Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Should someone who disapproves of illegal aliens be considered a racist?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should someone who disapproves of illegal aliens be considered a racist?

I have my opinion, but I want to know the opinions of others.


    




Marty K
No, it's a lie used as an excuse and a distraction.


e fitz
no, cuz not all illegal aliens are of a different race than you.

e.g - if you are white, some illegals are white too (european adn such)


gsschulte
Rating
how is that racist? i dont like criminals so it really doesnt matter what color they are or where they are from.


Leogirl0804
No it does not. What it makes me is a law abiding citizen who respects the laws of her country.


captain_madden
Absilutely not.


Jen G
Rating
No


♥austingirl♥
No, not at all...because I sure don't consider myself a racist, just a defender of my country. Illegals drive down pay for all Americans while corporation's profits are in the billions...it has nothing to do with race. If a massive influx of white Canadians were sneaking in and sapping our economy I would feel the same way!!


?
Rating
No, only when they make actuall racial remarks.


FREAKZILLA
Rating
yes , last night a guy broke in to the convience store down the road , then a man called him a thief , this is also considered racist


yo soy boriqua
No but I think the Mexicans are asking for poeple to turn racist. As it was quoted in the last question the darker the skin the more pity they want.. uhh let me think about it. NO!!!


DAR
Rating
Only if in fact they are racist.

Being against illegal alians doesn't make you a racist, but it isn't mutually exclusive of being one, either.


amish_renegade
No it has nothing to do with race, it's about federal law. It's not racist it's a federal crime..........


fscarberry20
Rating
Illegal aliens are not determined by their race, but by their countries. So no, its not racist.


_Kraygh_
To disapprove of someone breaking the law?

Racist?

The two aren't related...


Shutzie
Rating
absolutely not. theyre breaking the law. if you were discriminatory towards legal ethinicities that live here, then there would be a problem


Avery
Rating
Only if the main reason is that they don't like Mexicans. In which case, they'd disapprove of all Mexicans and probably all Hispanics.


?
Rating
no,,, someone who hires illegals should be considered un-American,,,,Bush makes a mockery of our nations laws


Bob
no it has nothing to do with race. it has to do with braking the law


Chris J
No, illegal immigration is about respecting our laws not race. Illegals come in all races.


hm10s4
I have noted that everyone who responded here has referred to the Mexican nationals...This question says nothing about one race or another it simply states a question about all illegal aliens.....
The answer to this question is NO. It is not a racist comment. It has to do with federal law and the people who break it. As every other country, we have an immigration policy, which all aliens are required to go by. It has been this way since the beginning of our country.


el_oso_candeloso
nope not at all!


yars232c
"We call things racism just to get attention. We reduce complicated problems to racism, not because it is racism, but because it works." - Alfredo Gutierrez, political consultant, as quoted by Richard de Uriarte, The Phoenix Gazette, March 14, 1992 (quoted in The ProEnglish Advocate, 1st quarter, 2002)


?
no way


IKnowAll
they are a fine american


Mr Wolf
No.. but let them speak without racism too...


pong_bing_ping
No, but on the contrary. If you approve of illegal aliens and you are the same race of the alien , then you are a racist.


?
What is racist about not wanting people to come to your country illegally and take advantage of our country? Why would that be racist? I'm not sure most people know what the meaning of racism is. If I was on here shouting "F'in beaners!" That would be racist...


ADF
Rating
It depends upon what he bases his disapproval on....if it is based on race then yes. If it is truly based on the opinion of nationality, and it holds true for Europeans, Canadians, Hispanic, African, Asian across the board, then no.


xcelix
Rating
Not necessarily, but people posting questions specifically meaning Mexicans, are racist.


TRUTHSEEKER
calling some one illegal is not racist. calling them aliens sounds a little racist. but that's my opinion.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Remenber when slavery used to be legal ??
Laws are not always justice and right.

Everything that Hitler did in Germany was ...


 Who would support sending illegal immigrants in the U.S. on a trip to England?
...


 Do you think the children of illegals should share their parents legal status?
I just think coming here and popping out babies is a sorry way to get citizenship.

This should be outlawed....


 The Media keeps saying most Americans are for amnesty , I don't believe it. quick poll?
Let me know what you think. I am not racist and should never even have to say this. Hispanic americans are welcome here. I just dont think the average american is for just giving rewards to law ...


 We want a bigger house"...( for free )...?
i saw an article in a newspaper that enraged me to such a degree that i nearly choked on my sandwhich, i was spittin crumbs of anger i can tell you .....The article concerned was a photograph of of ...


 Why do ILLEGALS feel that THEY are any more?
deserving than the poor people in THIS country who are LEGAL Americans???? If ANYONE is entitled to utilize our welfare system, it is LEGAL Americans!!!!!! NOT criminal lawbreaking foreigners!!!!!!<...


 I heard some states allow immigrants to go to colleges and issue driver licences. Can any one name those? Thx
...


 What Do You Think Should Happen To Asylum Seekers Within the UK?
Everyone has an opinion.....Send them back? Let them stay? They get more than UK citizens? Filling in the unemployment gap? Raping the system?

What do you think?
Additional Details


 What do you Americans think of the immigrants of every species?
Do you think they should stay in their countries? And do you think the ones that are here should get out,and go back to where they came from?Why?...


 I Want To Escape From The USA and Move To a Better Country?
According to independent studies that factor in a number of aspects such as infrastructure, incomes, healthcare, poverty, crime, education, personal liberties, life expectancies, demographics, etc. ...


 Do you think most of people try to hide their racism to mexicans, with this "illegal immigration" thing?
...


 How much has your area changed?
http://www.telegraph.co. Details
Sydney are you sure you are not ...


 OMG, An Illegal Mexican............?
ok now that I have your attention let me start my question

Most people seem to agree that Mexico's government is corrupt and is keeping its poor, poor. That being why mexicans flee ...


 Why don't the Minutemen just get day jobs?
...


 For anti immigration xenophobes:are your kids learning the fine art of fruit and vegetable picking?
...


 By hook or by crook i have to go to the dream country uk...anyone can help me?
...


 What do you think about all the illegal immigrants in the USA?
I have seen a lot of people in this country who are illegal. Most of them are from Mexico. But what is your viewpoint about these people? Do they deserve a certain legal right in this country? D...


 How many illegals does George W Bush has, working on his ranch?
The way Bush and Ted Kennedy stick up for illegals it seems like they are the main employers of illegals in the country,many wealthy individuals in this country have been caught using illegals to ...


 Congress passed the border fence bill, what do you think about it?
...


 Have any of you noticed that I now have an......?
imposter?????...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034