Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Should we make Spanish the official language in California or it's better to have two languages?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should we make Spanish the official language in California or it's better to have two languages?



    




LiVeStRoNg
Rating
It's better to have two languages spoken. It would be more conveinient if everyone knew how to speak english, but that's a long and hard task to teach many.


Gizmo
Rating
I'm still waiting for it to drop off into the ocean.........


Ancespiration
Rating
California is a state within the United States. The official language should be none other than ENGLISH.


princess_29_71
Hell no!!!!! California is in the U.S. no matter what mindless Mexicans say. ENGLISH ONLY


ed
Rating
Why not "Broken English" everywhere. It already exists in most areas. At the age of 7, I knew 6 languages.................................. broken English.


cheow069
NO--
BECAUSE WE ARE ENGLISH SPEAKING NATIVES HERE --AND ALL BECAUSE WE ARE THE MELTING POT DOESN'T MEAN WE SHOULD HAVE TO CHANGE OUR MAIN INGREDIENT (ENGLISH) BECAUSE WE HAVE ADDED EXTRA SERVING INTO THE DISH--BECAUSE IT'S SPANISH TODAY BUT IT MIGHT BE ARABIC(EXAMPLE) TOMORROW.


Just me
If anyone wants to live in this country they need to learn Engish.


famke
English of course! If you come to our country at least be able to communicate a bit and not make us conform to suit you.


dimps902000
The main language of any place should be the language of the people that are from that particular place...

For example...Spanish/Spain Haiti/French or Creole USA/English

The predominant culture should then be the second language if you have to choose.


innocence faded
No. The official language should be ENGLISH. My grandparents learned it when they came here (yes, even with working, they found the time to learn) so the immigrants of today can learn it too.


sharpshooter
The US don't have an official language. The Congress don't want to make English an official language, but want to make English into our "common" and "uniting" language.

Voters of California have already voted English the official language in California.

New Mexico is the only state that have English and Spanish as the official languages.


kimberly0627
Rating
If is part of a country where the mojority speak english it should also speak english


joeandhisguitar
Rating
Duh...It is better to have ONE official language which should be English.


Fluttery
I think we all need to come up with a new language for everyone in america.....spanglish.A combo of both,then everybodys happy.


js3971
Rating
Whatever language uses "Like Dude" a lot, that should be the official language of California.


Julie
That is one of the stupidest things I have ever heard. Look at the problems in Canada because of English and French. Where do you get your thinking from? This is the US and we speak English here.


DEPORT ILLEGAL ALIENS

ENGLISH ONLY IN AMERICA


DougBriggs
Rating
The official language in all of the United States is English and should stay English. The Constitution of the U.S. should decree that English is the natonal language everywhere in the nation.What modern nation has ever changed the "official" language in any subdivision to accomodate immigrants? Imagine immigrants lobbying for a change in the official language in any part of England! The Swiss, because Roman Switzerland was very long ago settled by Germans in this area, French in that area, Italians in yet another area, evolved therefore into a multilanguage nation -- not because of recent immigration, but as a result of historic immigration. The Constitution of Switzerland provides for the official languages to be unchanged from what they were in each area in 1848: "Title 1, Art. 4 National Languages -- The national languages are German, French, Italian, and Romansh."

Another reason English should be the "official languaage" in the U.S. is that it is the language most recognized across the globe. Every international airport in every country that is recognized by th International Congress of Aviation Organization must have an English speaking controller on duty during all hours of operation. Why? Because "international" means there will be pilots from scores of nations who would otherwise be unable to communicate with air traffic control if there was not ONE common language agreed upon, and it was English. Even when Russia was the USSR every Russian interntional airport was required to observe this rule. Newcomers must accommadate to the customs in place where they arrive, they can't bring and impress their customs on those already there.


