Should all non-Native Americans be deported from the U.S.?

left the forum

No. I am a native American, born here and SOME people want me to be deported because I disagree with them. I believe in a reform to fix the immigration problem in an intelligent manner while they believe in killing and hate.
So, again, I think that they should not be deported.

Penny

Me Navajo, husband Cherokee. I guess we get to stay.

Destrada

Could you elaborate a bit? Are you asking whether everyon who is an immigrant, or offspring of immigrants all be sent away? That Only Native American Indians be allowed in the U.S? Can you tell I'm laughing out loud? Please give more details, or I'll have to say your're crazy, ( in a fun and humorous way)

Clairey

And put them where???
madagascar is too small.

Bob T

no,

Yak Rider

Everyone born in the United States is a native American.

Lovely girl <3

Nope. America is a melting pot. The only reason people make a big deal about immigrants is when they come over illegally and take all our jobs! Wouldn't you be upset about that?

sandy121648149

There are only Americans and illegal aliens.

solarianus

That's just silly. There is no valid reason for kicking out some immigrant that came here legally 50 years ago. According to the census bureau, 10.4% of Americans are not native (i.e. foreign born). Do you have any idea what it would do to the country if they left all at once? First you have to come up with the money to ship 30 million people and their property all around the world. I'm interested on where you think we'd get that much money. Now we would have to deal with all the social, economic, political, and logistical repercussions from kicking out quite a few members of our government, kicking out many members of our military, and sending so many of our teachers, doctors, nurses, auto mechanics, technicians, service providers, etc.

Respect for American law would be further eroded when you show that clearly that it doesn't really apply to the government, only its' subjects *ahem* citizens.

That is even without all the unrest created when you get a few MILLION people that are here perfectly legally and have no intention of being kicked out.....not to mention the millions of friends and family members of said people that have no intention of letting anybody force them out.

Amustapha

Why should those Siberians have the run of the place? There was another culture before the 'Native' Americans, you know.

Evie B

No, this is just stupid. Would you include yourself in being deported? Would you be willing to self deport to give anyone without American Indian blood an example to follow. No we are all Citizens of America now and any talk like this is just stupid!

Docar; I agree she is a racist, but you do not make your post based on facts. There have been people in the Americas for over 50,000 years. This is fact and that date predates the population of the European Continent by several thousand years. The assumption that we came to this continent on a land ice bridge 13,000-14,000 years ago has been debunked for a long time now.

RayIsBack

I have never met an American Indian who likes the term ''native'' and i live next to the Cherokee reservation so running deer or flying dove time to find a new cause to try and make yourself look cool They also think your silly if you claim to have Indian blood and are white as the driven snow
Actually blacks have more claim to Cherokee blood than white as on the trail of tears there were almost 2000 black slaves as these people don't do women's work [work the fields] and still don't to this day barking dog

Anko

let me think..............................UH......
NO!!!!!!
as soon as you get all of your casinos off westhampton!!!

freebienutter

Hell no the rest of the world could not take that amount of millions back to the small spaces they originally came from.

MidnightRose DG

No, unless they have had guns on airplanes or they are terrorists! LOL!

White House Watching

If you mean illegals then YES. If you mean legal people that have come here legally and follow the rules and become an American Citizen then NO. Immigrants are welcome the are valuable. Illegals are law breakers and do not respect the laws and are not wanted.

Oh, golly!

Yes, as long as you mean all pre-Columbus immigrants, i.e. those who are not Sioux, Apache, Cheyennne, Cherokee, Abenakis, Accochannock, Alabama Coushatta, Abanki, Alaska Natives, Arapaho , Arikara, Assiniboine, Blackfeet,
Caddo, Carrier, Catawba, Cayuga , Cheyenne, Chickasaw,
Chicora, Chilcotin, Chippewa, Chippewa Cree, Chitimacha,
Chocataw, Chumash, Coharie, Comanche , Costanoan, Cowlitz, Cree, Creek, Crow, Dakota, Delaware, Dene,
Edisto, Essellen, Goshute, Gros Ventree, Gwitch'In , Haida, Haliwa-Sponi, Hidatsa, Ho Chunk, Hohokam, Hopi, Houma, Hupa, Huron, Illinois, Innu , Inuit, Inupiaq, Iowa, Iroquois, Kalispel, Kaw, Kiowa, Klallam, Klamath, Kootenai, Lakota, Lumbee,
Maidu, Makah, Mandan, Mattaponi, Meherrin, Menominee , Metis, Miami, Mingo, Miwok, Mohawk , Mohegan, Monacan, Montaucketts, Munsee Delaware , Nansemond, Navaho, Nez Perce, Nisga'a, Nootka, Ohlone, Ojibwe, Omaha, Oneida, Onondaga, Osage , Ottawa,
Paiute, Pamunkey, Pawnee, Peoria , Pequot, Pima, Potawatomi, Powhatan, Pueblo, Quapaw, Quinault, Ramapough.

May have missed some out. Most emigrated long ago from NE Asia.

BTW, compared with Australia, New Zealand, China, Canada, Brazil, Columbia, Chile, etc., the USA has treated its indigenous people most terribly. It would be called genocide by all but the americans. Until recently, the natives were still used for target practice. They still have very little rights over their tribal lands, and their culture is all but completely destroyed. So it's completely incongruous to find groups in the US campaigning for rights of indigenous people elsewhere when right at their doorsteps the original American are languishing and drowning in fire-water and surfeit of white thrash.

Micky....the resurrection

As a native American(I'm from here so I'm native) of European descent, I have no problem with non natives coming here as long as they do so legally and have loyalty to this country.

Dirty Martini

If you aren't born here, you aren't a native. But if you are here legally you can stay. And if you were born here, you can stay too.

Give up the "native" American line tonite sweetie. In case you haven't heard--its 2009. Let's live in today, shall we.

Ricky ng

You can do it, but can you tell me how ? you are talking about million and million of people my dear.
or maybe you can learn from British immigration dept(The u.k. Border agency).They are Best of Deport people.believe me !!

Enemy

Eheh

Mrs Bewick

Wouldn't it be grand if we could put the world back to how it was 400 years ago and start again. Imagine how much better we could make it with hindsight.

musicman812

How are you going to run your casino?
=====================================
So it's apparent when somebody asks a retarded question we're too PC to make them regret asking it? 6 thumbs down because my answer broke some bleeding hearts. :(

DOCAR

RACIST! Define "native American". Immigrants from Asia?

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: