. You can't say that one person deserves freedom but not another based on their birthplace. Besides, how would you enforce that? Make them wear a Mexican flag so whenever they said something out of line, they could be prosecuted? Sounds a tad like Hitler.


Steve
Rating
If our laws are morally correct, they should apply to all people at all times equally.


Cassie
Rating
I get so sad when I read these answers where there is so much hate in the heart towards other people....................Jesus came for everyone, including people from all over all the earth. The US is just a small part of this world. When we try to stand above all, we fall. Remember how long the Roman Empire lasted?? about 200 years..............the US is still a baby country going through growing pains.


Eric
it doesn't matter if u are an immigrant or not once u step into the USA u have rights that's why the USA takes war prisoners to Guantanamo in Cuba cuz they have no rights there as they would have if they were here in the USA and to say that illegals are criminals is retarded and is wrong ,u are trying to say that people who are citizens are freaken perfect NO!!! they commit crimes to nobody is perfect.


Rich
Rating
"I will speak against those who cheat employees of there wages who oppress widows and orphans or who deprive foreigners among you justice, for these people do not fear me" says the lord of heavens armies" Malachi 3:5
" you shall love your neighbor as yourself"Mark 12:29

My Job is being taken by illegals however I can not let fear decide my actions that is a lack of faith.I can not blame poor people for trying to survive. I can take actions to make Mexico a better place to live I can buy mexican products. I could ask congress to stop making bombs and start Helping our neighbors to the south I can ask them to enforce the laws that are already laws,And I can ecourage the mexican people to speak up and use speech to improve there own corrupt goverment. We have to be examples of freedom and examples of integrity. Freedom of speech is a right given by GOD not by man, Read the declaration of independence.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Jail, or deportation for illegal immigrants?
Jail AND deportation? Deportation, and jail where they come from? Mobile jail? Jail-to-go?
Additional Details
jail/deportation si!...


 How unfair?? Its so biased!!! 10 points and 5 stars for an honest view!?
I have been reading a few answers here, and so many of them say stop immigrants comin to US. They shudnt expect to be catered to all their needs.. I am askin all ya users, Who Are the Real americans??...


 Has the flood of immigrants and Asylum seekers brought crime and drug gangs to your area?
...


 Do you think that people are FINALLY starting to wake up?
It seems more and more that people are changing their opinions on how they feel about granting amnesty to people that are here illegally?

Do you think that it is finally starting to sink ...


 A question coming from the other side?
You've seen all of gwb22's questions. Would you say that he is racist against hispanics? Being Puerto Rican should I be offended by him? Let me know what you think about him. Don't ...


 Why are some Americans so afraid of different immigrant groups ?
I grew up in an
Armenian
Jewish
Lithuanian
Polish
Portuguese
Cape Verdian
Laotian
Cambodian neighborhood in the smallest state in the nation,we all got along ...


 What do you think Prince Charles will do when he gets into power about all these immigration spongers?
...


 Why do rednecks want to close off their borders but yet have to outsource tech work to india?
Not only tech work, but any type of work needing brains. Not only to India, but Asia, Europe, Indonesia, etc. Can we trust minutemen to with the task of patroling our borders if they dont even have ...


 What will the illegals do when we begin a massive fence, massive fines for employers, and massive deportation?
Will they become law abiding and submit to the authorities? Will they clean up their act, cross back into their native country? Will they get mad and act up?...


 Should I have to speak Spanish in America to survive?
It is hard to get a job anymore if you don't speak Spanish..Is that fair? I wouldn't mind learning the language but should it be imposed upon us? Some day we will have to #2 for English ...


 Why hate immigrants?
Few questions, what have they done that has wronged you as a person?
When have the specifically taken your job?
What are they actually doing wrong?
I believe that if England when ...


 American culture is not the way for me, how can a US citizen permanently move to another country?
Please don't take offense when I say that American culture isn't for me. It may be the best country for someone else, but I feel like another country would be the best country for me... it&...


 Is Immigration good for the United States?
...


 Would you buy a brick?
Do you think it would be a good idea to buy a brick and mail it to you Legislators with a note to use it building the US/Mexican wall?
Additional Details
YO! Buy a white brick so the ...


 Do you feel New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin's comment's were racist??
He said "we are going to rebuild this the Chocolate City" & also "What can i do to keep Mexican people out of New Orleans?" The latter comment was insensative & racist,yet ...


 British people better wake up to the reality today?
End immigration into Britain for sure....


 What is it about illegal immigration that makes people so angry?
And why, exactly, can't the United States do what Spain is doing with their "illegal" immigrants? They have just as many illegals as we do (despite the contrast in size between Spain ...


 Do you think they should allow immigrants to cross the border?
...


 I'm a REAL American why should I have to pay when I shop in immigrant shops?
They are in my country shouldn't they have to PAY ME for the privledge of being here???...


 Why are you against those who feed you?
Growers: Migrant Workers Needed

“They’re part of our economy. Without them the agricultural economy is dead."


http://www.rnews.com/Sto...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.374