Japal911
We are in America, we speak english.


elleroshelle
Rating
THIS IS AMERICA. THE LANGUAGE IS ENGLISH. I THINK IT SHOULD BE A REQUIREMENT TO LIVE IN THE U.S. THAT YOU SPEAK FLUENT ENGLISH. NO IFS ANDS OR BUTS ABOUT IT. I THINK PEOPLE SHOULD LEARN DIFFERENT LANGUAGES BECAUSE YOU MAY NEED IT BUT I THINK WE SHOULD ALL SPEAK ENGLISH. AND VICE VERSA IN OTHER COUNTRIES. IF WE GO THERE WE SHOUL D LEARN THEIR LANGUAGE


wannabebeachbum
Rating
Neither, California is still part of the U.S. Learn to speak English!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why do racists think other races are bad when their ignorance just reflects their stupidity?
...


 Against or for immigration?
I have a debate in my history class and I can’t decide if I should be against or for immigration in Canada. I'm an immigrant myself, I’m thinking about going against immigration. I don’t have ...


 8 out of the 10 FBI most wanted are illegal immigrants, does anyone think this is a problem?

Additional Details
Of course I think it is a problem. My question is what should be done about it and how come this isn't on any news channels or politicians debates?...


 Does it make you mad...?
When Spanish is written before English or any other random labels, does it make you mad? I mean i think there is 17% of people in America who speak Spanish frequently then like 80% English and the ...


 How about this middle ground?
Who would be willing (if put to a vote) to grant amnesty to illegal immigrants, but only to the illegal immigrants that fit this criteria: Have never received any type of welfare (excluding EMERGENCY...


 Do you agree or disagree?
Before any American gripes about someone from another country learning our language they should make sure they have a working knowledge of it themselves.
Do you agree or disagree?
A...


 If illegal immigrants really want to stage a protest to show how "valuable" they are to America, why don't..
they stage a strike? Don't cross the border and Don't labor in America for 2 full months. That will really show us. If they are so valuable to the United States, within 2 months we will ...


 Should the government deport illegal immigrants?
...


 If the hispanics wnat to be in America, then why are they waving Mexican flags? Let then wave them in Mexico.?
...


 So whats bein done about illegal immigration?
i only hear of "the wall" and a couple of deportations here and there....


 Racist or Realist?
Was Enoch Powell a racist or a realist, looking back to his rivers of blood speech, and what has come to pass???...


 Are you willing to sign this petition?
http://www.grassfire.org
This isn't right. This bozo was sneaking drugs into our country and of course he was an illegal from Mexico. These border ...


 Please help me to understand why they are singing the National Anthem in Spanish?

Additional Details
Singing the National Anthem in a language other than English is disrespectful, in my opinion. If you feel the need to sing it in your native language, maybe you need ...


 What would you do in their position?(serious answers PLEASE)?
I am not here to get foolish answers like "i'd shoot myself"

I'm being SERIOUS.

Ok, so in some cases the dirt poor that have to come illegally aren't ...


 Views on Immigrants prt 2. Ok the main complain is tax $ and illegas, are these actual facts?
OK the best responses I got from my,"Why do some Americans have wrong views on immigrants?" were tax $ and illegals or "criminals", but no hard facts. 1st, how can illegals pay ...


 Why don't Americans pick on Asians, or, would you start a whole underground railroad with blacks again?
I mean, since a lot of you are obviously racist....
Additional Details
I am just trying to point out that at some point, you hate a race, then you love it. Like calling Polish Polacks ...


 Did you know these interesting facts?
1. 40% of all workers in L.A. County (L.A. County has 10 million people) are working for cash and not paying taxes. This was because they are predominantly illegal immigrants, working without a green ...


 Please help me explain something to my hard-headed girlfriend?
She keeps insisting that "having papers" means to become a naturalized U.S. citizen and I keep telling her no it means having a temporary work I.D, work visa or green card. I know this ...


 Will Illegal immigration turn into a new Civil war?
What are your thoughts?...


 What do you think of iilegal immigrants in the US? and of the political reform to make them legal?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044