Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Should spanish and english become the oficial languages in america?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should spanish and english become the oficial languages in america?



    




MSG
The official language should be English only, those who don't want to speak English would be welcome to go home to a country that speaks whatever they wish.


labgirl
Rating
No. I'm 27 and don't know spanish and do not plan on learning. This is America. If your coming to live in our country, then learn the damn language.


i like tacobell
AS MUCH AS SWAHILI SHOULD


JUSTME
Rating
What the heck.... English only.


jpzilveti
No way! As a Latin American, having grown up in NY, I think it's pathetic that some people move to a new country and don't even try to learn that language.

No excuses for being a "multi-cultural or ethnic society"


Shaz
English should be the only official langauge


U.
No.


whitelily
Rating
NO! WE ARE AN ENGLISH SPEAKING COUNTRY! YOU WANT TO SPEAK SPANISH, STAY IN YOUR OWN COUNTRY!


lakay
it should be English only, if you want to speak spanish or any other language- Go Home!!!


Voice of Liberty
NO, JUST ENGLISH. Why have two languages? This is rediculous. For the last 300 years, this country has had one dominant language - english, and we have functioned very well thank you very much. We are considered the great melting pot, but like it or not we do have one culture, we can be identified as a society by key things. Our language being one. If we take this language crap too far, we will split the country and it will destroy us. It will be less efficient for our economy to function, there is no room for communication error in our hospitals, and our children should be focusing on mathematics and science in school instead of wasting time teaching them another language only because the people that come to this country are too lazy to learn english.


chefsky2001
Are we in mexico? English! they chose to come here speak our language


Dreaming Free
Just English!!!! Go to Mexico for Spanish, Italy for Italian, China for Chinese get the picture?


DAR
English is the language we all use to speak to each other, and the language of our laws. There are over 200 languages spoken in this country. Spanish may be the predominant second language in the south, but there are equally Russian and Korean enclaves, and many areas of the east and mid west would more logically have a second language of Polish or German.

Why would Spanish be second?


Janet P
Rating
There is no need to have two. We have done well with one. I think adding a second would make it even harder for those wanting to immigrate legally into the US.

If we are picking a second one I would think German would be a better choice, they are many languages that are similar and a wider variety of immigrants would benefit from it.

Oh course if we are just worried about what most people are speaking then we have to make it Mandarin, more people in the world use that language then any other.


Steve
Official language entails more than just making it available to those who wish to use it. If Spanish or any other language were given the status of official language then people would be free to insist that:

All government publications be printed in that language;
Congressional sessions would have to allow speeches and voting to take place in either language;
Federal courts would have to be able to conduct business in either language;
Interstate commerce, including contracts, could be written in either language;
All federal government services would have to be available in either language, throughout the entire country.


SWMynx
Rating
No, English should be the agreed upon language.
If we need another language we should be learning Chinese or Arabic so we can more easily communicate with them before conflicts erupt.

In this country the inability to speak or understand English is a real hindrance, maybe not to the people who only speak Spanish between themselves, but to those of us who need to communicate with them on the job or understand some important issue they are discussing that involves our job or workplace.
"What is that burning smell in the room down the hall" in Spanish doesn't mean anything to me but I'd kinda like to know if we might have a fire!!


MH/Citizens Protecting Rights!
Rating
Absolutely NOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! This is the United States of America -- English is our Official Language and if you don't want to learn English -- get out!


Lakota
I speak a Native American language -- Lakota.
It is my first language. English is second. I will never recognize Enlgish as an official language, or Spanish either, but moving to a country and refusing to learn or recognize the language that the majority of it's citizens speak is idiotic.


Crazybird
No.....English only. If you don't want to then go south of the border where they do.


JessicaRabbit
Rating
English - YES!!!! Spanish - NO WAY!!!!!!!!!!

America has always been an English speaking country! It is insulting to include Spanish.


bobby u
Rating
NO! we have catered enough to the Spanish speaking people and they have gladly re payed us by giving us about 8 million illegals. LET THEM LEARN TO SPEAK ENGLISH!


iwannarevolt
Yeah, but in addition to spanish and english, we should be able to speak french as well. Those who oppose this and only want english as the sole language are part of the reason why we speak mainly one language...they're too damn arrogant to realize that we're the only country that doesn't speak more than one language...mainly as a result of their arrogance. The two as*faces known as MSG and dreaming are part of that arrogance(and lack of brains and compassion).


Yukaza
Rating
No . 85% of the people in the USA speak English.

Since the huge majority speak English. Why should Spanish even be considered ?


henke
Why are all the different native American languages not considered official languages in the US
Many people are saying that if you come here learn the language but how many of you speak a native american langage


c00kies
Rating
America doesn't have an official language. English is the primary language but is not exactly official. In my opinion, it doesn't really matter whether America declares one or two or even three official languages. If people want to learn a 2nd, or 3rd, or 4th....well, it is available everywhere. Also, I think knowing more languages is always better than knowing just one. I speak English, Spanish, Chinese, Cantonese, and little French and I'm proud of myself.


Dum E.
Rating
Totally yes. Like why would we not?


kick it
I believe its official languages should contain those of its direct neighbors. Canada as well as Mexico. As is done in Switzerland....For being such a small country it has 4 official languages...it works, and you can choose to learn whatever second language you want in school.


saulg21
This country is made up of so many ethnic cultures and many Americans speak a second language. Let sleeping dogs lie and forget about this "Official Language" crap.


Julie
Rating
No. all languages should be......


euroteacher0
Rating
Whether it's "an official language" or not, people need to accept that a whole lot of people speak Spanish in the U.S.

But, perhaps just to avoid all of the pain and agony that people will suffer if Spanish is declared an official language, perhaps no, we shouldn't have it as another official language.

However, I would recommend learning Spanish to anyone. If nothing else, it may help to ward off alzheimers when you're old and grey.


dVille
Rating
I believe that English will still dominate for a long time but Spanish is gaining inroads as their population increases.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why have we become anti-immigrant when we are all immigrants?
Seems strange that so called pure blood individuals who are of course not so, keep banging on about immigrants etc. People should read a history book!...


 Mexicans are always saying that they were here first.............?
No they were not....the native americans were. The mexicans as we know now were not even in Mexico first... the native Mexicans indios were. The Mexcians as we know now are all mixed blood . The ...


 Canada or america?
Hi please can any one give me genewine reasons about if canada is better than america or is america better than.canada.am confused.whcih 1 ...


 Should illegal immigrant workers get legal working status in the U.S.?
...


 Why are anti illegals trying so hard to prove they are not racist?

Additional Details
Some of you need to learn to read, I didn't say anti illegals were racist....


 Why the american hate the mexican?
...


 Would you be in favor of a Nationwide ID card program?
I would imagine that there would always be those people who forget theirs, lose them, etc.

I think that would cause headaches, but anything to help end illegal immigration....


 I'm sorry if my question offended you. Please will help tell me why it was offensive so it won't happen again
I just recieved a violation for inciting hatred and violence. I did not realise that my question did that .. So I make big apologies for all those I offended. It was not my intention to upset anyone.....


 United Statesians, you say to Mexicans "get out of America", but Mexico is in America, where should they go?
Europe? Africa? Asia?
Additional Details
Did I said to someone that I am an immigrant?...


 Why is it that every other country can come to america but mexicans can't?
people have a problem with illegal immigration, but what you dont realize is, there wouldnt be a problem if they didnt have to fight for the same opportunity that everybody else has. mexicans are ...


 Would it be a good idea for the US to do to Mexico what it has >?
done in Iraq?The more I think about it the better it sounds.A major problem in Mexico is infrastructure.Alot of places don't have running water or decent roads.Why don't we go help out M...


 Should we grant conditional legal status to undocumented workers with good moral character and 5 years in US?
...


 Why do minorities make up the majority of prison populations?
Yeah,you can call this panchas stupid question of the day....


 Why the minuteman are so coward, and why do they refuse to love Democracy and learn a second language?
What kind of retograde ideology to this project called minuteman have?
Who pays them?...


 What are your views on illegal immigration?
most people dont offer up opinion because they dont want to deal with it at all. I feel for the people who have to cross the border, but when they send non taxed money back to their country it doesnt ...


 If someone is against illegal immigration does that make them a racist?

Additional Details
I'm torn on this issue because how could someone not want someone else in there country without being racist. If it were white people coming to this country from ...


 Why are some people hating Mexicans so much but they love our food?
It dont make sense to me. if u hate us so much then stop eatin and buyin the things that we make....


 What state has benefited the most from having undocumented workers?

Additional Details
Wow, I'm getting honest answers, did the racists take Friday off from the site?...


 Whose with me?
well done to Nick Griffen and the BNP,today you won a victory for free ...


 What are the criteria for being British?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084