Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Should illegals be granted amnesty if they join the military?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should illegals be granted amnesty if they join the military?

And fufiul at least a couple years of service. The more you serve the faster you gain citizenship.
Additional Details
Obviosly if they qualify.


    




sobriquet
What if al quaida slipped through our borders and joined the military?


mdk
Not a bad idea.The military has traditionally rewarded those who have honorably served, VA benefits, GI bill, so, why not citizernship?


Beelzebub
Rating
Yes if your willing to die for this country you should have the right to live, sleep, eat and **** here too!!


Yaktivistdotcom
Rating
Sounds fair to me. If someone is willing to defend the country, they have earned their citizenship.


FRAGINAL-NOYPI
Illegals wanting to be soldiers must be legalized because they will be sacrificing their lives for the country. However, they must first take their allegiance and renounce their former country.


seeking speaker
This sounds like a good option to me if totally on a volunteer basis. Of course, for their safety and the safety of those around them, they would need a working level of English first.


celtic_saltire
YES.


cdmillstx
Illegal aliens should not be allowed in the military (or in any government job, for that matter) in the first place.


cfoster001
No. I think that if this Immigration Reform Bill is passed, it will be major chaos in this world. I really think that Congress is breaking America's laws and I am so disappointed with our leaders wanting "ILLEGALS" to remain in our country. It means that our leaders are actually siding with people who break the laws of our country. They might as well let everyone in our jails and prisons out!

People, it is time to stand up for what is right. Wake up America!!!


borreguini01
Rating
just for yor information, the army has decieved hispanic people ofering citizenship to them and their families if they join the army. they never got anything from the army.

besides that i saw it by myself. I was working at a fast food restaurant as a cashier when two officers came in. I asked them if I could help them. it was a man and a womman. the guy, didn;t answered me. he was looking to my co-workers. he talked to one of them ( illegal )and said. Ă¿ou would be a good soldier"
what was he thinking about???
Americans don't want hispanic people coming to this country but they can recruit them to send them to die???


sara b
Rating
ironic question, because a not insubstantial part of the force in Iraq is already being "outsourced" to private militias from latin america (Peru and Columbia).

Under the new immigration bill, this is one of the requirements they want to put on high school/college students who are here illegally but came before they were 14. They would be required to serve 4 years and be honorably discharged, then they would be on the "fast track" to citizenship. Also it would help the army meet its recruitment goals which right now it's failing to meet.

As for letting any illegal immigrant join the military...lolol..my husband is illegal and he did ROTC in the MEXICAN army. There is a 6-month ROTC stint that is required of all young men in Mexico. So...where would their loyalties really lie??


AveGirl
Rating
Definately, that would be better than straight out rewarding a criminal for a crime.

I think for some of the lighter crimes with regular citizens as well, this would work.

Gets prisoners out and rehabilitated, also solves the illegal immigration problem.


Yak Rider
No.


Anne
Rating
no, if would only bring more into this country


AD
A.S.E. your stupid they dont get highly educated and wealthy ppl.. they go to the hood and draft ppl here. hum i wonder why.... wtf is up with that


Brand X
If that's what it takes for you to accept amnesty, I'm willing to compromise


jimbo
Rating
I do not want to be in a fox hole with a law breaker!!


pomona909rocks
Rating
first u say us to leave....but then when u guys come crying to us to join the army and we give u amnesty!!

HEy man!! FUK U


pepsi
Rating
Yes im sure Osma would like amnesty


Jacob W
Negative. Illegals should be deported at once if they returned the should be jailed and then banned for good.

There are plenty of fine legal immigrants who are already serving. If you ask me if military service with a good record should be a shortcut to citizenship I would be all for that.


.


Mike
Heck no. I don't want our own army run by illegals. It's bad enough that half our country is.


Cat's Eye
Rating
No. The military only takes highly educated, highly trained people, so they wouldn't qualify anyway.

Besides, amnesty doesn't require they become citizens.


se ñorita glitterbabeprincess
Rating
WE ARE NOT GOING TO KILL OURSELVES, TO DEFEND GRINGOS!!!! WHY DON'T YOU GRINGOS GO FIGHT THE WAR. YOU SHOULD DEFEND YOUR PEOPLE.

PROUD TO BE MEXICAN!!!!!


rabidliberal
I think it is a good idea. I also think that any one granted amnesty should be required to register for the draft.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Where is everyone from?
will give out best answer =) make me entratained and u will get it =)...


 What is wrong with immagration?
lets remember immagration built this country....


 How Do I Migrate To England?
i am a student from the caribbean going to england to do a law degree. after i would like to live and work there. how do i go about doing this? whats the processes?...


 How do you guys feel about people that think only whites should live in america?
Its pretty much an open question.
Additional Details
by the way im not just talking about whats been going on lately but also neo-nazis and white supremacists. all those people....


 What is wrong with mexicans?
people always talk down about them. what in the world is wrong with them?
Additional Details
for the people who say that mexicans bring diseases and all that other sh!t is pissing me off....


 My family want move to england?
i move england from afghanistan and claim asylum in 2005, i not get asylum, i stay here because i think it easy ride, you get nice car, nice house, benefits etc, you english treat us like kings, ...


 Im mexican. how can i deal with racists at my skewl?
i have mexican blood, but was born in compton. there are random people at skewl that pick on me cuz im mexican theyll say comments and racial slurs. wats a good way of gettin back at them?/ i dont ...


 Was this country built by immigrants?
And if so why are we so quick to forget it?
Additional Details
I think this is a good question. Many illegal immigrant sympathizers argue that this country was built on the backs of ILLEG...


 If the resolution to deport around 4000000 Mexicans were enforceable, how should Mexico prepare to receive'em
...


 Are they really going to deport ?????????
how can they deport 12 million people??????...


 How do we solve homelessness?
...


 Are Illegals Helping Stimulate our economy?
I meen by illegals being here are they keeping down wages? Or are they keeping America competitve by keeping the Wages low and Jobs in the U.S?
Additional Details
yars323 are you willing ...


 Do you think the US Government should invest some billion dollars to improve Public Education in Mexico?
So All the Undocumented can understand the Anti-Immigrannts laws that you talk on and about, on and on.
We don't need open or closed borders! We just need a smart border....


 Do immigrants illegally in the U.S. have any regard for the American way of life?
lately i have seen a lot media coverage on the Criminal acts of illegals. They are many times caught by law officials in many cases released to continue breaking the law. I find it Ironic,. that a ...


 Should we give back part of the US to Mexico?
I keep hearing about how we stole the southwest and CA from poor ole Mexico, and that by rights they deserve to be in this country as a result. Therefore I have two questions to resolve, the first ...


 Instead of illegal aliens, should we call them uninvited guests?
or Guest P...


 Will a wall on the border reduce immigration?
The UK is surrounded by water yet we still have hundreds of thousands of immigrants coming into this tiny country each year.
I think the wall is just a money making scheme for large US ...


 Should California become a state of the country Mexico again?
If there was a vote for the people of California to vote that California be part of the U.S., Mexico, or even a seperate country from both mexico and the U.S. what would your vote be....


 Asylum seekers - your view?
plz reply truthfully and give your view best thought out reply will win best ...


 I vanna live the UK please help please scape me from the UK?
I don't feel I am a human no more it just doesn't feel right to be here????????????????????...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024