Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

The British complain about immigration but how many of them emmigrate?
Find answers to your legal question.





The British complain about immigration but how many of them emmigrate?

Following yesterday's question I stirred up a hornet's nest. I decided to check how many Brits there are abroad. I found the following on the BBC

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/shared/spl/hi/in_depth/brits_abroad/html/

Australia 1,300,000
Spain 761,000
United States 678,000
Canada 603,000
Ireland 291,000
New Zealand 215,000
South Africa 212,000
France 200,000

In 8 countries alone there are 4,260,000 British people "stealing" jobs from the citizens in these countries.

Germany has a further 126,000 Brits, Portugal 49,000, Netherlands 48,000, 212,000 in South Africa, over 100,000 in the Middle East, approx 100,000 in Asia, and 150,000 in the Asia pacific region not including Australia.

If the British want immigrants out of their country are they prepared to take back those Brits who emmigrated?

Is it right that British people can "steal" jobs elsewhere but other immigrants can't "steal" jobs in Britain?
Additional Details
Note the following article about immigration and the necessity of immigrants. Note the section about skilled immigrants.

http://news.independent.co.uk/uk/this_britain/article1221080.ece


    




Mama~peapod
Rating
For LEGAL British immigrants to the USA, we don't 'steal' jobs as you put it. Many are on a H1B visa, which you need a minimum of a degree, and/or highly needed job skills, you are paid more than the state average for that job, and the US employer has to prove they can NOT get an American to do that job.

Why did I move from the UK? for a better lifestyle and more pay than that is paid in the UK.

The main sticking point for many people both in the UK and US, is illegals do not want to go through the same process as legal immigrants to gain the right to work and live in a country.

Anyhow, have you got something against the British? as all your questions appear to be that way?

*Edit* Yes there is a visa called a H2 visa for unskilled workers or people who do not hold a degree.
QUOTE"Several of my colleagues went to the states to do semi-skilled work with no problem" They would of had this visa,assuming they had one to start with!


QUOTE "Regarding the test of whether another American can do the job - it's rubbish."
So you have been through the H1B visa process personally have you and know all the requirement for that visa?

Secondly Americans are very proud of where and who they are, and their flag and what it represents. Why do you view the British who do the same with distaste?


monty
Rating
They are moving out because of the errosion of our culture and way of life that our forbearers fought for it`s discusting that we accept what is happening on the back of their legacy to us.


Thomas M
More British live abroad than immigrants live in Britain. This will probably change soon, though.

As for "stealing jobs" - it's just silly to talk about that. Immigrants create jobs, too, by buying things, and by starting businesses.

However, a lot of those British overseas are retired sun-chasers, not people working abroad. This is especially true of the ones in Spain and France.


SUE G online
we emigrated to spain for 3 years but have since come back for various reasons, but we didnt steal anyones jobs, we were self employed supplying accomodation for tourists like yourself


♀Sweet ♥
Rating
A lot of Western immigrants have funds to cover their lifestyle and don't rely on benefits from the country they go to. That's the difference. This country (UK) is too pigging small for any more residents. What's more, many immigrants coming here just don't understand Western lifestyle and aren't prepared to accept it either. They don't deserve the life we can give them.


soppy.bollocks
Rating
I moved to China 4 years ago because of rising crime and a general breakdown of decent society where I lived and grew up (a white area).

I don't hear people spouting that "you come over here and take out jobs" nonsense anymore, they're more likely to complain about the rising crime-rate that they believe is perpetuated by certain ethnic groups.. Also people do not like to be alienated in there own areas as there is no longer a need for immigrants into the UK to adapt to British culture. From what I hear the government needs to take measures to integrate immigrants if hostility is to be avoided.

This is what I'm hearing every time I call home and is also part of the reason for the British exodus.

