Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Since the Asian Gunman killed 32 in Virginia Tech rampage, should immigrants go through psychological testing?
Find answers to your legal question.





Since the Asian Gunman killed 32 in Virginia Tech rampage, should immigrants go through psychological testing?


Additional Details
By the way, I had already received a report that the young man was a student from China, studying in a visa. With the visa process is a medical exam. The USA does not pay for these medical exams; the seeker of the visa does. The Chinese have doctors who can give psychological exams. Although it is possible to fool the exam; it is not probable to fool a great percentage. There are checks and balances within the exam that can cast doubt on an applicant that tries to cheat the test. Doubt is failure. It is possible that this applicant would have been a failure, never entering the United States.

As for the arguments about the American born killers; that is pure crap. This happens to be a foreigner who has attacked an American institution. This is really no different from the Islamic attacks on America. Those were also foreigners.


    




Calvin of China, PhD
Rating
I have had the opportunity to see some of the people who are being allowed into the USA by out thought to be perfect system that is overseen by the National Visa Center for the Department of State. I have also had a chance to look into the medical examination. Both are absolutely flawed.

It would seem the USA should go a step further and assure we are actually receiving more quality people. Right now we are allowing too many uneducated and those who have no talent. Most of them see America as a place to get a government check. Really, this is their goal.

There is a big question; how does immigrants that are over seventy years of age helping the USA? And yes, there are many mentally ill immigrants who are entering the USA.

If there was a system in place, we would be able to be more selective. The interviewers are not especially trained for their mission and they are lacking in special skills. They misquote regulations and really don't have a fixed criteria on who gets in and who does not.


chinkus_01
Rating
Since the Columbine shootings were committed by American good-old-boys, shouldn't all American youths under go psychological testing?
Since the Oklahoma bombings were committed by American good-old-boys, shouldn't all Americans undergo psychological testing?
etc...
etc...
etc...


Cybeq
If immigrants should then everyone should. This kind of thing is not limited to one particular race.


strong_intelligent_freedom
South Korean nationalist. For all of you, I'm Chinese. I hope you guys know the difference. Look at a map if you don't know. It's like saying the French are just like the Germans because they all come from Europe.


NASA
Rating
No thats a little extreme, because one man did something blame the entire race?


piscesgurl310
Were you also saying this about whites that committed numerous other school shootings? Columbine? Amishh community?


Jerry M
They definitely need to be better screened and checked out. Also schools need to have in place safeguards for kids burning out. But I guess if it's going to happen not much can be done no matter what race. There's also ways of tricking psychological testing.


sheriwx
I don't think it had anything to do with the gunman's ethnicity. There are crazy psychos in EVERY race. Sometimes I think that we Caucasians have even more than our share of crazies. I just don't think that his ethnicity has anything to do with it.


Mr.Pwn3r
I'm part Chinese.
The guy was South-Korean.

Please know the difference.

And please, this guy has been on US soil for a very long time. The professors at Virginia Tech should have forced him to go for treatment the moment they recieved his violent stories.


rain
Rating
wow, what racism. one asian kills and you want to screen the whole race. did you even listen to his "manifesto"? he was directing his anger more at the "rich" people that "have it all".. just like the columbine example. by the way, when that happened, did you say that all white youth should undergo psychological testing? what about the unabomber (does he taint the reputation of all white people)? why is it that only ethnic minorities become tokens and representatives for an entire ethnicity and millions of people? in the meantime, people would just treat white criminals as individual cases.. what hypocrisy... educate yourself.


TiredofIdiots
no. Unless the person has signs of instability. Me being Asian american gave seen more than my fair share of psychopaths and sociopaths living in texas; and some happen to be white. I won't stereotype all whites as being crazy though. Yes he gave asians a bad stereotype but he had problems and we are all not like him.


Billy
Rating
u r a liar
what report?
he was korean

why is american born killers argument "pure crap"?
regardless of race, an attack on an institution is just that


free_eagle716
There's some value to that question. I'd be willing to support something like that if the applicant paid for it and wasn't limited only to people from a specific country.....


Sixthsense
Oh Molly, how so self-centred and uninformed you are!?! Why not first recommend psychological testing for the non-immigrant youths who set the stage for 'school shootings!' People who reason like you are those that force guys like the one from Virginia Tech. into such action (reactions) when you torture and torment them with your POISONOUS INSENSITIVE MOUTHS.

It is insulting for you to generalise, as though all immigrants should be grouped as psychologically unstable-infact your kind of reasoning deems a psychological test.

