Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Why are illegal aliens that show up in the hospital ER required to be seen (for any condition)?
Find answers to your legal question.





Why are illegal aliens that show up in the hospital ER required to be seen (for any condition)?

What law requires they be seen? If there is such a law, shouldn't we demand it be changed? This misuse of the ER (going there for non-life threatening injuries) is one of the things that drives up health care costs for us all - making it unaffordable for many. The ER shouldn't be used for primary care IMHO. Peace!
Additional Details
G T - Great answer!


    




lymanspond
Rating
well the way I look at it, if they show up at the ER, they better have proof of the immunizations(every illegal should have that) if they don't have the proper immunizations they should be detained, it is a public health situation, do you want to catch polio from your salad at the restaurant because the illegals were chopping up the lettuce?(how long ago was your polio shot?)


FatPizza9
Rating
Great point. We need to get the illegals out of here. Cut off the jobs, start actively looking for where they are and deport them. Instead, we have Democrats, like the NY governor, trying to find ways to invite more, like giving them drivers licenses.

Politicians are truly pathetic. 80% of us are so pi//ed off on this issue, yet they disregard our wishes, blatantly, and try to figure out how they can sneak in more illegals, just to get the Hispanic vote.


Grand Old Party
Yeah all you have to say is "No hablas ingles, no dinero" and you get everything for free. They need to change this and they also need to take anchor baby laws out of the books.


Uncle Ben
Rating
This law passed in 1986 is the culprit you seek! We in Health care are required to treat all who present to the ER...Serious situations as well as the "Colds, Moles, and Sore As*holes"...It makes for a great deal of abuse of the system in turning a service to help those in serious and life threatening situations into a free clinic for all too often those who have sold all their Lortabs for crack and can't get their prescriptions refilled until the first of the month. It perhaps was a good idea on paper but as the saying goes " The best made plans of mice and men often go askew"...


Joe Iwojima
Rating
send them home to mececo for el presidente to care for.


amnesty sucks
Rating
Not sure what the law is but it is their policy not to turn people away and then have taxpayers foot the bill, or close the ERs when they can't afford to stay open.

This is one reason I get so pissed at the pro-illegals that claim that we need them here. Excuse me but we don't need them and our economy would be much better without having to shell out BILLIONS each year for a bunch of criminals that are breaking our laws.


Sasha
Rating
Well, first of all. Some of the others answers are not correct. I was taken by ambulance to a hospital about 7 years ago. I am an American and White. I had a job but no insurance. I needed emergency surgery and they transfered me to a County Hospital. The doctor that did the operation was upset. He said I almost died. Before they came to transfer me. I heard a man that could not talk English. A Spanish interpreter told the doctor this man had no insurance and no job. Next thing I heard the doctor say. Prepare the operating room because he needs surgery. The Government has been aware of this for years. The hospitals care more about illegals than they do their own people. Regardless of the laws that are suppose to exist. They do not follow those laws.


gustooch
because americans are a soft touch.


loutejada
because they are human beings, and because most of us in the medical profession are there because we care about people, we took an oath


z
Rating
that a real good question i think the libs call it compassion but go and try and get some of that free med yourself and see what happens and the word nobody understands ILLEGAL


CwboyBill
Anyone that shows up in the ER is entitled to medical attention per national law. Because we are a nation of compassionate people (and we really are), I don't have a problem with this act of mercy for people in need. What I DO have a problem with is the fact that these illegals are not DEPORTED after proper and / or life saving treatment. I really can't believe anyone (or at least very few) Americans would want another human being to bleed to death on the sidewalk of your neighborhood hospital but as tax paying CITIZENS we should expect these people to be expelled from the country as per our own LAWS. Are we really asking too much to have the laws enforced? What sort of deal with the devil has the president and congress made to turn a blind eye to the number one issue in our country??


schazjmd
Rating
Federal Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act, also known as COBRA or the Patient Anti-Dumping Law. "The avowed purpose of the statute is to prevent hospitals from rejecting patients, refusing to treat them, or transferring them to "charity hospitals" or "county hospitals" because they are unable to pay or are covered under the Medicare or Medicaid programs."


Stats C (unbiased analysis)
doctors must take the hippocratic oath... thats why they have to treat them

dude, the illegals are just ONE reason.

the BIGGEST factor in unaffordable health care is the DRUG COMPANIES

why is the same medicine is so much more expensive here than in other countries?... pfizer and the likes know that congress will protect their profiteering


miniejllo
because if its an infectious disease then the doctors save themselves one trolleyload of work.
and because they are human beings too.
and anyway, if you want to send all illegals back to their country of origin, then where better to pick them up than a hospital? you have to give your details, and if you're badly hurt you are unlikely to run off...


EM
Maybe because they are doctors! and not border patrol agents!


Laura
Rating
because they are human beings.. i've never seen anyone go to the ER because of a cold! i know for a fact that many insurance companies will not insure you if you cannot provide a valid social security number (even if you are willing to pay the premiums!) .. i have yet to find one that will. also why don't you look at all the american citizens that are draining the economy! how many black and white people that are on medicaid? how many on unemployment? because they claim they can't get a job?
illegals cannot get social security if they are unemployed! don't know where you all get off at just blaming illegals, your own citizens are draining welfare and your own gov't is raising taxes to create more social programs to help the "poor" so stop complaining because some ppl are willing to live without the benefits of a real job so they don't have to raise their children in a country that offers them nothing! same reasons your ancestors came here! remember how they hated the Irish and the Italians?


BJ
So, you would do what with them?

Kick 'em to the curb....
Let them sit in the waiting room and die?
Give birth on the sidewalk?

The reason healthcare cost are so high is because 47 million AMERICANS have no health insurance because they can't afford it and another 51 million AMERICANS are underinsured....


needtoknow
Rating
Something about a Hippocratic oath that is taken by doctors when they apply for med school - "First, do no harm",,, I'm not sure exactly what it is, but I can't see just no assisting anyone in need. Granted, the illegals are making it harder for the rest of us, but if someone is ill or injured, they should be assisted, regardless of their ethnicity or financial ability.


MEETOO
what are you Hitler


♥♥Cheelicious♥♥♥
The correct name of the law is EMTALA, it is in place for everyone. It only requires EMERGENCIES to be stabilized before transferring them to another hospital. Would you rather an unconscious person die because they could not produce a drivers license????





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 How did women and Black people get the right to vote?
I want to use the same methods to get the right for undocumented workers to vote. I can vote already because no one checks id, but I just want the right....


 Do illegal aliens make you angry?
...


 In orlando, americans are being arrested for protesting the protest! instead of rounding up illegals, they are
arresting legal citizens and taking them to jail for protesting the protest. they are calling it "trespassing". is this happening anywhere else?...


 Do you think bush is raciest against Mexicans and how do you feel about them not able to come over here?

Additional Details
i think mexicans should be able to come over here so viva la ...


 How does a superpower not have control over its border?
You have to enforce the rule of law as it relates to the border and you have to enforce the rule of law as it relates to benefits. Then the American people will be open to resolving the issue as it ...


 Can the U.S. afford to deport the illegals especially during this recession?
If we are struggling to get bailouts, why would anti-illegal immigration protesters push for "mass deportation"? Do they ignore the catastrophic consequences the U.S. would face just to get ...


 Can I kidnap Illegals and turn them over to the INS?
Would I be arrested or can I say I made a citizens arrest and make up something like he was harrasing me and my family?...


 Which do you prefer? beans or mashed potaoes?
remember the mashed potatoes are made with butter and the beans with lard.
Additional Details
they eat both in chula ...


 Is it racist to ask a Hispanic for ID he looked under 21 buying 12 pack beer asked for ID accused me of being?
Is it racist to ask a Hispanic for ID he looked under 21 buying 12 pack beer asked for ID he accused me of being racist .What do you people have to say here? Racist or ?...


 If I were to immigrate to other country, which country is best,?
1. In term of Security,
2. Good Goverment,
3. Low crime rate.
4. Friendly ...


 Why should illegal immigrants have any rights in a country they don't respect??
A lot of people have come into the US legally. Do you think it's fair that illegal immigrants not have to go through legal channels like others have? Just because some are working and ...


 How much is corporate America to blame for the illegal problem?
And why?...


 What are some of the reasons why so many Mexicans immigrate to the U.S.?
...


 Is the planned attack on Fort Dix another example of what illegal aliens have to offer ?
Being 3 of the 6 terrorist filth were in this country ...


 Would the whole discussion about illegal immigration be different if...?
the majority of illegal immigrants were white, blond and with blue eyes? (oh... and a bank account in Switzerland)...


 Do you think the government should put Bills such as the past immigration bill before the people for a vote?

Additional Details
Yes Spider Pig That would be nice too.A big NO vote from me on that one.

I think anything that has a major impact should be up to WE THE PEOPLE since it IS ...


 Is it necessary to build wall b/n U.S – Mexico border?
...


 How many of you who talk about the Indians owning this land are making arrangements to move off it?
I have seen this stated over and over. So now that you are so aware of this important information why aren't you moving off this land you state even you don't belong on and agrue over and ...


 Should the Ghurkas be allowed to immigrate here ?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/
If they've put their lives on the line for this country why not ? makes a change from people who hate us and want to kill us coming ...


 Why can't Ilegal Immgrants become citizens?
how come people that cross the border illegaly not able to get citizenship?? if they were part of America, they would have to pay taxes. then if they do this, america would be getting more money. isn&...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034