Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Should kids of illegal aliens who are here thru no fault of their own qualify for in-state college tuition?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should kids of illegal aliens who are here thru no fault of their own qualify for in-state college tuition?

Think about U.S. citizens in other states who don't get the "in-state" college tuition rate of a neighbor state, yet a non-U.S. citizen kid of an illegal alien would qualify in many states.

However, also think about the kid of an illegal alien who has been here since they were 1 (or 5, or 7) and are now 16/17 and applying to get into college. It wasn't their fault; it was their parents fault. Perhaps we should ensure they get legal status in a timely manner?

We can't send them back at that age. Perhaps, in the end, that is the solution: pick a timeframe (for example, 3 years) and say, "If the Federal (U.S.) Government can't enforce its own rules, these people -- once found -- need to prove English proficiency and knowledge of the Constitution (same as any other applicant) to obtain legal status.

Of course, improving federal enforcement will go a long way toward alleviating all these predicaments.


    




slap the liars
Dude....don't be a panzy a s s. It is not your fault that those little people are here.
It is their lazy, good for nothing, put themselves BEFORE their own children, lame brain, leach as s, pole smokin aliens.

Deport them ALL!

Lets start sending the F*%K'N message.....come here legally or get the F@#K out.

Don't blame yourself blame the parents....it is what it is.


Turtles are HAWT
How about this:

Illegal is illegal. The children may not have had a choice, but wouldn't it be better to teach those kids that there are consequences to breaking the LAW, and gently send them (and mommy and daddy) back to the parents' original country? This would deter a LOT of the incentives, plus it might teach those kids a little bit about respect, something they obviously won't ever learn from their criminal parents. Besides, how do YOU feel about working 5 months a year just to pay your taxes, while 75% of that money goes to support those "children." I have a sob story for you if you are so inclined ...


cool.panamania
No,American kids should have first priority to these benefits.


Joel W
Rating
NO!

Just because those folks evaded the law for many years, they are not entitled to benefit from their crime. Futher, their parents are their legal guardians, and are responsiable for the crime they committed. Their parents committed a crime in their childs name.

To everyone.. there is not any way in the world those folks could be here without using a fake identification. None. That is a felony offense. And if they do have one, there is nothing in the world to stop them from having many I.D.'s, and some very decidedly do. and when they do have multipul identifications, they may well have tapped into multipul social services accounts in more than one state.

We will not know what is happening in this process until we have the real I.D. on line and working. States are actively trying to stop that, and I hope they get burned trying to stop it. But one way or another, I, personally, want the laws enforced, and the criminals in our country that wilfully broke the law... punished. And I want Mexico out of our national affairs in a very serious way.


Jeff F
Rating
No. It's not the fault of the citizens of the US either. It's their PARENTS fault. Paying for their own responsibility and that of their parents. They don't belong in our public schools at all.They shouldn't even be taking spots in our public institutions that should be filled by citizens of this country.


Doc
Rating
Illegal is Illegal! If the family came into the United States illegally then no matter how many days, months or years they have been in our country they are taking our U.S. citizen taxpayer employment, schools, social welfare and hospital services illegally. Over 20 million illegals are not what America needs. Their own country should provide what they come to our soil for. Why doesn't the U.S. help those countries provide for their own so they will have no need to come here against our laws of immigration.


Boomer Wisdom
Sure, as long as we invoice the parent nation for the services rendered to their citizens. This would cover medical, legal, and prison expenses, in addition to the added educational services.

With a mark-up, of course.


wendy.bryan
Rating
I don't think that being born here of illegal immigrants should automatically qualify one for citizenship. in many other countries the minor children of illegals are just as illegal as their parents. when they reach 18 (if this is the minimum age) they can apply for citizenship like every one else.


the absolutely vague fragi-nopie
Rating
So in your mind the children of parents who break the law should be rewarded with extra privledges that citizens get.


momoffour
No, kids of illegal aliens should not be able to qualify for in-state college tuition. They are also illegal. Maybe it's not because of something they did, but they need to understand the consequences of their parents' actions. I'm not saying that we should send them back. I'm just saying that they should be required to go through the process of becoming legal that their parents refused to do. If kids of illegals want to become citizens, they should be able to. But they should not be rewarded for their parents' crime.


lone wolfe
Rating
NO And they should not become citizens.We should complain to our Representatives about this.


NSA
Kids of the upper middle class and the wealthy parents who are citizens do not qualify for these tution programs. Kids of non-citizens should not qualify.

The children of illegal aliens upon reaching the age of 18, are old enough to know that they need to apply for citizenship.


Green is the new RED!
Rating
No they shouldn't get free college tuition or anything else. American kids should be getting that assistance!


gomanyes562
Rating
I agree with that. It's not like the feds are going to deport them anytime soon, so might as well put them through college so they can do something productive while they're here.


Mom of 2
Children of illegals should receive NO benefits of any kind simply by being born here. They need to go back to their parents homeland along with the parents.


Dirty Martini
No they should not. Anything we do that incentivizes this illegal behavior will just encourage it. Any parent would risk something that incentivizes their children. But if their children don't benefit perhaps they'll be less likely to commit the crime.

The children of our servicemen and women don't get in state tution when they are transferred from base to base and haven't been in a state long enough to qualify for residency. That is a travesty in my opinion.

Yes we should let the children of criminals qualify?

NO, I say, HE11 NO!


Stevie
if they are old enough to go to college, they are old enough to apply for citizenship. if they do that and obtain citizenship, their parents can live with them legally.


Alwaysright
Rating
i think if they haven't been in trouble with the law they should be able to get a student visa to finish their studies, then have a chance at getting legal status as the wouldn't be a burden to the US after being in college.i feel for those who are now paying for their parents mistakes.and as for our own kids they have chances at numerous scholarships and grants if they apply themselves in school.our kids simply don't care anymore.they think in the here and now instead of their future.


laura_9090mi
I'm sure I will get plenty of boos for this one, but what kind of people have we become when we have no compassion for others? I am not sure if they should qualify for in state tuition immediately, but I do believe there should be a way they could become citizens especially if they were born here.

My other issue is this name calling of illegals. I lived in SW Texas for a while and met and worked with quite a few illegals. I have to tell you, you who think they are lazy are misinformed. I have watched them work sun up to sun down in blazing hot weather in the fields for so little money. I would like to see any of you who made the judgmental comments work your butts off like these people do. Most of them are trying to make a better life for their children...just like you are if you have children.

The other thing I think Americans forget is that your ancestors came here ...pretty much the same way...illegally! They came and stole things they had no right to (which is pretty much what you accuse them of). Maybe you all should walk in their shoes before you judge them so harshly.

By the way, how many of the nasty posts have been by so called christians? I am not, and I have more compassion than you have ever thought of!
Shame on all of you!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 This is why ALL immigrants should be given a fair chance in this country.....?
"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the ...


 So, is the AMERICAN Government going to construct the "Great Wall of China" along the border with MEXICO?
And what do Mexicans think about this?...


 Why are so many unaware that many mexicans have never crossed over the border and that the border crossed them
since 1600's .The American states of CA,AZ,NM,TX were once part of the mexican government and the USA harrased Mexico to sell it for 2 cents an acre but the people could stay.
Then they ...


 Could Yahoo please moderate this board?
I can't tell who runs it anymore. It seems to be somewhere between board trolls, the KKK, and delinquent teens....


 Do you think that the time has come to form "STATE MILITIAS" In accordance with our CONSTITUTIONAL right
as citizens to protect against INVASION? http://www.independentam Details
Don C thanks for your correct ...


 Did you know that illegal "immigrants" and all non citizens can vote in California?
It's true. Although they are technically not allowed to, they do it anyway.

In California, there is no ID requirement to register to vote. You may vote by mail and there will be no ...


 Why do liberals, have this idea of a dream world ?
Liberals have this way out idea, of a world where everyone loves everyone, a world where no one wants to harm anyone. Do they not understand, that we never have had this kind of a world, and never ...


 Is it time to shut the door?
I Quote from a Yahoo news story:
Eleven Pakistani nationals, ten of whom hold student visas, and one UK-born Briton are being questioned at various locations in the UK.
Prime Minister G...


 Why does a bunch of racists anti-immigrants want to impose their will to the American people?
The American people want a comprehensive immigration reform....


 How does the black community feel about Mexican immigration?

Additional Details
Do you think it will help or harm your community?...


 Why do most people always make the mistake that immigrants are here to pick fruits or do menial job?
i know so may immigrant who want to be president.
Additional Details
even if they cant be president, may want to go to capitol Hill, become governors, enterpreneurs, i know of am ...


 Okay, who's ready for a real perplexing question?
Ok you know how they say the earth is nearly3/4 water right. Now check this out, I heard it on a Can-I-Bus cd. If you have a glass of water and put 3 cubes of ice in it, you will see the water ...


 Shall we all join the bmp???????? i just have! lets keep it reall?
...


 Does the illegal immigration crisis scare you?
http://www.newsmax.com/n
I have no problem with those law abiding immigrants.

This is a terrible ...


 The Death of England R.I.P.?

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/
"England Rest In Peace"

Gobbled up by the Euro Monster and fed to the vultures. These people don't give a ...


 Question for Christians who are against undocumented workers.?
Why don't you turn the other cheek? If illegals are taking you jobs and benefits, why don't you give them your coat also?

Luke 6:29
Additional Details
4 fake C...


 I have a child over 18 years, how can my child legally prove they are still dependent on me?
...


 What do you think about the mexican goverment?
...


 Do you think it is unfair to expect immigrants to feel British if we Brits always feel the need to refer?
to them as Asian, Polish, Cossovan etc. How can we expect them to when we, oursellves, always think of them as foreigners, no matter how long they have lived in this country and how well they have ...


 Can you read the stats?
http://www.csmonitor.com Already, 1 in 5 US doctors is foreign born, as are 2 in 5 medical scientists, 1 in 5 computer specialists, 1 in 6 people in engineering or ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034