And for Pete's sake don't come on here and call me a racist (I could easily prove otherwise) for sharing my opinions on why British citizens are leaving the country in droves.


alex s
Rating
My husband and I are two of these statistic's - but you didn't cite Bulgaria and there is alot of us here too. We did not take jobs away from Bulgarians - rather we formed a company and have made jobs for them - but I do see your point and agree with you to an extent. There are many jobs in the UK that are so lowly paid that the typical English man can't afford to do them, plus a great many that just won't work for any reason. This is a topic that will incite many opinions, has huge implications in many area's and is due to a succession of weak governments. Many English have left simply because they can't afford life in the UK anymore.


mattysmum2692
I think the reason so many people immigrate OUT of the UK is because we are taxed so highly. If we didn't have so many immigrants here, we wouldnt have such a tax burden and we could afford to live in our own birth country country comfortably.

As far as us Uk citizens 'stealing' jobs from other countries, I think you'll find it is alot harder for us to gain entry into another country than it is for immigrants to access Britain. Any non-citizen wishing to move from Britain to Canada for example, must prove they have a skill that is in demand. Why does Britian allow thousands of immigrants with no skills in here - don't gimme the story about them taking the low paid jobs, I'm sure some do, but I would bet my last pound that statistically there are more claiming benefits than working.


clint_slicker
Rating
Yes Britain would take these people back. most of the people emigrating from the UK are highly skilled workers. I'm not sure I understand your "steal" jobs as someone must have had the job for it to be stolen and you can't just sack someone like you can in the USA.

Most British people don't have a problem with immigrants it's the unskilled illegal immigrants that are causing the problem. These illegal immigrants don't want to integrate into the local communities and also get advantages over the local population, first council houses, government loans, etc. Why should someone who has not paid into a system get more out of it than I can?

Very few people would complain about people stealing, I would say more people want them to find work legally and pay taxes back to the community. The biggest complaints are that they refuse to learn the language, they don't work, crime rate rises in areas of high illegal immigrants.

The largest number of illegal immigrants in the UK is from Australia, but the pubs would all close if they left. There is still far more entering the UK than leaving with Britain one of the top 5 countries on taking on immagrants.

Bring on immigration as the country need no ideas and blood but please do it legally.


colin h
Rating
BRITISH HATER <<BRITISH HATER??? dont ask if you dont like the answers you get,,go to a muslim site


BENTLEY BOY
Rating
I Live abroad, and your statement about stealing jobs is incorrect! Most people who live abroad, not all ,are retired or semi retired , so we are not working! and to say we are living in our own community's,why not? the immigrants that have moved to the UK , seem to all live together( southall, Birmingham, luton, Bristol , etc .To add. I can assure you in the country i live in most Brits don't work! there is barely enough work for the locals!!! but its not on your list!


Catwhiskers
Rating
You have made a good point. As far as I am concerned, as long as immigrants are in this country to work, then I have no problem with them.
Its the ones who come here to claim benefits that I do not agree with but the immigrants cant be blamed. It is the government that allows them to do it.
I would gladly swap lazy british benefit-claimants for immigrant workers.


frank S
Rating
Your arguments are flawed.

Many of the Brits who are working abroad are providing training of skills to the indigenous population who cannot receive that training and mentoring within their own country. This particularly applies to the Middle East, China and previously in the Indian sub continent. They usually return home on completion of that task.

The majority of the others live abroad because they have retired or have the economic means to do so and do not present a burden on the tax payers of the indigenous population.

If the notion that immigration is supposed to be a benefit to the economy of the country then why not send the immigrants back home to benefit the economy of their own countries.

RESPONSE:

Your thread suggests that you support immigration and all the problems that it has brought and will bring in the future. (in a recession for instance)

It is true that two wrongs do not make a right, however I would suggest that the level of British emigration is justified.

Many of us feel that our opinions and rights take second place to those who have brought themselves to our shores.


jmilwacker
Rating
there are more than 1.3 million pom in oz, but you can have them back. They carry on here like its their country anyway, also have you noticed how many immigrant's are in your cricket team? Peiterson's from South Africa just to name one.


skullpicker
Rating
I love Great Britain, even in its current state. Where else on earth can you open a conversation by referring to the weather being so bad and get a laugh out of it? If it was sunny all the time we would have nowt to talk about! The trains don't run on time, but again this is a great source of conversation in the barber's/at the bank/down the pub.

And of course the history of the British Isles is unmatched by ANY country in the WORLD. Which country has united so many other countries through a common langauge? Which country is the oldest industrialized nation in the world?...Britain. And why is this country so great...well..as Al Murry say's..................it's in the name...


Millie
I totally agree with you, the idea of stealing jobs is ridiculous. I'm glad that having lived abroad myself for many years I am able to see things from a very different perspective. Is this a free world we live in? Or is it just a free world for British people to move around in as they please?


Wiggly_pumpkin
Rating
I agree with you as well !
I think the older generation who seem to complain the most dont want the immigrants to get the free handouts ie houses benefits etc
There was an article in the paper telling people how to come to the uk and get the most out of the system that they could
I do however have no problems with any one working for their living :)


Hugo Fitch
Rating
Quite right.

I'm quite happy to welcome decent people into this country, perhaps we ought to encourage even more estuarine riff-raff to leave to make more room?

After all, estuarines are of no use to this country with their arrogant, self-centred ways and whining gobs.


janet w
i read your questions. i have come to the conclusion you are not a brit or an american. you are a muslim who hates the brits and any one who is not muslim. please stop getting on here and creating hate. as long as they are legal who cares where they go.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Is the inscription in the Statue of Liberty outdated?
"Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore,
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,
I ...


 If Bush and Fox said "let's open the borders everyone come and go as you please" what would ur reaction be?
...


 Why do Illegals and their supporters ignore what the bible says? Are they all Atheists?
Starting in Romans chapter 13 verse 1>

1. Everyone must submit himself to the governing authorities, for there is no authority except that which God has established. The authorities ...


 Does it really benefit the USA to not allow financial aid to undocumented students who want to attend college?
( or are capable of doing so )

i know that many of them op out to not attend college because it is harder for them to be able to ...

here somethign which i found :

S...


 What does the word "Illegal " mean to you?
There is a Judge who says it is illegal to enter a country unlawfully. But it is not Illegal to be an illegal immigrant here (so no arrest should be made base on that).

Should that rule ...


 I am illegal how can I become legal in the U.S.? Or apply for residency?
I am living in the U.S. and I have no documentation I have been here for 15 years. This is my senior year and I have the hopes of going to college, but it is difficult because I have no social ...


 Could i be drafted into the army even if i am not a U.S. citizen?

Additional Details
i am saying if, there is a war going on right now, that they need more people to fight....


 What country are you moving to if Huckabee wins?
or any republican for the ...


 Did you know America is the name of the whole continent?
USA is but one country among 40 others in the continent named "America."

"Indians" in any of the 40+ countries are also called "Native American" because they ...


 All illegals are criminal?
well i see " to many racist in this country against minority groups , what about the guy in philadelfia , the one that kill the little girls is he a criminal o just because he 's citizen ...


 Illegal Aliens in the US??
is it true that if the US got rid of all our illegal immigrants our economy would crash??...


 How can we afford so may immigrants in our country and how come they seem to get priority above tax payers?
...


 Should the US close the borders to all immigrants? Why or Why Not?
...


 When it comes to immigaration many people give their opinions and don't even know their facts.?
many people on here have negative views on immigration, but have you people taken a history class?Have you guys learned this country was founded by immigranst and its those same people that help ...


 What is the actual reason why the government was pushing for amnesty for illegals?

Additional Details
It has nothing to do with being "Compassionate" to illegal aliens, but it has EVERYTHING to do with money.

http://www.youtube.com/w...


 Are The MINUTEMEN and Immigration Issues Dead To Most Americans?
According to the Chicago Herald it is. But I'm not sure.

http://www.dailyherald.c...


 Why is it that everybody goes around and See's Mexicans doing?
all the hard work that AmeriCANs can't do or choose not 2 do because they think that their 2 good 4 us Mexicans ?...


 Would you move to another country in order to have a better life?
I saw a question that said:
"How's the USA going to be a better place when saturated with a bunch of 3rd world losers?"
and I wanted to ask this question....


 Should Mexico feel ashamed that their people have to leave the country for help?
...


 Do you think it is right that an American pizza business accepts pesos as payment?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034