Should all illegal aliens be deported.?

NSA

Yes. Immediately . Right now! Yesterday would be better. Get rid of them. Give 'em the boot!

mikeab84

Those all good points, but I believe that it hurts the wages of American's lower middle class work (dont give me this jobs americans wont do crap-they wont do them for $5 an hour, 70 a week)...

I think if someones been here for decades, and has established a family its one thing, but a 20-something who just got here should be sent home...

The people who really need to be punished are the employers who hire them illegaly.

firewomen

I see you have bought into that "let them stay, we can't do without them!

mnwomen

Yes they should. The work got done before the illegals and it will get done. I would rather pay more and know the money goes to someone who is legally here. Also there will be less cost to the taxpayers when we dont have to pay for their education and other benefits.

Joe R

Yes. we have plenty of people to do the work that "only they will do" Those folks are on welfare right now.

salyers274

why do you think they do it for cheap cause the employeer knows they are illegal,if they were gone pay would go up,unemployment go down less strain on services money beening sent home would be spent here your not thinking

George A

YES! The key word here is ILLEGAL. They are here illegally & should be deported back to their own country & made to get the required paperwork & come across the border legally then.
Let's twist this...if a country was paying $5000 day & all you had to do is work 3 hrs a day. You as an American citizen crosses their border illegally to get that job. You get caught, should you be able to keep that job or should you be deported back to the US? (Unless you end up in very dark, damp smelly jail cell to be forgotten for years)

koolpenguindb

yes the illegal ppl should be because they live here free and get money and the ppl here that need jobs are outta luck wich sux

362436

yes they should, the crime is not being here the crime is stealing peoples social security numbers so they can get work, plus they use or welfare so how is that helping the economy, someone who truly knows economics needs to be president

Seen it all before

not in the UK they don't
they seem to be involved in quite a bit of crime too - we could do without that for sure

i think we could do quite well without people using our services without having a right to be here - our NHS is being abused and is not able to cope with the needs of the legitimate population

I'm gonna start another riot

Are you saying that only illegal aliens are the only people in America who would accept work to build roads ? Are illegals the only people in America who will now accept work to build a house ? In case you are not aware the housing market is weak and going bankrupt millions of people have lost their homes and it does not matter how much an illegal saves on any house the fact is people are not able to keep them. Where is written that an illegal does not need to have a license to wire a home for electricity but everybody who wires a house is suppose to either follow the law or face time in jail. What you are saying is that we are suppose to ignore many laws to accommodate the illegal and if cheaper is better why hasn't this caught on in Mexico ?How can you morally pay taxes when to do so you must use fraud to accomplish that ?

Justme

YES! Do you really believe our whole economy depends on people [who aren't suppose to be here] working on our American jobs? I think not. I would rather have these jobs be a requirement for people to receive public assistance. I don't know about you, but I'm tired of paying able body people not to work.[ there are many untrained,uneducated people on public assistance who would love to learn a trade]. If more Americans were working maybe they could afford these houses. It's a fact that people will find other ways to make money. sometimes, not legally which increases the crime rate. I could say more but I hope you see my point. Think about it.

Another

Yes, but of course.

The harm of them, is greater than the good.

http://www.theconservativevoice.com/article/30115.html

Zelie

The only reason that deporting illegal aliens would hurt the economy would be the cost of such an impossibly huge operation. Unfortunately at this point, it is a more idealistic than realistic solution.
Unlike many Americans living in their ivory towers of liberal idealism, I have seen the devastation caused by these invaders. They have caused countless working class americans to lose their jobs. Who do you think used to build houses, work in delis, do landscaping, clean houses, among other things?? The ONLY reason Americans aren't doing much of that anymore is because they CAN'T compete with illegal wages! They have to charge a reasonable price to SURVIVE. And thats only the job market. I'm not even going into the whole rent increase thing. How they all get to live twenty to a house so we can't afford to live ANYWHERE anymore.
The bottom line is that illegal aliens are turning America into a Third World country. The working class where I live many other areas of this country are being forced out of their home towns to simply be able to survive. What many out-of -touch and privileged citizens see as good for this country in the short term, is clearly going to cause long-term devastation. I believe it is too late. The only hope is securing the border for real, cracking down on employers, and taking away ALL incentives for coming to this country.

Lori K

Yes, definitely. If we truly need more immigrant workers, we can raise the number of legal work visas issued. Illegal alien workers DO work for cheaper and as a result depress wages. They are a huge contributing factor to our current economic woes.

Report and deport.
***edit***
Your last argument was lame. The net annual cost of immigration has been estimated at between $67 and $87 billion a year. I'd pay a few million to get rid of them.

Marine5

YES I DO...
Think they should all start heady back to their Home Countries...NOW !!!!

fatamorrighan

yes, deport them all!

EB3

YES,YES,YES, and 99.9% of them if you look around california it is looking more and more like a third world country

M B

Yes, deport.

So let me get this straight, you think that people who are paid minimum wage which is approximately $6396 annually, some how manage to make a huge dent in the economy. Lets do some math shall we?

Lets assume all taxes are paid by an illegal and not just social security and medicare which is common. The breakdown would be as follows:

Salary $6396 annually (some states will be a higher some lower)
SS $396.55 annually
Med $92.74 annually
Fed $984 annually
State (depends on state)

Grand total of $1473.85 taxes annually, how much do you think the cost of the medical services they receive for free total? or maybe education for their children, food and housing assistance not to mention the cost of prison for those who commit crimes? Think about it, were loosing money on these people, allowing our laws to be ignored and overcrowding the school systems for citizen children. One single trip to the doctor would eat up their entire amount of taxes paid for the year and probably many a year to come considering the current cost of health care. We are loosing money - no way around the fact.

*All the taxes were based on the fact that they choose zero dependents, most will claim dependents which will greatly lower the total taxes paid.

http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p15.pdf

67 Bronco

Yes they are here illegal what exactly don't you understand. Believe me don't think for one minute they give more than they take.

Bobby Ray

NO!
True that it will hurt the economy! why do you think they created that little thing called Amnesty? they first pass laws to get rid of them, and then......Hey! why isn't the economy doing as well as it was? why?........because they contribute billions to this economy, and without them, there's billions not coming in any more. It's not just the work that they do, it's the spending that they do to. There's a whole lot of cars, cloths, food and electronics that they buy.

kvnsnz14

no they should not

an illegal alien finishes highschool and cant get college and gets deported
thats a big waste of money when he could have recieved a college education and pay back everything he took through the taxes he would have to pay
and since he went to college he wouldnt have a low paying job

dirtyharry

we need the law abiding and hard working with a strong values to stay. the rest we kick out along with our ungrateful citizens.

Larry M

www.mybordersolution.com

this is what needs to be done..

macdyver60

I bet the Native Americans wish they had!

Memememme

It would definitely hurt their economy. Many states that passed anti-illegal aliens laws like in Arizona feel it backfired and hurt their economy. It's costing them billions $$. See below.

http://rds.yahoo.com/_ylt=A0oGkyHHNjtI6msBxX5XNyoA;_ylu=X3oDMTEyZ2d0YWQzBHNlYwNzcgRwb3MDMQRjb2xvA3NrMQR2dGlkA0gxMjhfODE-/SIG=120prrhi5/EXP=1211926599/**http%3a//www.youtube.com/watch%3fv=es3hq0XM-cw

katiebee993

no i think that everybody deserves a chance to be free i agree that illegal aliens should not be allowed in cause we need to keep some sort of order but i think that the immigration system definitely needs some reformation!

Dustin B

If our gov. was really worried don't you think they would be trying to help raise the standard of living in Mexico ? Instead we get to listen to all of the ways that they MIGHT be able to slow the illegals down. Help them gain the resources to stay at home and be able to provide for their families other than American owned sweet shops and a government that is more corrupt than the mob. Our economy is definitely effected by illegals ,every year millions maybe billions of dollars are collected by the IRS from immigrants that are afraid to file due to deportation. So maybe the real problem is the U.S. has a vested interest in them coming here . We're over seas trying to rebuild a gov. for a people whom don't want us there and we cant take care of our own neighbors that would give their lives to have what most take for granted.

Deliahh

If all illegal aliens were deported, it would hurt the economy sooo bad!, Everything would all bad, high classed along with middle class would not want to do their jobs, or say they will not even pick fruits for us. Im not saying we are lazy but they are so much help to eve cmmunity. I know some myself, and they are very lovely people. They shouldnt get deported but should be helped to stay here legally. That would be Awesome.

lil_weezy20006

you dont have enough man power to deport all the illegal immigrants, therefore you also cant generalize and profile cause theres bad ones and people who come here to work the economy will be torn up in ways you cant imagine

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: