Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Why can't Spanish be the official language of America?
Find answers to your legal question.





Why can't Spanish be the official language of America?

Americans could learn spanish in two weeks.


    




flatline
Rating
Why can't English be the official language of Mexico?

Mexicans could learn english in two weeks.


cadaholic
what is wrong with you?


Blue Steel & Lace
Why can't English be the official language of America.
Hispanics could learn English in two weeks.

It works both ways...


the crusader
Because English is the language of America. I think the real question is why can't people who want to live in this country learn to assimilate and speak English? Ever heard the saying, "When in Rome, do as the Romans do"?


CC Moody Trojans
Rating
I am Mexican-American.Spanish did not come from Mexico.Besides that I hate the spanish blood Mexicans who control the wealth, because they do not take care of their poverty.I speak spanish but sorry I do not agree with you.


Stranger
Rating
Ok....Im hispanic I see your point in the sense of that its hard for spanish speakers to learn English......but really why force a country to change its ways just because they have a growing population of Spanish speakers....Hispanics, latinos all come here expected to hear another language....they country already allowed them in....now we have to change a major concept of being American....If someone moves to mexico...shouldnt they be expected and obviously learn to get use to Spanish...


aprildite
Rating
Ha, Ha. I think I'd be laughing more heartily if we weren't already headed that way. I think it's ridiculous that we have formatted American television shows, products, stores, etc. etc. to include the Spanish language. Whenever Americans go abroad, one of the first things you imagine is the trusty "phrasebook." You know, where is the hotel, where is the bathroom.... and if it's a semester abroad, several semesters in that countrys' language are required before you can even consider it. So in my opinion, if anyone wants to travel or LEAGALLY immigrate here, they can learn the blasted language.


JOSS
Because this is America!!We speak English!


Samantha
Rating
Heard of when in another country do as they do? That applies here too.


lonewolf1
Enough is enough, we do need to learn other languages, but English is our language no matter how hard you want it to be for you and your illegal friends and family, and it will never happen.


Cheez_Mastah
Rating
Because this country was founded with the English language and that has been what was primarily spoken for some 200+ years now. To change the official language would cause massive nationwide riots and cost trillions of dollars to change everything to Spanish. Don't like English? Deal with it or move out. Not to be racist or anything, but thats just the way it is.


Zero1
Why do so many Spanish people immigrants fail to want to learn to speak English. Since most Americans speak English why would we consider any other language as our national language?


Meridianhawk42
Rating
I took two years of Spanish and college and never made more than a D. If it's the easiest language to learn, I'm in big trouble. I hated those classes.


john h
Rating
Get real !!! This is America.........if people don't want to speak our language....they should return to the country that speaks their language. Love it or leave it.


HITLERY
Rating
I don't want to talk like i have crap in my mouth.


life_will_be_ok
because america rules


badjanssen
Rating
if i dont hear a latino speaking spanish for 2 weeks...then i will learn spanish....


Sharp Marble
Rating
because English is. Why don't the illegals who only speak spanish just learn english in two weeks?


C. J.
I'm just gonna sit back and watch this question self-destruct on it's own.


suede_blueyes
Would any other country be expected to change it's national language because of being overrun by illegal immigrants? Hardly!

Why is this even a question? Spanish is the language in MEXICO, French is the language in FRANCE, Italian is the language in ITALY, Chinese is the language in CHINA, English is the language in AMERICA! GET OVER IT!


Paul K
Rating
Because it is American-English. Learn the rules or don't play the game.


alandicho
Rating
people who doesn't speak english should be booted out of UNITED STATES OF AMERICA!


*^*hEaThEr*^*
Rating
no they cant... it took me like two years before i new... and i told talk with no american accent either... ud think i was actually spanish..... thats like asking why cant the official language of puerto rico be english..... its cus when this country started..... it was primarly english and then people immigrated


Savannah
thats like asking why can't French be the official language of Germany... and no,actually,it takes a few years to become fluent in any language,not two weeks...


Mama Jazzy Geri
In my opinion, when this country was formed many years ago it was done with the immigrants from England. So ever since the newcomers who came to this country brought their languages with them. They spoke it in their homes but when they went out to work they all wanted to speak English it was the "language of the land".

It would be the same thing if we went to France....would we want them to change their language to ours...whatever we speak? I don't think so.....When you move to another country you put down your old ways and pick up the new ways of your new home.

You can still keep your mother tongue with your family and friends but when you do business in America...you should respect the language of the majority of the people. It's seems most fair to me and most Americans.

Our country is like a soup...with many ingredients..but we have "one language" to use and it does not hurt to have something we call our American way of speaking and communicating. One last comment my grandparents came from Italy and they insisted their many children speak English...even though they spoke Italian at home. I'm proud of my heritage but respect the fathers who were our first leaders and also the leaders we have today. Don't break something if it isn't broken....like our first language English. Proud to be an American!


johny1punch
how old are you peppy ?


walter_b_marvin
Rating
When the majority of people in the country are hispanic, let it be put to a vote. BTW To speak spanish well and to understand vanicular spoken spanish is not that simple, especially for older folks that don't speak it now


Crabby Patty
Rating
I swear I have seen exactly this question before. Since the answer is obvious the reason for asking it is obvious too. If you just want to piss people off or stir up bad feelings why not try a new subject. This one isn't worth debating.


Wendy P
I love this tricky and controversial questions!!..... technically it could since most of the countries in "AMERICA" speak Spanish (to all the ignorants who think that America is just the United States of America well...go back to school and learn some geography, America is all the Continent!) but if you are referring to the USA...well ....this country language is English and it has been that for a very long time...if you come to this country wouldn't be that bad to try to learn the language, and get yourself educated...(and that goes to all the ignorant non immigrants also)


Erika B
Rating
I think it's maybey because english has dominated for several years, and then when the people who spoke english moved away to get away from the scary frenchies they took english with them and it became the official language. i dunno. Better than having german as the first. besides... spanish people could learn eniglish in two weeks


Debi
Rating
Why can't you go back to Mexico?





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 For those of you against illegal immigration is there anything that would cause you to support even one person
Any exception at all?
Additional Details
you are right it does keep them down that's why i'm wondering why people don't ...


 Can you answer 4 Questions about Immigration honestly ?
1. Have you ever lost your job to an illegal immigrant?
2. Have you ever been a direct victim of a crime committed by an illegal immigrant?
3. Have you ever had a friend who is an illegal ...


 Why are people so against immigration, of any kind?
Why are people so against immigration now, when in reality the likes of America and Australia were built by immigrants. Couldnt tomorrows immigrant, be our future?
Additional Details
I...


 Why do Americans think that illegal immigrants receive free health care?
Most illegal immigrants are scared to apply for any type of government benefits (food, health care, housing, ect.) because you have to supply a VALID social security number & card and also 2 ...


 Do you agree with the fact that a great wall is goint to be built on the limits Mexico US?
Don't you think it's like the wall of Berlin? instead of going forward aren't we going backwards?...


 Whats the underlying reason why this government has allowed huge masses of immigrants into britain.why,why,why
...


 If Hitler was around today ........would he have as many followers?
...


 Do you feel like a foriegner in your own country/town/city.?
...


 Why has America failed us ?
...


 If Britain is so bad why do half of the world want to live here is it just the free benefit system?
...


 Is it just me or is Michael Moore the most patriotic man in America ?
SICKO...nationwide this Friday
Additional Details
it was my PLEASURE to defend this country (navy) for 20 years so people like MM could have a ...


 Can an illegal alien really cut my grass better?
Can an illegal alien really do that much better of a job cutting my grass as opposed to just a regular ol legal Mexican?...


 Romanian & Bulgarian beggars on the streets of the UK?
On the way to work each morning I walk past this Romanian woman begging outside McDonalds (on Princes Street in Edinburgh). She seems to work in tandem with at least three other women & they ...


 Why are "Americans" so ignorant about this fact...?
America is a country made up of immigrants. Generations ago this country belonged to Native Americans. After that many migrants travelled here for a better life, therefore meaning American is ...


 What you think of this ?
America is rich, mexico is poor , but we are going to take over your country, and deportall the americans and canada. this is true will happen and be true . america will be part of mexico and we ...


 People who are born in the UK say they are english.?
So if a dog is born in a stable does it make him a horse?...


 Why Are Americans So Against Mexicans?
Seriously guys, why are you so racist against Mexicans? Mexicans come here to try and raise their family...and people judge them because they come here "illegally"..so what..they aren'...


 Where can i get a forged u.k passport from?
i need it urgently as i hve been told part of my extended family are being smuggled over in a container heading for u.k?if possible i want a good forgery as they will need it to claim benifits when ...


 Why should illegal immigrants be treated unfairly and unequally?
Why must our US government treat illegals so unfair and unequal...i mean they don't treat us that way they allow us to come and have we heard a complaint...NO! So why do we treat them that way ...


 Has the UK now lost its identity as a Nation,due to the massive influx of people from other Nations.?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084