Pedophiles and other queers in your society should be recommended for the testing you propose. What is worse than abusing children, or commiting incest, or bestiality-or will you still educate me that the majority doing this are immigrants-oh please!


Natalie
Not realistic. Who would fund this? Taxpayers? HELL no.


Pearl Jam
Rating
Chinese immigrants are always good immigrants. Unless they're illegal, or spies. The last two types are more common than you'd think.


nasty joe
im going to find you and kill you


nummy
Rating
Asians are overachievers.


The Instant Classic
No more radical Islamists should be given scholarships ahead of every other group of people. This Asian punk was a Muslim, you wait and see.


Trojan8408
That is BS and you know it since it is UNREALISTIC and also, STUDENTS WHO ARE IMMIGRANTS LIKE THIS GUY, WILL NEVER HAVE TO BECAUSE SCHOOLS CLAIM-KEY WORD CLAIM- TO HAVE THIS POSITIVE ENVIRONMENT AND SUPPORT SYSTEM IN PLACE FOR STUDENTS


JOSE J
He was a legal, american citizen. That is their way of showing their love to this nation. Illegals are too busy working to make a living.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Racist ???
Do you consider yourself a racist person?...


 Does Illegal immigration really hurt our health care?

Additional Details
In the U.S....


 If a Brazilian or Mexican who has never been to US says " I am American ". Is it right or wrong ?
USA is not the only country in the continent America....


 How can Liberals rationally make the argument that illegal immigrants have not committed a crime?
It is pretty clear in our immigration laws that you have to enter this country, whether it is permanently or for a vacation, in an authorized manner. At that time you will be issued either an ...


 Shouldn't it be illegal to give aid to illegal immigrants as they're trying to cross the border?
I'm confused... when did it become socially acceptable to aid in a criminal act? I see legal citizens going down to the border and giving water and food, shoes and whatever else to those that ...


 Do you believe that illegals crossing our border may be carrying Nuclear Fuel?
Really, how does our government know that some of these people aren't carrying the hard to get Items that it takes to make a dirty bomb?

In a recent article, the Boarder Patrol ...


 How can we deport 12 million illegal immigrants?
Do you think it's possible to do it? It will take a long time obviously, but what solutions would you give on this issue?...


 Why Can't We Build A MASSIVE Wall To Keep All The Illegals Out Of Our Country?
A massive wall, 50 feet high, 10 feet wide, with an earthen berm behind it to allow border patrols, with motion sensing equipment and cameras, built along the US Mexico and US Canada borders would be ...


 If the illegals put as much effort into changing their government?
Instead of illegally coming to the US. If they united in mexico and demanded jobs and change. Why do they feel this country owes
them anything? I think they are barking up the wrong tree?<...


 Aren't illegal immigrants the backbone of America?
Aren't they the people that do all the jobs that need doing and Americans won't do? Aren't they the future of America?...


 Do you agree with pro legal that all border patrol agents be unarmed ?
They claim they are all to trigger happy....


 Really who cares if they Learn English or not?
Does it really offend your ears and your sensibilities to hear a language other than English being spoken? That's the most flaccid argument I hear and some people think its SO incredibly ...


 Why doesn't Mexico build a wall to keep out Gringos?
they come to Mexico and they don't get jobs, they do a lot of drugs and corrupt the mexican people by getting them to transport their illegal substances. They refuse to speak the language or ...


 Why is the Spanish language everywhere in the southern U.S.?
All I have seen in the past few weeks are more and more spanish speakers who do not speak english. I cant stand it anymore, why dont they speak english, the American dominant language. I went to F...


 Do you think immigrants should be allowed in the US???
add an additional statemant as to why and you will be chosen as best answer....


 What's Spanish language got to do with it?
Would you be more tolerant towards English Speaking Illegal immigrants?
Additional Details
for further reference,I never thumbs down any answer to my questions.Thank y'...


 Were You Offended At Seeing All Those Chinese Waving Their Flags?
In San Francisco yesterday for the Olympic torch? Don't you think they should be waving the American flag? If they like China so much they should stay in China!
Additional Details<...


 Why do ppl got 2 hate on mexicans?
if u think we should close the borders i guess we might as well tear down the statue of liberty as well, you know that thing that says "Give me your tired, your poor,Your huddled masses yearning ...


 Construction workers that are working on my house. Is it too late to ask for legal papers after they started?
the project?
Additional Details
hehe.....Mexicans work 100% better?? Yeah maybe at sneaking into a ...


 Me and my gf are having a baby! shes 18 and lookin after baby, im in full time work! do we get help?
im in full time work and earn about 900 a month! we live together and pay rent! will we get any help from anywhere money wise?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034