Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

What is it about illegal immigration that makes people so angry?
Find answers to your legal question.





What is it about illegal immigration that makes people so angry?

And why, exactly, can't the United States do what Spain is doing with their "illegal" immigrants? They have just as many illegals as we do (despite the contrast in size between Spain and the U.S.), and they say, "Okay. We'll help give you a home and a job and acknowledge you even if you're not a citizen - but you have to pay your taxes to stay." And the government and businesses in Spain make money from tax collection, which in turn better benefits the Spanish citizens and legal immigrants because less companies are running around the market away from people in a panic due to the economic crisis. In Spain, the people don't worry about "illegals taking citizen tax money", because they've actually thought it through.

What is it about this tax system that people can't see in the U.S.? Is there some kind of paranoia or something that runs Americans into clinging to complete hostility towards illegal immigrants?
Additional Details
Ah. Should have mentioned earlier that I've actually been to Spain. Unlike some people...

I also live in a border state. I still don't understand the level of intolerance.


    




Ladron3dfx
Rating
Most of those who are angry about illegal immigrants do not even know them, do not speak to them, do not in any communicate with them therefore it becomes easy to label them criminals, drug runners, murderers, rapists, ethnic secessionists, to make wild outlandish claims against them. It's a deliberate attempt to demonize them and curtail any form of pathway to legalization. Look at some of their user names, some are in english and some are in spanish. I'm not angry at illegal immigrants, I'm angry that nothing is being done in the congress to resolve their status.


Patrick G
Rating
Sorry to burst your bubble... but your fantasy world description of Spain does not exist.



Lilly M.
Rating
Its not immigration, its an invasion.


enter name here
Oh I don't know.... maybe the whole illegal part.... not to mention the whole failing to assimilate themselves by at the very least learning the common language... :/ That could just be part of it..


Look unless you live in one of the Border States then I am sure you are just thinking that we are all paranoid... I live in Texas, I have to deal with and live with illegals all the time... and trust me it's not paranoia...

I have absolutely NO problem with immigrants as a whole... however illegal immigrants have no rights... by law they have no rights... and honestly I don't want immigrants to be hindered by (or hinder) our society because they lacked the patience to wait their turn...


kerfitz
Rating
Spain has nowhere near the same numbers of Ilegal aliens as the US. The simple fact that these individuals are CRIMINALS (entering the country without authorization is criminal) is why I do not want them here. The sheer numbers of them and the fact that they will work for less than minimum wage drives down the base salaries of ALL. They do not assimilate into society and send massive amounts of money "home" reducing the value of our currency. (Mexico's second largest income is from money sent "home" from illegals in the states).

I've also been to Spain. You may have seen a small area with many immigrants but it is nowhere near the levels in the US, where illegals are widespread through the country. Spain also does not look kindly upon illegal immigration and does take measures to deport any illegal immigrants. Something the US needs to get better at doing.


lady.qu_app
The reason it upsets me that they want to make illegal immigrants legal and allow them to stay here is because I have paid thousands of dollars on immigration for my spouse to live in the United States legally. If they allow illegals to stay here, I want a refund.


Immoral Hazard
Supporting illegal immigration is immoral. It only supports the root causes of the impoverished conditions that led to the migration. And it threatens to import that same poverty to this country.

I don't know anything about Spain's immigration policies, but I do know that the US has the most lenient LEGAL immigration policy in the world.


Docar
Rating
So if I raped your child and killed your family, stole your money, insulted you, robbed you, injured you, you would be happy? Of course not. Millions of people are affected by these criminals directly and millions more indirectly. After a friends child was made into road kill by some drunk illegal Mexican (illegal aliens are responsible for 28% of the DUI deaths in the US but only make up 3% of the population) he might be able to better explain it than I can! But I sure as he!! am angry about it!


alexg114
Rating
its pretty simple.. there are many people waiting to come into this country legally. The illegals don't care about that, they come when they want and when its convient to them. This holds up the process for people who are patiently waiting and doing the right thing.

why do you want to reward people who are taking the easy way in and punish the people who are doing it the right way, by making them take longer to come in.

By your logic why do we have any immigration laws? why don't we just allow anyone to come anytime they want?


jm_wright93
The majority of the illegals do not pay taxes her in the States. In California we have had several hospitals close due to illegals using the services and not paying, also we have had a lot of fires in Southern California started by illegals campfires. So yes I do get angry about it.


Jeff K
We take in about 130 thousand people legally in this country every year. Spain and europe in general are having alot of trouble with illegals.What do you think the riots in France and Britain were about last year? They send so much money out of this country and are a burden on our education system. 250 million on college in California alone, When we build schools out here to accommodate the numbers we have to bring in trailers within 2 years for more class rooms. When we passed prop 187 they over turned it, so we don't have control of our own state anymore.There have been several hospitals go out of business because they treat illegals who can't or won't pay their bills and no way to track them, so the hospitals asked the government to reimburse them and we are talking millions, the government wouldn't so those hospitals are gone from the community now.


Fly Boy
They did not abide by our laws in coming here. There are many people who are waiting legallyy to come here and the illegals jump in front of them. If someone breaks into your house but mops the floor is it ok. We want the border closed because if they can do it so can others who don't like us and are here for the wrong reasons.


Lurch
Read this material and you will share my outrage:

http://www.thedustininmansociety.org/no_more_deaths/no_more_deaths.html

You won't hear this on NBC or CBS.


Steph
They don't have to pay taxes, and we basically pay for them to live here in the us, including hospital bills, etc... how old are you not to know this?


sisterof_thedarkmoon
Rating
This is complete fabrication. I suggest you educate yourself a little on Spain and illegal immigrants.


Cheshire Cat
Rating
I can tell you what makes me angry about the illegal immigration.

When I immgrated to the US I had to do a bunch of things

-Hiv test /drug Test/ std test
- proof of my education
-shots against hepatitis, tetanus etc
-x-rays of my lungs
-proof that I don't have a criminal history
-proof that I have enough funds
-sign a waiver that I don't ask for government benefits
-interview in the us-embassy
-wait till my immigration went trough
-pay all the fees (including the medical examination , the translation of my documents)

So why in the world should the illegals get permanent resident granted without doing the same ?
I would feel discriminated.Are they better than me ?


Bishop
Rating
Maybe a better question to ask is If Millions of illegal immigrants run from the problems in their own countries then who will solve them? And what future does that leave for the families they leave behind?


Ya heard me
Rating
If one thinks for one minute that the illegals contribute more then they take, they need to do a wee bit more research.


ironman
the fact that my children can not get an education because too much time and money are spent on illegal children,the whole system in texas is overloaded,maybe when people like you start to hurt by this problem you too will get angry,really there is so much wrong with illegal immigration i could spend all day telling you why i am angry,so why dont you wash your own car and why dont you mow your own grass,and on and on,lets just catch them all and lock them up for a few years and then send them home,dont wait until they rape your daughter,or kill your parents.do the right thing now ,LETS GET RID OF EVERY LAST ONE,and make this country a better place to live


amnesty sucks
Rating
THEY ARE BREAKING OUR LAWS. THEY ARE TAKING JOBS FROM AMERICANS. WE ARE PAYING BILLIONS TO SUPPORT THEM. THEY BRING DISEASES WITH THEM SINCE THEY DON'T GET IMMUNIZATIONS. THEY DON'T PAY TAXES. THEY STEAL IDENTITIES. THEY CREATE MORE CRIME. THEY BRING DRUGS. MUCH OF THE PRISON POPULATION ARE ILLEGALS.

THEY DON'T BELONG HERE! Does that help?


Ida Slapter
The US takes in more immigrants than all the other countries in the world combined. I think we've done enough.

How about we send you our 40 million illegals?


Joel W
Rating
For Starters...

The Dark Side Of Illegal Immigration
http://www.usillegalaliens.com/the_dark_side_of_illegal_immigration.html

Look to the left side of the page and click on number three in that index. But do read it all.
===========================

They are illegal, crime ridden implicated in identification theft and enormous damage to American Citizens, associated with the narcotics problems, and cost the American People a huge amount of money.


Guy
Rating
just one word RACISM, spain is a civilized country from 21 century, USA still live in 17 century, they use witch hunting to resolve their problems yet.


themrmike
Rating
i think it has some thing to do with the arcane notions associated with the word illegal.tmm


♥eli
It's the lack of understanding on why they come here illegally, and the lack of what they actually do for America......and that's a lot.

They pay taxes, they are consumers and they love and respect this country just like US born Citizens! Yes! there's bad....just like US born Citizens, but some people....especially on here, try to make it seem like they are ALL are bad!.....NOT TRUE!

Here's a really article that tells the TRUTH!

Contributions of Immigrants to the United States (legal & illegal)
http://www.usimmigrationsupport.org/cont...
19 minutes ago


GreasyTony
It's the lack of understanding on why they come here illegally, and the lack of what they actually do for America......and that's a lot.

They pay taxes, they are consumers and they love and respect this country just like US born Citizens! Yes! there's bad....just like US born Citizens, but some people....especially on here, try to make it seem like they are ALL are bad!.....NOT TRUE!

Here's a really article that tells the TRUTH!

Contributions of Immigrants to the United States (legal & illegal)
http://www.usimmigrationsupport.org/contributions.html





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Should the USA change its official Language to Spanish?
That way we would be considered hispanics also and we could bust Illegal Immigrants without being called ...


 Do you feel that groups such as La Raza should be allowed to exist?
Do you feel that groups such as La Raza should be allowed to exist and receive federal funds?...


 If we get rid of all illegals, are u willing to work for $4 an hour to wash dishes/pick fruits?
Since this is what those companies pay them.
Additional Details
obviously 4bucks and hour isnt minimum wage, but do you think the american companies who break the law by hiring illegals, ...


 If latinos get kicked out of the country who is going to do the dirty work?
who is gonna come from over seas and do the dirty work that americans don't do.?? and look it up from a non-racial prospective....


 Why can't we build a wall?
The Chinese built a big beautiful wall hundreds of years ago that people travel thousands of miles to see. Why can't we build one like that from the California to Texas? It'd be a great ...


 Should non-Americans citizens who criticise America be allowed to stay there?
i was thinking of the anti-american reporter from the uk; catherine elsworth, living in silver lake, los ...


 Today I read an article......it accused a "white girl" of a horrendous crime.....?
and I got scared. There are alot of white girls who live in my town.......what should I do?...


 Why is it that illegal immagrants get more rights then the natural born citizens of the US?
People born in America do not get nearly any kind of help or aid as some one who is comming into the states....


 Are undocumented workers the biggest worry in your life?
I understand there is an issue at hand. No disagreement.

What I want to know is: Do you see it as the be-all-end-all deciding factor in electing a president, and, how much does this ...


 The pro-illegals claim that the illegals do the jobs that "Americans won't do." Is this accurate?
Here's proof that there nasty jobs that "Americans WILL do." What do you think of these disgusting jobs, that Americans do?

http://dsc.discovery.com...


 What should we do about illegal immigration?
DO NOT make this a race issue. This is strictly a question dealing with the rule of law and our constitution and our combined set of morals as the USA. Whoever has the most reasonable solution IMHO ...


 What if you saw an illegal, read details?
You and a group of minutemen watching over the border spot a brown skinned girl, about 9 to 10 years old walking towards a small residential area. She appears to be crossing the border but you'...


 Did you see the movie,"The Day After Tomorrow"?
Do you remember the part where all the Americans were trying to go to Mexico because it would be warmer there?
How friggin ironic would that be?
What if all of a sudden Americans needed M...


 Do animals need passports as they fly in an airplane?
...


 If U.S. govt. grants Amnesty to illegal immigrants, will it get your Thumbs Up or Thumbs Down?
...


 Can we afford to live without immigrants?
I think that if we send all the immigrants back then they'll be enough jobs for those on benifits etc.
But I was told that we have to welcome immigrants to our country otherwise if its just ...


 120 million hispanics in the US by 2050?
Jorge Ramos mentioned last night in the Texas Democratic debate that the US would have 120 million Hispanics by 2050. I'm not a US citizen or anything, but I would be pretty pissed if there was ...


 How does illegal immigration damage the U.S.?
...


 Why do foreigners who live in Britain continue to babble in their own language????
sit on a train or bus and you really do feel like YOU are in a different country!!!
Additional Details
If I lived in a foreign country I would have the manners to speak that tongue....


 Why can't I get job that illegal alien can?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024